Been thinking about @my-rose-tinted-glasses post for over a month. This originally started as a reply, but once it was clear I was overthinking and oversharing, I scrapped it. But definitely read the post for full context.
I can't stop thinking about expecting happy endings and how it impacts our emotional experience. I am sure Rose is right and someone actually staying dead would make us all a lot more scared. And I do think being confident it will end happy takes the suspense away. But at the end of the day, if it's done well, it hurts me.
I enjoyed Wicked Game for the fun soap opera it was and I did get some feelings during the journey. Sads were felt, but they just weren't big, and I was definitely immune to the fake death. Daou did a good job being a sad dino, so it wasn't the acting. It was the entire show. It just didn't heavily impact me.
For me, some stories just don't get their claws in me the same way. But right now, watching ITSAY, I am feeling every freaking emotion turned up to the max and I KNOW both seasons end happy. In this case, the lack of suspense may be the only thing getting me through it! To My Shore was so cruel that I had to ask about the ending so I could mentally prepare if that was going to end bad. I was also convinced a certain character in the MOST TRAGIC WEDDING EVER was alive. Without a body, there is no proof of death and I expected a miracle (we won't talk about how this messed with me in My Stand In... Kat was entertained by my delulu... I even doubted the proof... LOL! I didn't say I was smart). But even my certainty didn't stop me from crying a million tears watching that wedding and every scene that preceded and came after!!!! The writing and acting was SO PAINFUL.
The more I think about it as I write this, the more I have to admit that knowing it will end happy probably does tone the pain down a bit, at least in most cases. But that doesn't spare me from epic pain, it just might help me survive it. I get to hold onto that small glimmer that no matter how broken things are now for the characters, everything will be right in the world in the end. And when I know it ends sad... the reverse is also true... looking at you XNamping!!! Every fucking second of that story crushed me!!!!
So personally, I am good without the suspense that it might be a sad ending. I don't think that is the magic that makes something devastating to me. I'm not sure what is the magic recipe.... maybe I just need to take the story seriously to really feel it. Or maybe I need to want to feel it.... to want to go on that journey. Knowing it's HEA may have taken the edge off, but I can think of a long list of series I knew would end happy and managed to completely wreck me along the way. For me, the Wicked Game was a fun watch, but despite the the great acting and moments that did manage to hurt me, many of the punches missed me and I just don't think it's because of the predictable happy ending. In fact, having that character stay dead would have felt like a cheap shot.
On that note, I HATE a sad endings that feel cheap. I don't like sad endings, but there are many I have loved. They need to feel right. I have to feel that my mourning is justified and the ending somehow fits better than the happy ending I craved. I get so pissed when something ends tragically (or even just bittersweet) without feel necessary, earned, or the entire point of the journey. So if it's going to have a sad ending, I need to respect it. Convince me. Make me love it. Wicked Game had zero chance of doing that for me and if it had given me anything less than a HEA, I would have rioted.
Thank you Rose💜 for making these thoughts swirl around in my head until they spilled out. Sometimes overthinking is fun.