I was confused on Jax’s reaction at first.
When Pomni put the bucket on Kinger’s head, I just figured that Jax didn’t like Caine talking about C&A because a business causing this would make the situation too realistic.
But on rewatch, I saw that he actually started squirming a bit earlier.
“What is going on right now?”
I thought his reaction here was pretty weird. Like yeah, Kinger can talk normally in the dark. Everyone in the group immediately understood and started listening. Except for Jax.
Because Kinger just broke the script.
“Like it or not, all we are now is a bunch of cartoon characters.”
“We’re still people though, right?”
“I thought we were at first, but… as time goes on we just end up falling into our archetypes.”
“Kinger’s the crazy one…”
“Wait, the bucket makes him sane?”
He wasn’t just reacting to the C&A “adventure” being based on real life. He’s reacting to his script, his read of the situation, being broken actively.
Jax’s theory has been supported regularly, Ragatha constantly pushing a positive attitude, Zooble being grumpy, and even Gangle’s sad mask (he literally breaks her happy mask to reinforce his coping mechanism). Kinger was probably the most consistently archetypical “character” in the circus. And now his role is being undeniably shattered. Not only that, but it’s being shattered with more proof that the circus is full of real people.
“Just fill me in afterwards.”
Jax’s coping mechanism is essentially metaphysical solipsism. No one else here is real except for him, thus, he can do whatever he wants. Doing whatever he wants is one coping mechanism; controlling the world. Believing that the entire circus is meant to be predictable, cartoonish, and entirely fictional is the other coping mechanism: justifying that control.
He doesn’t seem to fully believe it (hence his grief over Ribbit and Kaufmo), but rather he forces himself to believe it. Because otherwise, he’d have to
- recognize that everything is real, so his situation isn’t a “funny cartoon thing,” it’s an active issue
- come to terms with the fact that he’s stuck like this forever and it really isn’t funny
- reckon with the consequences of his actions
- stop controlling the people around him for peace of mind
- or continue to do so with the awareness that he’s fully being a horrible person
“Oh my God. This is real.”
Kinger showing his sanity diminishes the entire basis for Jax’s denial.
And now he has to face his situation head-on.