Mistakes that Novice Writers make - Part 1. Story Construction.
Mistakes That Novice Writers Make and How to Avoid Them –
Part One Story Structure.
Hi again you lovely lot, here again for another dose of Witchy Writing Wisdom, you lucky buggers. That or you’re bored and have nothing better to do, either way, hello.
As you all probably know by now, I’m Willow, Paranormal Romance author, witch, medium, endless reader and cat slave.
A few people have asked me to put together a video on the mistakes that you might make as a novice writer and how to either avoid them or learn how to fix them.
This is a very wide topic and far too much to cover in one video so I’ve decided to make this into a series of videos that I will post each day until it’s finished.
Making these mistakes can immediately give you away as an amateur writer and, even if you aren’t, they can make you seem that way. You could have been writing for the best part of your life, but if you never learnt the basics then you will never improve past a novice. Harsh, but true unfortunately.
These are a basic guide of what to avoid and what not to do. This is coming from bitter experience, writing class lessons, the opinions of other writers that I have spoken to asking what they would include in this list, readers themselves and a shit ton of practice. All of which I’ve done so you don’t have to. How much do you love me now? The answer had better be a lot.
This first video will focus on what to avoid in your story construction and what is seen as amateurish. Let’s dive in, shall we?
Firstly, a bad story concept. This sounds so obvious, doesn’t it? but for some it’s not. If you think your story through, follow a story formula to make sure you have all the elements you need, and plot it properly, that will be a massive help.
What can also help is joining a writing class or group, if you can’t get to one physically, then online forums and groups can be just as good. There you will be able to get a lot of feedback if you pitch the idea. Believe me, people will question things and make you think about it. They will likely pick up on and question the things that you hadn’t even thought of.
If you don’t want to do that, then getting it checked by a beta reader can make all the difference. Some new writers seem to think that they have to go it alone all the time, that they can’t ask for or accept help when it is needed or offered. They will self-edit and review before publishing and then wonder why they are getting negative reviews. That lack of help shows. And I’ve been just as guilty of this myself in the early days. I thought that no one else would know and love my world as much as I did and therefore couldn’t be of any help. I was so wrong. Help is always a good thing and even the best, most successful writers still have trusted beta readers to show their work to first.
This moves us on to plot holes. Yet again this is a problem that can be fixed with careful plotting rather than trying to just write without a plan, and then with careful editing and observation.
Poor cause and effect is just as bad as a plot hole, your reader knows that stepping out in front of a car will hurt, it will cause damage and possibly kill you. but if your character walks away without a scratch it will jar with your reader. Just because you need that car to hit someone to show who is the bad guy, you still need to keep it realistic.
If you character shoots and kills someone research what the lawful procedure will be, what will be their punishment and comeback in your country. If your character breaks into a house and gets caught what would happen if it was a real-life situation in the place your story is set? All of this might seem like it can be skipped, because hey, it’s all fiction, right? Wrong? Just because its fiction doesn’t mean that anything can happen, things have to feel realistic, they have to have an element of truth to them for your reader to gel with the story.
Random story elements will also confuse your reader and lead them down a path you never wanted, so by the end they feel cheated out of a potential plot point that they found quite enticing.
Just because you get an idea for a funny, quirky or poignant scene doesn’t mean you have to use it if it doesn’t make narrative sense.
This brings me to my next point, overly confusing plot. Inexperienced writers often feel that they have to try and impress their readers and make an impression, which to a certain extent is true, but they go about it the wrong way. Trying to be too clever, or too complicated will almost always backfire.
Having a large, convoluted and detail laden plot can put a lot of readers off and can be very hard to write successfully.
Having 6 red herrings, 3 turncoats, 10 hidden clues, 5 points of misdirection and 4 plot twists, all in one story will just make for an exhausting and hard to follow plot that most will either give up on without finishing it or feel confused and unsatisfied by the end. And that is not what you want.
Don’t try to be too clever, don’t try to baffle your reader. You want them to relate and engage, not feel like they don’t know what 2+2 is.
As with anything there are extremes and while being too complicated is bad, so to is being too simplistic and vague. Some writers drift towards vague writing as a way of creating mystery and surprises within their story, but in reality, this rarely works.
Unneeded scenes are a big problem with novice writers. They seem to think that the more there is, the better it is, which is not always the case.
Don’t get hung up on word count. By trying to bulk up your story you can often do more harm than good.
It might seem cute or easy to add an extra scene with your main characters dog doing all sorts of weird and wonderful things, but it will be recognised as what it is. Filler.
Say it with me, if nothing actually happens in a scene, if it doesn’t add to character development or if it doesn’t push the plot along, then it doesn’t belong in your book.
Now, I’m not a total monster, I know these kind of scenes can creep in, and you’ll love them, but they need cutting. Notice my word choice there, cutting, not deleting, cutting. Nowhere is it against the rules to add the scene at the back of the book as a deleted scene or to put it in a blog post or on your website. It doesn’t have to die, it just has to get its arse out of your story.
Under these rules you can include big scenes that are masquerading as really important but focus more on what’s not happening rather than what is. For example:
You have 5 people in an office having a meeting. They spend 4 pages of back and forth dialogue discussing possible problems, chatting about how, no, Gerald didn’t place that order, no, that big client didn’t cancel his contract blah blah blah, all filler and no real information for us readers. It’s not needed.
Have a meeting to discuss a problem that is happening or has happened, one that does actually affect the story, not what might happen. Keep it current, keep it relevant.
Our last problem relates to the ending. As I’ve said many times, your ending must be satisfying to the reader. If your ending seems too easy, too obvious or very short and rushed, your readers will know, and they will not like it. Weak endings weaken your entire book.
That’s it for book structure mistakes. Thanks for watching, tune in tomorrow for the next part in the series focusing on Characters and Narration.
As always, hit me up on social media with any questions or suggestions for future videos or even books you might like me to read and review.
Blessed be, and happy writing.









