Today I saw someone notice the pro-Israel throughline in The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, and it made me think about a few things.
1. Shit has been hinted at since season 1. Overt in season 5. Yeah. Midge and her family, like many Jewish families in America, especially during that time, were Pro-Israel*. I admit, when I watched the season 5 scene set in what I presume was the West Bank, I cringed.
It didn't line up with my worldview and what I hoped would be Midge's. But I kind of knew. Because...
2. Midge's politics have always been about what benefits and suits Midge. While she can be giving and caring, we know she also has the frequent capacity to be deeply self-centered. So it wasn't surprising that she was accepting an award in Israel. It suited her wants and needs. This is pretty common for ASP characters. Is it a good thing? I don'tthink it is.
3. The fact that no one pointed this out with season one, when Noah and Astrid talked about their many trips to Israel, is indicative of a gentile audience who didn't start thinking about Israel at all until October 7th. So welcome, I guess, to the existential crisis I keep having.
4. The Lenny of it all: the real Lenny had a deeply ingrained sense of justice (something irl Lenny shamed other jews for lacking. Which i feel in my guts sonetimes), and was very to the left for the era he lived in. He criticized Israel for not speaking up when the Rosenberg's were executed in the 50s (I assume because he was against the death penalty). It makes me wonder about how that would have looked had we gotten more time with fictional Lenny in season five, and the friction that may have popped up when bumping against Midge's indifference.
Anyways. The existential crisis of being Jewish in this moment in history continues. Please do not yell at me in the comments.
*I've stopped using the word Zionist because too many people are just using it to mean "dirty jew" and have a way to argue that that's "not what they meant." š
















