Evidence of Potential Theft Perpetrated by Tumblr User @/mewtwoandme2 / @/mewtwoandme
This is a bit hard for me to write. I know that people frown upon call-outs, and the “best practice” is to DM the involved parties. Frankly, I am highly uncomfortable with contacting Mtam at all. This is not an isolated issue, and I have no desire to approach Mtam with an open hand when I believe that they have already taken from it so freely. The two blogs belonging to Mtam that I am aware of, @/mewtwoandme & @/mewtwoandme2, have been blocked since 12 July 2024.
I am doing my best to present an objective timeline of events as I understand it. Obviously, I am no mind-reader, and I am not in contact with all involved parties. I am also not in the Commewnity server where I assume people share concepts and WIPs, so I have not seen such in-progress work by Mtam on the artworks and concepts laid out here. I also do not follow Mtam or hardly any of the more popular Commewnity artists; the only way their artwork comes across my dash is through reblogs from other users. I used to follow Mtam and other popular Commewnity blogs, and Mtam even used to follow me from @/mewtwoandme2, but I severed those ties about a year ago via un-following and soft-blocking.
I understand that we are all in a niche corner of the larger Pokémon fandom that involves numerous users working from the same four base designs: Mew, Mewtwo, Mega Mewtwo X, and Mega Mewtwo Y. There are bound to be similarities, especially in combining the traits of the various base species. I know I have OCs that look similar to other users’ by pure accident, or by cheeky anons describing a TRRC drop-off as similar to another user’s OC in my Pokémon IRL (@blastedoffagain) askbox. Any of these instances alone might make me raise a brow and ultimately move on; many of them did. It is largely the combination of these multiple instances that puts knots in my stomach.
DO NOT harass any users involved in this situation. I will block you and recommend they do as well.
I drew glasses on a Mewtwo OC of mine named Lavvy that a good friend gave me years ago. The concept was largely private until I decided to use the same structure on @mushroom-for-art’s Mewtwo OC Maybe. He loved it, so they are a canon accessory now, with my permission! Only after this did we see Mtam’s Blu get glasses of the same structure. Neither Mush as Maybe’s owner nor I as the artist were ever asked if the concept could be used on other people’s OCs.
- First post to Toyhouse by me dated 31 July 2020 (the link won’t work, but here it is anyway; my Toyhouse is log-in, adult, and largely authorized-only): https://toyhou.se/7722695.lavvy/gallery#25044217
- First post on tumblr dated 6 May 2023, character featured is Maybe owned by @mushroom-for-art: https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/716633498209959936/hi-mushroom-for-art-again-i-hope-you-dont-mind
- First post on tumblr by @/mewtwoandme dated 25 July 2023: https://www.tumblr.com/mewtwoandme/721158383013707776/i-finally-made-some-proper-character-ref-sheets
Imp is @mushroom-for-art’s version of the Mewtwo from Pokémon: Genesect and the Legend Awakened. Clearly Imp’s markings escaped unscathed, and the colors are far from exact. Mush and I still remain uncomfortable. The side-by-side shows that both palettes follow the same pattern, but lighter and shifted in hue, sporting higher-saturation eyes. The darkest parts of both designs’ tails are particularly close to one another. Mush particularly feels Mtam’s shiny was drawn similarly to their feminine ‘Two proportions, possibly referencing Imp’s canon gender.
- First post on tumblr by @mushroom-for-art dated 16 June 2023: https://www.tumblr.com/mushroom-for-art/720320394292248576/weve-had-mewtwo-now-heres-my-version-of-newt-her?source=share
- First post on tumblr by @/mewtwoandme dated 3 July 2023: https://www.tumblr.com/mewtwoandme/721859672231084032/if-you-were-able-to-change-mew-and-mewtwoa
The Nitpicks, Sixteen & Seven:
I know this is more of a stretch and could easily be coincidence or harmless inspiration. I've included it because, in the context of the rest of this document, even less blatant use of my work adds to the harm as a whole.
This was originally brought to my attention at the time of Seven’s first teases, mostly because of the language used to describe her. As far as I know, Six and Seven look absolutely nothing alike. Both characters are described as smaller because they are more mew than their predecessors. It’s also funny to see Seven paired with Jericho, since Six’s original purpose was to be a breeder for M1 if he was ever recaptured. Luckily, Six escaped long before M1 was recaptured for the events of Detective Pikachu. I also chuckle that as numbers, Seven comes right after Six, which is Sixteen's primary nickname.
- My description of Six as “more Mew” posted to tumblr on 21 November 2022 (before I added Rota/Eve to the canon and made Six a direct clone from one of Eve’s fossils): https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/701563890209800192/m16-mewtwo?source=share
- Reference to Seven being more mew-like by @/mewtwoandme on tumblr dated 15 July 2023: https://www.tumblr.com/mewtwoandme/722960078930591744/perhaps-instead-of-giving-them-big-doses-of-human
I still don’t really know exactly what to say about this. The stripes, the darker sclerae, the sassy personality, the pawpads, even the lore of the synergy being injected into him and erupting out, albeit at different points in their lifespans. Much like the Ideal Shiny vs. Imp, the palette is lighter and shifted in hue, while the eyes are brighter in saturation. Legion is also just a few inches taller than Syn’s 7’01” (215.4 cm), and it is known Syn’s own synergy stone will grow to consume his body as time goes on due to its exponential needs. Like the overall post, it’s less the individual similarities and much more-so the combination of everything that makes me exceedingly uncomfortable. It feels to me that they copied every trait that distinguishes Syn from his canon Pokkén Tournament counterpart.
- First concept of Syn’s and the Seaside cast’s stripes as draw-overs and phone sketches, dated 21-23 February 2023:
- Concept of Syn’s stripes first posted to tumblr (pre-shadow Syn without hs name attached) by me on 8 March 2023: https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/711268926528552960/oh-gods-theres-three-of-them-oh-noooo
- Seaside cast official stripe release posted by me on 11 April 2023: https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/714334567478214657/thank-you-everyone
- Syn’s first ref with stripes posted on tumblr 9 September 2023 (image shown is a version closer to what it was at the time dated 11 December 2023, I’ve made a few edits and updates on the actual post since then since then!): https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/728049113586925568/behold
https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/736455927217127424/since-people-apparently-draw-my-idiot-way-more
- Evidence of Syn’s specific Synergy lore, including the reasoning behind his grey sclerae, posted to tumblr by me on 12 December 2022: https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/703495870447042560/syn-id-like-to-know-more-about-him
- Syn’s true ending [WARNING for body horror and crystal growth], posted to tumblr by me on 28 February 2023, before he got his stripes and the Mewtwonite X blue in his Synergy stone: https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/710537824396574720/tw-crystal-growth-body-horror-forgot-about-this
[No image due to graphic and potentially sensitive content]
- First post of Legion by @/mewtwoandme on tumblr dated 6 September 2023: https://www.tumblr.com/mewtwoandme/727718432968261632/i-uhi-may-have-done-a-thing-yesterday-so-i
The Mega Evolution Panel:
This is what made Mush finally make his post. It feels like the same panel, only with a few things made different such as the head being turned the other way, the fingers being closed into fists, etc., along with the expected difference in artstyle. My panel looks similar to the canon mega evolution sequence from the games because I used it as reference, especially for the preceding panel with the orb thing. Even so, Sivith's legs are angled the way Six's are moreso than the canon sprite.
- Frames from the canon Mega Mewtwo Y animation in the Generation VI Pokémon games:
- My panel of Six’s mega evolution first posted on 15 December 2023 (bonus original sketch!): https://www.tumblr.com/seasidemew/736760488521777152/prev-first-next
- WIP posted to tumblr by @/mewtwoandme on 8 March 2024: https://www.tumblr.com/mewtwoandme/744436899811360768/let-the-carnage-begin-yes-yes-im-still-slowly
- @/mewtwoandme’s panel of Siv’s mega evolution [WARNING for graphic infanticide in full comic page] first posted to tumblr on 12 July 2024: https://www.tumblr.com/mewtwoandme/755840287223480320/warning
- Comparisons of both panels with one another and canon material, @/mewtwoandme’s feels closer to the game source when flipped around entirely IMO:
I am at my image limit, so that's all, folks. I really don't want this to become a whole thing. I just wanted to show my perspective and how Mush and I both got to this point of discomfort.
Edits: Again, it is not any individual thing or detail that is worse than the others, even in each case; it is the combination of all things establishing a pattern that makes us feel this is targeted and intentional. I genuinely hope we are wrong.
Added a section I cut to move and forgot to paste back in
Added link for the specific image of 2023 Syn I used
If you made it this far, thank you for reading!