GO Fan Fiction Friday - 24 July 2026 - Agnes Nutter
When I first read Good Omens, I adored Agnes Nutter (the name is an utter dream). When I saw that the funny and sexy Josie Lawrence had been cast to play her in the television show, I was even more smitten.
Agnes crops up in a lot of fics. But a few stories centered on her stand out. Let's start with the fic that inspired this list.
Marginalia: The Nice & Accurate Story of Agnes Nutter (M) by @dbacklot99 tells the story of Agnes Nutter beginning with her childhood. Told through the POV of her closest friend, Cora. It's a touching story, and well worth a read. I've recommended it before and will keep sharing it because I believe it is criminally neglected by the fandom. Out of the thousands of fics I've read, it ranks among the very best.
In The Extraordinary Haunting of A. Z. Fell and Co (M) by @tawnyontumblr, a book collector acquires a 17th century book of prophecy, along with a ghost set on vengeance. Once the ghost discovers Fell is attracted to the barista across the road, he'll never get a moment's peace.
@thisisshiny's Jasmine Cottage (M) tells the story of a historical botanist (specializing in poisonous plants) and an antiquarian bookseller who jointly inherit a cottage from a distant relative (Agnes Nutter). The only catch is that they must stay there together one weekend each month or the property reverts to the National Trust. Unfortunately (or maybe, fortunately), Agnes's cottage is sentient and makes its opinions known.
Endless Night (T) by AppleSeeds, Crowley finds himself stuck in a time loop that resets every four hours while celebrating Halloween with his uni friends in a cottage. His guide through the process is the spirit of his friend Anathema's dead ancestor, who helps him figure out that the only way to break the loop is to make the man he's been pining after, happy.
The Nutter Curse: An Epistolary Romance (T) by @bohoteacher and @thinkinginscripts has Agnes's actions affecting people long after she's gone. While researching Agnes Nutter, Aziraphale writes to Anthony Crowley, a descendent of a family in which all the men are cursed by the witch. We get an interesting look at the reason for the curse while learning more about how it plays out in Crowley's life (as well as the possibility of breaking it.)
In Somewhere Between the Pages (T) by @eybefioro and @itsscottiesstark, Crowley travels to Edinburgh to attend the first ever book signing by his favorite author, Agnes Nutter. He ends up waiting in line behind a friend he hasn't seen in years. Agnes plays a small role in this story, but it's a charming one.
Finally, in Stuck on You (E) by Zin_Lynn, our angel and demon seek the help of the last true witch in England when a drunken hand fasting goes awry. They find themselves unable to stop touching each other.
Are you an Agnes fan? If you have other faves, please reblog and share them or add them in the comments.
Remember to thank our wonderful writers by leaving kudos and comments. They work so hard to bring us hours of entertainment. Let me know how important they are to us.
I'll be back next week with another list of fics on a theme. Subscribe so you never miss out. You can find a link to every list I've created since 2024 on the post pinned at the top of this blog.
