You Should Feel Lucky - Part XI
Tags: minors DNI, dub con/non con, stalking, stalker!joel, dirty talk, Stockholm Syndrome, pet names (angel, sweetheart, darlin, etc.), praise & degradation, yelling, crying, violence, swearing, begging, obsession, name calling (slut, whore), pain, Joel is a sadist, rough sex, humiliation, degradation kink, multiple orgasms, anal sex, painful anal, anal creampie, depression
WC: 4.3k
Summary: You may have given up on life, but not on Joel.
A/N: We have returned to the main timeline for this part. I know it's been a longer gap between chapters than usual, but I hope you enjoy this one in all its usual depravity. I want to thank @milla-frenchy for being my sweet beta reader and always supporting me and stalker!joel in all his sick ways. I'd also like to thank this anon for inspiring the first part of the chapter. As always, you guys are the best and I am so appreciative of every comment, reblog, and message. Love you all! š¤
Divider: @/saradika-graphics
Days drifted in and out, and you slowly started to forget who you were. You hadnāt been to work in weeks; you werenāt really even sure how behind on your bills you might be. Your phone was dead the majority of the time, so it was hard to know who in your life had really noticed your absence.Ā
Self-care had completely fallen to the wayside. Showers were few and far between, laundry even less often. You ate at least one meal a day, but that was usually only when youād finally gotten so hungry that you felt faint and couldnāt ignore the gnawing feeling in your stomach.Ā
It was a Friday evening and unsurprisingly, you had no plans. Youād finally gotten yourself to shower that day and were in a fresh pair of pajamas, cuddled into the corner of your couch, staring at the blank TV screen. It should have been concerning to you that you felt just as entertained watching a black screen as much as you did watching a movie, but the growing depression seemed to swallow up any remaining insight that you had left.Ā
Your head was so empty and body so numb and tired, that you hadnāt realized you started to drift off. The soft tug of sleep pulled you into a gentle doze as your eyes closed and your body sunk further into the plush of the couch.Ā
You didnāt hear him come in - didnāt hear the front door creaking open that you hadnāt even bothered to lock, didnāt hear the sound of his boots as he kicked them off in the entryway, didnāt hear the patting of his feet as he approached your sleeping form, and didnāt hear him take a seat on the coffee table across from you.Ā
It wasnāt until his hand settled on the outside of your thigh that your eyes shot open and you realized you werenāt alone. The usual panic didnāt set in. Instead, you stared at him for a moment. Your body stayed still, allowing his hand to rest on your leg. You watched as he furrowed his brow.Ā
āCanāt be doinā that, angel,ā he said. His voice was soft yet stern. āLeavinā your door unlocked like thatā¦what if someone came in and hurt you?āĀ
Your expression was blank as his words drifted in one ear and out the other. It didnāt feel real. It didnāt feel like he was truly there. Joel took immediate note of your change in disposition. Concern bubbled low in his belly and he stood up from the table. He knew he needed to snap you out of this in some way, but wasnāt sure how.Ā
āStand up.ā The command was sharp despite his voice still being quiet.Ā
You stayed laying on the couch but tilted your head up to look at his face. The evening sun created a glow around him that enhanced the unique shape of his features. You werenāt aware that you were smiling at him until his voice cut through the air again.Ā
āWhatāre you smilinā ābout? I said, get up. Now.āĀ
You closed your eyes, flipping to your other side so that your back was facing him. Your mind was entirely too empty to be concerned about any potential consequences from him. Besides, it didnāt feel like you had control over anything - your body, your thoughts, your words. Youād never felt so far away and disconnected before.Ā
āThe fuck is wrong with you?!ā His hands grabbed you harshly by your arms, hauling you up and forcing you to stand in front of him.Ā
Your legs nearly gave out and he gripped you harder. If youād been able to focus on him, you wouldāve seen that his look was one of concern, not anger, but your gaze was fixed straight ahead on his chest as your body swayed slightly.Ā
āJesus Christ,ā he murmured as he picked you up, carrying you in a cradled position to the bedroom.Ā
He set you gently on the bed, overtop your comforter. His jaw clenched and he exhaled a sigh of frustration before he spoke, āYou eat anything today?āĀ
You looked at his eyes again. Had they always been so brown? So dark? His gaze was fixed on you. You shrugged your shoulders in response to his question.Ā
āUse your words.ā His voice was slightly louder than before as his irritation started to slip through.Ā
āN-no.ā Your voice came out crackly, as though you hadnāt used it in days. Which, you hadnāt. You werenāt sure the last time youād actually spoken.
āJesus, angelā¦ā He pulled out his phone, checking the time. āItās 7 oāclock ān you havenāt had anything? The hell-ā He cut himself off, instead just rubbing a hand down his face and turning around to leave the room.Ā
When Joel opened your fridge to find something to prepare for you, his heart sank. It was bare. There was some rotten produce that smelled rancid, and beyond that it was just condiments and some sort of questionable leftovers. He cleared it all out, wiping down the fridge in hopes of getting rid of the smell. He didnāt want to leave you to go to the store, so he ordered pizza and salad, along with taking time to complete an online grocery order for delivery. He periodically popped his head into the bedroom, and each time you were just staring up at the ceiling.Ā
While Joel waited for the food to arrive, he finished your partially started laundry, cleaned the few dishes that were in the sink, wiped down your counters, and vacuumed. It wasnāt like you to leave your home in this condition and he couldnāt shake the unsettling feelings stirring within him.Ā
The food arrived and after Joel put your groceries away, he plated the pizza and salad and brought it into the bedroom. You were curled up in bed with the blanket pulled over your head. He set your plate on the table beside you, carrying his plate to the other side and sitting down beside you on the bed. Carefully peeling back the blanket, he saw that your eyes were open and there was a trail of tears running across your face and onto the sheet beneath you.Ā
āOh, darlinā,ā he said as he scooped you up, pulling you up against his side as he lowered himself into the bed. His arms wrapped around you but he kept enough distance so he could see your face. You couldnāt help but to cry more at the embrace. You hadnāt been hugged in a while, and the tender act only brought more of your emotions to the surface. Joel shushed you gently as he kissed your forehead and then looked down at you.Ā
āWanna tell me what this is all about?ā His hand stroked up and down your back as he spoke. You didnāt think comfort from him would feel this safe or soothing, but it did. You couldnāt help but to lean into his touch as you peered up at him and responded, āI donāt know.āĀ
Joel didnāt know what else to ask, so he just sat up in the bed, lifting you with him and reaching across you to hand you your plate of food. Your stomach rumbled immediately upon holding the food in front of you. Of course, it was your favorite pizza, and you could tell by glancing between your plates that he had already removed the tomatoes from your salad, knowing you didnāt like them. It felt thoughtful. You took a bite of the pizza and it felt like your mind was already starting to come back to life. Bite after bite seemed to refuel you. The brain fog youād been struggling with started to dissipate, you felt less shaky, and you werenāt crying anymore.Ā
Your plate was completely empty within a matter of minutes and you sighed in contentment. Joel reached over, taking your empty plate. āWant more?ā When you looked over, he was smiling. His eyes were warm, almost prideful. You shook your head no, letting him stack both empty plates and set them off to the side. You felt more alert than you had in days, the desire to sleep finally not all encompassing.Ā
āI, uhā¦ā He scratched at the back of his neck as he spoke. āI missed you, angel. Tried giving you some space after everything that happened last timeā¦not sure that was the best idea now.āĀ
It felt as close to an apology as you were going to get. Youād spent days dwelling on your last incident with him, replaying it over and over in your head until you felt nauseous. Youād always known him to be violent, angry, sadisticā¦but there was an added layer of cruelty that you hadnāt expected from last time. You learned to not seek apologies from him. So, you just nodded at his words, not sure how to respond appropriately.Ā
āDidja miss me?ā His words were still spoken with his usual nonchalance, but there was a vulnerability to his tone that caught you off guard.Ā
You took a moment to think about his question. You could feel the heat of his gaze on your face as you looked down at your lap. Memories of his multiple acts of service bubbled up. You thought about the care he offered you - his version of safety. You knew that as long as he was in your life, nothing else would hurt you - nothing other than him. Images of you underneath him rose up - the many times that he made you come undone over and over. No one in your life has ever brought you as much pleasure or as much pain as he has. What did that mean?Ā
Your eyes lifted to meet his, and you nodded. It was the truth, as much as you hated to admit it. At the same time, if he were to leave, and be guaranteed to be gone from your life forever, you imagined that might also be the happiest day of your life.Ā
Joel smiled. It was a little lopsided and didnāt quite reach his eyes. But nonetheless, it was a smile. A chill ran up your spine, though you couldnāt quite place why. It wasnāt until you blinked and he was suddenly on top of you that you realized your body was likely sensing what was to come. Your hands moved in front of you on instinct, a weak attempt at creating any amount of space between your bodies.Ā
It was as though Joel hadnāt even noticed. His lips met yours as he pressed his hips against you. He was already hard, very hard, and it had you wondering how long he had been like that. As he settled against your core, you felt your body already responding to him. A wet spot formed quicker than you would have liked and you whimpered into his mouth as his tongue moved against yours.Ā
āThatās it, angelā¦I know you missed me.ā His hand slipped between your bodies, rubbing your clothed pussy as he continued kissing you. His touch was always one of precision. He knew just what to do, where to press, how firmly, and always the right speed. It had you arching off the bed within moments, your hands coming to his curls at the nape of his neck as you tugged gently, moaning.Ā
āMore, more, more,ā you were chanting, not even realizing it because of your focus on the orgasm building low in your belly. You felt a rush of slickness as you grunted at the peak of your orgasm, grabbing onto Joel tightly as he helped you work through it.Ā
He chuckled, pulling his hand away and looking down at you. āNeedy lil thing tonight, huh?āĀ
You nodded. You werenāt sure what had seemingly possessed you, but you knew that this was the best youād felt in weeks. You felt alive, awake and the arousal just continued coursing through you. Your hands trembled against Joelās shoulders, your eyes looking up at him wide and pleading.Ā
It made his cock throb and his eyes go dark. Fuck, he thought to himself, sheās so fucking willing right now. He couldnāt help but be selfish and think about how he might use it to his advantage. His eyes searched yours for a moment. You already looked fucked out and desperate. He cradled your jaw, his thumb swiping gently across your bottom lip.Ā
āAngel, what dāyou think about us tryinā something new, hm?ā His eyes twinkled as he spoke, not able to completely hide his eagerness. āLooks tāme like youāre needinā somethinā a little more today.āĀ
Without hesitation, you nodded your head. You were pretty sure youād take whatever he wanted to give you. Your eyes were focused on him, your body like a magnet to his. If you didnāt know any better, youād think he put you under some sort of spell with how badly you craved him right now. All sense of safety seemed to leave your body, replaced with an insatiable need to be as close to him as possible.Ā
āI got you,ā he murmured as he lifted off from you and rolled you onto your stomach. Your breath hitched and you became putty in his hands, letting him move and shift you as needed until you were on all fours, completely stripped of your clothing. Joel remained fully clothed, a juxtaposition that had you squeezing your thighs together, enjoying the feeling of being on display for him.Ā
His breath hit your bare pussy and you shuddered as his tongue licked a long trail from your clit up to your entrance. He pushed his tongue inside of you, swirling it and groaning at your taste. Joelās hands held your cheeks spread for him as he buried his face between them, licking and sucking lewdly as you fell onto your forearms, making incomprehensible noises.Ā
When you started to orgasm for the second time, he didnāt eat you through it. Instead, he pulled back, enjoying watching how your pussy clenched around nothing and how sweet pearls of cum beaded and then dripped down your soaked folds. He kept you spread, his tongue finally meeting your skin again, warm and soft as he licked you clean. You caught your breath just for it to falter once more as his tongue moved up to your tight ring. Lurching forward, you looked over your shoulder at him.Ā
āWh-what are you doing?ā Your eyes were wide, nervous for what he was about to say and do.Ā
āGonna be good fāme, angel?ā He unzipped his pants, reaching in and pulling out his thick cock. You moaned and looked back down at the blanket underneath you. Your hands fisted it lightly, preparing to brace yourself. āGonna let me make both of us feel good, hm?ā His cock swiped up and down, the head of it getting caught at your entrance before sliding through again.Ā
Surely he wasnāt going to just go for it, right? While youād never done this before, you were sure there had to be some sort of prep involved. Before you could panic too much, you felt him press slowly into your wet pussy. Feeling relieved, you lowered your head with a deep moan, welcoming the stretch.Ā
āOh my god, Joel,ā you gasped out as he pushed all the way in. You felt the head of his cock deeper than you thought was possible and you arched your back, pushing back into him and melting into the sensation of him filling you completely. āSoā¦fullā¦,ā you panted as he set the pace of his thrusts. āUhā¦uhā¦uhā¦pleaseā¦Joelā¦ā You werenāt even quite sure what you were asking for, neither was Joel, but the sound of your moans was music to his ears and only spurred him on further.Ā
āSo full, huh?ā His hips snapped against you. His thrusts were rough but steady. āDonāt think youāre full enough quite yet, angel.ā The tip of his thumb pressed to your puckered ring and once more, you tried moving forward, away from him, but his hand grasped your hip, pulling you back. āWhere dāya think youāre goinā, hm?āĀ
He removed his thumb to spread your cheeks. You heard him spit and then felt his saliva drip down your hole. His thumb quickly scooped it up, spreading it around your tight ring before dipping his finger in again. You groaned this time, loud and deep as his cock continued fucking into you. It was a new, unfamiliar stretch, but by the time he had worked most of his thumb inside, you felt your second orgasm building quickly.Ā
āOhhh my godā¦ā You gripped the sheet and lowered your head, your forehead pressed to the soft fabric underneath you as you pushed back into him and trembled.Ā
āThere ya goā¦fuck yeahā¦shitā¦ā Joel dragged his cock in and out slowly, letting you savor your orgasm as you shook against him. His hand held you firmly, keeping you up and arched so he could continue fucking you. When you stopped shaking, he popped his thumb out, watching in awe as your hole stayed open for him just a little. He knew his thumb wasnāt even close to the size of his cock, but at least he could say he tried to work you open beforehand.
Joel leaned over your back, kissing across the back of your shoulders and letting your spent body rest for a moment. His cock was hanging between your thighs now, dripping precum onto the blanket beneath you. His eyes were focused on you, becoming hungrier and hungrier as the moments passed by. His cock was coated in your slick as he nudged the head of it against your still-tight ring.Ā
This time you didnāt lunge forward, your body stayed relaxed from the orgasm and Joel held you up by your hips as your upper body pressed against the bed.Ā
āYāready, angel?āĀ
You gave a weak, timid nod, and Joel began to press inside of you. The stretch was unreal. There was no comparison to anything like it, and you grunted, trying to relax but the overwhelming sensation had goosebumps dotting your entire body. You moaned his name and reached around to try grabbing his wrist, but Joel was too focused on how your body was opening up for him. He looked down as he continued to push inside. He groaned, watching inch by inch slowly disappear inside of you.Ā
āJesus Christā¦so fuckinā tight fāme, darlinā...ā Before he could think better of it, his hips rolled forward and he plunged inside the rest of the way. His head bowed and he moaned, āFuuuuuck.āĀ
āOw, ow! Joel!ā You tried to reach back again in hopes of pushing him away, but it was no use. He pulled out halfway, just to roll his hips again. It felt like you were being split in half. With each roll of his hips, he pushed you further and further into the mattress. You were completely prone underneath him now, your legs spread as he continued inserting himself into your tight tunnel. It was too much, and a sob fell from you as he snapped his hips quicker. āPlease! I canāt,ā you cried out, hoping heād take some modicum of pity on you.Ā
When he heard your cry, he stilled. He stayed buried inside of you, but his hand reached up, brushing the hair from the side of your face so he could see you. His fingertips became damp with your tears and he leaned forward. āToo much, angel?āĀ
You nodded, desperate for his empathy and hopeful that he was going to listen to you. āPlease, Joelā¦it hurts too much.āĀ
āAw,ā he cooed, kissing your cheek and using his hand to rub up and down your side. āIāll go slower, hm?ā He tried to ignore how his cock throbbed knowing you were in pain.Ā
You knew Joel well enough to know that there was no point in refusing, so you just stayed still and tried to keep your body pliant for him. His cock pulled out slowly and pressed in again even slower. You felt helpless under his full body weight, just feeling the drag of his cock and the painful stretch that was starting to gradually morph into pleasure. His hand slipped between the mattress and your cunt, his middle finger rubbing against your clit as he continued his careful thrusts.Ā
āShit, sweetheartā¦goddamn, you feel goodā¦tight lil asshole, fuckinā squeezinā meā¦āĀ
The combination of his words, steady thrusts, and the pressure on your clit had you moaning louder and louder. Joel smiled, noticing how quickly you acquiesced to him. He was proud of you for taking his cock so well. His thrusts started to get lazier, his mind just focusing on the sensation of your tight walls hugging his thick cock.Ā
He picked up the pace, no longer rolling his hips but instead hammering them against your ass. Your cheeks bounced against him with each thrust and you yelped at the sudden sharpness.Ā
āFuck, I knew youād take it so good, angel..goddamn.ā His length railed into you over and over. Your eyes rolled into the back of your head as his groans filled the room and you felt another orgasm start to build. It was entirely too much. The sensations had tipped into overwhelming and you were desperately gripping the sheets underneath you as you started to quiver against him.Ā
āShit, can feel you clenching around me. Ahhh..fuckā¦ā His rhythm became even more erratic as his balls tightened and he was right on the precipice of his own orgasm. āSo fuckinā tight, fuckinā whore...youāll take anything I goddamn give you, huh?ā One of his hands moved up to fist your hair, pulling your head slightly back as he continued railing into you. āRuining your fucking asshole, angel...never gonnaā¦ah, fuckā¦never gonna be the fuckinā same againā¦ā He was panting aggressively above you, sweat beading across his brow as he fucked into your ass.Ā
Tears ran down your face and you cried out as you felt him start to release inside of you. He was so snug against your walls that you felt his entire length pulsing as his cock emptied. He was pressed firmly against you, his balls pulsing against your cheeks as he grunted and groaned. Feeling the spurts from his cock pushed you over the edge as well, hurtling through your fourth orgasm of the night.Ā
Right as you started to come down, Joel pulled out from inside of you. He immediately looked down, his hands spreading your ass cheeks so that he could see his spend drip out.Ā
āWouldya lookathatā¦goddamn, angel. Beautiful fuckinā thing.ā His fingers scooped it up, tenderly pushing his cum back inside you. He could see just how much he opened you up. He smiled at how red and sore you looked, savoring the sight as much as he could. When he finally got enough, you were half asleep and limp on the bed. He chuckled as he climbed off of you.Ā
You only passively noticed as he pulled fresh clothes onto you, not cleaning between your legs because he wanted his cum to stay tucked inside of you for as long as possible. He rolled you onto your back, propping you against your pillows. Your eyes closed and it was quiet for a few minutes. When you heard something again, it was the clinking of ice as Joel held a straw to your lips for you to drink. The water felt good on your throat, soothing the soreness from the crying and moaning.Ā
āTake a bite,ā he murmured, feeding you a protein bar.Ā
Your eyes stayed closed as you took a couple bites. You didnāt have an appetite, but you knew youād sleep better with something on your stomach. Joelās touch was gentle. He swept hair away from your face and pulled the blanket around you so you were more comfortable. His lips brushed your forehead then lips in soft kisses.Ā
āDid so good, angel.ā His thumb stroked your cheek and you leaned into the tender touch. āAnything else you need?āĀ
You hesitated, remembering the unsuccessful begging you did the time before, wanting him to stay and hold you. So instead, you just opened your eyes to look at him one last time as you shook your head.Ā
Something unspoken seemed to flash between the two of you. You watched in real time as Joelās eyes switched from dark to soft. He held your eye contact for a minute then got up and walked out of the room.Ā
This time, tears didnāt come. It was what you expected, so you hunkered down in your bed and closed your eyes to try and drift off to sleep once more. You felt taken care of, even despite the assault that your body had just endured.Ā
Right as your mind started to wander, you heard the creaking of the floorboards and opened your eyes again, turning to the side to see Joel standing in his boxers. He looked at you for a moment then got into bed, reaching over and turning off the bedside lamp. You stared at him with a confused expression. You couldnāt read his face. It was blank. But he placed his hand on your shoulder, gently turning you away from him as he sidled up behind you and wrapped his arms around your waist, spooning you.Ā
āGānight, angel.āĀ
āGood night, Joel.ā You smiled to yourself as you fell asleep. And while you couldnāt see him, you hoped that Joel was doing the same.Ā
AO3 | masterlist | YSFL masterlist
Let me know if you'd like to be added or removed from list!
Tag list: @untamedheart81 @shadowqueen2024 @shrewdreader @m3rdim @taniamiller @joelmillerspnk @have-you-seen-my-sanity @wand-erer5 @whorefordaveyork @jasminedragoon @pedge-page @cinnxmxngxrl @arthursdodobird @honey-moon-13 @jules6898 @valyrianjoel @spectralgalaxygauntlet @missadangel @mydarlingjoel @jamjamjamming @biagaloree @sub-aro @kai-lovey @david-10ninch-blog @pdrospnk @ratatouilleremyrini @gunnersaurusrex @joelsarchive @xkyxkyxxlylcylulucuflfluclu @bevellin777 @cordycepskiss @upintheclouds95 @fairly-feral @rawndoldersupremacist @milla-frenchy
ouuuuuuuu this was so HOTTTT!!! (and also concerning!!) š„µš„š„ joelās response to the readerās depression gave me such whiplash, because he does take care of her but also takes advantage of her vulnerable state and hurts her.. the ending tho š¤












