MUSIC IN MMXV: A RETROSPECTIVE AND COUNTDOWN
It seems like everywhere I turn, music is just falling from the trees, wafting from the heating vents, pulsating out of car windows as the drivers pass by. By now, as the year draws to a close, and the cold season is now in full swing, the soundtrack of today has become as colorful as the foliage dusting the city streets in golden red leaves. Despite being somewhat of a slow burn at the start, two thousand and fifteen, MMXV, has been hell-bent on overloading me with information. Many of my favorite musical acts all came back this year, releasing LPs, EPs, singles, music videos, and heading out on the road. The middle of September marked a change in the weather, and what followed was a cavalcade of good music that quickly made up for lost time. MMXIII was the year of âdo what-the-fuck-ever,â MMXIV was the year of hidden gems discovered late, and MMXV, I say, is the year of confidence. With that I give you a retrospect of the music I heard this year, the good, the bad, and the ugly.
All releases are ranked according to my feelings on the records at the time of this pieceâs publication. As Iâve been able to sit with some previously reviewed releases for a bit more time, scores may not represent their initial standings. Each albumâs numerical score is tallied by adding together the scores for each individual song (out of 5) and then averaged out. Any score with a (+X) integer means that the score has been rounded according to its success as a record.
Before we begin, here is a list of honorable mentions that unfortunately did not make the cut for various reasons (listed on their banners), but they are all very much worth a listen.
With the unexpected dramatic Eastern sample at the start of Fan of a Fan, the producers trick the listener into thinking this album is going to be somewhat good. Well, thatâs unfair. For the most part, the producers do a pretty good job with the material on this albumâthe issue is clearly the two idiot headlining stars, who have penned some of the laziest, dumbest, and most sexist lyrics to be found in an age where sexism generally isnât selling very well. Between Chris Brown over-singing about sex (or potential date rape, on some of these songsââIâm about to get up on that ass right nowâŠâ) and Tygaâs horrible rhyming skills, Fan of a Fan is a true travesty. Something akin to typhus. Lyrically, the album is 85% bad pick-up lines and 25% blatant crassness. The issue with Brown and Tygaâs approach to sexuality is that itâs entirely negative. Itâs about them and their pleasure, their needs, their unbridled libido regardless of how it is received: âYou should have left her in the kitchen.â Itâs wholly classless and lame. Despite some catchy hooks and thick beats here and there, the lyrics of this thing just totally destroy any potential it had. Nearly every song has the same theme and formulaâbut the two still had the audacity to put a love song amidst the sexist trash. A good friend of mine whoâs passionate about equal rights and gender equality made a lovely observation about this albumâit is soaked from head to toe in generic hip-hop, the kind of music that proves people right about its musical integrity: âI will give this hypothetical woman 1,000 compliments about her beauty and sexuality, but only on my terms.â Itâs sad that this is ruining the legacy of an otherwise complicated and diverse genre. If youâre going to rap about sex and how super-cool-fly-awesome-dope-and-whatever you are, do it with some finesse and skill. Go talk to Angel Haze and learn about the genre youâre dealing in. I cared so little for this record that I donât even care about the bannerâs spelling error. Meh.
With mainstream pop music in such a confused state that itâs the human equivalent of a dim-witted young child continually eating bakerâs chocolate, itâs difficult not to outright despise a good deal of it. Despite standards of audio quality and production at an all-time low, at least MMXVâs pop scene has started asking the talent in question to actually be able to sing, or at least have something to say. Both can be said for Meghan Trainor, whose big hit âAll About That Bassâ became the most overplayed song of the last two years. Trainor followed up that songâs success with Title, an album that does not just pay homage to its 1960s influences, but downright rips them off. Title suffers from a lack of charm and class. The annoying, loudmouthed personality found on âBassâ is found on almost every other song of this record, and is in rare form on garbage like âLips Keep Movinââ and âDear Future Husband.â Trainor, a self-confessed non-feminist, has certainly done a lot to make women in pop music look like bimbos, and even if she has a lovely singing voice, itâs not enough to save Title from being stuck within the confines of her gimmicks. The songs are bad, the hooks are lame, and Meghan Trainor is the annoying girl at the party that nobody actually invited. And she brought her fucking guitar with her.
Once Björk began writing nonsense lyrics in order to pander to the artsy-fartsy crowd, I knew it was over. Once she decided to create an entire album made of a cappella throat noises, I knew she was jumping the shark. And once she worked with Timbaland, I gave up hope. Which is why Vulnicura, in particular, angers me. When I heard a part of the albumâs opener, the orchestral and somber âStonemilker,â I thought Björk was coming back, stepping away from the pretentious heights of MedĂčlla, Volta, and the abysmal Biophilia. Unfortunately, I was wrong. Very wrong. Although she doesnât dabble too much in her usual cut-and-paste approach to music production on this album, Vulnicura just proves to me that Björk is out of ideas. This is her big divorce album, its narrative telling the story of the break-up with long-time romantic and professional partner Matthew Barney, beginning with the moments leading up to the end. With a smaller tracklist and an album cover featuring a chest wound modeled into the shape of a molten vagina, Vulnicura is supposed to be fantastic, and her label very much wants you to think so, too. It is supposed to be amazing. It is supposed to be Björk. But, unfortunately for me, this album is what Tori Amosâs Unrepentant Geraldines was in MMXIV: so bad that it pushes beyond the borders of merely being disappointing. The songs lack melody, cohesion, focus, and artistry. They play randomly, and they drip like a collection of leftover material from previous works. Björkâs material post-2004 is best left in the trash bin.
Woof. This album is an old dirty mutt with rabies. Just shoot it and put it out of its misery. All of the potential Imagine Dragons has as a rock bandâand that potential is thereâis drowned out by the effect that studio polish and mainstream success can have on newly successful bands. This is something that tends to happen to acts who can offer something new to the pop music scene and are picked up by a major label. This is also why somebody like Alanis Morissette was met with confused reactions when she released the sprawling mess that was Supposed Former Infatuation Junkieâand itâs also why manufactured pop stars and singers end up doing more interesting music once they step outside the confines of their labelâs stranglehold. So really, the over-production on Smoke + Mirrors implies that Imagine Dragons is a good band caught up in their celebrity at the moment, suffering under the weight of massive pressure set by the need to perform wellâfor themselves, for the fans, and for their record label. Unfortunately for those who enjoyed the lean, smart, and slick pop of Night Visions, this is merely a consolation prize, as Smoke + Mirrors is still overblown, poorly executed, and exhausting to listen to. Most of the good ideas on this album are drowned out by the noise, compression, and studio gimmicks running amok. And to think people are listening to an album like this through Apple iPhone earbuds, transcoded from a YouTube video clip. This is the future of mainstream music production, people, and itâs not prettyâŠ
Iâm not sure I know enough about Will Young to understand 85% Proof. Or maybe itâs just that I find the material on this album nowhere near as inspired or interesting as what one will find on his previous effort Echoes. But what really irks me about this album is the way it is presented. All of the worst material is right up front. The triple punch of âBrave Man,â âPromise Me,â and the vintage-soul-inspired âLove Revolutionâ left me unsatisfiedâshocked, in fact, at how unfinished these songs sounded. Itâs not that there arenât good ideas hereâitâs just that the album feels rather under-baked. It rides on the coattails of its productionâBritish soul music blended with modern boy-band popâand thatâs actually a very nice combination of sounds. Youngâs voice is in nice form, and he emotes and performs the songs very well. Unfortunately, much of the albumâs content is flat and missing a memorable hook to keep it in my mind. Thereâs an argument that not every good song needs to have a hook, but every good pop song will, and Will Young sings pop music. The slower songs on this LP hit harder than most of the upbeat stuff, and while not all is lost on 85% Proof, itâs really nowhere close to being a good record.
I refrained from writing a full review of this album because I know my boys can do better. Never fearing the unknown, having already experimented with acoustic rock, grunge, rap, and disco, Duran Duran donât need to try anymore. With highly palatable albums like All You Need is Now, Astronaut, the misunderstood Red Carpet Massacre, and the dark Pop Trash, their limitless lack of fear is what has allowed the band to endure for over thirty years. But with Paper Gods, Duran Duran lost the ground beneath them and stumbled head-on into a brick wall. The boys are no stranger to funk and nu-disco, two genres theyâve done very well with in the past, which makes this album all the more confusing. While I can forgive bad productionâand believe me, it is a brickwalled, compressed messâI cannot forgive bad songwriting, and much of the material on this album is faceless and dull. âLast Night in the Cityâ may be one of the absolute worst songs Iâve ever heard, nonetheless on this album, and âYou Kill Me with Silenceâ Xeroxes its melody from The Scriptâs âFalling to Pieces.â While there are some nice momentsâlike the lead single âPressure Off,â which features the albumâs only decent production workâPaper Gods is this yearâs unexpected bomb.
Madonna. The name just stirs up so many feelings in me: joy, love, respect, excitement⊠frustration. Throughout her thirty-year career, Madonna has had her peaks and brief lows, but sheâs always pulled it off at the end of the day. The way she navigates the pop scene has made her a median that separates the good from the bad. But beginning in 2012 with the unfinished and poorly-received album MDNA, the cracks in her confident façade have begun to fall away. Many would argue this truly began with 2008âs Hard Candy. With MDNA and Rebel Heart, Madonna proved she could put in little effort and still get a big payoffâin terms of both positive reviews from music professionals and the adoration of fans. But while I enjoy a great deal of the fun pop jams on this thingââDevil Pray,â âRebel Heart,â âWash All Over MeââRebel Heart still spells trouble in Madonna-land for anybody who really knows her career inside and out. The confidence and self-awareness she had during her Bedtime Stories era, the professional attitude on Confessions on a Dance Floor, the creativity of her Erotica albumâall of that has been tossed out the window on Rebel Heart, which very openly and honestly panders to the people who long for the return of Blond Ambition: crucifixes, sex, soft-core pornography, and swearing. All the energy and creativity she put into her Rebel Heart Tourâwhich features dancers on flexible stilts, a murder sequence, a Parisian night club with one dancer dressed as Josephine Baker, and a recreation of the Last Supperâshould have been put into making this record a stunner. Sadly, itâs all bad production and some truly embarrassing musical mistakes that should have been deleted in the studio (âBitch Iâm Madonna,â âIlluminatiâ). Although Rebel Heart is enjoyable for what it is, I hope she never releases another album like this one or MDNA again.
What Hilary Duff lacks in artistry she makes up for in simplicity. Her music is a great example of how far one can take sincerity and a positive attitude. She first caught my attention with her previous LP Dignity, to which she contributed a lot of the songwriting, so it was only natural for me to anxiously await Breathe In. Breathe Out.âthe return of a pop singer who I feel is quite underrated. There was good news and bad news to be had with this album, though. The bad news? Duff wrote very little of this album herself, and as a result, it plays as a less personal effort in comparison to the angry, sassy, sexy cuts on Dignity (âDanger,â âGypsy Woman,â âStrangerâ). The good news? Duff is an excellent pop curator, and she has assembled a list of studio tracks that fit her overall narrative: surviving a divorce. While she has some no-boys-girls-only moments on this album, the record attempts to focus more on Duffâs recovery after heartbreak. âSparks,â which some have called the sleeper hit of the year and her best single overall, is the perfect summer jam, one that epitomizes the good vibes from a girlsâ night out. This is followed by rebound anthem âMy Kindâ before we get into some sadder territory. âArms Around a Memoryâ and the title track push Duff into a more somber space, her voice accurately playing the part of sad (but not that sad) pop princess. Duff is a mom now. Sheâs an actress focusing on her career, and sheâs an Instagram superstar. The joy in her music reflects that, and Breathe In. Breathe Out. is pop music made for pop lovers who arenât satisfied by what Justin Bieber and will.i.am have to offer.
Itâs difficult to discuss Marilyn Manson as a band, because its namesake and creative energy lives and dies with their charismatic frontman. The love child of David Bowie and Madonna, Manson made quite a name for himself in the 1990s. Heâs been simultaneously hailed as a genius and as the worst thing to happen to American youth since the draft. But amongst all the noise and controversy, Manson and his Spooky Kids released some of the most interesting art-rock ever recorded with Mechanical Animals, Holy Wood, and The Golden Age of Grotesque. But then came the greatest hits collection Lest We Forget, and it signaled a shift in musical direction and confidence for the group, as retrospectives often do. Just as The Immaculate Collection draws a very clear line between Madonna in the 1980s and Madonna post-cone-bra, Lest We Forget was the end of Manson: Stage 2, the sleek and rebellious outfit who actually had something interesting to say. What followed were three miserable albums that rested on their laurels: Nazi imagery for funsies, loud industrial beats, and lame lyrics. It was mostly a collection of songs packaged for the Hot Topic crowd. The Pale Emperor had all the makings of being the fourth album in a row to disappoint me, but for some reason it did just the opposite. Instead, it became an album of hope: hope that anybody can come back, no matter how far gone they may be. If Manson can scale back and cut out the bullshit, anybody can. And this album is thoroughly decent. Unlike Born Villain, there are not just glimpses of good ideas; no, these ideas were expertly executed. The troubling guitar work on âThird Day of a Seven Bingeâ and the drama of âWarship My Wrackâ blend with poignant social commentary like âKilling Strangers,â and add up to the return of Marilyn Manson: The Observer, the Conscience, the Social Mirror.
I encountered James McMurtryâs latest LP Complicated Game purely by chance. By using the music aggregator website Album of the Yearâs music rating system, I have been exposed daily to new albums to put on my âto-hearâ list. And for some reason, the âAmericanaâ tag attached to this album piqued my interest, particularly when combined with the recordâs very modern and subtle graphic design. What I was treated to was thoroughly decent, an album full of narrative poetry inspired by John Fogerty, Warren Zevon, and Bruce Springsteen. McMurtry, normally a very politically charged songwriter, got a bit more polished and less direct with Complicated Game. The melodies here are allowed to shine organically thanks to a lack of overproduction. While this album took longer to grow on me than some of the others on this list, Complicated Game has some lovely moments worthy of praise: in particular, the quiet âLong Island Sound.â The brief moments of pop on this album are interesting, although itâs clear McMurtry fares best when he allows himself the time to breathe. As a result, the opening track, âCopper Canteen,â soars to heights that his simpler material does not. Overall, this is a competent, professional album that proves one can step back from the ledge and still enjoy artistic success.
Singer-songwriter John Grantâs third LP is a grower. It did not hit my ears as skillfully as his previous effort Pale Green Ghosts, which is as close to perfect as perfect can get. That said, Grey Tickles, Black Pressure is a project that has grown on me considerably, its subtle pop hooks slowly finding their legs. This album does suffer from lack of focus, with the ever-moody Grant at odds with the sense of peace heâs finding in his personal life, and as a result, the angrier moments of this album donât feel as sincere or potent. There are also some ideas on this record that Grant has previously done better (âSnug Slacksâ is a very odd do-over of âBlack Beltâ from his last record). But the songs are still good at the end of the day. âBlack Blizzardâ and âGuess How I Knowâ marinate in their drama, their presentation and production bombastic, and âDown Hereâ shows that Grant still works well when working on a slower, calmer, and more atmospheric plane. Judged on its own merit, Grey Tickles is a collection of clever kiss-off tracks and tales from the middle of a mid-life crisisâbut unlike many mid-life crisis albums, on Grey Tickles, John Grant remains John Grant: humbled, ready to claw some eyes out, a bit giggly, and terribly sexy.
Of all the LPs on this list, Unbreakable, which marks the triumphant return of Janet Jackson, is the only one that rivals Richard Hawleyâs Hollow Meadows in regards to its self-awareness. Over time, Unbreakable has proven itself to be an album best listened to when one has the time to focus on the music. While there are some good party jams to be had (âDammn Babyâ and âBurnitup!â), Unbreakable also wades in deeper waters, drawing lyrical inspiration from Jacksonâs Rhythm Nation 1814 period, the plight of todayâs social climate, the death of her brother, and where the singer finds herself today. Even this far into her career, Jackson not only serves fans with a collection of welcomed, expected R&B and pop-inspired songs, but still finds the time to dabble and experiment. This is something she hasnât truly done musically since 1997âs The Velvet Rope, as her work between 2001 and 2008 stands huddled together under the same thematic and artistic umbrella. The thick urban production of âDammn Babyâ and the Minneapolis throwback âNightâ sit next to sexier cuts like âNo Sleeepâ and more somber, acoustic moments like âAfter the Fall.â While the album sprawls uncomfortably at times, the positive sides to Unbreakable far overshadow the brief missteps, and with this album, Jackson took herself out of the pop race Madonna is still trying to win. This is simply Janet Jackson, the singer, the songwriter, the R&B songstress, the dancer, the artist, the pop star. Take her or leave her.
The reemergence of new wave apostle Joe Jackson is something that can never truly be predicted. While he has steadily been releasing records with his name on them, itâs a crapshoot as to whether any given release will be a classical composition, pop music, a film soundtrack, or a covers album. Although it was his signature piano-pop sound that made him a superstar, it is his musical curiosity and love of sound that established him as a dark horse on the new wave scene. From the pop-punk sarcasm on Look Sharp! to his tribute to wartime-era jazz club tunes on Joe Jacksonâs Jumpinâ Jive, he always keeps his fans guessing, and it makes his album releases true events. With this yearâs Fast Forward, Jackson has written and assembled some of the most accessible and artistically successful pop tunes in over a decade. While he winks at the landmark 1982 album Night & Day, he jumps across genres in such a way that Fast Forward mirrors not only his hits, but also his more experimental work. Aside from one very unfortunate misstep in the anti-extremist protest song âIf I Could See Your Face,â the entirety of Fast Forward is a musical time machine accompanied by an incredible ear for melody. The center of the show is Jacksonâs voice, which hasnât aged a day, and he equips it to convey humor, romance, and interesting storytelling. It is a very welcome return for a man who truly has no need to prove himself.
The icy-wet sound of British singer-songwriter Seal is a far cry from the UK house scene he crawled out of. Much like Peter Gabriel, Sealâs discography is mostly self-titled, which means the spotlight is always on him and what he can do. These albums are, as Gabriel says, like magazine issues that focus on where the artist is at a given time in his or her life. After dabbling with cover albums, Seal is looking back in his broken mirror again, and it seems heâs gluing the pieces back together. 7, Sealâs ninth studio album (seventh of all his original material), gets to the core of what makes music fun without relying on gimmick to distract the listener. 7 is oddly as grandiose as it is small and humbled as Trevor Horn and Seal make their magic yet again. Even lesser materialâsuch as âLife on the Dancefloor,â which tricks the listener into thinking itâs catchyâis carried by the fantastic production and vocal performance. But aside from a little smoke and mirrors, 7 is an album of songs that would mostly work even without the fancy studio time: âDaylight Savingâ is certainly helped by the dramatic vocal layering and banjo (yes, I hear it, Seal), but the lyrics and delivery are passionate enough to push the song from the tedious to the extraordinary, which is the same story with the dark âPadded Cellâ and sweet âEvery Time Iâm With You.â But one of the best moments comes in the shape of âLet Yourself,â the only song on the album Seal wrote entirely by himself. The album sags and mopes at times with some maudlin lyricism (âLove,â âThe Big Love Has Diedâ), but over all, itâs a worthy contender in a sea of self-assured albums that follow suit in not over-asserting their presence. Imagine Dragons could learn a thing or two from this.
With the mainstream music empire slowly eroding at the hands of iTunes, YouTube, and the many splintered branches of Napsterâs dead stump, the market has never been so open and wide. Although this state of affairs has made the art of good musicianship go the way of the hand-written letter, it has also made it easier for people to discover something outside of what the radio plays. I began exploring Mika in the interest of gay visibility, a search for fun pop music made by somebody who has had to deal with things Iâve dealt with as well. John Grant, Will Young, and others also join the ranks with Mika, but this year, Mika outdid them all with No Place in Heaven, his mature fourth record. With each album, this Lebanese-British singer-songwriter has experimented, but remained true to himself and his artistry. This means that we are lightyears away from the uncontrolled garishness of Life in Cartoon Motion, but still somewhere within the same universe. His work is consistent, which is the mark of security and self-awareness, two things any good musician and songwriter will have. On this record, many of the issues on his first three albums have been ironed out. The maturity he displayed on The Origin of Love is expanded on, and even when he does get cartoonish (âGirl Youâre the Devilâ and âGood Wifeâ), he does so in a subtle way that does not belie the intention of the heavier moments on this record, like âOrdinary Manâ and âHurts.â Any artist who can get better and better with each album is one worthy of our attention.
Lianne La Havas has her work cut out for her. In a world where Solange Knowles and India.Arie are overlooked in favor of Adele, Iâm not entirely sure La Havas will ever get the due she deserves. One spin of her sophomore record Blood and I knew she had somethingâtwo spins and I fell in love. Three spins in, and with each revolution, she kept quietly making her case, climbing up the list higher and higherâeven though she entered the running rather late, at the recommendation of Quentin Harrison. The soft, somber melodies of âGood Goodbyeâ and âWonderfulâ are drenched in drama, employing only La Havasâs silky voice and airy guitar strings to create the mood. The albumâs more up-tempo moments are just as thick and rich with content, but Blood feels no need to stomp its feet and scream from the top of its lungs. It lets the music do all the talking, from the soul licks to the indie-rock production and presentation, and La Havas walks the line separating the sides of the racial music divide with ease. Apart from a few odd moments, nothing on this LP feels out of place or unworthy of attention. This girl has the chops.
The line that divides MylĂšne Farmerâs career is only discernible in the clear difference between 1995âs Anamorphosee and 1997âs Innamoramento, two albums created in the wake of Farmerâs self-exploration and extensive foreign travel (the United States, China, India). If Farmer must constantly be compared to Madonna, then Innamoramento is her Ray of Light, and much of the work after that album also mirrors Madonnaâs in that a great deal of it, although enjoyable, follows a very specific pattern and rarely reached the heights of her earlier work. This is something that happens with many established pop artists, and Farmer is no exception. But unlike Madonna, Farmer doesnât go so far off the deep end as to royally embarrass herself musically, and there are no âBitch Iâm Madonnaâ moments present in her work. After 2012âs dated Monkey Me, the palate cleanser that is Interstellaires is a welcomed, fresh return to form, and the material is presented in such a way that reminds us that Farmer is a seasoned pro. While she doesnât reach the artistic bar she set for herself with albums like Lâautre and Ainsi soit je, her latest offering still brings the goods, from the dramatic, club-ready âStolen Carâ to the thoughtful, melancholy âInsondablesâ to the pure fun of âCâest pas moi.â
If you, dear reader, were to look at my Last.FM profile statistics, you might scratch your head and wonder why it is that Cry Baby, the debut album from Melanie Martinez, was not named Album of the Year. And you would be very correct in your confusion, as it is my most-played of MMXV. The dark humor and raw, unbridled imagination on Cry Baby made for what is the most interesting pop album Iâve heard in a very, very long time. But this album does suffer from a lack of seasoned professionalism and standards, and Martinez has been allowed to draw all over the walls as she sees fit. As a result, this album wanders a bit over the line between clever writing and riding-the-theme-until-the-wheels-fall-off. But I will not deny that sheâs fun, daring, and creative. Between the allegories for sexual assault, parental infidelity, loss of innocence, and murder, itâs hard to imagine that Cry Baby is also a pop album with hip-hop beats, fun hooks, and really catchy melodies. But thatâs exactly what it is. And what Martinez managed to do was fill the void left by Madonnaâs Rebel Heart. Normally, Madonna occupies a good 80% of my listening time in any given year that she releases a new LP. This is what Cry Baby did for me this year, and I listened to it on almost every walk I took, on every drive, and in every minute of down time.
British singer-songwriter Richard Hawley has a very natural, somber, and painful approach to music distinctly inspired by early soul and rock ânâ roll. He distills these influences through the lens of bittersweet memories, and the resulting music often results in tangible chills. For me, Hollow Meadows quickly set the standard for all albums released in MMXV, both before and after it. Although there is absolutely nothing new on this album for Hawley, who was just coming off the heels of experimenting outside of folk rock for the first time with his previous LP, this album is the mark of a seasoned professional who is very much in control of his art. Now, this is something more easily achieved when youâre surrounded by the right people, and the intrinsic nature of Hawleyâs musical style almost ensures the chance to grow as an artist, more so than a pop star. But that does not mean that Hollow Meadows is any less incredible for its confidence and lack of showboating. The music on this record whispers to the listen, and, as a result, it is my pick for Album of the Year.
Other Albums Discovered in MMXV
Bad Luck Streak in Dancing School (1980) â+
Trueloveâs Gutter (2010) â+
Hoodoo (1976 â Unreleased) â+
All About Chemistry (2001) â+
Boys in the Trees (1978) â+
Une enfant du siĂšcle (2010) â
More Than a Woman (2002) â
Lollipops & Politics (2010 â Unreleased) â