The summer Hikaru died ,ORV (we never changes good things), and the spook's apprentice (not sure, I read it in french sooo-)
Firstly
For Orv, firstly need to share how much I do love Dokja, I mean such a cutey (I'm still around the 270~ chapter so please no spoilers)
And goddddd wdym he is character
wdym yjh's 24737 messages to check on his bf (nobody can change my mind)
wdym secret plotter doesn't exist anymore...? who tf is he
but he looks so fun, hope we might meet him in some days chapter
AND OH
watched the movie ? this.. thing... how they dare calling it with the sale fckin name DO THEY DARE ?? I mean... most of scenes aren't respected... and stuff like.. idk... they don't even explain wtf are constellations and sponsors.. just "they re watching us" don't they give you power, and nobody asks why does Dokja doesn't choose one ?
Plus, when Yjh was about to drop kdj over the bridge, why Kdj was this afraid.. He initially wasn't... How did it ended up like that ?
and all the first part in the metre station (is it how you call it in English ?), why is it that bad... why don't they develop things about Pild... I don't remember his name but it was interesting (the old man with his towers which do bang bang bang with them) ALSO THE ZONE GAME why was it that bad...
and I don't even mention the end (what was that thing ?) or more "small stuff" like the fact kdj must have food and not "a lot of money" when he enters in the scenario's zone, and isn't it why people attack him in the first place ? to get his food ? accusing him of being selfish ?
they also destroyed the whole conversation between kdj and Sangah ? where she says "I read also a lot hahaha" and weren't they also talking about suic.. ? Am I fool ?? AND TF WAS THIS DOKKAEBI WHERE IS MY BIHYUNG ???
Everyone was so ooc, never wished to die this much by watching something. Literally my eyes bleed
ANYWAYYYY
gonna pass to The summer hikaru died bcs yeah it's just so wonderful (character, artsyle, may I eat it ?) and I need to buy the remaining volumes but I'm just a poor guy but I can afford everything for my little boys <3
and
The spook's apprentice, guess as everyone I've started to read it around 9-10 yo, and I'm still reading it bcs god it was really good ! I've remembered that my first crush was Alice, then Tom, then Alice bcs girl power I guess idk.
And how Tom is stupid
but I like them like, that's ok. however bro they've told you "don't do that Tom" AND YOU'RE RUNNING TOWARDS IT
if people die it's mostly bcs of him... sorry not sorry
(ily Tom)
I realise how it ended up being a crash out abt the AWFUL thing named "the live adaptation of orv"
(sorry guys if I don't answer to y'all, sometimes I forget that I have tumblr)
We are not judging how bad the movie is, we are judging which adapted the book the worst. There are good movies that are bad adaptions.
Propaganda below the cut (spoilers may apply)
Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant (originally the Darren Shaw saga/The Vampire's Assistant):
Took on a much more early 2000s teen flick approach to a book that, while initially for younger audiences, had a lot of very dark and Intense moments. The casting was also fairly bad and it really went in a different direction from the novel.
Bad acting, weird script choices, not even Ken Watanabe & Salma Hayek could save it
Characterisation was nothing like the books and it couldn't decide if it was a comedy or horror
Seventh Son (originally The Spook's Apprentice):
The book is a dark fantasy book for children, with fantastical elements that ring true to folklore but still have their own distinct flair, really well written horror centered on the fact that the protagonist is still just a boy, and a very strong theme that the spook opposes the forces of darkness and evil with knowledge and wits rather than heroics. The series as a whole has a lot of digs at established powers, both the Church or the nobles. It also has a mentor that is showed as imperfect from the get-go because of sexist tropes, and a protagonist who criticizes it even at the beginning when he's just a boy. The movie makes the protagonist an adult, turns the spook from an old wise man who practices using a stick (peasant weapon!) to fight and throwing silver chains to immobilize supernatural creatures, into the SURVIVOR of an ORDER OF KNIGHTS, and generally removes all the slow creeping horror to turn it into generic shitty fantasy movie #493, with bad acting on top. And it bombed so bad it probably RUINED the Spook's series chances to ever get a good adaptation, damnit!
Mentor gets changed from being part of a long line of people with a cool fantasy job to a discount Templar, cool methods of handling monsters got reduced to just killing them, awesome assassin grandma changed to Default Movie Witch, and more! It's pretty much not the story anymore.
It takes pretty much nothing that I liked from the books with the initial premise and some names being pretty much the only things kept intact.
The plot and world were completely changed. Most of the changes make for a much more generic and, in my opinion, worse story. Spooks in the books are seventh sons of seventh sons who are trained to fight creatures of the dark because seventh sons of seventh sons are able to sense the supernatural. They are hired for jobs by ordinary people, usually exorcising ghosts or capturing creatures like boggarts and witches. In the movie, the Spooks are also seventh sons of seventh sons, but for some reason, they are an order of knights. In the books lot of people think Spooks are charlatans until they come face to face with a ghost or creature of the dark because the world is usually pretty ordinary and peaceful. The setting is inspired by Lancashire and the world feels pretty unique. The setting in the movie is Generic CGI Fantasy Land where everyone has American accents and big CGI monsters are everywhere.
The protagonist Tom and Alice, his friend and later love interest, were aged up like in the Percy Jackson movies. In the books, Tom starts out as a 12-year-old and grows up as the series continues. He starts out very uncertain and wants to stay on his family farm. He only becomes a Spook because he knows he has to get a job to ease the financial burden on his family. He grows into his role as a Spook's apprentice over time. Alice is a pretty interesting character in the books, she is naturally very talented as a witch but struggles with the darker side of her powers over the course of the series. In the movie, they became incredibly generic Hero and Love Interest characters with pretty much no personality and instantly fall in love.
Mother Malkin was a first-book villain, who was mostly only such a threat because Tom was an extremely inexperienced 12-year-old at this point who accidentally released her and didn't realise how dangerous she was. She was monstrous and decrepit and fed on blood. In the movie she is turned into a beautiful seductress and a world-ending threat who can turn into a dragon. They also made her the Spook's lover for some reason.
Tom's mother is a really cool character in the books who pushes him to become a Spook despite him being reluctant and plays a larger role in the later books. In the movie, Tom is the one who wants to be a Spook and his mother doesn't want him to.
I think the character who got it worst was the Spook himself, John Gregory. In the books, he is a former priest at the end of his career as a Spook, he is incredibly uptight and disciplined to an extent that other Spooks find over the top. For example, he has a rule of fasting before a battle that he makes his apprentices follow and he only kills as a last resort. He's tough but usually pretty fair to Tom and explains things to him so he doesn't get hurt. In the movie he is pretty much the complete opposite, he's a drunkard who spends the whole movie making getting angry and fighting and doesn't seem very interested in teaching Tom how to be a Spook. Also, the accent that Jeff Bridges uses is terrible.
I'm not sure the movie would be enjoyable if you hadn't read the books, having read them I hated it, but I feel like it would be mediocre at best even without the comparison. The acting is pretty bad despite the big-name cast. I think you could maybe enjoy it in a so bad it's good kind of way. The books were spooky and pretty charming from what I remember and I think if they had been adapted more accurately, preferably as a TV show, it could have been pretty good. Sorry this is such an essay, I've never hated an adaptation more. It's been a long time since I've both read the books and seen the movie, so if anyone wants to correct anything feel free.
Every time Netflix pushes me to re-watch the truly terrible Seventh Son, I go ugh, because those books are AMAZING. They are first-class YA creepy and gory and the ISTP 8w9 witch assassin that shows up midway through is freaking incredible. She is a bona-fide bad-ass. I devoured those books during the pandemic, since they were all available through my library's digital download system, and even though the last one filled me with rage (Alice deserved better), they were just a spine-chilling good read. Some scenes have stuck with me in terms of "I shouldn't be reading this at night," while I simultaneously wanted to kick the main character for his recklessness.
And then Hollywood got their hands on it and thought, "Nobody wants to see this, so let's age him by eight years and sex him and Alice up and make it not-scary" (????). If you are not going to do the book justice, don't adapt it at all. :P
And yet, Ben Barnes is so damn pretty, I am still tempted to shut my brain off and watch it, even knowing I'm just gonna wanna read the books again and tell anyone who will listen that they are BETTER.
