Having two kids close together (18 months apart) has created such a conundrum for me when considering whether or not to have more children.
Next month, my oldest turns 3 and my youngest turns 1.5. Now that my oldest is speaking in full sentences and my youngest is walking, both my husband and I have been feeling more tempted by the idea of having more children. We are on the same page that if we have more, we will likely be done at 3 kids and 4 kids would be our max.
The conundrum comes in with the fact that because our first two are so close in age, they have such a close bond and they will really be able to āgrow up togetherā since they will be in such similar stages of life and development. This is something that I want for all of my children as, in contrast, I was 6 years apart from my middle sister and 12 years apart from my youngest sister and I know from experience that large age gaps can make it harder to forge strong sibling bonds. My husband, on the other hand, is 1.5 years older than his middle sister and 3 years older than his youngest sister and they all are really close. Yes, I know that some people are really close to siblings they have a big age gap with and some people arenāt close with siblings they are close in age with, but generally speaking I think it is more common and likely that youāre going to be close to someone who is only 2 years older/younger than you rather than someone who is 6 years older/younger than you.
Two pregnancies close together was challenging and with spending the last year and half in the trenches of having two very young children with no family around to help, I havenāt had the bandwidth to focus on restrengthening my body through consistent exercise. I also am committed to extended breastfeeding and plan to continue breastfeeding my youngest until she is 2-2.5 yrs. My body is not in the best position to get pregnant again so soon and I donāt want to have to stop breastfeeding my youngest due to my milk drying up because of pregnancy. Given those considerations, I likely wouldnāt be ready to get pregnant again for another year, meaning the age gap between my current youngest and a new baby, assuming I got pregnant a year from now, would be a little over 3 years.
Since my oldest two are so close in age, I would feel a bit guilty if we had a 3rd and they forever felt left out of the closeness that their older siblings share. As far as the sibling bond goes, my husband and I both like the idea of having another two about a year and a half apart so that we have two sets of kids close in age with a bigger age gap in the middle. HOWEVER, having already had 2 under 2, I know how demanding that is on me and I fear that it would be doing a disservice to my older two children to have another two kids close together. I worry that I may not be able to show up for them in the way they need if I am absorbed in having another toddler and baby. And because of my commitment to extended breastfeeding, I would do what I did with my older two and tandem nurse that I donāt have to wean the oldest of the two new babies too soon (in case the math isnāt clear, in order to have babies 18 months apart, you have to get pregnant with the second baby at 9 months postpartum, and there is no way that I want to wean before a year). Having been there and done that, I know how draining tandem nursing can be and, again, I worry about how I would handle it with two older kids to also take care of.
Given the many practical considerations, including things I havenāt even mentioned but also play apart in the decision makingā finances, having to get a bigger car, room arrangements, etc., sometimes I think that we should just stop while we are ahead and stick with two kids. Then I start to think about how many times Iāve heard stories or seen videos of middle aged or elderly people talking about how they wish that they had more children while they had a chance. The time of our life when we can have children is finite and fleeting. My husband and I are already going to be 30 (me) and 35 (my husband) this summer. As much as I worry over the challenges of having more kids, I equally worry over living with the regret of not having more and letting my decision to only have two be dictated by fear.











