Based on everything you know about the character, do you think Eddie is as hot headed and angry as the fandom makes him out to be, or is he made out to be that way because of the 2017 adaption?
Hmmm. Hot-headed, yes. Angry, no.
In the novel, Eddie is definitely sweeter and more soft-spoken than he is in the 2017 movie, but he still cannot keep his mouth shut most of the time. The main difference is that book!Eddie is much more naive and gullible, which makes him idealistic… which in turn gets him into trouble sometimes because he speaks up when things don’t seem fair. I wouldn’t say he gets angry, though. He’s just very passionate. He wants the world to be good, so he gets frustrated with perceived injustices. He’s extremely empathetic and intuitive, which makes him more introspective. He spends more time reflecting on his feelings and the feelings and motives of those around him than most of the other characters do, but that’s something that would be very hard to get across on screen. His hot-headedness mostly comes into play during moments of adrenaline - when he’s fighting with Henry, for example, and when the group is battling IT. During those moments, he gets louder, he swears more, he eggs people on, but those moments are important in the narrative because they AREN’T typical. Eddie is very emotional, but he’s FAR from mean-spirited, and his emotions are usually not channeled into anger or annoyance. For the most part, he’s not losing his shit every five minutes, which is how he’s sometimes portrayed.
There are a lot of things Andy/Jack got right about Eddie in the 2017 film. He’s a shitty liar, he has a lot of half-true “medical facts” in his arsenal that he thinks he’s an expert on, he’s scared of his mom, and when he panics he REALLY panics. He’s super talkative and inquisitive, too. There are moments in the movie that really accurately reflect book!Eddie, imo - like when the group is at the park talking about what they each saw, a lot of the background interactions between him and Richie that are more subdued (like when they’re in Ben’s bedroom), the projector scene, and when he’s frantically running around the sewers trying to keep the group together. It’s just that those moments are more lowkey and subtle compared to a lot of the ‘comic relief’ filler-banter between him and Richie, which paints him as more angry/irritable.
One thing I’m not a big fan of in the movie is how Richie and Eddie’s banter can be construed as kind of mean-spirited, UNLESS you go into it already knowing what their relationship is like. I think that’s the main thing that has sort of falsely bled into fandom - that Eddie sees Richie as this annoying pest, wants him to shut up all the time, makes fun of him, etc. It’s sort of created this too-common and strange fandom dynamic where Richie has to be constantly wooing a perpetually annoyed Eddie, which… makes sense if it is an AU where they have never met before, or a canon divergence where they do not remember each other and Richie has to kind of chip away at Eddie’s walls all over again. But in their established dynamic in the novel, that is not the case AT ALL.
As kids, Eddie deeply admires Richie and laughs at his jokes and Voices all the time, even when they aren’t very good. He never says ‘beep beep’, except for once as an adult, and he only really seriously talks back to Richie when he thinks he’s being too mean (like when he’s making fun of Stan’s religion too much). Otherwise, it’s playful banter and half-hearted attempts to make him stop calling him Eds and saying he’s cute, despite secretly enjoying the attention. He’s just as obsessed with Richie as Richie is with him, he’s just more introspective about it, which again, is difficult to get across in a film adaptation.
Basically my point is that Eddie is emotional but not constantly angry or annoyed. He’s a very nuanced character with a lot of depth and a high capacity for empathy that does not come across very well in the movie, though Jack did a great job with what he was given. I think it’s pretty impossible to understand him completely without reading the book, but that goes for all of the characters. So I always encourage everyone to read the book, at least certain parts of it (the chapter Eddie’s Bad Break is a great place to get a lot of insight into him).