âUltimately, the diagnosis was retained by DSM-5, but its name was changed to Gender Dysphoria (GD), simultaneously removing the stigmatizing ââdisorderââ from its name and shifting the focus to dysphoria as the target symptom for intervention and treatment, rather than gender identity itself.â
âGender incongruence (GI) refers to the feeling that the physical characteristics of the body are not in line with the experienced gender. This may (in the case of gender dysphoria) or may not be accompanied by distress.â
âAs times and cultural attitudes change, so have beliefs about what constitutes a mental disorder. [âŠ] it is not unthinkable that people transitioning from one gender to another might be treated by medical specialists who, like obstetricians, use their interventions to facilitate what society considers to be a normal life event.â
âOver the years, terminology has frequently been changed. If identities or behaviours are not in line with a personâs natal sex, we will use the term âgender incongruentâ; âtransgenderâ will be used as an umbrella term to refer to all kinds of phenomena related to gender incongruence. [âŠ] If a person experiences distress resulting from incongruence between gender identity and assigned gender (which happens usually at birth), this person is gender dysphoric.â
âAnother diagnostic exclusion factor was the clinically significant distress or social impairment criterion that must be met for a positive diagnosis in both the DSM-5 (Criteria B) and the ICD-10 (Criteria D). However, among health professionals who assist transgender people, it is understood that the anxiety and inadequacy felt by transsexuals is mainly a result of the conflict between the individualâs and societyâs moral values, which is also the source of the prejudice and social stigma to which they are culturally exposed. It is believed that in some families and social contexts, transgender people can be protected from prejudice and, consequently, from social suffering.â
âIt is clear that the decision on the DSM- or ICD-categorization of GIVs cannot be achieved on a purely scientific basis. Instead, scientific issues need to be considered in combination with the service needs of persons with GIVs and the psychosocial implications of DSM formulations for such persons, when one works towards a consensus among stakeholders regarding a pragmatic compromise.â
âBy 1975, transvestite/transsexual groups began using ââtransgenderismââ as a term inclusive of transsexuals and transvestites. In 1979, 1982, and 1985, Christine Jorgensen, then perhaps the worldâs most famous transsexual, publicly rejected the term transsexual in favor of the term transgender. In 1984, TV-TS Tapestry magazine featured an article recounting the importance of a ââtransgender community,ââ in which ââtransgenderââ was used as an umbrella term inclusive of transsexuals and cross-dressers. By the mid-1980s, ââtransgenderââ had been used multiple timesâin medical, pop-culture, and trans community sources alikeâas an umbrella term inclusive of transsexuals, crossdressers, and other gender-variant people.â
âImportantly, the term used in the source literature and by advocates of excluding gender dysphoria from diagnostic classification is a some what broader gender variance (GV), which is considered less pathologizing than either gender identity disorder or gender dysphoria.â
(Note: Text hyperlinked to posts that should have citations. Since I composed this on mobile it was quicker to do it that way.)
Awww shoot I got so close. Just to breifly explain I just went through my blog for resources I tagged for subjects like thisâtbh I was getting a lil excited there because I wasnât expecting to actually find 10 sources because after I note something the first few times I start to ignore taking note of it when it shows up in further readings.
Anyways I am not gonna hunt down a tenth referenceâI wasnât even following the âââcriteriaâââ for that anyways. I just wanted to have a little fun and actually see if I had 10 references related to this at all.
Itâs not strictly empirical data/medical practice, there is a mix of history/linguistics (again I wasnât following the criteria, I was just quickly grabbing what I had indexed for reference purposes) but I donât think that is an issue because I think the misunderstanding is linguistically based.
Hereâs the the summation of what I am trying to get at with the list of quotes:
Transgender is an colloquial umbrella termâit has been for decades. It emcompasses everyone gender incongruent/gender varriant.
Gender dysphoria is (1) negative gender varriant experinces or (2) a DSM defined diagnosis
Gender dysphoria was defined to help a certain demographic of transpeople get access to resources with insurance coverage.
Gender dysphoria is not a synonym for Transgender. Trangender is an identity. Gender Dysphoria is a diagnosis that focuses on distress that experince causes some trans people.
Being transgender is not a medical conditionâas in a condition that needs to be cured. Gender Dysphoriaâsevere distress that might accompany being transgenderâis a medical conditionm. Doctors want to cure Gender Dysphoria. Doctors donât want to cure a Transgender Identity.
Case and point: You need Gender Dysphoria to haveâŠ. Gender dysphoria.
Anyways as I think about it, maybe a bunch of the hostility from transmeds is from wanting social support for gender dysphoria specifically and thinking that is the same as wanting to connect to trans people in general??? Iâm just speculating here, but it kinda reminds me of people with major depression getting pissed off at people with adjustment disorder when they say, âIâm depressed.â Maybe they should make Gender Dysphoria support groups, instead of running around griping that all the general trans spaces get taken over by non-dysphorics/non-dysphoric supporters. People might already do that though. Idkâjust speculating.
Back on topicâŠ. depending on your situation you might need gender dysphoria to be able to transition (because without insurance it is finacially unachievavle in your personal situation), but that doesnât mean you need gender dysphoria to be trans.
AnywaysâIâm gonna @ you â @bitten-tongue666 â so you can see this. I was gonna jokingly say âbe respectful because I respected you and got 10 sourcesâ if I actually managed to quickly fetch 10 but even if I did I kinda doubt you would manage to be civil from what Iâve seen of your posts. Canât hurt to ask though.
Also I am interested in your references that directly imply, âTo have a transgender identity you need gender dysphoria,â because Iâve never seen academic literature that directly states that. I donât really need 20 sources. And gonna be frank and say I hope you donât just have a list of articles studying gender dysphoria or reviewing gender dysphoria treatmentâŠ. because the argument isnât whether or not gender dysphoria existsâeven as a socially constructed medical diagnosis it is a very much a reality for the people who have to live with it. Like Iâve seen a lot of transmeds just provide proof that scientistics study gender dysphoria and trans neurology, but the articles did not connect the dots the transmeds said were connected and when I asked them to point out where it is if Iâm wrongâthey just yelled their heads off silly with like âââ'I GAVE YOU EVIDENCEâââââŠ. (me: âbut ur first claim isnât in this evidence and ur second claim was it wasâŠ.â///them: âblllaaarrrggg!!!!â)
Idk if I would agree if your provided sources because it would just be overwriting that transgender has already meant something different for decades. But it would be interesting to seeâespecially since the DSM workgroup has stated that gender dysphoria was defined to manage and treat distress, not defined to define transgender. But heyâwhatever~~~ Hit me up.