Don’t get me wrong, I love Toby so much. But I literally don’t think he could be the trollhunter.
Cause Strickler only turned good because of BARBARA. And he only met her because Jim was the trollhunter, he only pursued her at first to upset Jim.
Jim survived the darklands because he had formed genuine connections with Nomura and Strickler that I don’t think Toby could.
Love Toby but he’s a bit awkward and sometimes he says some crazy shit.
Also I don’t think he would be responsible with it—? Like he was literally telling Claire that Jim found a magic amulet and they WERENT EVEN FRIENDS. Toby could not lock tf in for his life in the early days.
That’s why my headcanon is that the amulet was like “Toby Domzalski… take me to Jim that bitch thought he could get out of this.” Jim and the amulet are a bitter married couple.
Also they kinda did this in like season two, Jim wishes he wasn’t the trollhunter and DRAAL can’t even stop Gunmar.
Toby is cooked I’m so sorry. Love you Toby but you cannot lock tf in.







