Okay so this is just… wrong. It’s wrong. The question this person was asking is why Luke Skywalker isn’t as culturally popular like Anakin, Obi-Wan, Padme, etc.
For one, the main reason is this generation grew up on the prequels not the originals. This generation immediately attaches to the prequel trilogy because of this. Additionally, Luke barely has any content… ever. He had 3 movies that doesn’t have enough lightsaber battles or flashy battle scenes to hook a lot of the close minded fans in. The next 2 movies ruin his character completely. No fucking wonder Luke isn’t popular anymore.
Two, Is Luke NOT supposed to have flaws? Ah yes he must be this perfect person who never makes mistakes and always does whats right. Sounds like a Gary Stu… Disney tried that and look what happened to Rey. People HATE her including me. She’s probably the weakest protagonist in all of star wars. Most people in Luke’s position would have done the same or worse… but go off i guess.
Luke’s overpowered? OVERPOWERED? He could barely use the force in empire strikes back, lost against Vader in ESB and lost his HAND. He literally had to access the dark side to defeat Vader. He is FAR from being oVerPoWeRed. Also did we forget when he failed to save Han?
Luke IS a underdog thats the whole point. He’s a farmboy trying to topple down a empire and two sith lords who have decades of years of experience. Luke is way over his head. All of the odds are stacked AGAINST him. But ah yes Luke is a overpowered whiny farmboy who isn’t this cool, flirtatious guy so he is a bad character.
Please shut up. Some people like heroes that can actually inspire them. Absolutely no hate to Han, he’s great.
Okay, hold the hell up here. I’m sorry, I have to add some comments here, please, no offense but I have to talk about what you excerpted here @princealderann because I agree with you and I cannot believe those other comments.
Luke isn’t as culturally popular as Obi Wan, Anakin or Padme?
In what UNIVERSE is this true? Because it sure as hell isn’t anywhere I hang out. That person needs to go on Twitter and see people so excited if Mark Hamill makes any contact with them! Maybe in the circles they run in, but not in the wider universe. CF the reaction to that cameo.
Then I read the rest of it and I think “what OT did that person watch” and I give up. When you start telling me that Luke made a dumb decision in Empire (if he doesn’t make that decision, he’s not a hero) or that he’s overpowered and not interesting in Jedi, you’re telling me that you don’t get Star Wars at all. If you’re also telling me that Han and Leia have the more interesting story in Jedi, where most if not all Han and Leia fans will tell you they got the absolute shaft storywise?
I give up.
(edited to add - “we grew up” is THE MOST INFURIATING THING. I hate it with the fire of a thousand suns (or nuns, as we used to say on Television Without Pity)
I agree with all of the above.
But like....I can’t get past the part where this muppet with room temperature IQ is trying to spin the possibility of the stormtroopers confiscating the droids as a good thing.That alone is enough to tell you this halfwit isn’t worth the time it takes to type up a response to their headache-inducing garbage.























