I know I have probably talked about her too much but I suppose one of the reasons I am fascinated by Miranda Briar is that I myself have a very complex and painful past with institutions and control. I'm a survivor of a lot of awful mental health care systems (including certain branches of the TTI) and so i have grown into someone who doesn't entirely trust that a system can actually be for anyone. I trust my therapist but not the people she works for, to be blunt and keep it from getting too Much. And so while I am obviously not on team "murder Bartleby and blow up the Arcanum" the rage itself is something I feel very very deeply. While she's clearly not being selfless I understand what she means when she says knowledge shouldn't be hoarded by one group. I myself have BEEN HARMED by a system that knew more than me and wouldn't tell me anything. I wasn't allowed to research my own disability, I wasn't allowed to learn more about what they claimed to be experts in. That kept me trapped and believing things about myself and the world that they wanted me to believe. I was unable to help myself or call them out. And while obviously we know very little about what she's planning and how much she has other people in mind, I can see what she means in a lot of ways— if I didn't have the perspective of a player and I truly lived in the world of the Spiral, I would also have become distrustful and afraid of the Arcanum. I would also have assumed that they didn't have my interests at heart. Why would I? They HAVE historically been selfish. Just because they decided to turn over a new leaf now— what does that mean? I myself don't really believe in the idea of systems being reformed. For many of them, their very foundation is rotten. They are built on inherently harmful ideas, to "reform" them would still leave the inner rot, even if it's softer.
So I guess seeing her in the Darkmoor update was just... very surprising and I am not shocked at all I like her so much as a villain. I wasn't expecting Wizard101 to really be able to step up and meet me like this now that I'm not a kid anymore. I have met a lot of villains I have felt sympathy for, I have met a lot that I enjoyed. I have met MANY that I could see the people who harmed me in. I don't think I have ever really seen a villain that I feel would actually understand my rage or even agree with me in the way I mean when I say the fact that my abusers were allowed to "reform" makes me angry. Which is so surreal because as far as I can tell she's not a "victim turned villain". I would not expect KI to give her that sort of backstory. Her beliefs are *political* in nature, she seems to be not acting from injury but conviction.
But STILL she is so clearly in the wrong because we have no idea what she's planning but we have already seen people die for it and Bartleby is scared shitless of her. Which is like... of course I trust Bartleby. Of course I trust the Arcanum. The bond I have with the Spiral is the strongest possible bond one could have with a fictional world. But at the same time in any other world... no, I wouldn't trust them, would I?














