you and rafe navigating through the chaos of coachella, where a single moment turns into something bigger than either of you could’ve ever imagined. one stolen glance, one spontaneous dance, and suddenly the world can’t stop watching. from the sparkle of the crowd to the flash of cameras, your love story becomes more than just a secret between the two of you, it’s a viral sensation.
a collection of one-shots / stand-alones that capture the chaos of the world’s new it couple.
SYNOPSIS‧₊˚ Tensions boil over in the villa as a messy "Dirty Laundry" challenge exposes hidden truths, and as fractured alliances lead to screaming matches at the fire pit, a surprise voting twist offers the remaining couples a temporary moment of relief
WARNING(S)‧₊˚ swearing, verbal altercations,
˗ˏˋ series masterlist ˎˊ˗
THE morning air was always crisp before the humidity settled in. You woke up slowly, the gentle swaying of the outdoor daybed duvet almost forcing you back to sleep. For a second, you forgot you were surrounded by dozens of hidden cameras and a production crew, tracking your every breath. All you knew was the heavy, comforting weight of Rafe’s arm draped over your waist, his chest pressed firmly against your back as his breath floated over the skin of your neck.
You shifted slightly as a breeze swept over you, trying not to disturb him, but his grip tightened, a low rumble vibrating against your shoulder blade.
"Where y’goin?" he muttered, his voice thick with sleep as he buried his face into the crook of your neck, his breath warm against your skin. "The sun’s barely up..."
You smiled, turning your head to catch a glimpse of him. His usual smirk was completely gone, replaced by a soft drowsiness that you figured few people ever got to see. "As much as I want to stay out here, everyone is going to start waking up soon.” You told him softly, squeezing his arm. “If Sarah catches us out here again, she’s going to make it her personal mission to announce it via a megaphone."
Rafe let out something between a soft laugh and a sigh, slowly opening his eyes as they locked onto yours, making your stomach do somersaults. "Let her.” He whined, pouting. “Y’know how much shit I get from the guys?" He leaned in, planting a soft, teasing kiss just beneath your ear that sent a shiver straight down your spine as you shivered under his touch. "But fine. Go get changed.” He grumbled as you smiled, rolling your eyes.
“I’ll see you soon." You nodded, reluctantly sliding out from under the heavy blanket, kissing his cheek and giving his hand one last squeeze before jogging barefoot across the grass toward the bedroom.
WHEN Rafe walked into the guys' dressing room ten minutes later, rubbing the sleep out of his eyes, he was greeted by the familiar sight of JJ aggressively spraying cologne and John B trying to tame his signature messy curls in the mirror.
"Yo, look who finally decided to join the club!" JJ shouted, throwing a stray towel at Rafe's head as he coughed from the overwhelming scent of his own fragrance. Rafe caught it effortlessly, a small smirk playing on his lips as he tossed it back, shaking his head. "Man, you’ve got it bad.” JJ kept on, waving a hand in front of his face. “You’re out there sleeping under the stars ‘n shit.” He mocked. “I thought you were supposed to be the big man on campus, dude."
John B laughed from the mirror. "He’s whipped, man. There’s no saving him."
"Shut up," Rafe muttered looking through his clothes, though there was no real heat in his voice. "We were just talkin’." He dismissed them, shrugging. “And who said I wanted to be saved?” He threw out over his shoulder.
"Yeah, 'talking,'" JJ mocked, wiggling his eyebrows.
The playful banter was cut short when the heavy frosted glass door to the bathroom swung open, Topper stepping out with his face dark and a fresh towel slung over his shoulder. The second his eyes landed on Rafe, his jaw clenched, posture stiffening into that rigid, confrontational stance he took when his ego was bruised.
He marched right into Rafe's personal space, stopping just inches from his chest as the room fell still. "You must think you’re real fucking funny, don't you, man?" Topper spat, his voice dropping into a harsh, angry hiss. "I mean, what the hell? Exposing me like that in front of everyone?” He spat, though his voice dropped towards the end of his sentence. “For what? To make yourself look like the good guy? Like you haven’t been sneaking around with the bombshell chick since day one. Because, in case you weren’t aware, she’s not your partner—"
Rafe didn't flinch as Topper pushed a finger against his chest. He stood perfectly still, but the guys could see the exact moment the air in the room shifted, even Pope as he entered, yawning.
Inside Rafe's head, a familiar storm was cooking up—that hot surge of adrenaline, the old anger that used to send him straight to the bottom of a bottle or into a fistfight—flaring up behind his ribs.
“Like, forgive me for keeping a girl company when you kick her to the dust.” Topper egged on.
Don't do it, Rafe told himself, his knuckles turning white as he clenched his fists inside his pockets. He’d worked so hard to not be that person anymore, to not let the smallest things set him off.
"Topper," Rafe said, his voice terrifyingly quiet, dropping an octave. He took a single, slow step forward, his eyes locking onto Topper’s with a lethal intensity as he bent over to be eye-level with the fuming blonde. "I’m going to give you exactly five seconds to back the fuck up.” Rafe ordered, a snarl on his lips. “You crossed a line—you lied to Sarah, and you got caught. Don't direct your bitchy little temper tantrum at me—"
“What’d you say, man—
"Alright." Pope suddenly materialized between them, using his broad shoulders to push Topper back a few paces. "We are not doing this today. It’s only day five, nobody needs to be sent home over a dumb argument.” He rationalized. “Topper, get out of here. Rafe, sit down."
Topper threw his hands up in frustration, glaring at Rafe over Pope’s shoulder. "Wha— Me? I’m getting put out because Rafe is a snake—"
From the corner of the room, John B let out a dry, passive-aggressive chuckle as he adjusted a hat on his head. "You serious? You're actually sitting here whining but I bet you haven't spent a single second thinking about Sarah.” He reprimanded. “She actually trusted you, man. And she deserved a hell of a lot better."
Topper scoffed, glaring at John B. "Oh, and I suppose you think you’re that better guy? Please, spare me.."
John B just shrugged, jutting his bottom lip out. "At least I know how to look a girl in the eye and tell the truth.”
MEANWHILE, on the other side of the villa, you were doing your best to manage the absolute disaster area that was the girls' dressing room.
Sarah was sitting in the corner, her face completely bare and her eyes swollen from crying, while Cleo quietly rubbed her back. Kiara was applying her lip gloss in silence and sorrow, the lingering guilt from the Pope situation still hanging over her like a heavy fog.
"...Okay, yeah, no," you said, closeting your own worries as you clapped your hands together to draw their attention. "We are not letting the bullshit from the guys ruin our experience. No. It’s a fresh morning, the sun is shining, and we have an infinity pool that is practically begging us to lounge by it."
Sarah offered a weak, grateful smile from her corner, the girls chuckling. "Thanks. I’m just... I’m so mad at myself for being so blind.” She sniffed, playing with the used tissue in her hands. “I really thought Topper was different than other guys I’ve met. I know it’s a stupid thought for the first week, but…"
"He's a dick, sweetie," Cleo said flatly, not mincing her words. "And you're better off finding out now than on Day Twenty."
“Cleo makes a great point, honey.” You comforted, a hand on Sarah’s shoulder. “I mean, what’d you come here for? To find the right guy, right?”
Sarah pouted up at you, sniffing once more. “I don’t even know, I…” She took a deep breath, shoulders slumping. “I had just graduated with a Business Degree, had a job lined up, and I guess it felt like I had no clue what else to do in my life.” She explained, looking down. “I was so lost in LA, fresh out of a 2 year situationship, drowning myself in my own money, and I just said ‘why not’...”
Cleo chuckled. “I know the feeling, girl,” she started. “I was running around the Bahamas helping orphaned kids and decided I wanted to give love a try. Worst decision ever—got my heart broken and half my bank account drained.” She told you all. “Thought coming here would, I don’t know, do something for me…”
“See?” You jumped in, smiling. “This isn’t just about getting a guy. We all came here for ourselves. And even if we all leave single and more heartbroken than we were when we came in, I’ll be glad I met you guys. I like you all more than any of those dumbasses in the other room.” At your words, the three girls cocked an eyebrow in your direction, fixing you with matching smirks.
“...Even Rafe?” They said in unison as warmth flooded your cheeks, turning away from them.
“Shut up…” You grumbled, the trio laughing behind you.
Seeking to shift the focus entirely, your eyes drifted to Ruthie, who was aggressively straightening her hair in the corner, completely ignoring the rest of the room. Despite your better judgement, you decided to extend an olive branch.
"So…Ruthie," you said, leaning against the counter near her station, all of the girls watching you and Ruthie. "What about you? What do you do back home? Are you in school, or working…?"
Ruthie didn't even pause her straightener. She let out a sharp, dismissive scoff, her eyes fixed on her reflection. "None of your business, honestly. I’m not here to make small talk.” She snapped back. “Especially not with homewreckers like you..."
The room went dead silent. Kiara paused her lip gloss, Sarah rolled her eyes, and Cleo’s jaw tightened.
You just raised an eyebrow, entirely unbothered by the hostility. "Last time I checked, you were the one who chose to spend your nights on the roof with Topper knowing he was pillowtalking Sarah every night.” You snapped back, a smirk on your face. “I was just trying to be polite, but if you want to stay in your little bubble of delusion, be my guest."
Kie, Sarah, and Cleo tried to hold back their laughs as Ruthie slammed her straightener down on the counter, her eyes flashing with anger. "You think you’re so much better than everyone here, don't you? Just wait until the recoupling.” She narrowed her eyes. “We’ll see who’s laughing then."
She then unplugged her straightener, snatched up her sunglasses, and stormed out of the room, slamming the glass door behind her.
Confessional : You
"I tried!” You laughed, leaning back against the sofa. “I really did. I offered the olive branch, and she basically tried to stab me with it. I think she’s just pissed because her game plan blew up in her face, and instead of taking accountability for being messy with Topper, she wants to blame the bombshell who ‘threw a wrench in her “relationship”.’ But honestly? If she thinks she can scare me off, she’s vastly underestimating how much drama I had to deal with in Vegas."
THE kitchen was slightly less chaotic, though the air was still suffocating with unspoken tension. You walked in to find Rafe already at the stove, flipping eggs while JJ and John B leaned against the island, aggressively eating cereal straight from the box.
"Morning again, Angel," Rafe said, his demeanor instantly softening the second you walked through the door. He slid a perfectly cooked plate of eggs and toast toward you as you pulled out a stool.
"Ugh, I needed this." you said, hopping up, taking a forkful of eggs to your mouth. "The dressing room was like walking into hell.” You spoke through the mouthful. “And I think Ruthie is officially on a warpath."
“Tell me about it.” Rafe replied, throwing a look at you over his shoulder. “Topper tried to start shit with me as soon as I got into the room.” He sighed, rubbing the back of his neck as he turned off the stove and moved to sit down beside you, a plate of his own in front of him. “But I do feel like a bit of a dickhead for airing out the roof stuff in front of everybody. I didn't mean to drag Sarah into the crossfire, either. I just... I lost it when Ruthie started coming for you."
JJ paused mid-chew. "Bro, do not feel bad.” He cut in. “Top and Ruthie were moving shady as hell. They deserved to get exposed. You saved Sarah a lot of time, honestly."
"Agreed," John B chimed in, though he looked down at his bowl of cereal as he poured themilk, his fingers tapping nervously against the ceramic. "Actually... speaking of Sarah..."
You tilted your head, watching the way John B’s face was turning a steady shade of pink. "What's up?"
John B sighed, shoving his hands into his pockets as he looked up at you, JJ, and Rafe. "I’ve kind of... had a thing for her since Day One. When we did the coupling, I wanted her to go with me, but Topper got there first and she seemed so set on him. I didn't want to step on toes.” He confessed. “But seeing how he treated her? It kinda makes me sick. I mean, imagine what he’d do if they were actually together…"
JJ let out a loud gasp, slamming his hand on the counter. "I knew it! And you called me crazy, dude,” He exclaimed. “I knew you were looking at her with those big, puppy-dog eyes! Bro, you gotta get your girl!"
"It's not that easy," John B muttered, side-eyeing the blonde before looking at you. "...You're pretty close with her. Can you... I don't know, maybe talk to her? See where her head is at? I don't want to swoop in like a vulture if she’s still hung up on Topper."
You smiled, barely able to contain yourself. "No problem.” You shrugged. “I’ll see what I can do, John B. But…she’s still hurt, so, don't get your hopes up too much, okay?"
Before John B could thank you, the familiar, booming tri-tone chime of a phone echoed through the kitchen.
JJ pulled his phone from his pocket, his face lighting up. "Yo! Text!" He called, voice echoing throughout the villa as everyone emerged in the kitchen from different directions.
“What’s it say?” Kie asked first as everyone crowded around the island.
"Islanders, it’s time to see who’s been keeping secrets and who’s been keeping receipts. Please gather at the challenge area immediately for a little game called 'Dirty Laundry.' #PaintballProsecco #SpillTheTea"
It was clear that everyone was excited for another challenge but all you could think about the drama it was bound to stir up.
THE challenge area had been transformed into a massive, neon-splattered obstacle course. In the center stood Ariana, looking effortlessly stunning in a hot-pink blazer dress, holding a golden paintball gun.
Behind her were large targets with each Islander’s face on them.
"Welcome, Islanders!" She beamed as you all gathered in your respective team gear—white t-shirts and shorts that were practically begging to be ruined. "Today, we are playing 'Dirty Laundry.' The rules are simple. I am going to read off a series of anonymous confessional statements that you guys have made over the last four days. Some are paraphrased and some names are written out so as to not make it so obvious. If you think you know who said it, grab your paintball gun, aim at their target, and fire.” She told you, making an example of an empty target. “The person with the most correct guesses wins a special prize.” She smiled, facing you all. “But beware... some of these statements are going to leave a mark."
The tension was palpable as everyone grabbed their paintball guns, sharing nervous glances.
"Let’s start, shall we?" Ariana teased, pulling a card from her tray. "’___’s not showing as much interest as I’m used to, but I obviously can’t admit that with this new bombshell here. She’s not even all that but I need to secure my spot because I’ll be damned if I’m the first to go home.”
Before Ariana could even finish the sentence, your paintball gun was up—a massive glob of bright pink paint hitting Ruthie’s target right between the eyes. All the islanders followed your choice a second later, their shots hitting the target in rapid succession.
Ruthie crossed her arms, glaring at you from her place.
Confessional : Ruthie
"Did I say it? Yeah. Do I regret it? No. That bitch thinks she’s, like, the queen of the villa because she’s got Rafe wrapped around her finger, but let’s see how she handles a real challenge."
“Correct.” Ariana giggled, reading off the next card. “I felt kind of bad stepping outside of my coupling but I feel this, like, pull towards ___ and it just felt like an opportunity I couldn’t pass up.”
And seconds later, Cleo didn't hesitate. She fired a shot straight at Pope’s target, Kiara firing a second later, her face turning red as everyone looked at the two of them before the other shots followed, though some, such as yourself and Sarah, hit Topper’s target instead.
Confessional : Cleo
"I knew it was Pope. After everything that’s happened, it was just too obvious.” She shrugged, trying to feign nonchalant. “I guess it just hurts that he was honest with everyone else before he was honest with me. Like, if you want Kiara, just say that, bro. Don't play with my hair and tell me I'm your favorite if…whatever."
Confessional : Sarah
“I thought it was Topper until I realized they said they ‘felt kind of bad.’ That’s not really his style.” She threw out, picking at her nails as she shrugged. “ Oops.”
As the game went on, the statements got progressively messier. Topper’s target was covered in blue paint after a statement about ‘keeping his options open’ was read, causing Sarah to look away in disgust.
But the real shift happened when Ariana pulled out a final, highly specific card.
"I had a really good time with him on our date, but I'm scared to get my heart broken by a guy like him. He seems like a total playboy who gets around."
Kie’s eyes went wide and she instantly looked at Sarah, who froze.
The reactions weren’t immediate. At first, JJ joked with Cleo, thinking it was from her but she denied it. Rafe had even questioned you, not many dates having being had during the first few days. But then, it seemed as if everyone registered the answer at once as they turned to Kiara and JJ.
JJ stood perfectly still, his paintball gun lowering slightly. He didn't even fire a shot as the playfulness faded from his eyes. He just turned his head, his blue eyes locking onto Kiara with a wounded expression that made everyone’s stomach drop.
He’d clearly heard the statement, loud and clear, and based on the way his jaw tightened, it had cut deep.
Then a loud splat sounded out, Topper firing a shot at Kiara's target, laughing loudly. "Definitely Kie talking about JJ!"
You all shot him looks of disgust, groaning and shaking your heads.
Eventually, the game wrapped up with Pope winning the challenge somehow, most likely because of his accuracy to hit the targets. Ariana informed him that his prize would be announced tomorrow. But regardless, the laughter from earlier was gone, replaced by a heavy, awkward silence as everyone trudged back to the villa to wash off the paint.
BY mid-afternoon, the villa had split, almost everyone needing space from someone.
Kiara was in the outdoor kitchen making a massive bowl of pasta salad for lunch, her face tight with anxiety.
JJ was on the far side of the pool, working out with Topper yet, actively ignoring everyone.
You noticed Cleo grabbing a small plate of food from the fridge and walking past the daybeds, heading straight for the isolated garden area near the edge of the property. She looked completely defeated, her usual fierce energy replaced by a heavy, slouched posture.
You didn’t hesitate as you grabbed your own water bottle and followed her, finding her sitting on a lounger under a large palm tree, staring blankly at her plate.
"Hey," you said softly, stepping into the shade. "Mind if I sit?"
Cleo shrugged, not looking up. "Go for it. It's a free villa."
You dropped down next to her, letting the silence hang for a moment before you spoke. "You’ve been really quiet since the challenge, Cleo. Talk to me. What’s going on in that beautiful head of yours?" You nudged her shoulder.
Cleo let out a long, ragged sigh. "I think…I want to go home."
You blinked, genuinely shocked. "What? Why?"
"Because I’m tired of feeling like an idiot," Cleo said, her voice cracking slightly as she looked at you, her eyes swimming with unshed tears. "I came here wanting to actually get to know someone. I gave Pope a real chance, and he lied to me. And looking around this place? I don't feel a single connection with any of these other guys. John B is clearly pining after Sarah, Topper is a snake, JJ is... well, JJ, and Rafe is completely obsessed with you. I don't want to sit around here acting like a background character just to survive an elimination. It’s embarrassing..."
You reached out, covering her hand with yours. "Cleo, you are not leaving. Seriously. The girls would be absolutely devastated—especially me.” You reassured her. “You are the strongest, most authentic person in this house. Don't let one guy’s inability to be honest make you pack your bags."
"But what am I supposed to do?" she asked, a tear finally slipping down her cheek. "Just sit here and watch him pine after Kiara?"
"No," you said firmly. "You stay, you keep your head high, and you wait for the next bombshells to walk through those doors. There are going to be plenty of opportunities to meet new guys, Cleo. I would hate for you to walk out now and miss out on the guy who is actually meant for you—the one who will make you his first choice without hesitation. Just…give it a few more days. For me?” You tried. “For us."
Cleo wiped her face, looking at you for a long moment before a faint, familiar smirk returned to her lips. "You're real good at this psych stuff, you know that? I think you just manipulated me but I’m not even sure."
"It’s a gift," you laughed, shrugging and pulling her into a tight hug. "Now promise me you're staying."
"...Fine," she muttered against your shoulder. "I'm staying. But if the next guy they send in is a flop, I’m stealing your clothes and running away."
WHILE you were out in the yard talking to Cleo, Kiara and Sarah were in the kitchen, washing vegetables in the sink. The boys were completely out of sight, leaving the main house totally empty.
Or so they thought.
"I’m literally losing my mind, Sarah," Kiara whispered, leaning against the counter as she wiped her hands. "That confessional in the challenge ruined everything. I did have good time on our date, but.. I’m just so terrified.” She admitted. “It’s not like it was a lie. He’s good looking, funny, but he does seem like a total playboy. It’s like you can just look at him and tell he breaks hearts for fun.” Kie deadpanned. “I’m stuck between him and Pope, and I don't know what to do."
What neither of them realized was that JJ had just walked up to the side entrance of the kitchen to grab a drink. He’d frozen the second he heard Kiara’s voice, and every single word—playboy, breaks hearts, terrified —had hit him like a physical blow.
JJ’s face went entirely blank. The easygoing persona vanished instantly, replaced by a cold wall. He quietly stepped back into the shadows, his jaw clenched and feelings genuinely hurt.
If that’s what she thought of him after their date, fine. He’d start acting like it.
Sarah sighed, wiping her hands on a dishtowel. "Kie, you’re overthinking it,” she started. “Pope is great. An idiot but great… But he’s also got a lot of lingering feelings for Cleo that I think he’s not being honest about.” She told the girl. “And JJ might seem like a playboy, but he looked genuinely happy after your date. Maybe you should give him a fair chance…"
"I know, but I’m still scared," Kiara muttered. "I can't stop thinking about the kiss with Pope—it was perfect, but the guilt and Cleo are eating me alive. And with JJ, it was just one date.” She trailed off, sighing. “How am I supposed to choose between a perfect kiss and a perfect date?"
Sarah turned and looked her dead in the eye, hands on both of her shoulders. "You need to decide if you want to explore 'one date' or 'one kiss.' But you need to figure it out fast, because I feel like the recoupling is gonna be soon, and something tells me that those boys aren't going to wait around forever."
A half-hour later, you and Sarah ran into one another on the second-floor balcony. The sun was high, baking the wooden deck beneath your feet.
"Hey! I was looking for you!” You both said in unison, smiling and laughing it off.
“Sorry, you first,” Sarah motioned for you to speak, tucking her hair behind her ear as you both took a seat on the patio furniture.
“Okay, so I talked to Cleo and she’s in a really bad spot. She was even thinking about leaving…”you told Sarah, leaning against the railing.
“What—”
“But I convinced her to stay!” You quickly cut in, putting your hands out. “At least I hope so. But I think she’s done with Pope. Like, complete flatline."
Sarah nodded, her expression serious. "Shit…” she cursed. “I talked with Kiara. She is totally stuck.” Sarah exaggerated, running a hand through her hair. “She’s spiraling over Pope and JJ and doesn’t know who she wants.”
“...Honestly,” you started, palming the back of your neck, lowering your voice. “I think we need to…gently persuade Kie to go with JJ. If she stays with Pope, it’s just going to make Cleo want to leave again, and Pope clearly doesn't know what he wants anyways.” You explained in a whisper. “If Kie goes to JJ, it gives Cleo and Pope space to either fix their issues or move on entirely."
"I agree," Sarah said, her mind turning.
You nodded, silence falling over the two of you, until. "But, um, speaking of moving on…” you began nervously. “Since you’re done with Topper, I’m assuming…What’s your stance on John B?"
Sarah’s face flushed a soft pink as her posture straightened, her eyes darting away to look at the pool. "John B? I mean... he’s really sweet. I’ve kinda had a small eye on him since day one, honestly.” She admitted, a soft smile on her face. “He’s just so…different compared to Topper. Since things didn't work out with Topper, I think… I’d actually really like to get to know him."
You made a mental note of that but you kept your face entirely neutral. "Hm. Good to know.” You replied. “He seems like a really good guy, Sarah. I think you should definitely talk to him, see where his head’s at."
Some secrets were better left to mature.
THE rest of the afternoon was heavy, everyone feeling as if they had to get all of their ducks in a row.
Kiara, feeling the pressure the most, decided it was time to clear the air.
She pulled Pope first, sitting on the swing seat near the outdoor fireplace.
"Look, I know I’ve been kind of avoiding you,” she started, fiddling with her hands. “I just... I need to know where your head is at," Kiara said, her fingers still nervously twisting her rings. "The kiss during the challenge... there was a spark there, I won’t lie. But with Cleo in the mix, this is just so messy. I feel like I’m hurting someone no matter what."
Pope looked at her, his expression torn. He rubbed the back of his neck, looking every bit conflicted. "Kie, I’m not gonna to lie to you…” He began, a hand on hers. “The spark was real for me too. But…” He sighed. “...my mind isn't exactly made up between you and Cleo. I still have a lot of interest in Cleo and I don't want to throw that away if there’s still a chance. But, at the same time, I do want to get to know you. I don’t know, I guess I’m just in a weird position mentally..."
Kiara nodded, a bit disappointed by his lack of certainty. "Fair enough."
Confessional : Kiara
“I can’t lie,” she signed, leaning back. “I was hoping Pope would’ve made up his mind during our chat. Whether it was me or Cleo, it didn’t matter. I was just hoping whatever he said would’ve made this a bit easier on me…”
Seeking more clarity, she immediately went to find JJ after she and Pope parted ways, who was currently sitting alone on a sun lounger, staring out at the landscape with a defeated expression. Kie sat down at the foot of his chair, offering a soft smile.
"Hey," she said gently. "Can we…talk about the confessional? I feel like you've been giving me the cold shoulder since this morning. But I promise, it was taken out of context. Kind of…" She chuckled nervously, but JJ stayed unmoving.
He didn't look at her, just let out a cold, dry laugh. "Out of context?” He repeated, voice edgy. “Yeah, I’m good. You can save your apology.” He shifted in his seat. “Besides, its nothin’ I haven’t heard before."
Kiara’s face fell. "...JJ, I didn't mean it like that. I was just saying I’m scared because I don't want to get hurt—"
"Jus’ save it," JJ interrupted, his voice sharp and dismissive as he finally turned his head to look at her, his eyes entirely devoid of their usual warmth. "I know exactly what you’re doing. You’re only pulling me for a chat right now because you realized Pope isn't a sure thing and you don't want to be up for elimination. You think I’m just some dumb dude you can fall back on until a better option comes along.” He spat at her, face twisted in anger. “Well, I’m not interested in being your backup plan, Kiara."
Kiara stood up, her jaw slack with shock. "JJ, that’s not—"
"I’m done talking," JJ said flatly, getting up and walking away from her..
Confessional : JJ
He groaned, rubbing a hand down his face. "I’m being a dick? Look, I’m tired of being the guy girls use for a good time and then drop the second they find someone more 'serious.'” He pouted. “I actually liked Kiara. I thought our date meant something. But if she’s just going to label me a red flag like everyone else before she even knows me? Fine."
WHILE everyone was dealing with their own separate dramas, Topper finally managed to corner Sarah near the outdoor kitchen. You, Rafe, John B and JJ, who were catching up from earlier, watched from the safety of the main lounge couch, as the confrontation went down through the glass windows.
Sarah was standing with her arms tightly crossed, her posture rigid as Topper gestured wildly with his hands, clearly trying to smooth things over. But it looked like Sarah wasn't having any of it. You couldn't hear the exact words, but you could see her mouth certain words—liar, roof, and never again—before she forcefully pointed a finger in his face, effectively shutting him down.
Topper looked absolutely stunned as she spun on her heel and walked away, leaving him standing there like a lost dog. She’d stormed back into the house, her eyes blazing but clear as she caught your eye and gave you a sharp nod. She was proud of herself, and you were proud for her.
You quickly looked over at John B as she left the room, who was sitting on the adjacent armchair, practically vibrating as he watched the whole exchange.
"John B," you said, giving him a wide, encouraging smile, throwing a small pillow at him. "Go make your move!”
He didn't need to be told twice, shooting up from the chair and offering you a quick, desperate ‘thank you’ before bolting out the door to intercept Sarah near the daybeds—still giving the remaining three of you a good view.
You, Rafe, and JJ moved closer to the window to watch as John B approached her, leaning on the back of the sofa. John B didn't invade her space—he stood a respectful distance away, his hands shoved into his pockets of his swim shorts as he spoke to her softly. Within seconds, you saw Sarah’s shoulders drop, a genuine, relieved, tearful smile breaking across her face as she sat down next to him on the daybed.
Rafe let out a soft chuckle, wrapping his arms around your waist from behind and pulling you against his chest. He dipped his chin onto your shoulder, his lips brushing your ear. "Look at you playing matchmaker. I didn't know I was coupled up with Cupid."
You laughed, leaning back into his warmth. "I shot you with an arrow on Day One, Cameron.” You joked back, looking at him over your shoulder. “You just didn't know it."
Rafe smiled, his hands sliding down to rest on your hips as he pecked you on the cheek.
BUT the peace didn't last long, because Topper’s frustration with his failed two-timing attempt had to go somewhere.
Ten minutes after his dispute with Sarah, he’d walked over to Ruthie who had been avoiding him since and he didn’t know why. She was tanning by the pool while he tried to sweet talk her but she wasn’t for it, a shouting match erupting that had the entire villa hiding their grins as they watched from multiple parts of the villa.
"You need to stop following me around, Topper!" Ruthie yelled, sitting up on her lounger and slamming her sunglasses down. "What? Sarah threw you in the trash, and now you're acting like a lost puppy? It’s making me look bad!"
"Making you look bad?" Topper shouted back, his face turning bright red. "Y-you're the one who wanted this! You said Rafe was boring! You said Sarah was the ‘lesser version’ of you! All I’m trying to do is secure our spot, and you're out here throwing a tantrum!"
From the lounge, JJ let out a loud snort, high-fiving John B through the window.
Nobody even bothered to intervene.
Topper and Ruthie had isolated themselves so much that watching them turn on each other was pure reality TV gold.
And at least now everyone knew their intentions.
BY the time night fell, the villa had finally calmed down. The lights shifted to that soft, neon blue and pink glow, casting long shadows across the deck. Most of the Islanders had retreated inside to escape the bugs, but you needed to clear your head.
You were out on the patio, clad in a pink sports bra and leggings, aggressively working through a set, when you heard the glass doors slide open.
Out walked Rafe, carrying a towel and a water bottle. He’d changed into a loose white tank top that showed off the intricate maps of veins running up his arms, his buzzcut slightly damp from a shower. He stopped when he spotted you, watching you with an amused smirk.
"Midnight workout?" he asked, leaning against the squat rack. "I didn't take you for a gym bunny."
You paused, wiping a bead of sweat from your forehead as you caught your breath. "I like exercising at night. Clears my head.” You shrugged, grabbing your own water bottle from the ground. “When you spend all day listening to people spiral over who kissed who, you need an outlet to keep from losing your mind."
Rafe’s smile turned genuine, a soft, understanding look in his eye. "Mind if I join? I could use a distraction myself."
You smiled, face dewy from sweat. “‘Course not, handsome.” You teased, tossing the bottle to the side. “I could use the company.”
For the next hour, the two of you had the entire outdoor villa to yourselves. And what started as a workout session turned into recess with Rafe as he tried to show you how to do a proper clean-and-press, but you ended up laughing so hard at his "trainer voice" that he ended up dropping the weights entirely.
By one in the morning, everyone else in the villa was dead to the world as you and Rafe crept into the indoor kitchen like two teenagers breaking into a cafeteria.
"Shhh," you whispered, swiping a box of chocolate-covered pretzels from the pantry as Rafe crumpled the bag. "If JJ wakes up and sees us eating the good snacks, he’ll kill us."
"Let him try," Rafe murmured through a mouthful. He reached up to grab a glass from the upper cabinet, but his elbow caught a decorative ceramic mug on the edge of the counter, sending it crashing against the ground. The mug shattered against the marble floor, the sound echoing through the quiet house like a gunshot.
You both froze, holding your breath for a full ten seconds, waiting for a producer to yell through the speaker or a door to fly open. When nothing happened, Rafe looked down at the shards, then back at you, a massive, uncontained grin breaking across his face. He grabbed your hand, adrenaline pumping through both of your veins.
"C’mon," he whispered, the two of you bolting out the back doors, giggling like idiots as you sprinted across the dark lawn, finally collapsing into the large outdoor daybed in a tangled mess of limbs and laughter.
You laid there for a long time, catching your breath, staring up at the clear sky. The stars were out in full force, free from the city lights of Vegas that you were used to. Yet, it was something you were starting to admire.
"You wanna find some constellations? Look," you said, pointing a finger upward. "That one right there looks exactlyyyy like Topper’s big ass ego..."
Rafe let out a loud, genuine laugh, pointing to a separate cluster of stars. “I lowkey think that one’s Ruthie’s web of delusions.” He joked back, eliciting a small laugh out of you.
Rafe turned onto his side to look at you, propping his head up with his hand, his eyes incredibly soft in the moonlight. "...I know this is potentially super corny, but….you make me feel like a kid.” He told you softly. “Honestly..."
You turned your head to face him, noting his grim expression against his soft words. "...Is that a bad thing?"
"No," he said softly, his voice dropping into that vulnerable register that always caught you off guard. "It’s the best thing. You’re giving me the childhood I never had, you know?” He explained, thumb tracing your arm. “The kind I used to wish for. With you... I don't feel like I have to fight. I just get to be me."
At his words, your heart melted. You reached up, your fingers tracing the sharp line of his jaw before sliding into the short hair at the back of his neck. "You deserve to be happy, Rafe. You really do." The man smiled back at you softly, eyes tracing the features of your face.
He didn't answer with words. He just leaned down, his lips meeting yours in a kiss that instantly made the rest of the world disappear.
It started sweet, full of that deep, emotional reverence, but as you shifted, climbing up to sit on his lap, the heat turned dangerous—his hands gripping your waist, pulling you flush against his chest, his tongue sliding against yours with a desperate, addictive hunger.
You almost lost it when he groaned into the kiss, one of his hands sliding up to rest at the base of your neck—
"Hey! Lovebirds!”
“Oh! Break it up!"
The sudden voices made you both jump, pulling apart with flushed cheeks as Sarah and Cleo stood standing at the edge of the daybed, both carrying pillows and heavy blankets, looking thoroughly exhausted and amused.
Rafe groaned and rolled his eyes, shooting the girls a playful glare as you sat up on your elbow. “Cockblockers.” You grumbled, narrowing your eyes on the girls. “Shouldn’t you both be, I don’t know, sleep?”
"We might’ve been had we not heard you guys break that mug," Sarah laughed, dropping her blanket onto the foot of the bed. "And honestly? Neither of us wants to sleep in that bedroom right now. I swear Topper is snoring out of anger and I’d rather sleep at the bottom of an active volcano than next to him, and Cleo doesn’t want to sleep with Pope knowing he’s probably dreaming about Kie.” She deadpanned. “So, we’re crashing your party."
Cleo climbed in between you and the edge of the bed, rolling her eyes. "Yeah, so keep your clothes on, Cameron.” she teased.
Rafe groaned, burying his face in your shoulder, but he didn't fight it. He pulled you back down against his chest, wrapping the blanket tightly around both of you as Sarah and Cleo settled into the space beside you.
It was unconventional but as you fell asleep to the sound of Rafe’s steady heartbeat and the warmth of Sarah and Cleo, you wouldn't have changed a single thing.
THE morning sun hit the garden with a vengeance, but you were woken up by the scent of fresh coffee. You opened your eyes to find Sarah and Cleo already sitting up, staring at the foot of the daybed with identical, stunned expressions.
As you rubbed the sleep from your eyes, you found that Rafe was standing there, holding a large wooden tray stacked with three plates of perfectly cooked breakfast—french toast, eggs, fresh fruit, and three mugs of iced coffee.
"Morning," he said, a faint blush creeping up his neck as he set the tray down between the three of you. "I figured since you all decided to camp out here, you’d be hungry."
Sarah clapped her hands together, looking like she was about to cry tears of joy. "Rafe Cameron, you are officially promoted to the best guy in this villa."
Cleo took a sip of the iced coffee, raising her eyebrows in approval. "Damn, girl. You trained him well.” She nudged you, lowering her voice to a whisper. “This is elite."
You looked up at Rafe, a massive grin on your face as you caught his eye. He looked so incredibly cute when he was flustered, his fingers tugging at the hem of his shirt. "You're adorable when you’re blushing, you know that?"
"Shut up and eat your toast," he muttered playfully, though he winked at you before heading back toward the house.
The peaceful breakfast was cut short, mid-chew, when Pope came running out of the lounge doors, his phone held high in the air. The rest of the Islanders were trailing behind him like a flock of anxious seagulls.
"I got a text!" Pope shouted. “And trust me, you guys are gonna wanna hear this…” He egged on before reading. "Islanders, the power is shifting. Tonight, there will be a recoupling where the guys will choose who they want to couple up with. #ChooseWisely #FirepitFallout"
You locked eyes with everyone, though your gaze landed on Rafe who was leaning against the doorway between the yard and the kitchen. The atmosphere in the villa instantly did a complete 180. And now, Day Six was officially underway, and something told you…things were about to get brutal.
THE makeup room was a chaotic mess.
Kiara spent the morning pacing, trying to figure out where she stood between two guys and her friend. She first pulled Cleo first to ensure they were still on good terms regarding Pope.
"I just... I want to know if you're going to be hurt if… Pope picks me tonight," Kie asked nervously, sitting beside the girl as she did her makeup.
Cleo didn't even look up from her bronzer, patting the brush against the palette as she sighed. "Kie, I told you. He’s all yours. If he picks you, he picks you. I’m not interested in being a second choice.” She shrugged, fixing Kiara with a small, but short, smile. “We're good."
But when Kiara tried to talk to JJ near the pool, he was completely shut down. He gave her short, one-word answers, his face entirely devoid of his usual playful charm.
Frustrated and hurt, Kiara ran back to the dressing room in tears. Unbeknownst to either of them, Sarah had been standing by, watching the whole exchange.
Confessional : Sarah
“Where the hell does JJ get off on being a dick to Kiara? Is he seriously acting like this over a confessional?”
She slammed her soda down on the nearest surface, face twisting. "Oh, hell no.” Sarah marched straight out to the pool area, where JJ had resumed lifting weights, stopping right in front of his bench and crossing her arms. "Hey, you,” She gathered his attention, her shadow falling over him as he looked up at her. “Drop the weights."
JJ sighed, sitting up and wiping his face with a towel. "What's up, Sarah? I'm kind of in the zone—"
"You're being a dick," Sarah said flatly.
JJ’s face twisted. “What—”
"You heard one confessional, probably half of one, and decided to completely punish Kiara for it. She wasn't calling you a player to be mean, she was saying she was scared to get her heart broken because she actually really likes you.” Sarah defended. “You need to get the full story before you start throwing a fit.” She snapped. “Go and talk to her like an adult."
JJ blinked, genuinely caught off guard by her fierceness. He looked down at his shoes, the realization of his mistake sinking in.
Confessional : JJ
"Shit. I... I didn't think about it like that." He stared blankly at the camera.
MEANWHILE, Topper was busy still playing both sides of the fence. In a last ditch attempt, he pulled Sarah for one last chat near the fireplace, trying to salvage his position.
"Sarah, please," Topper said, looking at her with desperate eyes. "I know I messed up with the Ruthie stuff, but it was just a distraction. You’re the only girl in here for me, I can feel it.” He lied. “Just give me one more chance. Tonight. Let me prove it to you."
Sarah looked at him, her expression completely detached as she shook her head. "Topper, I think you're a great guy on paper, but.. I have my eye on someone else now.” She admitted through a tight-lipped grimace. “I don't think you and I are a match."
Despite her refusal, Topper was relentless—he grabbed her hand as she moved to get up, looking entirely sincere. "J-just think about it, Sarah.”
“Topper—”
“Don't throw away our connection over one mistake."
Sarah sighed, her throat growing tight as her old habits of people-pleasing kicked in, and she gave a vague nod, just to get him to leave. But he took it as a sign, an acceptance.
But ten minutes later, Topper pulled Ruthie into the private pantry, completely unaware that the hidden cameras were still tracking his every move.
“What do you want, Topper—”
"I’m over Sarah.” Topper whispered, his voice frantic as he held her by the waist. “I promise. She’s too much drama, okay? And tonight? Tonight, I’m picking you.” He told her, brushing hair behind her ears. “We’re going to take this to the next level, and we’re going to win this entire show together. Just…stay solid with me."
Ruthie smirked, wrapping her arms around his neck. "I knew you’d come to your senses.” She smiled. “Let’s get that hundred grand."
Confessional: Topper
"It is not two-timing.” He defended. “Look, in the legal world, you always have to have a contingency plan. Sarah is… a wild card right now, but Ruthie is a sure thing. I’m just covering all my bases to ensure I stay in this villa."
JOHN B pulled Sarah right after, sitting her down on the daybed where they’d shared a moment the day before. "Sarah, please listen to me," he said, his voice earnest. "Just drop Topper. He’s clearly a liar, and just trying to save his own skin.” He tried. “I know yesterday you said you weren’t sure but, just give me a chance tonight. I promise you, I’ll spend every single day making sure you know you’re my first choice."
Sarah looked torn, her eyes watering. "John B, you're amazing. And I think I could really like you. But... I just don't know. I’m still so confused right now. I think I just need to see where things go..."
John B sighed, leaning back against the cushions. He knew he couldn't force her. He would never want to.
Confessional: John B
"If Topper gets to choose before me tonight, he’s going to pick Sarah just to spite me, and I’m going to be left in a horrible position. I’m just praying the producers give me the green light first."
SURPRISINGLY, JJ also managed to find Cleo before the sun went down, sitting with her on the edge of the pool.
"Hey, Cleo," JJ said softly, dropping his usual goofy persona entirely.
She just smiled his way, focusing on kicking her feet in the water.
JJ wasn’t used to things like this, but it was clear that Cleo needed a pick-me-up. "I…noticed you’ve been sorta down today. For a few days actually…” He scratched the back of his neck. “I just wanted to say... I think you’re an amazing girl.” He told her, her brown eyes slowly turning to him. “And I know that our date proved we weren't a romantic match, but you’ve got a fire in you that I’ve never seen in anyone else—and trust me, I’ve been with a lot of girls.” He added, gaining a laugh from both of them. “I guess I just wanted to say…don’t let anyone make you feel like you're less-than. Just be patient, y’know? The right guy is going to come through those doors, and he’s going to worship the ground you walk on."
Cleo smiled, a genuine, emotional look in her eye as she bumped his shoulder. "Thanks, JJ.” She said, her heart swelling. “I guess you’re not just a pretty face."
He laughed, nudging her shoulder."Don't ruin my reputation," He whispered.
Just then, Cleo’s phone pinged.
“Shit…” she sighed. “Hey! I got a text!” Her voice boomed through the villa. Everyone emerged gathering around.
“What’s it say?” John B asked as he stopped, out of breath.
"Islanders, the clock is ticking. In one hour, the power shifts. Put on your hottest outfits and head down to the fire pit for tonight’s first official recoupling. #DressedToKill #FiresWillBurn #WhoIsYourType"
THE night was pitch black, the villa lit entirely by the fierce, flickering orange flames of the central fire pit. The air was heavy, the sound of crickets and the absolute terror of the ten Islanders gathered around the semi-circle couch.
In the center stood Ariana, looking like a goddess in a sleek velvet gown. She looked around the circle with a pointed expression as everyone’s eyes glued to her.
"Islanders," Ariana started, her voice echoing in the quiet night. "Tonight, the power is entirely in the hands of the boys.” She emphasized. “One by one, they will stand up, explain the reasons behind their choice, and reveal the girl they want to couple up with."
She turned her eyes to the right side of the couch, locking eyes with one of the guys. "Rafe.” She called, nodding at him. “You're up first. Please step forward."
Rafe stood up, his posture confident and relaxed. He walked over to the center of the pit, his blue eyes locking onto yours instantly. A soft, knowing smile played on his lips.
Despite everything—every cuddle, every reassurance—your heart was still racing wildly, a small part of you anticipating the worst as he took a deep breath.
"The girl I’m choosing tonight... she completely made my experience in this villa so far," Rafe said, his voice steady and full of deep sincerity. "I came here expecting a game, but she gave me something…real. She’s smart, she’s beautiful, she reads me like a book, and she makes me want to be a better man every single day. And she’s made these last six days the best days of my life. So,the girl I want to couple up with…” He took a deep breath, the ghost of a smile on his face.
“...is Y/N."
The girls, minus Ruthie, all let out a collective ‘aww’ as you stood up walking over to him with a massive grin. He pulled you in by the waist, planting a firm kiss on your cheek before leading you to the adjacent empty couch.
"Next up," Ariana continued, a smile on her face. "Topper."
John B instantly slumped in his seat, his brow furrowing as Topper stepped forward. Topper straightened his collar, giving the cameras a polished, confident look.
"The chick I’m choosing tonight... we’ve had some ups and downs," Topper said, his voice smooth. "But she’s gorgeous, she fits my lifestyle, she’s got great style, and I think together, we have what it takes to go all the way to the finale.” He grinned cockily. “So, the girl I want to couple up with…” He paused, eyes lingering on Sarah before they averted swiftly.
“... is Ruthie."
The entire fire pit went entirely stagnant.
Sarah’s jaw dropped. John B’s eyes went wide. Everyone held their breath.
And Topper didn't even look at Sarah as Ruthie stood up, a smug, triumphant smirk plastered on her face as she walked past Sarah, shooting her a snarky look.
Sarah bit her lip, her eyes filling with tears as Kiara reached over to grab her hand while the new couple a seat next to you and Rafe as you shot them both a mean glare.
"Next," Ariana said, her voice dropping into a serious tone. "...is Pope."
Pope stepped forward, looking entirely stressed. He didn't look at Cleo. And he didn’t look at Kie.
He didn’t look at anyone, really. He kept his eyes fixed on the fire.
"...This has been a really hard decision for me. I’ve had a connection with two amazing girls. But before I make my choice, I want to say... I’m sorry." He looked briefly at Cleo, who just let out a long, tired sigh. "And the girl I want to couple up with... is Kiara."
Kiara stood up, looking entirely guilty as she swallowed harshly and mouthed ‘sorry’ to Cleo before walking over to join Pope before the couple joined the four of you on the opposite couch behind Ariana. Cleo just adjusted in her seat and looked down at her hands in her lap.
"John B," Ariana called, motioning for him to stand.
And John B looked like Christmas had come early. He practically bolted to the center of the pit, his eyes fixed entirely on Sarah as he straightened out his shirt.
"The girl I’m choosing... she deserves the absolute world.” He said softly. “She deserves a guy who looks at her and sees his entire future, not just a partner for a game.” He threw a look over his shoulder, Topper’s eyebrows furrowing. “I’ve wanted to be with her since day one, and I’m never going to let her feel like a second option again. So, the girl I want to couple up with... is Sarah."
Sarah let out a broken sob of relief as she let go of the breath she was holding, running into John B’s open arms. He lifted her off her feet, hugging her tightly as the girls cheered.
"Lastly," Ariana smiled. "JJ."
JJ stepped forward, walking over to Cleo with a warm, respectful expression. "The girl I’m choosing, because I am choosing her... she’s had a rough couple of days. But she’s got a fire in her that this villa needs, and she deserves to find real love. So, I’m happy to be her partner, her protector, and her placeholder until the right guy comes along to give her what she actually deserves.” He smiled at Cleo. “The girl I want to couple up with... is Cleo."
Cleo smiled, holding back tears as she continued walking over to give JJ a tight hug. The pair pulled apart as they joined the rest of you on the couch.
Ariana smoothed her dress, turning and looking around the newly formed couples. "Well, Islanders, the choices have been made.” She smiled pitifully. “No one was left single and vulnerable….tonight.” She said, head tilting. “But I can't say the same for the next recoupling. Until then, sleep tight."
And the second Ariana’s heels clicked away down the path, the peace broke entirely.
Sarah stood up from John B’s side, marching straight over to Topper, her face red with a mixture of tears and pure rage. "You are a pathological liar, Topper!" she screamed, her voice cracking. "You literally held my hand an hour ago and begged me for another chance! And then you stand up there and pick her?"
Ruthie stepped in front of Topper, her arms crossed as she sneered at Sarah. "Oh, cry about it, Sarah. It’s not Topper’s fault that he’s just not into you.” She snapped. “You're boring, and he wanted a real woman who actually knows how to play the game. So, take John B’s hand and move on."
“Who the hell do you think you are—” Sarah egged on, stepping further into Ruthie’s space. The girl’s voices overlapped, drowning the other out just as Topper spun around, pointing an aggressive finger at John B, who was stepping up to protect Sarah.
“What’s happening?” You whispered, clinging to Rafe’s arm.
“I think shit’s finally going down.” He said plainly.
"You’ve been plotting on her the whole time!” Topper argued. “And you’ve got everyone thinking I’m the snake?! You’re a class act, bro—”
He kept going as Pope and JJ tried to separate the guys while Cleo and Kie tried to push Sarah and Ruthie apart, you and Rafe standing by in shock.
"Spare me the bullshit, Topper! You’re just here for the fuckin’ money—" John B shouted back, his face inches from Topper’s.
The voices were overlapping—a mess of screaming, crying, and pointing fingers. The cameras were zooming in, the drama reaching a fever pitch.
“God, they’re giving me a headache…” You muttered, massaging your temples. “Shouldn’t production step in—”
"Yo, shut the fuck up!"
The booming roar cut through the chaos and everyone went dead silent, turning to look at Rafe. He was standing at the edge of the pit, his chest heaving as he had you pulled against his side, his eyes flashing with a dangerous intensity.
He pointed a finger at Topper, then at Ruthie. "What’s done is done.” He told everyone. “You two want to be snakes? Fine. Go be snakes in the kitchen or something. But for the love of everything good, stop fuckin’ screaming.” He begged, throwing a hand in Topper’s direction..” You got what you wanted, Topper. Now take your girl and get out of here."
Confessional : Sarah
"Rafe screaming like that? Terrifying.” She sniffed, wiping her eyes. “But honestly? I’m so glad he did. Topper and Ruthie are both dead to me. John B is the only reason I’m not packing my bags right now…
Confessional : Rafe
"I tried to stay calm. I really did.” He rubbed his palms down his face. “But the screaming ‘n shit, Jesus... And I couldn't listen to Topper lie for another second. Plus, I just wanted to get my girl out of there and go to bed."
But before the couples could even trudge back inside, your phone buzzed in your hand.
“Wait,” you said, tugging on Rafe’s hand as he was leading you back inside the villa. “I got a text,” you announced, the rest of the islanders gathering around. "Congrats on surviving you all’s first recoupling. Seeing as tensions are high, one couple gets to escape the villa drama and go on a private, overnight beach date. However, the choice is up to you all. Please vote and make a decision."
You looked at Rafe, then at everyone else. Within thirty seconds, a silent consensus was reached.
“Topper and Ruthie?” You questioned, an eyebrow raised as you surveyed everyone. They all nodded as you cast the vote, typing their names and sending it back. Not because you loved them, or because they deserved it, but because you desperately needed them out of the house so everyone could breathe.
Five minutes later, Topper and Ruthie received the text that they had won the date. They didn’t say anything to anyone and left with smug expressions, leaving the remaining eight Islanders to finally collapse into the lounge couches in pure relief.
The girls were on one end, the guys on the other.
"...What the hell just happened?" Kiara whispered, leaning her head on Sarah’s shoulder. She looked over at Cleo, her eyes full of apology. "Cleo... I’m so sorry—"
Cleo just waved her off, taking a sip of her water. "Kie, please stop.” She interrupted. “He was going to choose one of us. He couldn't choose both. He made his choice. It’s done. We're good.” She finalized. “Let’s just…move on."
Kie just nodded, resigning herself to silence.
Sarah sighed, shoulders slumping. "After this shit-show? I am completely done with Topper. I can’t believe I was stupid enough to believe him…” She scoffed. “...And I should probably thank John B for…everything. Respecting my decision even when I was being naive and stupid, comforting me…”
“Yeah,” you nodded, yawning. “I think he’d appreciate that.” You smiled tiredly at the blonde. "Alright," you said, standing up and stretching your limbs. "It’s been a five-mile-long day and, frankly, I think we all need to sleep this off."
FOR the first time since you’d entered the villa as a bombshell, you and Rafe actually got to walk into the bedroom as a legitimate couple. You changed into a soft, oversized t-shirt, while Rafe slipped into a pair of grey sweatpants.
The room fell quiet quickly, the absence of Topper and Ruthie making the space feel twice as large and ten times lighter.
You climbed into the soft mattress, sliding under the crisp white duvet. A second later, Rafe climbed in beside you smelling freshly showered. He didn't hesitate, he instantly rolled onto his side, pulling your back flush against his chest, his large frame completely enveloping yours. His strong arms wrapped tightly around your waist, holding you like he never planned on letting you go.
"Rafe," you whispered into the dark room, your hands covering his. “...I’m really glad I met you.”
Rafe murmured, his voice low and sleepy as he dipped his head down, planting a soft, warm kiss against the bare skin of your neck. "So am I, Angel.” He whispered. “Get some sleep."
SYNOPSIS & WC─•❥ [8.6k] Raised under the suffocating pressures of Figure Eight, two best friends anchor each other through family tragedies while spiraling into opposite, deeply destructive coping mechanisms...
WARNING(S) & A/N─•❥ swearing, suicide attempt, overdose, substance abuse, physical violence/abuse, mental illness, toxic relationship, co-dependency, pls lmk what y'all think i rlly love this concept
YOU were seven years old the afternoon your world collided with Rafe Cameron’s. The country club was hosting a mid-summer gala—an excuse for the island’s elite to drink high-end scotch while solidifying real estate syndicates and shipping logistics. Your mother had spent three hours smoothing out the pleats of your dress, her fingers pinching your shoulders with a warning to be on your best behavior.
You stood on the veranda, the glare of the Marsh blinding you while the adults congregated. Your parents were in a corner with Ward Cameron, their voices dropping into that low register reserved for serious deals and contract closures. And you and your two older brothers were entirely forgotten, per usual.
"Go play," your mother had murmured, not looking at you as she waved a manicured hand toward the lawn. "And don’t get that dress dirty. Again."
At her dismissal, you wandered down the steps toward the edge of the forest. That was where Sarah Cameron found you. She was younger, a bright-eyed burst of energy in a pink sundress, dragging a boy by his wrist.
"Look, Rafe! I told you there were other kids. Hi!” Sarah announced, her voice high as she stopped in front of you, your brothers running off further. She looked between you and her brother, her nose crinkling as you both stood in silence. "You guys are boring. I'm going to feed the ducks." She rolled her eyes, skipping off. Sarah dashed away, leaving the two of you standing under the shade of a massive live oak.
Rafe was eight, adorned in khaki shorts and a polo shirt that already had a faint grass stain near the hem. He looked at you, his blue eyes squinting against the sun with his hands shoved deep into his pockets. He looked just as stiff, just as bored, and just as suffocated as you felt.
"Your mom looks mean," Rafe said plainly, pointing to the woman staring at you from afar..
You blinked, shocked by the blunt honesty of it, looking carefully over your shoulder at her before looking back at Rafe. "She's just... serious." You muttered.
"My dad is too," Rafe muttered, shrugging and kicking at a rock in the dirt. "He keeps telling me I have to stand straight because people are watching. I hate it."
"I hate it too," you whispered. “But my mom says ‘hate is a strong word’.”
A slow smile broke across Rafe’s face, clearing away the tense look he had been wearing all afternoon. It was a sweet smile, completely devoid of the sharp edges that would define him later in life. "Want to go look at crabs? There’s a whole bunch of them by the dock.” He invited. “If we're quiet, they don't hide."
You looked back at the veranda. Your parents were still nodding along to Ward Cameron's booming laughter. They wouldn't notice your absence for hours.
"...Okay," you said, nodding.
That afternoon was the foundation being laid. While your parents signed documents, the two of you sat on the edge of a weathered wooden dock, your legs dangling over the water, discussing the annoyingness of the adult world.
You discovered you were born in the same hospital, raised on the same private streets, and held to the exact same impossible standards for children. You were cut from the identical piece of luxury cloth, and you both already knew the fabric was itching you alive.
From that day forward, you were inseparable.
Throughout elementary school, Rafe was your constant. He was a sweet, hyper-attentive boy whose devotion to you was uncomplicated. At the private academy you both attended, he would sprint across the courtyard the moment the lunch bell rang, just to ensure he secured the seat directly across from you.
"I brought you those fruit snacks you like," he’d say, tossing three plastic pouches onto your tray. He knew your mother had started monitoring your ‘calorie intake’ under the guise of "healthy habits," restricting you from candy and sweets, so he took it upon himself to ensure you never went unsatisfied.
When the older kids tried to crowd you at the swings, Rafe would step in, his chest puffed out, his small fists clenched at his sides until they backed down. He shared his toys without a second thought—his limited-edition comic books, his favorite skateboard, his video games. If you expressed even a passing interest in something he owned, it was yours.
Every single afternoon, when the yellow school bus hissed to a stop on Figure Eight, Rafe would sling his backpack over one shoulder, get off, and wait for you. Your house was three blocks past his, down the oak-lined avenue. He would walk you all the way to your front steps, his feet dragging as the distance closed.
"I’ll see you tomorrow" he’d smile, standing on the bottom step, looking up at you with an earnestness that made little you smile.
THE downfall didn't happen gradually. No. It happened violently.
You were ten years old, finishing up fifth grade when everything fell.
It began on a random Tuesday. Rafe hadn’t shown up at the bus stop that morning, and when you arrived at lunch that afternoon, he was sitting at a table alone, his food untouched and his face pale.
You sat beside him, your shoulder brushing his. "Rafe? What's wrong?"
He didn't look at you, his eyes fixed on the wood of the table. "I think…my mom left."
The words were tiny, barely carrying across the noisy cafeteria.
"What do you mean?" you asked.
“I don’t know," Rafe whispered, his voice cracking, though he fought with everything he had to keep from crying. "Her and my dad got into this big fight last night. I heard things breaking and I heard the front door slams, so I looked out of my window. I saw her ger in her car, and…she drove away.” He told you, voice small. “...It’s been three days. My dad told us she’s not coming back and we aren't allowed to ask about her anymore."
You reached out, wrapping your small fingers around his wrist. His skin was freezing despite the indoor heat. You didn't know what to say, because in Kook world, mothers didn't leave. Mothers stayed and maintained appearances, no matter how rotten the house was on the inside.
And three long weeks later, tragedy snuck it’s way into your own home.
Your father—the only person in your house who ever truly looked at you with kindness, the man who would secretly buy you ice cream when your mother wasn't looking—suffered a heart attack in his office. There was no warning. One minute he was checking your homework, and the next, your mother was standing in the foyer, informing you and your brothers that your father was gone.
The news fractured the very ground beneath your feet, replaced by an adult grief that your ten-year-old mind couldn’t comprehend.
Almost immediately, the ways you chose to survive your individual grief diverged.
Rafe exploded outward. The sweet boy who shared his lunch dissolved into an angry boy. He began picking fights at school, disobeying his teachers. If a boy looked at him too long in the hallway, Rafe’s fists were flying. He became a regular visitor in the principal’s office, his knuckles constantly skinned and bleeding. The teachers began to look at him with a mixture of fear and pity, whispering about him while he was less than a foot away.
You, conversely, imploded—retreating into a deep silence. The world lost its color. You stopped raising your hand in class—your grades, which had always been immaculate, plummeted into a sea of red ink. You stopped speaking to your friends, choosing instead to spend recess leaning against the chain-link fence, staring blankly at the horizon. And stopped smiling entirely.
Yet, amidst the chaos, your friendship held, even growing tighter.
Whenever Rafe got into a fight, you were the one who walked him to the nurse’s office.
"You can't keep getting in trouble," you whispered one afternoon, walking him back to class. "I heard Ms.Barkley say that they might have to expel you…"
"Let them," he snarled, his chest heaving with a scowl on his small face. "I don't care. My dad doesn't care…” He trailed off, huffing. “Nobody does."
"I do," you said softly, peering at the boy. That’s when Rafe’s breathing hitched, his face softening. He looked at you, the anger draining from his face for a split second.
"I know.” He nodded, looking away. “You're the only one."
From that point on, you became his ultimate personal voucher. When the principal called your mother because you had lied to cover for Rafe—claiming the other boy had started the fight, swearing up and down that Rafe had only been protecting himself—you took the scolding without flinching. Prepared to do it all again.
And Rafe was there for you in return, unconditionally. When everything became too loud, when your brothers were screaming at home and your mother’s criticisms were suffocating you, Rafe was there when you came to his door to “play”.
He would sit with you in absolute quiet, sometimes for hours, just letting his presence act as a buffer between you and the rest of the world. He tried, in his own clumsy ways, to bring you back. He would bring you weird shells he found on the beach, or tell you stupid jokes he’d heard from the older kids, just trying to catch a glimpse of the girl he met under that oak tree.
But the true depth of your parents' cruelty became clear on the day of your father’s funeral.
The wake was held at the country club—the very place you had met. The room was heavy with the scent of floral arrangements and perfume. You were in a black velvet dress that felt like a straightjacket, standing beside your mother as she received condolences with an unbothered dignity that made you sick to your stomach.
Unable to breathe, you slipped away under the guise of needing to use the restroom, hiding behind the velvet drapes of the library corridor.
A few feet away, hidden by the height of a massive marble pillar, Rafe was standing. He had followed you, as he always did, but he had stopped because he heard voices approaching from the adjoining lounge.
It was your mother and Ward, the clink of ice against crystal punctuating their conversation.
"She’s taking this all entirely too hard," your mother’s voice rang out, sharp and absent of any warmth. "I had to take her to a child psychologist last week. The woman had the nerve to call it 'Prolonged Grief Disorder.'” She scoffed. “She’s just being dramatic. You know, her brothers lost their father too, and look at them—they’re doing perfectly fine. They’re back to their sports, their grades are alright. But she just sits there, moping.” She rolled her eyes, sipping from her glass. “I won't have a child of mine acting like a martyr for the rest of her life."
Rafe’s jaw clenched so hard you could see the muscle ticking from across the hall.
Ward sighed. "It’s the same with Rafe. Ever since his mother left, the boy has been unbearable.” Ward sneered. “He’s doing it for attention, of course. I tell him every day—'look at your sisters'. Sarah and Wheezie have stopped asking questions. They’ve moved on. They understand. But Rafe…” He sighed, shaking his head. “I’m giving him one more chance before I start taking things away. Or sending him away."
Behind the curtain, your breath hitched and you looked at Rafe—he was staring at the floor, his hands curled into fists by his side.
BY the time you entered middle school, the cracks in your foundations had widened.
Rafe was twelve, nearly thirteen, and he was a persistent disciplinary problem. He spent more time suspended than he did in the classroom and his anger had grown sharper, fueled by his father's growing disappointment in him.
You, on the other hand, had become entirely invisible. You were a ghost in the hallways—silent, fleeting, and entirely checked out. You didn't study anymore, you didn't do homework, you didn’t participate in class. You sat at the back, staring out the window, waiting for the bell to ring.
It was a Tuesday evening in late spring when you realized you were more alike than either of you cared to notice.
It had to be nearly ten o'clock at night and Rafe had just ended a screaming match with Ward, his father calling him a failure, a burden, because he wasn’t fond of his new stepmother, Rose. The words had burned like acid to his heart, Rafe slamming the front door of Tannyhill and marching down the dark streets of Figure Eight. He was fuming with rage, kicking violently at loose gravel, sending neighbors’ plastic recycling bins crashing into the gutters—hoodie pulled up with his hands in his pockets.
But as he rounded the corner onto your street, he stopped.
In the dim glow of the porch lights on your patio step was a small figure, curled up. You were sitting with your knees tucked into your chest, your head resting on your arms, your shoulders shaking with violent sobs.
Rafe’s anger evaporated instantly and he rushed to sit on the pavement beside you, his hand coming to rest on your trembling back.
"Hey," he said, his voice unusually soft. "What happened?"
You lifted your head. In the harsh fluorescent light, Rafe felt his blood run cold. Your left cheek was clearly swollen, a distinct handprint rising against your skin. Your eyes were bloodshot, your lips trembling.
"My report card came in the mail today," you whispered, your voice cracking. "I... I failed three classes."
"Did she…hit you?" Rafe’s voice dropped into a whisper.
You didn’t offer a clear answer, looking down between the two of you instead. "...She said... she said she's going to have to write a check to the school board just so they don't hold me back a grade. She called me a disappointment, said my father would be ashamed.” You explained, holding back tears. “She told me to get out of her sight."
Rafe stood up so fast his sneakers squeaked against the asphalt. He looked toward your house, his eyes wild. "She can’t—"
"Don't," you cried, grabbing the hem of his oversized hoodie, pulling him back down. "Please. Just... don't. You'll just make it worse. For both of us."
He looked down at you, his chest heaving. He reached out, his thumb gently brushing just below the red mark on your cheek, his touch surprisingly tender for a boy who spent his days breaking things.
"Fuck adults," Rafe said, the words heavy with absolute conviction. It was the first time you’d ever heard him swear. "They suck."
"They do," you agreed, wiping your eyes, a light laugh escaping you.
Rafe looked around the quiet neighborhood, the residents of Figure Eight were sleeping peacefully. And a reckless grin broke across his face.
"Come on," he said, grabbing your hand and pulling you to your feet. "Let's go make them miserable."
“Rafe, what—”
“They make us mad all the time. We can make them mad, too,” He looked at you. “Are you in or out?”
And you stared at him for a long while before following behind the Cameron boy.
That night, for hours, you and Rafe ran wild across the island. You didn't do anything truly criminal, but you were definitely in for it if either of your parents found out. You ran through the private golf course, tearing up the pristine sand traps with your bare feet. Rafe found a crate of expired fireworks behind a maintenance shed, and you spent an hour lighting firecrackers and throwing them into the empty swimming pools of the residents, laughing hysterically at the booming echoes as you ran off.
You climbed to the roof of the country club's boat house, stealing a cooler full of sodas and throwing the empty aluminum cans at the yachts docked in the slips.
For the first time in a long time, the devastating fog in your chest cleared away.
You caught Rafe's eye as you both sprinted away from a private security patrol car, ducking behind the dunes, a sound escaping your throat—it was a laugh. A real, breathless, genuine laugh.
Rafe froze, staring at you under the moonlight. The security car's headlights swept over the dunes, illuminating the lines of his face—he looked awestruck.
"What?" you whispered, pressing your back against the sand to stay hidden.
"...You smiled," Rafe said, his voice dropping. "You laughed. I haven't seen you do that since fifth grade."
The weight of his words settled over you, sweet and somehow still deeply painful. You looked at him—this boy who was constantly angry, yet always safe for you—and threw your arms around his neck, burying your face in his shoulder.
"...You're my best friend, Rafe," you whispered. "You're like... me, but in boy form."
Rafe’s arms hesitated before they tightened around your waist, holding you so close it nearly bruised your ribs.
HIGH School was harder.
When you turned fourteen, just weeks before the start of your freshman year, your mother, realizing your performance had slipped for the last time, dragged you to an upscale, discreet clinic in Charleston.
The diagnosis was unsurprising—severe clinical depression.
The doctor had handed your mother a pamphlet and a prescription as you left. And your mother had waited until you were in the parking lot before tearing the pamphlet into pieces and dropping the prescription slip into a trash can.
"You are not going to be dependent on medication because you refuse to control your emotions," she had said, her voice icy as she started the car. "You are fine. And you have responsibilities.” She spat. “Your brothers are utterly immature, they have no sense of…anything. And it’s up to you to represent this household."
The weight of the family name was officially transferred to your shoulders by the time you hit fifteen. While your brothers were allowed to be absent-minded teenage boys, you were expected to be the perfect daughter—the pristine hostess, the straight-A student, the family ornament at every event.
Meanwhile, Rafe was facing his own version of hell. As the oldest Cameron kid and only son, Ward had begun bringing him into the business meetings, demanding he understand the world of business. But Rafe didn't have the stomach for it, and his failures were met with scolding from Ward.
Throughout your freshman year, you watched each other die in slow motion.
He would sit with you on the beach after school, trying to talk about his day, and you would simply... drift. You would zone out in the middle of his sentences, your eyes locking onto a piece of driftwood or a wave breaking on the shore. He would catch you staring into nothingness for twenty, thirty minutes at a time, your face completely blank, your hands resting limp in your lap.
He’d take you to your favorite diner and you wouldn’t even touch the food. He’d drive you down to The Point to watch the sunset and you wouldn’t look up from your lap. Nothing made you happy.
In a desperate attempt to do something other than watch you become a fraction of who you were, Rafe did the one thing he swore he’d never do—he went to an adult.
He showed up at your house on a Saturday afternoon when he knew your mother was home. He stood in your living room, his voice cracking as he confronted her.
"Something is wrong with her," Rafe said, his tone desperate. "She isn't eating, it’s like doesn't hear me when I talk to her. She just stares at the wall. I think…she needs help.” He voiced. “Please,"
Your mother had looked at him with a blank expression. "Rafe, I think you forget that I know you.” She started. “You are a deeply troubled boy who has no right to lecture me on how to care for my daughter. She is perfectly fine, simply focused on her studies.” She lied, shrugging. “Now, I think it may be time for you to go…” She urged. “Before I call your father."
His efforts blew up in his face almost immediately. That evening, Ward cornered Rafe in the kitchen. Your mother had called him regardless, furious, claiming Rafe was trying to "stir up issues" around your family’s private life. Ward had cut deep that night, screaming at him for embarrassing the Cameron name.
But two weeks later, the final thread snapped.
It was a warm Friday night, the end of the year around the corner. The Kook kids were throwing a house party and Rafe was already there, a red solo cup clutched in his hand, his head buzzing from the cheap beer.
He’d spoken to you earlier, managing to get you to agree to show up. You told him you’d catch a ride with one of your girl friends. But when everyone started to trickle in and no sign of you, he pulled out his phone, his thumb hovering over your contact name.
Rafe
where are you at?
Ten minutes passed. No response. You always responded to Rafe within seconds.
Rafe
hey. you there?
You
i dont think im coming rafe.
Rafe
come onnn
it sucks without you here :(
Is your mom home? i can sneak you out
You
no. im just tired.
im really tired rafe.
Rafe
youre always tired lately.
i’m omw to get you.
You
don’t
rafe
im sorry.
And that was the last text.
Rafe stared at the words 'im sorry.' A sudden surge of fear and adrenaline slamming into his chest. It wasn't a standard apology, and even if it was—it was so out of place, unwarranted. You hadn’t done anything. But then he remembered, remembered you opening up about the diagnosis, about your mom ripping up the help you needed and trashing it.
He was right. About you needing help, he was right. And if he was right, then he was late.
"Whoa, Rafe, where you goin’ man?" Topper called out as Rafe dropped his beer cup onto the dirt and sprinted toward his truck.
He didn't answer. He threw his truck into reverse, the tires screeching against the gravel as he sped toward your house.
He ran every single stoplight on the island, his heart hammering against his ribs while he cursed to himself, hitting turns so fast that his truck held itself up on two wheels.
When he pulled into your driveway, the house was completely dark and he didn’t even bother to cut his car off. Rafe leapt out of the truck, taking the porch steps three at a time, rattling the front doorknob—It was unlocked.
He threw the door open, slamming it against the wall as he called your name.
"Hello?!" he yelled into the silent house. "Where are you?"
No answer. The silence was deafening as Rafe sprinted up the staircase, his feet heavy against the hardwood.
He checked your bedroom. Empty, but the bed was neatly made, too perfect.
He checked the other rooms. Nothing.
Then, he saw the faint sliver of light bleeding out from beneath your bathroom door when he checked your room one more time.
He called your name, cursing and throwing himself against the door, rattling the handle.
It was locked.
He pressed his ear to the wood. Inside, he could hear it—a ragged, shallow sound. You were hyperventilating, your breath coming out in tiny, desperate gasps.
"Open the fucking door!" Rafe screamed, banging his fist against the wood. "It's me! Can you hear me?! Unlock the damn door!"
Still silence from the other side, save for the desperate gasping for air. He could hear you panicking, your body shifting.
"Fuck—get away from the door!" Rafe roared, his voice breaking into a terrified sob.
He backed up two steps, throwing his shoulder into the heavy wood paneling. The wood groaned but didn't give. He cursed, his vision blurring with tears. He backed up further, raising his leg, and kicked the lock with everything he had.
The door frame splintered with a deafening crack as the door flew inward., hanging from a singular hinge
Rafe stumbled into the room, and the image before him burned itself into the framework of his brain for the rest of his life.
You were curled on the cold marble tile beside the bathtub, your knees tucked to your chest. Your face flushed with a thick sheen of sweat coating it, your eyes wide and glassy, fixed on the ceiling. Next to your limp left hand lay a small, orange plastic bottle—completely empty.
"No, no, no," Rafe chanted, dropping to his knees, his hands trembling violently as he grabbed your shoulders. "What did you do? What did you take?” He shook you, pulling you into him. “Shit, look at me, hey, look at me!" He panicked. “Why did you do that, huh, why would you do that?!” He cried, chest shaking as he watched you fall out of consciousness.
Your eyes rolled toward him, struggling to focus on his face as your lips turned blue.
"I'm sorry," you choked out, a tiny, fractured sound—sounding scared and genuinely sorry. "Rafe... I'm... I just... I didn't want to do it anymore."
"No, don't say that shit, don't you dare say that!" he screamed, his tears spilling over, hot and fast onto your cheeks. He reached for his phone, his fingers slick with sweat as he dialed 911. "I need help!” He sobbed as he read them your address. “Hurry, please, she's—"
Before he could finish the sentence, your body went entirely rigid. Your eyes locked, rolling back into your head as a violent seizure took hold of you.
Rafe dropped the phone, sobbing your name,cradling you and trying to keep your head from cracking against the marble tile. He held you, his own body shaking.
"Don't do this," he sobbed into your neck as the distant sirens began to wail across the water. "I need you. Why didn’t you just tell me you needed me?"
THE paramedics carried you away on a stretcher, a white sheet covering your trembling form with a mask over your face. Rafe had ridden in the back of the ambulance, his fingers locked around your limp hand, refusing to let go until the doctors at the hospital forcibly pushed him out of the trauma bay.
An hour later, your mother, brothers, and Ward arrived.
There were no tears from your mother. She looked panicked, afraid, but only for a moment. And mostly for herself. There was a hushed, frantic conversation with the attending physician and two local police officers in the corner of the waiting room. Words like 'accidental’ were thrown around, accompanied by the subtle implication of a substantial donation to the hospital.
The narrative was being rewritten in real-time, the truth being buried before your stomach was even fully pumped.
Your mother spoke with Ward before they both walked over to where Rafe sat on the chairs lining the walls, his clothes stained with your sweat and vomit from the bathroom floor.
"Thank you for…finding her, Rafe," she said, her voice entirely flat. "But the doctors said that she is stable. So, it’s probably best if you go and get some rest, now.” But it wasn’t a suggestion. “I can handle it from here."
Rafe stood up, his eyes bloodshot and his jaw set. "I'm not leaving."
"Yes, you are," Ward’s voice boomed from beside him, his father’s heavy hand clutching Rafe’s shoulder, his fingers digging into the muscle with a certain force. Ward looked at your mother, giving her a tight, understanding nod. "We’ll be leaving. Give her our best.” He offered, patting Rafe on the shoulder. “Come on, Rafe."
Ward dragged him out to the parking lot, even when Rafe tried to protest, to scream, but Ward threw him against the side of the truck, his face inches from Rafe’s.
"Son, listen to me," Ward hissed, his voice low and lethal. "You will never speak of what happened tonight. To anyone.” His father clarified. “Not to your sisters, not to your friends, not to her when she wakes up. If this gets out, it will ruin her family's reputation, and it will ruin ours by association. Okay?” He emphasized, voice rising as Rafe opened his mouth to speak before being cut off. “It never. Happened. Do you understand me? It was an accident."
And Rafe swallowed, eyes tracking his father as he backed away, rounding the car to get into the driver’s seat.
But Rafe didn't anticipate not seeing you for the rest of the summer.
Your mother moved you to a private inpatient facility in the mountains of North Carolina under the guise of a "summer camp". Rafe spent those three months trapped in the torture chamber of his own mind.
Every time he closed his eyes, he heard the sound of the bathroom door splintering.
Every time he looked at his hands, he felt your body seizing beneath him.
To cope with it all—his dad’s glare, his sisters questions, classmates wondering where you were, to drown out the absolute terror of not knowing if you were truly okay—Rafe turned to the only things that offered him comfort.
He started going out every single night, partying, drinking until his vision went black, pouring alcohol down his throat like water just to stop the shaking in his fingers and the feeling like the world was ending.
You watched it all from a distance, unable to stop him this time. When you were finally allowed to have your phone back in August, you scrolled through his stories and his friends' stories in the dark of your bedroom, your chest tightening.
He looked different. Unhinged.
THE first day of sophomore year was a hot morning. You walked through the courtyard of the academy, wearing a pristine, fitted, high-collared sundress when Rafe intercepted you by the lockers. He looked awful—there were dark circles under his eyes and he smelled faintly of smoke and expensive cologne. But the moment he saw you, a light found his eyes.
"Y-you're back," he said, stepping into your personal space, his hands hovering near your arms as if he wanted to touch you but was terrified you’d break. "You didn't call me." He frowned. "The whole summer. I called your mom like fifty times, but she told my dad and.... I didn't know if—"
"Rafe," you whispered, looking around frantically. Several girls were watching you from down the hall, whispering behind their hands. "Please. Drop it."
"...Drop it?" Rafe’s voice rose, before he looked around, lowering it. "Are you serious? You almost —"
"I said drop it." you snapped, your voice cracking with an overwhelmed panic. "Just... stop. Seriously."
Rafe flinched as if you’d struck him. The hurt in his eyes was agonizing to look at as he swallowed hard, his hands dropping back to his sides. "Just... tell me you're okay. Alright, just tell me that."
You looked at him, forcing your face into that flat expression that made you look too much like your mother. "I'm fine, Rafe. I'm…medicated now.” You said, shame creeping onto your face. “Everything is taken care of."
You nodded before you turned and walked away, leaving him standing alone in the crowded hallway.
But from that moment on, the dynamic of your friendship shifted into something deeply complicated and dangerously blurred. Rafe was always a step behind you, watching your every move. If you talked to another guy, Rafe was there, staring the guy down until he left. If you sat alone for too long, Rafe would appear, sliding into the seat beside you, his eyes scanning your face for any sign of the vacancy that had preceded that one night.
But while he was trying to watch you, his own life was descending into chaos. The pressure from his father had amplified astronomically. Ward was constantly comparing him to other kids his age, demanding he step up.
And to survive it all, Rafe graduated from beer to hard liquor, and eventually, to prescription pills and whatever else he could buy from the dealers on the Cut.
You noticed. Of course you noticed.
You’d catch him in the parking lot before school, his pupils dilated, his hands twitching against the steering wheel.
"You need to… slow down, Rafe," you told him one afternoon as you both sat in his truck. "You're drinking like a fucking sailor. And everyone’s talking about it..."
Rafe laughed, a bitter sound that made your chest ache. "Everyone drinks.” He muttered. “Topper drinks, Kelce drinks. You drink even though you’re not supposed to…” He trailed off, shooting you a look. The reminder of the bathroom floor hung between you like a knife. You dropped your eyes, swallowing the lump in your throat. “It’s just alcohol. I'm fine."
"It's not just alcohol," you said, your eyes dropping, not elaborating any further.
"You don’t know what you’re talkin’ about" he retorted, his eyes flashing with a sudden anger. "And you don't get to lecture me..."
IT all boiled over during the winter of your junior year.
You rarely went to parties anymore. Your mother preferred you to attend mixers and volunteer events. But on a Friday night in January, your phone wouldn't stop buzzing.
Group chats were lighting up with an address on the north end—a beachfront property under construction. You ignored them, until Kelce, one of Rafe’s friends, had sent you a direct message on snap.
Kelce
Hey, u might want to come get Rafe.
He’s losing his mind. Thought u were the best person to hit up.
Needing to escape the suffocation of your own house, you slipped on a thick sweater that probably belonged to Rafe, took your car keys, and drove towards him.
The house was a half-finished mansion crawling with hundreds of drunk teenagers. The bass from the speakers was vibrating through the floors as you pushed through the crowd of sweaty kids, your eyes scanning the rooms until you found him.
Rafe was leaning over a glass-topped coffee table, a rolled-up hundred-dollar bill pressed to his nose, as a thick, white line of cocaine vanished up it. You watched as he straightened up, his jaw twitching, his eyes completely bloodshot.
He caught your figure through the crowd of people, his vision zeroing in on you and the look of disapproval on your face. He froze, the rolled bill dropping from his fingers. He looked caught, a sudden flash of panic crossing his features before he quickly masked it with a smug, intoxicated grin.
"Hey," he slurred, getting up and dragging himself over to you. "What’re you doing here? You don't do parties."
You didn't say a word, the reality of how far he had fallen slammed into you. And you could only wonder if it had anything to do with you. You stepped forward, grabbing the collar of his shirt, and dragging him forcefully out of the room. He was high enough that he let you pull him, stumbling down the unfinished staircase and out onto the dark, chilly beach, away from the noise.
The moment the cold sea air hit your face, you let him go, turning on him with a fury you hadn't felt in years.
"What the fuck is wrong with you?" you screamed, your voice tearing through the sound of the crashing waves. "Coke, Rafe? Really? Are you trying to kill yourself?"
Rafe laughed, a loud, jarring sound that made your jaw clench. He began pacing the sand, his arms swinging wildly. "Oh, now you care?”
“I always cared—”
“I'm having fun! Everyone does it!"
"No, they don't!" you shrieked, tears of frustration stinging your eyes. "It’s like you’re trying to ruin yourself and I’m sick of being the one to try and help—"
Rafe stopped pacing. He stepped into your space, his face contorting into an expression of unadulterated malice. The coke was burning through his veins, stripping away whatever filters he had left.
"You're sick of me? I’m trying to ruin myself?" he roared, his chest inches from yours. "That's funny…That's really fucking funny coming from you, because finding my best friend on her bathroom floor then not hearing from her for a whole fucking summer will do that! Forgive me for hangin’ out with people that are less fucked up than me and you!"
The words slammed into your chest like a physical blow. It was the unspoken rule. And he had thrown it in your face.
And before you could even think, your hand flew out, the sound of your palm cracking across Rafe’s cheek echoing over the empty beach. The force of the slap turned his head to the side.
The silence that followed was absolute. Rafe didn't move, his cheek turning a violent shade of crimson in the moonlight. He looked down at you, the wild look in his eyes dying out, replaced by a devastating horror at what he had just said.
"So, it’s my fault?" you whispered, your voice shaking so violently you could barely form the words, though your face was still contorted with anger as your eyes welled with tears.
“No.” Rafe's face softened, his hands reaching out for you. “You know I didn’t—”
“Get one of your ‘less fucked up’ friends to take care of you then, asshole,” You spat, voice shaking as you turned and walked toward your car, your heart shattering into a thousand pieces as you hugged yourself.
"Hey! Wait, please!" Rafe’s voice called out behind you, but his shoes slipped in the sand, and he couldn't catch up before you got into your car and threw it into drive, speeding away.
TWO hours later, you were sitting in your bedroom, staring blankly at the ceiling, as music played softly, replaying the argument over and over until a faint scraping sound against your window made you tense.
You stood up, knowing exactly who it was as you pulled back the curtain.
Rafe was standing on the roof, his clothes soaking wet from the midnight rain, his hands gripping the window frame. His face was soft, entirely sobered up by the cold and the reality of what he’d said.
You unlocked the window, pushing it up an inch. "Go away, Rafe.”
"Let me in," he pleaded, his teeth chattering. "Just let me talk to you. C’mon, I'm freezing."
"No," you said, your voice cold. "You threw that shit in my face and basically blamed me for your drugs problems, hey—"
Rafe shoved the window up the rest of the way and scrambled into your room, bringing the cold, wet scent of the rain with him. You backed away, sighing, but he was faster. He caught your wrists, his grip tight, backing you up until your spine hit the bedroom wall.
"I'm sorry, okay?" he whispered frantically, his face inches from yours. He was breathing heavily, his chest rising and falling against yours as you turned your head to the side. "I'm sorry. I didn't mean it. The... it just makes my brain go crazy.” He explained.
“Yeah, cocaine will do that to you,” You sassed, narrowing your eyes at the boy.
He just nodded, accepting the blow. “But I can’t pretend that I'm not scared for you, all the time. I'm scared I'm going to lose you again." Rafe told you, eyes locked on your face. “I know you don’t wanna talk about it, but that shit was scary for me, too. I didn’t know what to do—your mom wouldn’t let me talk to, my dad wouldn’t tell me anything. I…can’t lose you. And I've already come so close once...”
"...You're losing yourself, Rafe," you choked out, looking up into his blue eyes. “And, clearly, you blame me for that—”
“I didn’t mean that.”
“You had to.” You corrected. “Otherwise, you wouldn’t have said it…”
The proximity between you was close to none and you could feel the heat radiating from his skin despite the cold wafting in from the open window. You could smell the faint tang of liquor and the distinct scent of him.
“...It’s not your fault. Okay, I don't blame you,” Rafe reiterated. “It’s my fault for not knowing what to do with myself without you.”
For a second, the lines that had blurred over the years became completely transparent, hanging in the quiet space between your lips.
"Promise me," you whispered, your hand coming up to rest against his wet jacket as you finally looked at him. "Promise me you'll stop the coke. At least. Please."
Rafe stared down at you, his eyes flickering down to your lips. He wanted to promise. He wanted to be the boy who could save you again. But he stood there, silent, just breathing you in, his forehead coming to rest against yours in a silent surrender.
The moment violently broken by the loud buzz of his phone.
Rafe flinched, pulling back just an inch to pull the device from his pocket. The screen illuminated his face, displaying Ward’s name. He answered it, his voice dropping into a tense register. You could tell by his face that the conversation was far from casual or pleasant.
Ward’s voice was loud enough that you could hear the distortion through the speaker. "It's past midnight…Get your ass home. Now." And then the line went dead.
There was a banquet tomorrow and Ward was probably on Rafe’s ass as much as your mother was on yours.
Rafe closed his eyes, a defeated sigh escaping his lips as he lowered the phone. He looked back at you, the tension turning bitter. He moved toward the window, moving to climb back out until your voice traveled across the room, calling his name.
"Try not to make a scene this time," you said softly, referring to his habit of getting into arguments with the older members at these functions.
Rafe paused on the window sill, a slow smirk returning to his face as he looked over his shoulder, his eyes glinting.
"Yeah, make sure you wear enough lipgloss to leave a mark on all the asses you'll be kissing tomorrow," he retorted, his voice dripping with that boyish sarcasm you missed.
You rolled your eyes, a small, involuntary smile tugging at the corner of your lips. "Fuck you."
"In your dreams," he whispered, winking, and then he disappeared into the dark.
THE banquet was like every other mind-frying event. The country club ballroom was packed with Figure Eight’s wealthiest, all dressed in formal attire, smiling and pretending the world outside their island didn't exist.
Your mother had spent the entire morning criticizing your posture, ensuring your dress was flawless, reminding you that you were the face of the family today. You stood by her side for hours, nodding politely to associates, your smile plastered wide.
Across the room, Rafe looked nice in his tailored suit, but you had been watching him all night. Every twenty minutes, he would slip out to the terrace or the men’s lounge, returning with increasingly glassy eyes.
He was sneaking drinks from a silver flask he’d hidden in his jacket, drowning out the feeling of Ward’s watchful eye. By nine, he was visibly swaying, his laughter a little too loud and Ward’s face was turning a dangerous shade of red.
You knew what would happen if Rafe was caught drunk by his father in front of these people. Slipping away from your mother, you intercepted Ward just as he was marching toward Rafe.
"Mr. Cameron," you said, forcing your voice into its sweetest pitch, knowing the man had a sweet spot reserved for you—whether it was real or fake. "I'm so sorry to interrupt, but I’ve actually developed a terrible headache and Rafe offered to drive me home.” You lied, noticing the flare of the older Cameron’s nostrils. “Would it be alright if I stole him away for the evening? I’d hate to make a scene by fainting here."
Ward stopped, his eyes shifting from you to Rafe, who was leaning heavily against a cocktail table.
"...Of course, honey," Ward said, his face smoothing into a charismatic smile. "Take care of yourself.” He squeezed your arm, calling out to his son. “Rafe, get her car keys. Take her straight home." He ordered, fixing Rafe with a sharp, lingering glare.
Ten minutes later, you were in the driver’s seat of your car, the formal gown gathered around your legs, driving back toward Tannyhill while Rafe rode shotgun, the silence in the vehicle thick.
"Why can't you ever just survive the night?" you snapped, sighing as Rafe continued sipping from his flask before you snatched it from his hands and threw it out of the window, your hands returning to grip the steering wheel until your knuckles splintered. "One night, Rafe. Why do you always have to do this?"
“You sound just like him…” Rafe scoffed, leaning his head back against the leather seat, staring out the window at the passing streetlights.
“Don’t ever,” You warned, shooting the boy a warning glance.
"I'm sorry I'm not a perfect little puppet like you.” He slurred. “It must be so nice, huh? Just putting on that fake little smile, talking to those old creeps like they actually give a shit about you."
"Or maybe I think that we both have enough problems that I don’t feel like creating more," you snapped, the frustration boiling over. “ I lied to Ward tonight to protect you, Rafe, like always—"
"I didn't ask for your protection!" he yelled, turning his torso toward you, his breath smelling heavily of bourbon. "I don't need you to save me!"
"Yeah, you kind of do!" you yelled back, your voice cracking as you pulled into the driveway of Tannyhill. The house was empty. "You're a mess—"
"So are you!" he fired back.
You slammed the truck into park, both of you jerking forward as you turned off the ignition. The silence that followed was heavy with the weight of everything. You looked at him—his tie was loosened, his suit jacket wrinkled, his face beautiful.
You sighed, not wanting to argue, especially not when he was drunk. You composed yourself and kept your comments to yourself as you opened the driver’s side door.
"Come on," you whispered, the anger draining out of you, leaving only exhaustion. “I’m not arguing with you.”
You helped him out of the truck, his heavy arm draping over your shoulders for support. You guided him through the door of Tannyhill and up the stairs to his bedroom, the room you had spent half your childhood playing in.
You pushed him gently onto the mattress as he collapsed backward, groaning as he kicked his legs up.
Sitting on the edge of the bed, you leaned over him, your fingers working efficiently to unbutton his stiff collar and pull the tie from his neck. You reached down, unlacing his formal shoes and sliding them off his feet, before pulling his heavy suit jacket off his shoulders.
Rafe watched you through sleepy, hooded eyes. “...’M sorry for yelling at you,” The alcohol had slowed his rage, leaving behind that flirtation that always hovered when you were alone.
“It’s fine, Rafe.”
He reached up, his fingers catching a loose strand of your hair, twisting it gently. "...You look really pretty in that dress," he murmured. "Even if it's for them. You're the prettiest girl on this stupid island. To me."
Your heart skipped a beat as you swallowed hard, your fingers freezing on his shirt cuff. "You're drunk, Rafe."
"I am," he whispered, a drunken, lopsided smile spreading across his lips as he tugged lightly on your hair, pulling your face a few inches closer to his. "But I'm not blind.” He defended. “Just stay here. Just for tonight."
It was the line you had been dancing around for years—the blurred boundary between best friends who saved each other's lives and two people who were destructively in love. But you looked at his glassy eyes, heard the faint slur in his voice, and you knew you couldn't cross it.
Not like this. Not while he was using alcohol to escape the reality of who he was. To love him now would mean drowning with him. And you were already drowning all on your own.
You gently detached his fingers from your hair, placing his hand back on his chest.
"I can’t,” You forced out. “Goodnight, Rafe,"
He stared at you for a long moment, a flash of heartbreak crossing his features before his eyelids grew too heavy to hold open. Within minutes, his breathing evened out as he fell asleep.
You stood up, smoothing down your gown, taking a deep breath as you walked out of Tannyhill with a heavy, aching chest, driving yourself back home—ready to receive a mouthful from your mother the next morning for leaving.
THE next two years were a blur.
As junior and senior year passed, the mirrors of your lives grew increasingly warped.
Rafe got worse. The cocaine became a regular habit, his debts to local dealers grew, and his outbursts at Tannyhill became almost daily.
You got worse in the opposite direction. You became the absolute pinnacle of perfection. You won the academic awards, you chaired the charity galas, you became the perfect daughter your mother had always envisioned…at the cost of whoever you really were.
You hid your depression behind a wall of prescription pills and big events.
Rafe hid his troubles and flaws behind white lines and empty bottles.
You screamed at each other on weekends— arguments where you tore each other’s choices to shreds—and then you would show up at each other’s windows on Sunday nights, because the rest of the world was a lie, and you were the only two people who knew the truth.
You both applied to the same university. It wasn't discussed. But it wasn’t accidental. Neither of you could survive where the other wasn't.
On the scorching hot morning of your high school graduation, the country club lawn was decorated with white tents and rows of folding chairs. The families of Kildare were gathered to celebrate the bright futures of their children.
You had just received your diploma, your mother nodding with a stiff approval from the front row and as the crowd dissolved, Rafe found you by the edge of the veranda you’d met near all those years ago. He was wearing his graduation cap crookedly, his gown open over his suit. He looked even older—the sharp lines of his jaw completely formed, shoulders broad, a map of muscles. But when he looked at you, the boy from fifth grade was still there, buried deep beneath.
"Well," he said, stepping into your space, his hand coming to rest on the small of your back. "We're out."
"We're out," you agreed, the weight of the college years ahead pressing down on your chest as a professional photographer hired by the school approached, his camera raised.
"Smile, kids!” He urged. “And congrats!"
Rafe’s arm slid around your waist, his grip tightening, pulling your side flush against his. You turned toward the lens, your posture straight, your face instantly smoothing into that perfect, practiced smile. Rafe leaned in, his jaw tightening as he forced his own confident smirk for the cameras.
The flash went off, capturing the two of you.
To anyone, you looked like the epitome of privilege and success.
Nobody would ever know about the bathroom floor, the white lines, the bruises or the empty bottles.
You stood side-by-side, your bodies locked together, completely unaware of how much more complicated your lives were bound to get.
PLOT you enter the hunger games a proud weapon of your district, only to find your sharpest blade is the boy beside you, and you’re not sure which one of you the capitol wants to break first.
CONTENT chapter thirty-two, best read in dark mode, rafe cameron x reader au, rafe being tortured by jabberjays, reminding me that y/n has to be the one captured soon im gna cry, small rafe & y/n moment to rmbr that theyre tg honest (edit: hi i didnt know i wrote so much of this draft already so ill finish it off and release w no mistakes hopefully)
main masterlist | series ml | tag list | previous
you’re crouched low in the sand, pressed into the shade of a tree whose branches dip so far down they nearly brush the ground. finnick has his chest braced against the trunk while peeta sits across from him, resting on a root.
“so besides castella and harmon, who’s left?” katniss asks.
your head perks up. castella and harmon. your first time hearing their names said aloud. it hits you in some way, proof that katniss truly had done her research before this.
“maybe chaff,” peeta says. “just those three.”
“they know they’re outnumbered. i doubt they’ll attack again,” finnick adds, rolling a bit of sand between his fingertips.
“seven against two?” rafe’s voice cuts in low, and for a second his eyes flash toward the group like he’s measuring them all out.
“we’re safe here on the beach,” finnick finishes with a nod.
“so what do we do? we hunt ’em down?” johanna throws out, itching for something to do. you don’t blame her for being the one to kill cashmere earlier. she spent all that time trying to keep wiress and the others alive, just for her to go like that.
but before anyone can answer, a scream rips through the air, cutting from the jungle. it’s a girl’s scream.
you jolt, your head snapping up, heart slamming once against your ribs. the sound doesn’t belong here, at least not with who’s left alive. it sounds too young.
“katniss, help me!” the voice cries again.
you don’t even need to think about it. of course everyone looks to katniss. and in the blink of an eye, she’s already moving, shooting up from the sand so fast it’s like she’s spring-loaded. her bow’s in her hand and her feet are carrying her toward the trees before any of you can react.
“prim! prim!” she screams. you’re quick to remember that’s her sisters name.
it chills you, because you’ve heard this before, this trick. you’ve heard these birds echo the voices of the dying in previous games, long before even your own. you’ve heard victors choking on sobs, usually their family begging. the sound is designed to tear you in half, and to rot you from the inside out.
“jabberjays,” you breathe, but there’s no time for any of it to sink in. you’re already pushing to your feet with the rest of them, bodies surging forward to chase after katniss.
the jungle swallows her quickly. katniss is fast, cutting through the brush with a desperate speed that leaves the plants snapping back in her wake. your chest burns trying to match her pace, branches catching against your arms as you force yourself forward. you can hear the others scattering out in a broken line behind you, some falling behind, but finnick and peeta stay closest, their voices pushing out after her.
“katniss!” your own voice breaks panicked, because the sound is too loud, all of it - her shouts, your shouts, the thunder of bodies running through the greenery. it’s too much noise, and it must be too easy to track.
castella and harmon could be anywhere. this could drag them in like a beacon. you know katniss hears her baby sister’s cry, but she has to hear you too. she has to know this isn’t real.
she’s just too fast. finnick manages to stay on her trail, but even he looks strained, jaw set as though he knows he’s seconds from losing her.
you’re running blind, lungs burning, when it happens. there’s a sharp stumble, the thud of a body hitting the ground. beetee.
it jolts through the ground. everyone falters, just for a heartbeat, and you whip around instinctively.
“beetee!” johanna calls like there’s no time to slow down, and she doubles back immediately.
you skid in the dirt, shoes slipping, and for a split second your eyes lock on rafe. he’s stopped mid-run, frozen halfway between the you and beetee, eyes flicking from you to the path katniss disappeared down.
your chest heaves, breath ragged as you rush past him. your hand catches his arm, grounding you for half a second. “go, go with them!” you push at his shoulder lightly.
he lingers just a second, scanning you, then but he listens, sprinting after finnick, who’s paused only long enough to glance back and see what’s happened. rafe gives him that sharp hand gesture where he points ahead with his hand, the kind that means don’t worry, just go. finnick’s jaw clenches before tearing off again.
then you’re dropping down beside beetee. his glasses are askew, his coil of wire half-unraveled like a trail behind him. his hands fumble uselessly, as if his brain can’t keep up with his body.
“beetee, please,” you beg, crouched low as you press a hand to his arm.
his eyes are glassy, distant. you know what he’s hearing. you know who he’s lost.
johanna kneels on his other side, one hand already braced against his back, the other swiping angrily at the mess of wire. “c’mon, genius. this isn’t where you get to fall apart.” her tone is biting, but you can see the tightness around her mouth.
you help gather the wire too, looping it clumsily into manageable coils, anything to lighten the load. between the two of you, you manage to wrestle it together and sling it back into beetee’s trembling hands.
then, both of you hook your arms under his, hauling him upright. he stumbles, but with the combined force, he finds his feet.
johanna’s voice comes out harsher than she probably means it to. “no one else is going to die. we just—” she cuts herself off, teeth sinking into her lip as she tries to swallow the burn in her chest. finally she spits it out, “we have to be careful. stick with the group.”
you nod hard, still clutching beetee’s arm as his weight leans on you. “together. we’ll stay together.”
somewhere ahead, katniss’s voice still carries. the jabberjays don’t stop. even as you and johanna drag beetee forward, the voices chase you through the trees, calling katniss’s name over and over, a child’s voice ripping itself raw. “katniss, help me! please!” it doesn’t let up.
you can hear katniss ahead, her bow catching branches as she barrels through the jungle.
and then, just as suddenly as it began, the cries cut off.
you look toward the dark tangle of trees, chest rising and falling like you’ve been holding your breath for miles. the silence lasts a second too long before it fractures.
“finnick!” a girl’s scream tears through the canopy. you jolt, head snapping to the sound. finnick himself lets out a ragged curse somewhere ahead.
“annie!” it’s his voice this time, desperate.
another jabberjay swoops low, wings thrashing the air, and the sound shifts again. it’s male now, a man’s voice howling through the branches, “katniss!”
your chest tightens, pulse hammering, but it’s the next one that cracks you open.
“rafe!”
it’s not katniss’s sister, and it’s not annie. it isn’t some nameless voice pulled out of the districts. but you know this one. it’s so familiar.
your throat goes dry, your body cutting off your breath like it doesn’t trust you to survive it. “sarah,” you swallow. your stomach caves in, folding around the name.
you both promised, in a thousand whispered plans, that you’d protect her. how did they get her voice? how did they catch the sound of her screaming?
it nearly tears you apart, even if you’re not the target, because you know rafe is hearing it too. and unlike you, he doesn’t get the buffer of disbelief. he’ll believe it, he’ll feel it in his marrow.
your legs keep moving, but the sound begins to fade. and with each step, you realize what’s happening: the voices are following the others up ahead. panic eats its way up your throat. you think that if you lose the sound completely, it means they’re too far ahead.
“c’mon,” you gasp, adjusting beetee’s weight. you steal glances at the back of peeta’s head, his blond hair bobbing just ahead. as long as he’s in sight, you’re not lost. peeta’s the thread tying both groups together.
then he slows, stops. your heart lurches, and you see him crouch.
through the break in the brush, you catch it all in fragments. katniss is curled on the ground, hands clamped over her ears, jabberjays darting like knives in the air. peeta kneels in front of her, calling to her. finnick stands like a shield behind them, swatting at the birds, jaw tight.
and rafe . . . he’s a few feet off, hands over his ears, body pitched forward like he’s trying to collapse in on himself, but he doesn’t move away. he stays close, even through the torment. and for one splintering moment, you think he’s waiting for you.
you drop beetee’s arm. the coil wire falls heavy in the dirt. your legs carry you forward before you’ve even decided, cutting through branches, reaching for him.
but when you do, you slam into nothing. the impact rattles your teeth, sends you stumbling backward with your palms stinging. confusion surges first. it’s a forcefield.
you blink, dazed, staring at the faint shimmer in the air where your body hit. then you try again, shoving forward, shoulder-first this time. nothing. it throws you back, relentless.
“no—” your voice cracks, rising with panic. you press your hands flat to the invisible barrier, dragging them down as if you could claw it apart. “no, how long ‘til it lifts?”
beetee, still catching his breath, adjusts his glasses. “if the gamemakers designed this as part of the system then it won’t release us at whim,” he says, “an hour, perhaps less, but no sooner than that.”
an hour. this is an active sector. you have to wait for an hour.
your heart breaks as your gaze locks on rafe. he’s still crumbling in the sound, shoulders rigid, face strained like he’s holding himself together by force.
you press your palm harder against the barrier, almost like you could reach him. like if you push hard enough, your hand might break through. you want to tear it away with your bare hands. you want to be in there, shoulder to shoulder, anything but standing useless on the outside.
but the arena has made sure: all you can do is watch.
you sit there the entire time, your knees dug into the dirt. your eyes never leave him. rafe shifts between trying to shut it all out with his fingers shoved into his ears and his heads bent low, and snapping up to swat the jabberjays away when they get too close to him, or katniss, or finnick.
it’s unbearable, watching him, knowing it’s sarah’s voice they chose.
and after what feels like forever, the first real movement startles you. rafe rips his hands from his ears, his grip snapping around the handle of his mace, and with a sudden, violent swing he brings it across a small cluster of jabberjays swooping too close.
the crunch being sharp, feathers scattering, finnick averting his gaze. rafe pins them into the dirt. he doesn’t look relieved. if anything, he looks colder, staring down at the bodies as if he isn’t even seeing birds anymore, but just bloodied, broken things.
your head tilts without meaning to, your palm pressing harder to the forcefield, like you could reach him if only you leaned far enough. you can’t. all you can do is watch as he sits down hard, knees bent, arms hooked over them, his forehead resting against the edge of his wrist.
time blurs. minutes stretch into what feels like an eternity. you don’t even notice it at first, not until peeta finally manages to reach katniss. the barrier collapses without warning, and the jabberjays scatter. the others begin to move, relief rushing through the group, but all you see is rafe.
you’re already moving before you even think. you drop down behind him, close enough that your knees brush his back as you settle on the dirt. your hands reach for his shoulders, light at first, the touch almost cautious. he flinches, just barely, like a twitch under your fingers, but you don’t draw away. instead you squeeze gently, then lean down, your lips pressing to his shoulder blade, tasting salt and sweat.
your arms slide around him from behind, circling his frame. you rest your cheek against his back. the sector is quiet now, the jabberjays gone. it’s over, and you want him to feel that, through the press of your arms, that you’re here.
“are you okay?” you whisper, leaning into him. you don’t really expect an answer, not after what he just went through. he’s silent, but you can still hear katniss gasping, her breaths jagged while peeta murmurs quick reassurances, telling her she’s alright, telling her the capitol wouldn’t dare touch prim.
“your fiancé’s right,” johanna cuts in, standing again after checking on finnick. her axe is loose at her side, her voice carrying that bite that always makes you wonder if there’s something else behind it. like envy, maybe. “the whole country loves your sister. if they tortured her or did anything to her, forget the districts, there would be . . .” she smirks bitterly, eyes flicking away, “riots in the damn capitol.”
johanna doesn’t stop there. she turns her face up, addressing the canopy above like it’s snow himself looking down. “hey, how does that sound, snow? what if we . . . what if we set your backyard on fire? you know you can’t just put everybody in here.”
“johanna—” you try calling her name low, a warning, but she barrels on.
eventually her eyes come back to the group, her tone dropping quieter. “what? they can’t hurt me,” she says. “there’s no one left that i love.”
your expression falters, your gaze slipping down to the ground beneath her boots. you pity her, almost. you can feel it in your chest, but you know better than to let it show, because johanna would tear you apart for it. so you stay quiet, watching as she looks over to katniss, her voice barely above a whisper. “i’ll get you some water.”
even now, she’s focused on katniss, protecting the girl who was just forced to hear her baby sister’s cries through a flock of mutts. still your mockingjay.
you glance at katniss now. her face is a mess of shock, grief, and confusion all blurred together. but you turn back to rafe. he’s still folded into himself, silent, distant. your hand lifts, brushing dirt off the fabric of his suit in small strokes, like it matters, like if you can clean away what clings to him, maybe you can take some of the weight too. you smooth the fabric at his shoulder.
“it wasn’t real, rafe,” you murmur, low enough for only him to catch. your hand finds the back of his neck, slick with sweat, and you rub slow circles there. when your palm comes away damp, you wipe it against your thigh without thinking, your eyes never leaving him.
he doesn’t answer or even move. you let him have that silence, watching the tightness around his jaw, the way his shoulders haven’t loosened even once.
then, carefully, you reach across and set your hand against his chest. his heart beats hard beneath your palm, proof that he’s still here. “strong heart,” you tell him quietly, pressing your fingers into the fabric.
his eyes drop down to your hand and he stares at it like he doesn’t know what to do with the words. then he looks away, angled just enough toward you that you know he heard, even if he can’t face you yet.
“no fear,” you add, softer still, rubbing small circles into his chest, coaxing him back piece by piece.
your hand shifts, reaching past him to the far side of his head. you guide him toward you, pulling him in until you can press your lips to the side of his face, before you ease back and breathe, “let’s go, c’mon,” when the sound of the others moving nearby filters through, meaning it’s time to leave.
he doesn’t move right away. not until you rise, brushing dirt from your legs, and extend your hand down to him. he looks at it for a beat, then lets you help him up.
he still looks gutted, the memory of sarah’s voice echoing in his head. annie’s screams, prim’s cries, they even cut deep enough on their own, but sarah . . . that had been unbearable.
you keep your touch on him as you guide him forward. the two of you retrace the path back toward the beach, back to where you’d run from an hour ago.
SYNOPSIS‧₊˚ [6.2k] The heat in the villa reaches a breaking point as Day Three brings hidden betrayals to light. You and Rafe solidify your bond while the villa’s existing loyalties crumble around you.
WARNING(S)‧₊˚ swearing, mentions of parental neglect/abuse, mentions of grief/loss/death, mentions of past trauma, reference to substance use
˗ˏˋ series masterlist ˎˊ˗
THE MORNING LIGHT in the villa always felt a little too aggressive, draping itself over the scenery like it was personally offended you were still asleep. You felt a dull ache in your back from the hammock, but the memory of Rafe’s arms wrapped around you acted like a shot of espresso to your heart. You’d managed to sneak back into your bed next to JJ just before the sun peaked, but you weren’t exactly stealthy.
As you walked into the makeup room, the air was already thick with the scent of sunscreen, expensive perfume, and the rev of five different hair tools. The second you crossed the threshold, the room went quiet.
Sarah, who was carefully blending her bronzer, dropped her brush. A slow, mischievous smirk spreading across her face. "Well, well. Look who finally decided to join the land of the living.” She quipped, eyeing you through the makeup mirror. “...Or should I say... look who decided to finally come back to the bedroom?"
Confessional : Sarah
"You know, I know it's still very early..." Sarah started, smiling and blushing at the camera. "But I'm loving whatever her and Rafe have going on. I think I'd be okay if they end up winning this."
Cleo paused, a mascara wand hovering dangerously close to her eye as she smiled. "I was half-convinced you’d been kidnapped by production, but then I saw Rafe’s bed was half empty, too. Care to explain, bombshell?"
You felt the heat crawl up your neck, a traitorous blush staining your cheeks. You walked over to your station, trying to act nonchalant as you grabbed your moisturizer. "I…couldn't sleep.” You shrugged shyly. “The hovering tension in that room was enough to give me a migraine. I just went out for some air…"
"In the hammock? With Rafe?" Sarah egged on, wiggling her eyebrows. "Because I definitely saw you two looking like a literal Pinterest board for 'star-crossed lovers' when I looked out the window."
You bit your lip, unable to hide the small smile as you sat down. "We just talked, Sarah. He was stressed about the Ruthie situation, and I... I don't know, we just vibe.” You lied. “So…we ended up falling asleep out there."
The girls erupted into a chorus of ‘oohs’ and giggles, but you noticed Kiara wasn't joining in. She was staring at her reflection, looking absolutely drained. Her usual spark was replaced by a heavy, moping energy as she mindlessly brushed her hair.
"...Kie?" you murmured, stepping away from the group. She didn't look up, so you nudged her gently as you passed by. "Hey. Come talk to me for a second?" She snapped out of her stupor, nodding and following you out of the main room.
You led her toward the quiet corner near the closet, where the rows of clothing provided a bit of a privacy shield.
"You look like you're carrying the weight of the world, right now, girl," you said softly, a hand on her shoulder. "Is it still the Pope thing?" You asked, only being briefly filled in last night.
Kiara let out a long, shaky breath, finally meeting your eyes. "I just feel like a total bitch.” She admitted, fighting tears. “Pope told me he kissed me during the challenge, and then I had that talk with Cleo last night... it was so awkward. She was so hurt, and I feel like I've ruined a potential friendship over a guy I barely know.” She shook her head as if trying to erase the memory. “I hate that he lied to her, but I also hate that…I enjoyed the kiss. I’m just... I’m a mess."
Your hand ran down her arm, squeezing her hand. "Kie, stop. You didn't lie. Pope did. You were blindfolded!” You laughed, trying to lighten the mood. “You can't control who chooses to kiss you or how your body reacts to it. And Cleo is a big girl—she’s processing, but don't beat yourself up for something that wasn't your fault. This place is designed to test people. It’s testing him, and he's the one failing, not you."
Kiara gave you a small, grateful smile, wiping a stray tear. "You're right. I just... I hate the drama."
"Then leave the drama to Ruthie," you joked, making her laugh. "Come on. Let’s get our bikinis on." You kissed her cheek, squeezing her hand.
Confessional : You
"The girls are all so sweet, but the energy is definitely shifting. It’s only Day 3, and we’ve already got secret kisses, lying partners, and…late-night hammock sessions.” You stifled a laugh, hiding your face.
ONCE everyone was suited up in their tiniest bikinis, the girls migrated toward the daybeds while the boys scattered about the workout area. Most of them, anyway.
You were just settling in when a shadow fell over you. You looked up to see Rafe, looking effortlessly handsome in dark trunks, holding a plate of fruit and a toasted bagel.
"Morning, angel," he said, his voice that low, raspy growl that made your toes curl as he handed you the plate. "A token of my gratitude for keeping me company last night."
Sarah literally gasped, clutching her heart. "Making her breakfast on day three?” She fawned. “Stop the tape… Did you guys bone?” She eyed you both skeptically over her sunglasses. “You totally boned, didn't you?"
You nearly choked on a grape that you’d plucked from the plate. "Sarah!” You scolded. “No! We did not! It’s the third day, chill out..." You reprimanded, your face warm.
Rafe just smirked, a confident look in his eye as he glanced at Sarah who continued staring. "A gentleman doesn't kiss and tell, Sarah. But for the record, your imagination is way more active than our night was." He looked back at you, his thumb grazing your wrist as he let go of the plate. "Enjoy, angel."
As he walked away, Cleo, who had been oddly quiet since the morning started, finally spoke up.
"Oh, he’s got it bad for you," she noted, her voice steady but lacking its usual punch. You just laughed, throwing a strawberry slice into your mouth as your eyes stayed glued to the girl.
"Cleo, you okay?" you asked, leaning forward, swallowing. "We haven't really talked since..."
Cleo sighed, adjusting her sunglasses. "I don’t know, girl.” She sighed. “I’m not mad at Kie. I told her that. But Pope? I don’t have any other choice but to keep my guard up.” She explained. “He’s been trying to apologize all morning, but it’s hard to trust someone who can look you in the eye and lie about who he's thinking about. So, me and him? We’re on okay terms, I guess." She then looked at Kiara who'd been sitting silently and offered a small, genuine smile. "But we're good, Kie. Seriously."
The two girls shared smiles and gave each other a quick, firm hug, breaking the tension.
THE AFTERNOON was a blur of games that were mostly just excuses for the islanders to get sweaty and flirtatious. Between games of pool-side trivia and sun-tanning, JJ eventually made his move. He sauntered over while you were grabbing a drink, flashing that signature Florida boy grin.
"You know," JJ started, leaning against the outdoor kitchen counter. "I’m a big believer in exploring all my options. I know you and the buzzcut are 'a thing,' but I can't help that you're easily the hottest girl in this villa.” You rolled your eyes at his words. “I think we’d have a lot more fun than you and Mr. Serious over there."
You laughed, leaning back against the fridge as you cracked open a can of soda. "I can't tell if you're joking or dead serious." You chuckled. "JJ, you are a menace. Are you ever not hitting on someone?"
"Hey, I'm a bombshell. It’s in the job description. Did you not read yours?" he teased. "But for real. You're gorgeous, man. Just…keep me in mind if he gets too moody for you." He threw a thumb over his shoulder to where Rafe was.
"I…appreciate the offer, JJ," you said, patting his arm politely as you moved to exit the kitchen. "But I think I'm exactly where I want to be.” You scoffed, turning to face him as you walked backwards. “But y’know what? Go find Cleo, I think she could use a laugh."
He took the rejection with a wink and a shrug, wandering off to find his next target.
“He got you, too?” A voice met your eyes as you passed the pool, looking down to find John B kicking his feet in the water. “He’s been hitting on everyone, and I mean everyone, all damn day.” He laughed.
You slowed your pace, deciding that a little more mingling couldn't hurt—especially since Rafe was currently occupied with a workout and the girls were all relaxing. You dropped onto the edge of the pool next to him, letting your feet sink into the cool, chlorinated water.
“He’s definitely persistent,” you agreed, watching JJ's retreating back as you sipped on your drink. “But I think he’s harmless. Just a lot of energy.” You shrugged. “How are you holding up, John B? You’ve been kind of the 'calm in the storm' lately.”
John B ran a hand through his messy, sun-bleached hair, a self-deprecating smile tugging at his lips. “I’m trying to be. Honestly, I’m just taking it all in. Back home in the Outer Banks, things are… slower. I spend most of my time at the history museum my dad and I own. It’s a lot of old maps, dusty artifacts, and trying to make ends meet.” He reminisced. “So, this is definitely a change of pace.”
You tilted your head, interested. “A history museum? That’s actually really cool. I didn't peg you for a history buff.”
“It’s the family legacy,” he said, though a shadow crossed his face. “To be honest, that’s kind of why my last relationship went south. I was so focused on the museum, on the money, on the success of it all… I wasn't really there for her, y’know?” He looked at you. “I was in the room, but my brain was always somewhere else, counting coins and worrying about the mortgage. I came here because I realized I don't want to be that guy anymore. Not like my old man. I want to actually… connect. You know?”
You nodded, understanding. It was clear that John B was a provider type, but one who had let the stress of survival drown out his capacity for intimacy. “It’s hard to balance the real world with romance. Especially when you feel like the weight of a legacy is on your shoulders.”
“Exactly,” he sighed, looking at you with genuine appreciation. “You get it. Kie’s great, don't get me wrong, but I feel like I’m still learning how to be a partner. Plus, I don’t think either of us see each other that way, to be fair.” He admitted with a light laugh. “I’m a work in progress.”
Confessional : John B
“She's really easy to talk to. She doesn't just hear you, she listens. It’s a little intimidating, actually.” He pondered. “...Damn, Rafe is a lucky guy.”
After chatting with John B for a bit longer, you headed toward the outdoor gym area to grab a towel, but you stopped when you saw Pope sitting on a lounge chair, staring intensely at a notebook.
“...Planning a bank heist?” you joked, leaning against the squat rack.
Pope jumped slightly, looking up with wide eyes before relaxing. “Oh, hey.” He came back to reality. “Neither. Just… well, I just graduated with a dual degree in Computer Science and Mathematics. My brain doesn't really know how to shut off, I guess. If I was back home in Maryland, I'd be helping my dad run our seafood shop to kill time, but since I've been here, I find myself doing equations while I’m here just to.. stay sharp.”
“Maryland, huh? I can definitely see that.” You added. “What made you wanna do this?”
His smile faltered slightly as he looked toward the pool where Cleo and Kiara were talking, guilt clouding his face. “I just… I’ve always felt like the second option. In school, in my career, and definitely in my love life.” Pope admitted. “I’m the guy people call when they need their computer fixed or their taxes done, but I’m rarely the guy they call just because they want to see me.” He told you, sighing. “I came here hoping I could finally be someone’s first choice. Guess I screwed that up…”
Your heart twinged for him. “Pope, you’re brilliant and you’re kind.” You smiled at him. “The right person isn't going to see you as an option, they’re going to see you as the prize. Don't let all of this reality TV chaos make you feel like you're less-than just because you aren't doing backflips into the pool and didn’t have your mind made up on day one.” You reassured him. “I’m sure genuine apologies and some time will fix whatever you think is broken.”
“Thanks,” he whispered, looking a bit more confident as he gave you a small smile. “I needed that. Especially today.”
Confessional : Pope
“Y/N is a like a blessing. She’s got a really confident, almost intimidating, energy, but she’s also so grounded. Talking to her makes me feel like I’m not a complete screw-up. It’s nice…”
Finally, you crossed paths with Topper near the fire pit. He was dressed in a crisp, polo shirt that looked a little too formal for the 80-degree weather.
“Tense morning, huh?” you said, stopping to adjust your bikini top.
Topper nodded, his expression stiff. “You could say that. I’m used to a bit more… decorum. I work in the legal system back in New York with my grandpa. Everything is about rules, reputation, and standing.”
“Rules, huh?” you asked, a playful but sharp edge to your voice. “You don’t strike me as the type.”
Topper’s posture went from stiff to defensive in an instant. “They already told you? Shit, man.” Topper stressed. “Look, it was a one night stand. I tried everything to get my ex to understand that but she broke up with me anyway. I’m a changed man, or a changing man, I promise—”
“Topper, what the hell are you talking about?” You interrupted, putting a hand out.
“...You weren’t talking about me cheating on my ex?”
“...No.” You deadpanned. “No, I wasn’t.”
“Oh,” he tensed. “Shit.”
‘“Right…” You gave him a curt nod before moving on. He was a tough nut to crack, and your gut was telling you that his "perfect" exterior was holding back a lot of buried secrets.
By the time you finished your rounds, you felt like you had a much better handle on the guys in the villa. They were all just as messy, hopeful, and complicated as the girls. But as your eyes drifted back to the patio where Rafe was finally finishing his workout, you knew that none of them could hold a candle to the boy waiting for you upstairs.
EVENTUALLY, you found Rafe up on the patio, away from the chatter and the music. He was staring out at the horizon, looking thoughtful, sweating lightly from his workout. You joined him, leaning against the railing.
"You look tense," you noticed. “What’cha thinkin’ about, big guy?”
"Thinkin’ about you, actually," he admitted, turning to face you with a breathy smirk. "I saw you down there getting to know everyone. Forgot you missed all of the introductions.” He observed. “The, uh, psych thing—is that what you want to do? Listen to people's problems for a living? I could see the gears turning in your head from all the way up here."
You cringed, shaking your head. "God, no. I’m studying Forensic psychology, actually. I want to get into the heads of the people that most people are afraid of.” You explained, taking a seat next to him. “Criminal profiling, court evaluations... that kind of stuff."
Rafe’s eyebrows shot up. "No kidding? That’s intense.” He scooted closer. “So, you’re basically a human lie detector?"
"Something like that," you challenged, shrugging. "Want to test your theory? You try to lie to me, and I’ll tell you exactly how I know you're doing it."
He looked intrigued, his eyes darkening with a mix of amusement and something else—admiration. "Alright. Lay it on me."
And for the next twenty minutes, you put him through the wringer. You pointed out the way his jaw tightened when he lied about his favorite color, the way his pupils dilated when he talked about how much he liked the villa, and the subtle shift in his posture when he was being genuine.
"You're terrifying," Rafe laughed, shaking his head. "It’s scary how well you can read me. But it’s also... kind of hot." He paused, his expression turning a bit more serious. "Is that the only work you’ve ever done? Just school and psych stuff?"
You went quiet suddenly, shoulders stiffening. The lightheartedness of the moment vanished, replaced by a cold, familiar stone in your gut. You looked away, picking at a loose thread on your bikini bottoms. "Um, no. I…I've worked a lot of jobs."
Rafe, however, noticed the shift instantly. "Hey. You don't have to talk about it if you don't want to."
"It’s fine," you said quickly, forcing a smile that didn't reach your eyes. "Let’s talk about something else." You sucked in a deep breath. "Like why you really left the room last night. Was it Ruthie or were you secretly hoping I would follow you?"
Rafe took the hint and let the subject drop, though his eyes lingered on you with a new sense of curiosity. "It was definitely a mix of both." He smirked, feeding into you. "I haven't slept that well in... well, ever. You're a good pillow."
You laughed, the tension easing. “Since, I know you saw me chatting with some of the guys, it's your turn,” you started, shifting. “So, tell me more about you. What’s the 'Rafe Cameron' story? Family, work, the whole deal?"
Rafe’s face tightened as he thought of his family—his dad. "I mean, you know about my job and stuff. But there’s not a lot about my family. I have two sisters, and my parents…well, uh…they…” He looked like he’d hit a road block, like he was malfunctioning before your eyes, like he was about to shut down.
Noticing this, you quickly changed gears.
“Hey,” you put a hand on his thigh. “It’s okay. Another time.” You reassured, standing up. “But I’m feeling a little racey…” You stretched, a smirk on your face. "Race you to the pool!" you shouted, pecking his cheek and not giving him time to sink into the mood before you sprinted down the stairs, hearing his heavy footsteps behind you.
You ran across the lawn and canonballed into the pool, hitting the water with a massive splash, surfacing just in time to see him dive in right next to you. In the center of the pool, hidden from the main group by the rock feature, he grabbed your waist, dragging you over to him.
"You're fast," he panted, licking his lips.
"And you're slow," you teased, a taunting smile on your face as your arms went around neck, swaying in the water.
"...Y'know, I've never felt like this," he whispered, his forehead resting against yours. "It’s been three days, and I feel more free with you than I do with people I’ve known for years."
"...Trust me," you whispered back, the water swirling around you both. “I know the feeling.”
Confessional : Rafe
"She’s smart. Like, scary smart. It’s intimidating as hell, but I can't stay away from her.” He trailed off, staring out at nothing as a soft smiled graced his features. “I think I’m in trouble."
THAT EVENING, Kiara made dinner for the entire villa—a recipe from her parents’ restaurant, she’d told you as you hovered while she cooked.
She told you a lot more about herself as she threw ingredients around—she told you all about her non-profit environmentalist group and her animal rescue, even opened up about her coming on Love Island because she never had a serious relationship before, with a guy or a girl. The conversation drifted away when the kitchen started to fill.
The smell of garlic, spices, and fresh seafood filled the air, momentarily bringing everyone together. But the peace was short-lived.
After dinner, you were sitting on the edge of the fire pit when you overheard Pope pull Cleo aside near the outdoor kitchen. Despite wanting to give them privacy, you couldn't help but listen.
Hell, you were all on national TV anyway.
"Cleo, please," Pope was saying, his voice thick with frustration. "I'm sorry I didn't tell you. I just didn't want to make things weird because I still like you—"
"It’s already weird, Pope!" Cleo snapped, her voice cracking. "I get that this is a game. I get that we’re supposed to explore. But you lied to my face.” Her voice cracked. “You let me think we were getting somewhere while you were dreaming about kissing Kie. It makes me feel stupid.” She spat. “So, do me a favor... don't choose me at the next recoupling.” She ordered, clearly hurt if her voice was anything to go by. “It’s clear where your heart is…"
You heard as she turned and walked away, her head held high until she passed the cameras and hit the shadows of the garden. You followed after silently, watching her shoulders shake.
You found her by the daybeds, wiping her eyes furiously. She jumped as you sat down next to her before relaxing. "...Of course you heard." She sighed. "I just feel so stupid," she sobbed. "It’s been three days. Why am I crying over some guy I just met? I’ve been through worse. I mean, the first guy I thought I was in love with played me and robbed me, so why does this hurt so much?"
"Because it’s like re-opening an old wound?” you offered. “And because you're human, Cleo," you said, pulling her into a side-hug. "And because you actually gave him a chance. He’s the one who lost out, not you."
Cleo sniffed, wiping her eyes. “Thanks…”
You stayed with her until her breathing leveled out, a silent bond forming between the two of you.
THAT NIGHT, you and Rafe didn't even bother with the bedroom. Once the lights went low and the snores started, you met him by the large outdoor daybeds.
"Ready for Round Two?" he whispered, holding open a thick blanket.
You climbed in next to him, the cool night air replaced by his heat. You were just settling in, whispering about nothing, when you heard hushed voices from above.
You both looked up toward the rooftop terrace and froze.
There, in the moonlight, were Ruthie and Topper. They were talking in low, frantic tones, but you managed to hear a small snippet of their conversation...
“You’re seriously still trying to deny it?” Ruthie whispered, a playful but sharp edge to her voice. “Topper, the chemistry during that kiss and tell challenge was loud enough for the whole island to hear.”
Topper stepped closer, a nervous glance darting toward the shadows before his eyes locked back onto hers. “I’m not denying anything. I just didn't think you’d call me out on it tonight. We were supposed to be playing it cool, since, you know...”
“Since when do you 'play it cool'?” Ruthie scoffed softly, tilting her chin up to meet his gaze. “Besides, you didn’t seem to care about 'being cool' when you kissed me. Admit it, it wasn’t just for the game.”
A slow smirk broke across Topper’s face, his voice dropping an octave as he closed the remaining distance between them. “...Fine. It wasn’t. You’re a dangerous distraction, Ruthie...”
“Good. Because honestly? You’ve spent way too much time losing your mind over a certain golden girl who doesn't care about you like I do.”
Topper’s expression softened, the guard completely dropping as he reached out, his fingers brushing gently against her arm. “She’s the last thing on my mind right now. Especially with you standing here...”
And then—right in front of God and the cameras—they leaned in for a long, passionate kiss.
Your blood turned to ice. "...Are you kidding me?" you hissed under your breath, gaze whipping between Rafe and the couple on the terrace. "Ruthie has been riding my ass for forty-eight hours about 'stealing' you, and she’s up there with Sarah’s guy in the middle of the night talking shit—"
Rafe’s hand went to your shoulder, his grip firm as he saw you moving to get off of the daybed. "Hey. Let them dig their own grave." He coaxed. "We saw it. That’s all that matters."
You huffed, backing down. "I officially hate them," you muttered, leaning back into his chest. "And Topper has been acting like he's obsessed with Sarah."
"People are snakes," Rafe murmured, pulling you closer. "But we aren't. It'll blow up on them eventually.” He squeezed you tighter. “...Who are you, um, picking at the recoupling, anyway? You know, whenever it comes around..." He tried to feign nonchalantness.
You fixed him with a tight-lipped deadpan expression."Is that even a question?" you whispered, turning to face him. "I'm picking the guy who makes me breakfast and races me to the pool.” You told him simply, snuggling closer to him, heart pounding as you asked the same question. “...What about you? If the guys pick... are you picking the bombshell or sticking with the girl on the roof?"
"That's not even a serious question." He rolled his eyes. "I'm picking the only girl in this villa who actually sees me," he said, kissing your forehead.
And you fell asleep in his arms, the anger fading into exhaustion.
THE CONFRONTATION didn't happen at the fire pit.
It happened at 7:00 AM.
You woke up to a shadow looming over the daybed. You squinted against the early morning sun to see Ruthie standing there, her face contorted with a fake, concerned expression that didn't hide the malice in her eyes.
"Unbelievable," Ruthie sneered, loud enough to wake the dead. "I knew you were a sneak, but sleeping out here like a common tramp?” She hissed as the other islanders gathered around, following behind Ruthie as you were sure she made a scene before leaving the bedroom. “And Rafe, I thought you had more class than this. You’re literally sneaking around behind my back—"
"Sneaking around?" Rafe’s voice boomed, echoing through the villa. He didn't just wake up at Ruthie’s loud words, he practically exploded. He sat up, his eyes flashing with a cold fury you hadn't seen yet as his arms remained around you."You want to talk about sneaking around, Ruthie?” Rafe’s eyes narrowed. “Because last time I checked, I wasn't on the roof in the middle of the night sucking face with Topper!"
The silence that followed was deafening. The other islanders, still in their pajamas, looked confused and shocked.
"...What did you just say?" Sarah asked, her voice small, looking from Rafe to Ruthie.
Rafe sighed, running a hand down his face. "...I’m sorry, Sarah," Rafe retorted, standing up and pointing a finger at Ruthie as you sat up straighter in the daybed, rubbing sleep from your eyes. "But she’s been harassing her for 'stealing' me while she’s been sneaking off with Topper. Probably since night one, and night two, and definitely last night on the roof. I saw it. I saw them. We both did." Rafe exposed, throwing a hand out in your direction.
Ruthie’s face went through five different shades of red. "H-He’s lying!” She tried, looking around at everyone “He’s just trying to cover his own ass for being a liar since day one!"
"...I think I saw them too," John B muttered from the back of the group, looking uncomfortable. "I didn't say anything because I wasn't sure, but I saw them leave the room late on night two."
Sarah turned to Topper, who was looking at his feet. "Topper? Is it true?"
Topper didn't answer. He just turned and walked away, and Sarah let out a scoff that morphed into broken sobs, chasing after him toward the back of the villa.
"You're a piece of work, Ruthie," you said tiredly, standing up next to Rafe.
THE GROUP dispersed in a cloud of tension. The girls, minus Sarah who was still locked in a room with Topper, gathered in the makeup room, the energy frantic.
"I can't believe them," Kie whispered, shaking her head. "Sarah is devastated..."
“Believe me, I was beyond pissed last night,” You gritted your teeth, moving things around. “They’re both assholes.” You looked at Cleo and Kie, face softening. "But how are you guys holding up? After everything with Pope…"
"I’m okay," Cleo said, though she looked tired. "At least I know where I stand now. But, I mean, Sarah... she thought they were real. He was all over her. I can’t believe he was sneaking around. And with Ruthie of all people…"
“Especially since Ruthie was trying to jump down your throat every chance she got…” Kie added.
You spent the next hour getting ready, but your mind wasn’t only on your friends—it was on Rafe. You headed to the kitchen and decided to return the favor from yesterday.
You made him a massive plate of eggs, bacon, and toast, bringing it to him where he was sitting alone at the breakfast bar.
"A token of my gratitude," you said, sliding the plate over, putting your hands on his shoulders and kissing his cheek.
He giggled, kissing your cheek back before taking a bite, closing his eyes. He paused mid-chew, shoulders slumping as he groaned. "This?” He pointed at his plate with his fork as you poured a glass of juice for yourself. “Is the best thing I’ve ever tasted. Seriously. You’re a lifesaver."
“Why, thank you, Mr. Cameron.” You courtesied, smiling as you sipped on your glass of juice.
While he ate and you both talked, you spotted Sarah sitting alone on a lounge chair near the pool, her head in her hands. You curtly excused yourself from Rafe and walked over, sitting quietly beside her.
"Sarah, I don’t even know what to say…” you started. “He's a liar," you said softly. "You deserve so much more than a guy who uses you as a placeholder while he sneaks around."
However, Topper chose that exact moment to race over, looking like he wanted to apologize.
But you didn't give him the chance.
"Don't," you said, standing up to block him as Sarah shifted away from him. "Seriously, Topper? You're a piece of shit. You lied to her face for four days while you were chasing Ruthie.”
“I know, I just—” He breathed, panting like he’d been running all around looking for her.
“Go. Before I forget there are cameras watching."
Topper looked stunned, then scuttled away like a kicked dog, not without another guilty glance over his shoulder. You were turning around when Sarah lunged forward, hugging you tightly and sobbing into your shoulder.
"Thank you," she whispered. You stood shocked for a moment before relaxing and hugging her back, rubbing a hand over her back. When she pulled away, you helped wipe the tears from her eyes.
"Maybe you should talk to Cleo," you told her, still wiping her eyes. "She’s in the same boat. Maybe you guys can be help each other."
Sarah nodded and gave you one last hug before going to find Cleo as you returned to Rafe who’d been watching the whole time, admiring you from afar.
LATER that afternoon, the dreaded ping of a text echoed through the villa. It was you and JJ, again.
"Text!” You both called aloud.
"Hit me," Rafe said, beckoning you both to read the text as everyone gather.
“JJ and Y/N, it’s time to see if your bombshell status pays off. You each get to pick one Islander for a proper date outside the villa! #BeachVibes #DoubleDate"
You didn't hesitate, smiling as you bounced on your feet. "Rafe."
JJ looked around and smirked. "I’m taking…Kiara."
Pope, sitting nearby, looked like he’d been punched in the gut, but he stayed silent.
Damn. Two for two.
Back in the dressing room, the girls were hype for you.
"Go enjoy yourself," Sarah said, managing a weak smile. "Your guy is the only one not fucking up right now."
Kiara squeezed your arm as you looked each other over, both adorned in beautiful flowy dresses. "I’m just excited to get away from the villa energy and try to have a good time with JJ. He’s actually kind of funny when he’s not being a dog."
THE DATE was on a secluded beach, with a long table set up under a canopy as the sun began to set.
JJ and Kiara seemed to be hitting it off on the other end of the table, their laughter drifting over the sound of the waves. There was something in JJ’s eyes you hadn’t seen with yourself or any of the other girls. Sometimes, you’d get a snippet of their conversation as the wind carried it and he was actually talking about something other than boobs, butts, and sex.
But you and Rafe were in your own world.
"I…felt bad for shutting down earlier," Rafe said, picking at his dinner. "About my family. My relationship with my dad... it’s not just 'not great.' It’s toxic." He admitted, wiping his mouth with his napkin. "He’s a powerful man, and he uses that power to crush anything he can't control. Including me." He paused, his voice cracking slightly. "And my mom, she passed when I was ten. She was the only one who kept him in check. Since then... it’s been hell."
You could tell it was a very sore subject for him, from the shake in his voice to the trembling of his hands.
You reached across the table, taking his hand in yours. "I get it, Rafe. More than you know…"
He looked up, surprised yet concerned. "You mean that?"
You nodded, taking a deep breath. "My parents... they were very verbally abusive. Everything was about control. If I wasn't perfect, I was nothing.” You told him, avoiding his eyes as unwanted memories flooded your mind. “I ran away when I was sixteen. I just... I couldn't breathe in that house anymore." You felt the familiar sting in your eyes. "They didn't even put out a missing persons report. And I haven't spoken to them in years. They don't even know I’m here."
Rafe squeezed your hand, his grip grounding you. "How did you live? At sixteen? How did you get this far?"
You took a deep breath, the secret you’d been guarding finally pushing its way out. "...When you asked if I’d worked anywhere else... that’s, um, why I got quiet." You choked out. "I did a lot of what I had to do to survive.” You told him, swallowing harshly. “...I worked as a bottle girl in some pretty shady clubs. I... I even stripped for a while."
The silence was heavy. You waited for the judgment, for the look of disgust.
"It wasn't the job I was ashamed of, necessarily," you whispered, your voice trembling. "It was the things I did to feel numb while I was doing it. The people I let into my life because I thought I didn't deserve better." You felt a sob rise in your throat, pulling your hands back and hiding them under the table as Rafe remained silent and tears welled in your eyes, your throat growing tight. "I don't want to talk about this anymore." You rushed out in one faint breath.
"Hey, it's alright," Rafe said, standing up, rounding the table, and pulling you out of your chair. You looked up at him as you took his outstretched hand. He didn't say a word. He just led you down toward the shore, the cool water lapping at your feet. You walked in silence for a long time, the only sound was the crashing of the waves.
"...I'd never judge you, by the way," Rafe finally spoke, looking down at you as you walked.
When you finally felt calm enough to speak, you looked up at him. "Thank you. For not... for not making a scene. I've never told anyone that.” You admitted, voice still hoarse. “And…I hope it doesn't make you look at me differently."
Rafe stopped, turning you to face him. The rising moonlight hit the sharp angles of his face. "Look at me.” He ordered, a hand under your chin. “My past is full of demons I wish I could forget, too. I’ve done things I’m not proud of just to survive my father’s shadow. I’m not judging you. If anything... I admire you more for being here, standing on your own two feet after everything....No one's perfect. But I like you just the way you are." He smirked down at you, squeezing your hand.
You smiled tearfully as he leaned in, his hand cupping your jaw. "You're officially the strongest person I've ever met."
And then, he kissed you. Truly kissed you. It was deep, desperate, and full of a shared understanding that felt like a lifetime of connection packed into a few seconds.
WHEN you returned to the villa, the islanders welcomed you back with curious eyes.
In the makeup room, Kiara was beaming.
"The date was actually great," Kie admitted to Cleo, Sarah, and you. "JJ has this really soft heart under that whole 'playboy' exterior. He told me about his home life and how he just wants to be seen for more than his looks.” She explained, tucking a curl behind her ear. “I think I could really like him."
Cleo smiled. "I’m happy for you, Kie. JJ must really like you, because my date with him on Day One was... let’s just say it was a lot different." She chuckled.
You leaned against the counter, a dazed smile on your face. "I learned a lot more about Rafe today. I think... I could really see us being something real. Like, 'outside of the villa' real."
The girls squealed, pulling you into a group hug and jumping up and down like a bunch of school girls.
AS you prepared for bed, the girls started teasing you as you headed toward the door.
"Going to your man on the daybeds?" Sarah joked.
"Don't do anything I wouldn't do!" Cleo shouted.
You laughed, heading out to find Rafe already waiting for you. You climbed into the daybed, immediately curling into his side. It was quiet and there were a billion stars in the sky and you had one thought on your mind as you felt the warmth of Rafe next to you—I could get used to this.
"...We were meant to know each other, weren't we?" you whispered, tracing the tattoos on his arm. You’d ask about them one day. But you figured why rush when it felt like you had all the time in the world with this amazing guy?
"I think so, angel," he murmured, kissing your forehead.
"Why do you call me that?" you asked, looking up at him as he admired the way the moon reflected in your eyes. "...’Angel’?"
Rafe looked at you, his gaze intense and full of a soft, rare vulnerability. "Because that’s all you’ve been since the second I laid eyes on you.” He said softly, tracing your face with the tip of his fingers. “You’re the only good thing that’s happened to me in a long, long time."
At his words, you smiled and pulled the blanket up over both of you, falling asleep to the sound of his heart beating against your ear, knowing that this night was the night everything changed.
SYNOPSIS‧₊˚ [6k] After making a splash in the "Kiss and Tell" challenge, you find yourself drawn to the magnetic but "taken" Rafe Cameron.
WARNING(S)‧₊˚ ruthie's a mean girl, deception, swearing, suggestive content, emotional stress, not proofread ywt
˗ˏˋ series masterlist ˎˊ˗
“IT’S OUR COUPLES FIRST NIGHT IN THE VILLA. As our four couples sit shaking in their seats, our lovely Ariana is waiting to give them their first challenge.”
The air hummed with anticipation, the neon glow of the Love Island villa casting long shadows across the manicured lawn. It was the first night, and already, the drama was brewing. After the initial coupling, four pairs stood awkwardly — Cleo and Pope, Sarah and Topper, John B and Kiara, Rafe and Ruthie.
The host, none other than Ariana Madix, clapped her hands, drawing everyone's attention. "Alright, Islanders. It’s time for our very first challenge — 'Kiss and Tell'... or maybe just 'Kiss' for now…" Nervous giggles rippled through the group, the islanders sharing weary smiles and awkward glances. "Here's how it works: you'll each be blindfolded. Then, you'll be given the chance to kiss someone you might have a little bit of interest in…outside of your couple. No talking, just kissing. And please, try to be quiet." Ariana smiled mischievously. “With that, Islanders, please place your blindfolds over your eyes.”
A heavy tension hung in the air as the couples silently placed the thick, black blindfolds over their eyes. With one of their senses taken, Ariana continued. “If you’d like to kiss someone outside of your current couple, please, raise your hand.”
With slow, steady, and somewhat unsure movements — a few islanders took a leap and raised their hands. First it was Ruthie, then Topper, then Pope, then John B. The hosts’ eyes widened, turning to the camera and mouthing a ‘wow’.
“Islanders,” Ariana started once she made a mental note of who held their hand up. “When I tap your shoulder, you may silently get up and kiss the islander, or islanders, of your choice.” And with a wink towards the camera, Ariana stepped down from the platform and quietly started rounding the circle of couples, tapping Ruthie on the shoulder first.
A wide grin plastered on her face as she slid the blindfold from over her eyes. Quietly sliding off of her seat next to Rafe, she moved with surprising confidence. She wasted no time in planting quick, decisive kisses on all the boys. She started with Pope, attempting to deepen it, but he didn’t seem quite interested. Then she moved onto John B, the kiss not lasting long. She made her last move on Topper, a kiss that lasted a bit too long for comfort…and definitely was heard by the others.
Confessional : Sarah
“I’m not saying Topper got kissed…” She started, hands in the air. “All I’m saying is that I heard lips locking a little too close to my ear.”
Confessional : Ruthie
Producer: Do you feel bad about kissing all of the guys?
“Do I feel bad?” She asked almost unbelievably. “Why would I? This is Love Island. I’m just playing the game. Plus, maybe if I make Rafe a little jealous, he’ll actually show some interest in me…” She rolled her eyes.
Once Ruthie was sat and blindfolded, Pope was the next to receive a soft tap on his shoulder.
Slowly removing his blindfold and getting out of his seat, the boy found his way straight to Kiara. With a gentle finger under her chin, Pope placed a soft, sweet kiss on her lips.
Confessional : Pope
“I felt kind of bad stepping outside of my coupling with Cleo, but I feel this, like, pull towards Kiara and it just felt like an opportunity I couldn’t pass up.”
With Pope back in his seat, it was Topper’s turn. Ariana’s jaw dropped when he practically made a b-line for Ruthie, shoving his tongue down her throat.
Confessional : Topper
“I kind of had a feeling it was Ruthie that kissed me but after kissing her, I know it was her. For sure.” He smiled, leaning back. “Glad to know the feeling’s mutual.”
And lastly, after Topper had his fun, it was John B’s time to shine. He took a deep breath before he found Sarah, a brief but undeniable spark in their exchange—him taking her face in both of his hands and placing a passionate kiss on her lips.
Confessional : John B
“Sarah and I kept locking eyes during the coupling, so I was kinda bummed when she went with Topper…” John B shrugged. “But your boy never gives up, so of course I had to show her what she was missing. Even if she doesn’t know it was me...yet.” He winked.
With John B back in his seat, Ariana returned to the middle. But instead of instructing the islanders to remove their blindfolds, she glances over her shoulder, waving two people over.
“Uh-oh. It looks like our couples are about to get their first real taste of Love Island — please welcome our first bombshells, Y/N and JJ.”
The villa was silent as you entered the villa alongside JJ, small smirks on your faces as you anticipated the drama you were about to stir. It was exciting and nerve-wracking all at the same time.
Confessional : You
“Hi!" You beamed. "I’m Y/N, I’m twenty-two and I’m from Vegas. I just recently graduated with a Psych degree but I definitely gained some other…useful skills throughout my multiple careers." You laughed. "I’m here to take another chance on love and find my person. I know that coming in as a bombshell, it’s kind of my role to step on toes, but that’s really not my intention, and I hope I can get on with the girls before I have to steal one of their guys…”
Confessional : JJ
“I’m JJ, I’m twenty-two and I’m from Florida. I work as a surf instructor and I came here to work on my…non-commitalism? I think that’s what they called it… I don’t know, but girls apparently hate it." He shrugged, the producers laughing in the background. "I’ve been called a “red flag” too many times for my liking, so, here I am.”
As you and JJ come to stand beside the host, your eyes wander over the blindfolded, unexpecting couples. They were all attractive, even with parts of their features covered, and you could tell this would be a hard decision.
Silently, Ariana motioned for JJ to step forward and kiss the girls first. And the blonde could not be more excited.
Looks like JJ is wasting no time in taking his chances. This man’s got no fear as he approaches our first blindfolded girl.
Confessional : You
“Y’know, I’m kind of glad that I came in with JJ because, I can’t lie, he’s an attractive guy, and had I not? I might’ve gone for him. But after getting to talk to him, he’s very…different.” You laughed, a hand covering your mouth. “Like, it’s not a bad thing but…" Your voice dropped to a whisper as if anyone could hear you. "...he kept looking at my boobs in the car.”
The nearest couple to the three unblindfolded happened to be Cleo and Pope, and JJ didn’t hesitate in making an impression — a hand gently slid up the length of Cleo’s neck, guiding her to tilt her head up as JJ pressed his lips against hers.
Moving onto the next, Topper sat still, none the wiser to an all too happy JJ slowly approaching Sarah. Tucking a strand of hair behind her ear, he dipped down and placed a sensual kiss to her lips.
Then it was Kiara, both of his hands cradling the girl’s round cheeks as sloppily kissed her right next to her partner.
Lastly, he ended his show with a brief but still steamy kiss with Ruthie, who surprisingly (or not), gripped his arms as he locked lips.
As JJ made his way back to the platform, licking his lips — you and the host couldn’t do anything but shake your heads. Once JJ was planted in his spot, Ariana nodded her head in your direction as a silent signal for you to follow JJ’s lead, only this time…on all the boys.
With a deep breath, you quietly stepped down from the heart shaped platform, careful not to make noise with the heels on your feet.
The first guy you approached, Pope, caught your eye immediately — dark skin, coily hair, and muscles that clearly took some hard work and time. He was hard to miss, and you were glad you didn’t. Standing in between his legs, one of your hands slithered behind his neck, the boy visibly shivering under your touch before you dipped down and connected your lips with his. Pope involuntarily made a small sound of surprise before relaxing into the exchange, just seconds before you decided to pull away and approach the next guy.
This one was blonde and much lankier, his shoulders much too square for your taste. Even with the blindfold, you could tell he wasn’t quite your speed. But Kiss and Tell was the name of the game, and unlike the others, you weren’t given much of a choice in the matter. Bending down, you placed a kiss to his lips, not as engaged as before as you pulled away, gently swiping his chin before moving on.
The next guy was definitely something — John B had a nice tan, visible freckles and sun spots, and this fluffy, brown hair that definitely gave him some points. Your fingers trailed up his arms, feeling that slight hairs on them as you ran them all up until they could thread into his mess of loose curls, pulling at them slightly to tilt his head back as you slid your lips against his. As you pulled away, you could see that he was visibly breathless, the sight almost making you chuckle.
But you held it in and choked it down as your eyes landed on your fourth and final victim of the night. The smile was almost immediately wiped from your face when you got a good look at the guy you’d be kissing — a buzzcut, well-defined muscles that had maps of veins that you could spend hours tracing with your fingers, and this somewhat ever-present smirk on his face that didn’t seem to fade.
Rafe wasn’t just your type. He was straight up something out of a dream.
And you didn’t even get to see his eyes, yet.
And you couldn’t stop yourself as you quietly walked in his direction, stopping right in front of him. It was almost like the man could sense your presence as his head slightly angled itself upwards, almost like he could see you through the obstruction. The movement made your heart race but you didn’t allow it to throw you off your game.
Your hands started at his knees, slowly moving up as they caressed his thighs. Rafe was unwavering, deathly still, but his clenching jaw was a dead giveaway — and your sign that you must’ve been doing something right. As one hand remained planted on his thigh, the other slowly traveled up his chest, to his neck, all the way up until you could hold his face in your hand, slightly pulling it closer in order to carefully connect his lips with your own. Out of all the kisses you’d given out tonight, this one was the only one to make your head spin. Your knees nearly buckled when Rafe seemed to lose himself, groaning into the kiss.
You smiled against his lips as you slowly pulled away, the hand on his jaw coming up to wipe the gloss from his lips — leaving the boy stunned, his jaw still slack as you walked away.
Confessional : Rafe
Producer: Rafe, how do you feel about the last kiss you received?
“...I don’t know what the fuck that was.” Rafe stared blankly into the camera, a smile forming on his lips that he tried to fight. “But I liked it. A lot.”
With both you and JJ back on the podium, Ariana stood with her hands in front of her before speaking to the islanders themselves. “Alright,” She started, smiling. “You may now remove your blindfolds.”
You watched, nearly tap dancing on your feet, as the couples in front of you slowly removed the masks from their eyes. They looked at each other first…then at you and JJ. You both remained still as the islanders turned to you both one by one, sharing looks of surprise.
“Islanders, while some of you did choose to kiss someone, or a few people, outside of your coupling,” The host started, looking around with pointed glances. “Those last kisses were courtesy of our first official bombshells — JJ and Y/N.”
As the couples shifted in their seats, some looking nervous or shameful, you couldn’t help but let your gaze drift to the last boy you kissed.
Rafe’s eyes were glued to you as he relaxed in his seat, his eyes studying you like the most interesting piece of art he’d ever seen. You didn’t realize you were staring at first, but even when you did, the fact didn’t seem to deter you.
“Now that the first challenge has ended,” The host started back up. “Will you be honest and admit whether you chose to kiss someone other than your partner? Or are your lips officially sealed for good?” She taunted, looking around with a glint in her eye. “Until then, please, make your new islanders feel welcome. Who knows? You might want to be on their good side…” Ariana shrugged. “Until we meet again. Good luck.”
YOU TRAILED BEHIND THE GIRLS AS THEY WALKED TOWARDS A LOUNGE AREA, a fair distance away from where the boys had also gathered to chat. You figured it’d best to get on with the women first. You were here to find love, but you weren’t in the business of making enemies.
As they all sat down, you took a seat between the blonde and the girl with the brown curls.
“Okay, that was kind of crazy.” Kiara spoke first, eyes wide.
“Wait, you got kissed?” Sarah asked, jaw slack. Kiara just nodded sheepishly. “Oh my gosh, who do you think it was? Because, so did I, and I think it may have been-” Sarah cut herself off mid-sentence, eyes drifting to you. “Oh shit, we’re being so rude.” She clasped her hands over her mouth, placing a hand on your shoulder. “Hi. You’re gorgeous, like stunning, actually. I’m Sarah,” She started pointing to herself, then the others. “That’s Kiara, Cleo, and Ruthie.”
They all waved, sending you warm smiles, even though you could tell there was still some lingering worry. The coldest was Ruthie, offering you a pained grimace before rolling her eyes.
You introduced yourself in return, telling the girls your name before diving right into your real concerns. “Can someone fill me in? I know it’s still the first day but I feel like I missed so much. I mean, you’re already coupled up. How did that happen? Did the guys pick?”
“Actually, we did” Sarah beamed, tucking a strand of hair behind hear ear and glancing at the guys across the lawn. “So, I’m coupled up with Topper, that guy right there.” She pointed to him, sitting tense in his seat.
“Who I was coupled with first,” Ruthie retorted from her place next to Kiara, arms crossed as she looked you up and down briefly.
“Yeah,” Sarah cringed. “I did kind of steal him, but it’s still early! Sorry, Ruthie...” She apologized, Ruthie offering no words in response as she shrugged, trying to act unbothered.
Confessional : Sarah
“I don’t know if Ruthie is actually mad about the whole Topper thing. I hope not…” She trailed off, squinting. “It’s literally our first day. How mad can she really be?”
“Plus, you ended up with Rafe,” Sarah continued, relaxing in her seat. “I’d say that’s still a win.”
“I didn’t pick him,” Ruthie sassed back, trying to lighten her words with a chuckle this time. “But he seems to be interested in me so, yeah, ‘I’d say that’s still a win’.” She mocked lightheartedly(?).
Confessional : Ruthie
“Rafe’s not showing as much interest as I’m used to, but I obviously can’t admit that with this new bombshell here. She’s not even all that but I need to secure my spot because I’ll be damned if I’m the first to go home.”
“What about you?” You turned to Kiara, trying to break the tension in the air. “You’re with the brunette guy, right?”
Kiara simply nodded, a small smile tugging on her face. “Yeah, but I didn’t pick him. We were the only two that weren’t coupled up at the end of the first coupling. I, uh, had actually picked Pope, the guy sitting next to him.”
“Oh, him?” You asked, pointing over your shoulder. “Oh, that sucks. He’s hot.” You giggled, turning to direct your next comment at Cleo. “So, I’m guessing you swooped in and took him for yourself?” You joked, Cleo throwing her hands up as she leaned back.
“Hey, man,” She started. “I didn’t wanna do it to Kiara but I had to.” She defended, the topic clearly less offensive than the Ruthie and Sarah situation.
“So, besides me, did any of you kiss anyone?” You pressed, tucking your feet underneath you.
“Nope,” Ruthie was the first to speak after not including herself for most of the discussion. But something in your gut told you she wasn’t being quite honest…
“No, but I wonder who was the first guy that kissed me…” Kiara added, pouting. “He was really gentle, it was kind of sweet.”
Sarah sighed as she leaned into her seat. “Same, whoever kissed me did it like they’d been waiting to do it all day or something.
Confessional : Sarah
“I have a feeling it was John B that kissed me…” She laughed out loud. “I know it’s weird! But who else could it have been?”
“And you two didn’t get kissed by anyone outside of JJ?” You asked, shooting glances at Ruthie and Cleo, both girls shaking their heads.
“But what about you, girl?” Cleo interjected, hugging a pillow in front of her. “You got to kiss all the boys! Don’t be shy,” She urged, shrugging a shoulder with a curious smile on her face. “Who was your favorite?”
You laughed under your breath, palming the back of your neck. “I don’t think I should say…” The girls all collectively groaned, throwing their heads back. “I don’t wanna make anyone mad!” You defended, a small pout of your face as your eyebrows first.
“Oh, please!” Kiara stepped in. “We haven’t even shared a bed with these guys yet. Tell us!” She urged, playfully shaking your shoulder.
“Okay! Okay…” You surrendered, taking a deep breath and sinking into your seat. “...None of the kisses were bad…”
“But?” Sarah egged on, a teasing smile on her face.
“...But, one guy definitely made a… lasting impression.” You muttered, adjusting in your seat as your eyes drifted up to gaze across the lawn at the guy in question, only to find him staring back at you.
The girls followed your gaze like a pack of bloodhounds, their heads all swiveling toward the boys’ fire pit at once. Across the way, Rafe didn't even have the decency to look away. He was still leaned back, arms draped over the back of the sofa, watching you with that same heavy, unreadable intensity.
"No way," Sarah gasped, her jaw dropping. "Rafe? Seriously?"
Ruthie’s posture went from relaxed to stiff as a board in 0.5 seconds. She let out a sharp, forced laugh that didn't reach her eyes, smoothing down her hair. "I mean, he’s a good-looking guy, obviously. That's why I'm with him. But he's definitely a 'one-woman' kind of guy, you know? Probably just trying to be polite back to you."
Confessional : Ruthie
She picks at her manicure, looking absolutely livid despite her voice staying calm. "Am I pissed? No. I’m humored. It’s actually hilarious that she thinks she has a chance. She comes in, kisses everyone like she’s at a buffet, and thinks the guy I’m coupled with is into it?” She scoffs, flipping her hair over her shoulder. “I’m totally fine. Like, literally so chill right now."
"I don't know, Ruthie," Cleo smirked, nudging you. "He's literally burned a hole through the side of her head for the last ten minutes..."
You felt the heat crawl up your neck. "I’m not trying to step on toes, I promise. It was just... the chemistry was there.” You shrugged sheepishly. “I can't lie about it."
"Well, explore it!" Sarah encouraged, though she glanced nervously at Ruthie. "That’s what we’re here for, right?"
THE NIGHT WOUND down with a few more drinks and some awkward small talk, but eventually, the exhaustion of the first day hit. The villa felt massive and glowing, but as you retreated to the dressing room to wash off the day, the silence felt heavy.
You were standing at the mirror, scrubbing off your makeup, when the door creaked open. You expected Sarah or Kiara, but when you looked in the reflection, you saw the buzzcut and those piercing eyes. Rafe leaned against the doorframe, hands in the pockets of his pajama pants.
"Long day?" he asked. His voice was deeper than earlier, a bit raspy.
"You could say that," you murmured, reaching for a towel and wiping the water from your face. "I think I've met about ten people and kissed five of them. My brain is fried."
Rafe stepped closer as you hung the towel up, invading your personal space in a way that made your heart do a frantic little dance against your ribs. He smelled like expensive cologne and the ocean. "Only one of those kisses mattered, though.” He drawled, looking you up and down. “Right?"
You turned around, leaning your back against the cool marble of the sink. "You're pretty confident for a guy who’s supposedly 'happy' in his couple.” You challenged, quirking a brow. “Ruthie seems to think you’re pretty set on her."
Rafe let out a dry chuckle, stepping even closer until he was inches away. He reached out, his thumb catching a stray bit of damp hair stuck to your temple. "Ruthie is... a lot. And for the record? I didn't pick her. She picked me.” He assured, a soft smile on his lips. “Don't believe everything you hear in this place."
"So…you're telling me you're not interested?" you challenged once more, looking up at him.
"I'm telling you," he whispered, his eyes dropping to your lips for a lingering second before snapping back to yours, "that I haven't been able to think about anyone else since I took that blindfold off.” He rasped, the air growing thick as you noted the lack of space between you. “You've got this way of looking at me like you already know all my secrets. It's frustrating."
You shrugged. "Maybe I do," you teased, your voice barely a whisper.
He smirked, that dangerous look returning. "Then you know you should probably stay away from me.” He said, a hard look in his eyes. “But I really hope you don't."
He lingered for a second too long, the tension thick enough to cut with a knife, before he winked and headed toward the bedroom. You stood there for a full minute, heart hammering, trying to remember how to breathe.
And as the lights dimmed in the bedroom later, you climbed into your temporary bed next to JJ. Across the room, you saw Rafe settling in next to a very clingy Ruthie. Just before the last light clicked off, he turned his head. In the shadows, your eyes met.
THE MORNING SUN hit the villa with a vengeance. The makeup room was a blur of hairspray, bronzer, and whispered gossip. You were sitting in a chair next to Sarah, who was aggressively blending her concealer.
"So," Sarah whispered, leaning in. "I saw him follow you into the bathroom last night. Spill."
Your eyes went wide before you looked around the room, the other girls occupied as you bit your lip, trying to suppress a smile. "He basically said he’s not into Ruthie. He said he didn't even choose her, they just ended up together."
Sarah squealed quietly. "I knew it! He couldn’t stop looking at you, girl.If he’s into you, he’s into you. You should definitely explore it. Don't let Ruthie scare you off. She’s just territorial because she knows her spot is shaky."
"I just,” you sighed. “I don't want to be the villain," you admitted, applying some lip gloss.
"Honey, it's Love Island," Sarah laughed. "Everyone is the villain to someone. Go get your man." She nudged your shoulder.
You took her advice to heart. The rest of the afternoon was spent "mingling." You talked to Topper about his gym routine (boring, but he was nice enough), chatted with John B about surfing (he was definitely more Sarah's speed), and had a long talk with Kiara about how stressed she was feeling.
During a quiet moment by the pool with JJ, both of your phones let out that iconic tri-tone chime.
"Yo! I got a text!" JJ and yourself shouted in unison, jumping up. "JJ and Y/N, as our bombshells, it’s time to see if the grass is greener. You each have one minute to pick one Islander you're most drawn to for a private getaway in the Hideaway. #DoubleDate #HideawayHoneymoon"
Everyone went silent. You didn't even have to think.
"I'm picking Cleo," JJ said immediately, grinning at her. Pope looked like he’d just swallowed a lemon whole.
"And I pick... Rafe," you said, your voice steady despite the daggers Ruthie was throwing at you from the sun lounger.
Confessional : Pope
"I mean, JJ picking Cleo? It’s whatever. We’re just a couple of days in. But I can't lie, it stings a bit. Especially since I’m still sitting here feeling like a total jerk for kissing Kie during the challenge. I’m in the doghouse with myself, and now my partner is headed to the Hideaway with the guy who looks like a literal Abercrombie model.” He face palms. “Great."
Confessional : Ruthie
"She is so desperate. It’s actually embarrassing to watch. She’s gunning for Rafe because she thinks he’s the 'safe' option to stay in the villa, but she doesn't realize he’s just playing along to be nice. She’s clearly jealous of what I have with him. She can have her little hour in the Hideaway. He’ll be back in my bed tonight, guaranteed."
THE HIDEAWAY was everything you'd expect—plush furs, neon signs, and an oversized bed. There were two separate areas set up for the two couples. You and Rafe sat across from each other on a velvet sofa, a deck of cards between you.
"‘The Deep Dive’ game," Rafe read the box, a smirk playing on his lips. "You ready for this? I don't exactly play fair."
"I’m a psych major, Rafe. I literally study people for a living. Good luck," you countered, plucking the first card. "What do you think people would say is your biggest red flag?"
Rafe leaned back, watching you. "I'll go first.” He shrugged “I have a…temper. Or used to. I’m workin’ on it. And I tend to get obsessed with things—or people—pretty fast.” He edged, eyes glued to you. “Your turn."
You shifted, getting comfortable. "I overanalyze everything," you admitted. "I'll spend three hours wondering why you texted ‘gm’ instead of ‘good morning gorgeous’.'"
As the game went on, the walls started to come down. You talked about your pasts—Rafe’s pressure from his family, your desire to find someone who actually sees you and not just the version of you they want.
Then, the questions got… spicier.
"What’s the most adventurous place you’ve ever done it?"
Rafe’s eyes darkened, leaning in close, laughing lowly. "On a boat. Middle of the marsh. No one for miles. You?"
You pretended to think, feeling the warmth in your cheeks. "...A library," you whispered, the proximity making your skin tingle. "The 'History' section was too quiet for my liking, I guess."
He laughed, a genuine, warm sound. His laughter brought a shy smile to your face as you plucked a piece of chocolate from the small snack tray on the table, placing it on your tongue as Rafe leaned back, studying you with a smirk. "...I think I like you, angel.” He said softly. “And I’m not jus’ sayin’ that for the cameras."
You huffed a small laugh, chewing the piece of chocolate before looking at him through your lashes. “I think I like you too, Cameron.” The two of you stared at one another before deciding to look for another game, pulling a new deck of cards from under the table. “Truth or Dare,” you hummed, playing with the cards in your hands. “You up for it, Cameron?”
MEANWHILE, back in the main villa, the atmosphere was a lot less romantic. The remaining Islanders were gathered around the fire pit, the conversation turning to the "Kiss and Tell" challenge.
"Come on, we’re all friends here," Topper said, nudging the group. "Who actually kissed someone else?"
"I didn't," Ruthie said flatly, eyes fixed on the Hideaway door. "I stayed loyal to Rafe." She lied effortlessly.
"I didn't either," Topper added, looking Sarah right in the eye. No shame.
"Me neither," John B shrugged, looking as cool as a cucumber as he kicked his feet up.
The silence stretched until Pope sighed, rubbing the back of his neck. "I did.” He said, voice barely above a whisper. “I…kissed Kiara."
The group erupted. Sarah gasped, and Kiara looked like she wanted the ground to swallow her whole.
"Wait, what?" Sarah asked, looking between them.
"That…that was you?" Kiara stammered, her face turning bright red.
"I just wanted to be honest," Pope muttered, looking crushed. “I know I’m with Cleo but I just…”
Kiara stood up, her eyes watery. "I need... I just need a minute. This is a lot."
She hurried off the bedrooms and Pope started to stand up, but John B put a hand on his shoulder. "Give her space, man. Let her breathe."
Confessional : Kiara
“I think Pope’s a great guy and he’s definitely an option, but,” She sighed, running a hand through her curls. “I know that Cleo is really into him. This is a shit-show…”
IT WAS NEARLY 2:00 AM when you got the text telling you all that the Hideaway date was finally over and doors opened. You and Cleo walked out first, whispering and giggling about the night.
"I'm telling you, JJ is a menace," Cleo laughed, though she looked like she’d had the time of her life. “He’s funny, definitely a character. But I’m not sure he’s my type like that, you know?”
"Yeah, trust me, I get it.” You assured, keeping your voice low. “Rafe is... he's actually deep," you told her, smiling. "I didn't expect to connect with him like that…"
Behind you, Rafe and JJ were walking together, talking in low tones. "She's different, man," you heard Rafe tell JJ. "I’m not just talking about her looks. She actually listens, she’s funny, her personality is great."
His words brought a small smile to your face, one Cleo noticed as she nudged your shoulder with a smirk.
As you entered the bedroom, a few of the boys whooped and cheered. "Y’all are back! How was it?" Topper shouted as everyone walked to gather around the four of you.
But the mood was quickly killed when Ruthie stood up, marching right into your personal space, her face contorted with rage.
"Having fun, are we?" she spat. "You know, there are four other guys in here. But you had to pick the one who was already in a stable couple.” She hissed. “You have it out for me, don't you?"
“Hey—” Rafe intervened, putting an arm between you two.
But you didn't flinch. You just looked her up and down, keeping your voice calm and level. "Ruthie, if you're upset about the date, that sounds like a conversation you need to have with Rafe.” You clapped back. “He’s right here.” You looked up at him before narrowing your eyes back on her. “...Or maybe you're just upset because he didn't seem to miss you that much."
The ‘oohs’ from the rest of the group were audible.
She scoffed, taking a step back. "I'm the only one here with any respect." Ruthie yelled.
"Actually," you said, leaning in with a snarky grin, "you're the only one here making a scene. And for what it's worth? Rafe had a very good time.” You snarked with a cocky smile. “You should ask him about dare number three."
Ruthie stood there fuming with her nostrils flared before stomping off.
Rafe stepping in front of you, sighing as he ran a hand down his face. “I am so sorry about that shit. I know she’s not my actual girlfriend or anything, Thank God, but—”
“It’s not your fault, Rafe.” You chuckled, running a hand down his arm. “I’ve dealt with girls like Ruthie my entire life. I’m fine. Trust me.”
Suddenly, Kiara emerged into the bedroom and signaled Cleo, no one even noticing her absence. The pair walked off into the corner, their faces grim.
The entire room went dead silent as everyone watched them—you, Rafe, and JJ standing confused.
"...What happened while we were gone?" you asked, sensing the shift in energy.
“Kiss and Tell challenge, man…” Was all Topper offered, heading into the bathroom.
A few minutes later, Cleo and Kiara returned. Kiara was wiping her eyes, and Cleo looked furious. Cleo walked straight up to Pope, grabbed his arm, and pulled him outside. When they came back in five minutes later, the silence was deafening. They weren't looking at each other, and Pope looked like he’d seen a ghost.
The bedroom atmosphere was tense and awkward. And since you and JJ were the bombshells and didn't have official couples yet, you were assigned the spare bed in the corner.
As you climbed in, JJ’s lanky legs immediately tangled with yours. "Uh-uh. Watch the toes, JJ!" you joked loudly, trying to break the tension.
The room erupted in laughter, the first bit of relief in the last few minutes.
Across the room, Ruthie returned from wherever she’d stormed off to and tried to crawl into bed next to Rafe, throwing her arm over his chest. Rafe didn't even look at her. He stayed stiff as a board for about ten minutes before he sighed deeply and abruptly sat up, shoved his feet into his slippers, and walked out of the room without a word.
Ruthie let out a frustrated groan and rolled over, pretending to sleep.
You lay there, staring at the ceiling after watching him leave. Not able to sleep as your mind clouded with thoughts of him—the kiss, the bathroom, the hideaway. He was all consuming.
After a few beats, you quietly slid out from JJ’s side and crept out of the room.
The outdoor area was bathed in blue moonlight and in the large woven hammock in the center of the garden, was Rafe. He was wrapped in a thick blanket, staring up at the stars.
You walked over slowly, your feet bare on the cool grass as you stood before him, your frame casting a shadow over his frame. “Hey, Cameron,” you whispered, poking him. "Need some company?"
Rafe looked over, his expression softening instantly when he realized it was you. He didn't say anything. He just reached out, lifted the edge of the heavy wool blanket, and held it open for you.
You climbed in, the hammock swaying gently as you settled against his chest as he wrapped the blanket tightly around both of you, his chin resting on the top of your head as the villa finally went quiet around you.
rafe getting angry over you talking with some dude in a bar and ignoring you :<
the bar is loud, packed, bodies pressed too close together, but all you can focus on is rafe. or — trying to focus on rafe.
because he won’t even look at you.
you spot him across the room, leaning against the bar like always, drink in hand — but the second your eyes land on him, you know something’s off.
he’s seen you.
you know he has. but he looks right past you, like you’re not even there.
at first, you frown. confused. then a little annoyed. so you try again. you walk over, stopping just beside him. “rafe?”
nothing. he takes a slow sip of his drink, eyes fixed ahead, completely ignoring you.
your chest tightens. “rafe,” you try again, softer this time.
still nothing.
you shift closer, nudging his arm slightly. “hey — what’s your problem?”
he exhales through his nose, slow, like you’re the one bothering him. finally, he glances at you. just for a second.
flat. unreadable. then looks away again. that hurts more than it should.
“seriously?” you mutter. “you’re just gonna ignore me?”
no response. you swallow, frustration mixing with something a little more desperate now, stepping in front of him so he has to look at you.
“rafe, look at me.”
his jaw tightens. he looks at you, finally. but there’s something sharp in his eyes.
“what?” he says, low.
you blink, thrown off by the tone. “what do you mean what? you’ve been ignoring me —”
he lets out a quiet scoff, shaking his head slightly. “funny.”
“what?”
he tilts his head, eyes narrowing just a fraction.
“you didn’t seem to have a problem ignoring me five minutes ago.”
oh. your stomach drops slightly. “i wasn’t—”
“you were,” he cuts in, calm but edged. “standing over there, laughing with some random guy like i wasn’t even in the room.”
you hesitate. “i didn’t see you.”
“yeah,” he says flatly. “that’s kind of the point.”
there’s a beat, and suddenly the tension makes sense.
“so you’re ignoring me back?” you ask, a little incredulous.
he shrugs, taking another sip of his drink. “thought i’d see how you like it.”
your chest tightens properly this time. “rafe, that’s not the same —”
he doesn’t answer. just looks away again like he’s done with the conversation.
that gets to you. you step closer, voice dropping, softer now, almost pleading. “rafe, come on. don’t do that.”
no response. you reach for his arm, fingers curling lightly around his sleeve. “i’m talking to you.”
he still doesn’t look.
“please.”
that does it. his shoulders shift slightly, like something in him gives, just a fraction. a quiet sigh leaves him, heavier this time, like he’s been holding it in.
then he finally turns his head, looking down at you properly.
“you’re annoying, you know that?” he mutters, but there’s less bite in it now.
you don’t let go of his arm. “you started it.”
he huffs, running a hand through his hair, frustration still there but dulled now, replaced with something else.
something softer.
“you didn’t even look at me,” he says, quieter this time.
your grip tightens slightly. “i told you, i didn’t see you.”
he studies your face for a second, like he’s trying to decide if he believes you. then his gaze drops briefly to your hand on his arm. “yeah,” he mutters.
there’s a pause. then his hand comes up, settling low on your back, pulling you just a little closer like it’s instinct, like he can’t not.
“just — don’t pull that shit again,” he says under his breath.
you nod slightly. “then don’t ignore me.”
a small, almost reluctant smirk tugs at his mouth.
rafe hadn't stopped giving you kisses since he showed up at your apartment earlier that evening.
it started out with soft pecks all over your face that left you in giggles, and soon turned into a full blown makeout session that rafe wasn't going to stop any time soon.
you had somehow managed to free yourself, coming up for a gasp of some much needed air time. rafe would keep this up all night if he could, so this was your only chance.
"raaafe, i almost died from all the breath you were stealing from me there" you fake pouted, while actually trying to catch your breath at the same time.
"shit, sorry baby. you just look cute as fuck in these" he says, running his fingers over the fabric of your nightwear with a love-drunk look on his face.
they were a matching set with white and red hearts scattered all over the cotton material, and you had originally picked them because they were comfy looking.
a cheesy grin spread across your face at his swift approval of your chosen nightwear.
rafe always seemed like he would only be into scraps of lace, so your heart warmed over the fact he liked seeing you in something simple.
"i'm going to make some tea, want some?" you murmured as you started grabbing everything you needed, a smile still lingering on your lips.
you squealed as he suddenly wrapped his arms around you from behind, placing gentle kisses across the exposed area on your neck.
"can't keep my hands off you, so you're gonna have to make it like this because i'm not fuckin' moving" rafe says, words muffled by the kisses he was still attacking you with.
Heyy idk if you’ve seen the pheromone perfume prank on TikTok but it’s basically a perfume that makes your partner super attracted to you. Rafe is going out with Top and Kelce and we really don’t want him to leave so while he’s getting ready to leave after about 30 minutes of begging him to stay, we get in a cute comfy outfit like as low cut tank and some sleep shorts or smt and put on the pheromone perfume and while he’s kissing us goodbye he smells it on us and asks what that smell is and we act all oblivious. He is now hellllla turned on and has completely forgotten about his friends
"they can wait"
bf!rafe x fem reader // perfume prank
rafe is by the door grabbing his keys, already halfway out. top and kelce have been blowing up his phone telling him to hurry up. you’ve spent the last thirty minutes half begging, half teasing him to stay.
"come on, just one night," you say, leaning against the doorway with a little pout. "they’ll survive without you."
he laughs, shaking his head while slipping his jacket on. "nice try. i already told them i’d go."
you disappear for a minute, then come back out in a cute comfy outfit — soft sleep shorts and a low-cut tank, hair a little messy like you’re settling in for the night. you’d sprayed on your favorite perfume earlier, something warm and sweet that lingers just a little in the air.
rafe glances over while he’s checking his phone.
and just stops.
"what?" you ask, pretending not to notice the way he’s suddenly staring.
he takes a few steps closer, brow furrowing slightly like he’s trying to figure something out. “what is that smell?”
you blink innocently. “what smell?”
"that—" he leans in a little closer, catching it again. his hand finds your waist without him even thinking about it as he kisses your forehead, then sniffs like a dog. "your perfume."
you shrug lightly like it’s nothing. "just my normal one."
for a second he’s quiet, looking at you like he’s suddenly reconsidering every plan he had tonight. his phone buzzes again with another message from top.
rafe glances at the screen . . . then slowly flips the phone face-down on the table.
"they can wait," he mutters, pulling you a little closer like he’s already forgotten he was about to leave before yanking the both of you onto his bed.
authors note: so sorry for postponing this late because i got carried away with other stuff but heres the part two !! part one is here
warnings: none !!
you woke up the next morning to puffy eyes.
the rest of last night was a blurr. you remembered muttering something incoherently to the blurred faces of your concerned parents before collapsing onto your bed. but what happened last night rings in your head, clear as day.
you and rafe were over.
you took a shower. brushed your teeth. did anything except think about him. journalled and roll over on your bed and stretch. anything but touch your phone that was set down under your bed that you didnt switch off but can still hear notifications coming through.
hearing another call go through before going straight to your voicemail, you sighed and gave in to the urge, reaching under your bed and grabbing your phone.
there were over 100+ notifications from rafe, his name still unchanged:
rafe ❤️: baby im so sorry
rafe ❤️: y/n
rafe ❤️: please forgive me
rafe ❤️: i was drunk y/n
rafe ❤️: i wasnt thinking
rafe ❤️: please im so sorry i screwed up
rafe ❤️: give me one chance
you inhaled loudly, running a hand down your face before chucking it across your duvet and burrowing your head into your pillow. while you know he is sorry - because rafe cameron almost never apologised - what he said still stings.
school tomorrow is going to suck.
when you get there, unsurprisngly, you saw rafe waiting by the school entrance, flowers in his hands, massive arms folded. you got out of kiara, who offered to give you a lift, car. you cant stop your eyes meeting his baby blue ones that widen and soften when he saw you, taking a step forward.
he beegan to walk after you, eyes earnest like a puppy. but the cruelty of his words slapped you back to the present. kie saw this and exchanged a look with you before you go the longer route into school, or namely the one that doesnt involve you having to talk to him at the moment.
"y/n." you turned, seeing rafe jogg up to you.
well, shit. you know it was gonna happen now. trying not to, you speed up your pace and attempted to ignore him, but he gripped your wrist so gently you cant help but stop. "y/n, please."
you yanked your arm till he dropped his grip, turning around and seeing in your surroundings now that it wasjust you two. "fuck off."
"y/n. i was drunk and i am so, so -"
"dont say youre sorry." you snapped sharply. he didnt seem to hear you.
"baby, give me two minutes." he pleaded.
you crossed your arms in response, shifting your weight. the wind blew your hair into your face and he inhaled.
"i was drunk, okay? and i didnt mean any of it. you arent like your father. youre the most beautiful person ive ever met, inside and out, and you dont compare to that piece of shit. im not justifying what i said, but you deserve to have an explanation of why i keep drinking. i drink because it shuts everything up,” he continued, voice rough. “my head, my dad, everything. when i’m sober it’s like -" he let out a short laugh that held no humor. “it’s like i can hear every mistake i’ve ever made.”
you had looked at him then, really looked. his eyes were red, not just from last night. from not sleeping.
“that doesn’t give you the right to say that to me,” you said quietly.
his face fell immediately. “i know.”
“you compared me to my dad, rafe.” the words came out steadier than you felt. “do you know how fucked that is?”
he nodded quickly, stepping closer but stopping himself halfway when you didn’t move. “i know. i know it is. and i hate myself for it.”
the wind had rustled through the trees lining the school path. people were starting to walk past now, but neither of you moved.
“i didn’t mean it,” he said again, softer this time. “i was angry and drunk and i took it out on you. and you didn’t deserve that. you never do.”
you had swallowed, looking away from him toward the school building.
“y/n,” he murmured. “please look at me.”
against your better judgment, you dod.
“i know saying sorry doesn’t fix it,” he continued. “but i am. i’m really fucking sorry. i’d take it back if i could. i would never want to hurt you like that.”
you had let out a slow breath. part of you wanted to scream at him again. another part of you wanted to believe him, the love of your life.
and that was the worst part. because rafe cameron almost never apologized.
yet here he was, standing in front of you with crumpled flowers in his hands and guilt written all over his face.
“i’m not asking you to forgive me right now,” he said when you stayed quiet. “just… don’t shut me out completely.”
your fingers had curled into your sleeves. you saw kiara across the green, giving you an anxious look but you nodded to her in encouragement. “i don’t know if i can just pretend it didn’t happen,” you had admitted.
“i’m not asking you to.”
he had hesitated before holding the flowers out slightly, like he wasn’t even sure he deserved to give them to you.
“i just want the chance to make it right.”
you stared at the flowers for a long moment. then back at him, swallowing.
the silence stretched between you like an elastic band on its last edges.
rafe shifted where he stood, clearly fighting the urge to reach for you again. his fingers tightened around the stems, knuckles pale.
“say something,” he muttered quietly.
you exhaled through your nose, looking down at the ground before meeting his eyes again. "you really fucked up."
"i know."
"like… badly."
"yeah," he nodded quickly. "i know."
another pause.
his eyes searched your face like he was trying to read every thought passing through your head. like he was bracing for the moment you told him to get lost for good.
you rubbed a hand over your face. "you compared me to my dad, rafe.”
his jaw clenched again. "i know."
"that’s not something you just say."
"i know," he repeated, voice rougher now. "and i hate that i said it."
you studied him. really studied him.
he looked wrecked. dark circles under his eyes, hair messy like he’d been running his hands through it all morning, shoulders tense.
rafe cameron looked nervous. that alone almost made you laugh because in your relationship your boyfriend was for from that.
"you’ve been blowing up my phone all morning." you said.
"all night," he corrected quietly.
you raised a brow.
"i didn’t sleep," he admitted. "i thought if i stopped calling you’d think i gave up."
you sighed, looking away again.
the anger was still there. the sting of his words still sat in your chest. but the way he was looking at you - open , desperate, completely stripped of his usual arrogance - made it harder to keep the wall up.
"you’re an idiot," you muttered.
a small breath of relief left him, like the insult alone gave him hope. "yeah."
you hesitated before finally taking the flowers from his hand.
his shoulders dropped immediately, like a weight lifted off them.
"this doesn’t mean i’m magically over it," you warned.
"i know," he said quickly.
"and you’re still on thin ice."
"that’s fair." he agreed quickly.
you looked at the flowers in your hands before glancing back up at him. "you’re gonna have to work really hard to make this up to me."
"i will," he said instantly. "whatever it takes."
you rolled your eyes slightly. "don’t say that like you’re signing a contract."
"i’m serious."
you knew he was. another moment passed before you stepped a little closer to him. not much. just enough that the distance didn’t feel like a canyon anymore.
rafe looked down at you carefully, like you might bolt if he moved too fast.
"can i hug you?" he asked quietly.
you hesitated. "fine. but if you say anything stupid again i’m kneeing you."
"understood."
the second you stepped into him, his arms wrapped around you like he’d been holding himself back for hours. his face buried into your hair as he let out a shaky breath.
"i’m really sorry,”"he murmured against your head.
you closed your eyes, letting yourself relax into him for a moment.
"i know."
his arms tightened slightly, like he was afraid you’d disappear if he let go.
after a second you pulled back, pointing a finger at his chest. "don’t make me regret forgiving you."
"never," he said quickly.
you narrowed your eyes. “that sounded suspiciously confident.”
"because i’m gonna behave."
"you?" you snorted.
he smiled a little then - the first real one since you’d walked up.
"yeah," he said. "for you."
you shook your head, but a small smile slipped out anyway.
"come on," you muttered, starting toward the school building.
he fell into step beside you immediately, careful not to touch you unless you reached for him first.
which you did.
just briefly.
your fingers brushed his hand before lacing with it. and the relieved look on rafe’s face was almost embarrassing.
but you knew you two were going to make up. no matter what happened, the pair of you would always find each other again.
you knew it was inevitable when you guys started dating. but when he had came up to your doorstep with flowers and that smile you couldnt ever resist the day he asked you out, it was the furthest thing from your mind that you had to deal with it.
but tonight was the last straw.
you two had attended toppers party together by figure eight. but within minutes, just as you announced to your boyfriend that you needed to pee, his pupils blew wide and he mumbled something about finding kelce before walking off.
hoping he'd find you, you stayed in the area and talked to kiara, who you hadnt seen in ages. "hey, kie."
her eyebrows shot up in a pleasant surprise when she saw you, "oh hey y/n, long time no see!"
"how are you?"
"good, good." she grinned, "hows you and rafe?"
the truth? horrible. last night you found him sniffing a line despite your argument with him an hour before where he then promised to stop doing drugs. instead, you just plastered on a fake smile. "fine."
"okay, well," she looked over her shoulder, "we havent hung out in ages. the whole group misses you." the unspoken problem being rafe hung in the air before she cleared her throat. "see you around."
"see you." you echoed, then turned to go find rafe.
inside, the smell of whiskey hit before you even saw him. turning left, you saw rafe slouched against the corner while laughing with kelce, a half-empty bottle glinting under the kitchen light. for a second, you dont do anything, just watch rafe — it’s like watching someone you love drown slow.
“rafe.” your voice cut through the chatter. he turned and for a moment, you saw the spark of recognition, the man you fell for, behind the fog of alcohol.
kelce looked over his shoulder, and even though he was drunk there was no mistaking the annoyance in your gaze. saying something under his brewath, he excused himself, leaivng you to talk to rafe alone.
"hey, baby," rafe said, turning, ready to curl his arm around your waist. but you shove him off, and you already feel the tears coming. "hey whats wrong?"
"you said last night that youd stop. you know how much i hate it when you drink." you said, but you hated how much it sounded like you was whining. youd already told him so many times why you hated when anyone drank — because it reminded you of your father.
"yeah sorry." rafe said, trying to rest his forehead against yours. under any other circumstances, youd sigh and lean yours back, but you just about had enough.
"baby," he whined as you had to bite your bottom lip from crying. "its not that big of a deal."
"you think it’s not that big of a deal that you promised me you’d stop, that you’d try, and now i find you drunk, laughing like it’s nothing?!”
rafe flinched, but you could tell he wouldnt even remember the whole conversation when he woke up tomorrow. "i said i’d try. come on, y/n, it’s just—”
"no, rafe. im not doing this anymore with you."
"you'll come back anyways," he mumbled under his breath into the cup.
you paused in your tracks, and he swallowed when he noticed. rafe loved you — he really, truly, did, but his temper always got the best of him. he was exactly like his father like that.
"what?" you hissed, noticing several people now watching the interaction.
"you always talk about," he gulped the rest of the whiskey down, slamming it onto the counter, "leaving me, but we all know you cant."
"really?" hurt swelled in your chest. "well, guess what. we're over."
several gasps rung out on the eavesdropping crowd. you and rafe were known for being in love, for being the ultimate power couple and here the pair was, breaking up infront of half of the kooks eyes.
something flared in his eyes. "like fuck we are."
you didn't deign a reply and instead turned for the door. within seconds, rafe yanked you back so hard you nearly felt your arm break as you twisted into his chest.
"ow, rafe, that hurt!"
he didn't acknowledge that. "we're not over."
"and doing that makes it better for you?" you snapped. "we are over. dont talk to me again."
"no." now the pleading was in his tone. "no, y/n —"
"i can't do this!" you shouted, yanking his grip off you. "ive told you my reasons why and yet you still ignore all of them. ive given you excuse after excuse," your voice cracked and you could feel the tears now burning your eyes, the ones you refused to fall, "and ive let you prove yourself, but that whole —"
"get the fuck over it." he deadpanned, "how do you think it is for me?"
"how can you make this about yourself right now?"
"did you ever ask me why i drink?" he retorted, running his hand through his curtain bangs. "or how —"
"and did you ever tell me?"
"you never asked!" he shouted, so loudly you jerked slightly. seeing the motion, rafe stepped closer, hand coming to brush your shoulder to which you shook it off.
"no." you said simply. "we're over."
hurt that you were leaving him — his girlfriend of two years — but also his brain being slightly foggy, he shook his head, "fuck you. dont say i didnt warn you when you come back crawling to me."
jaw open, you wouldnt let him get the last hit, "yeah and you wont because youre exactly like your father. arrogant bastard."
he spun around so quickly you reeled backwards. "oh yeah? what about yours? quite the pair we were, huh?"
you felt the tears run down your cheeks before you ran out the house. you hated that you hurted him.
but little did you know that he had hated how he'd made you flinch. he'd scared you. and that was quite possibly the worst thing he'd ever done.
cw: first fluffy chapter in a while sooo I don't think there's any. I could be wrong though.
a/n: sorry for waiting until the end of the month to update I had some things to deal with. But I'm back and hopefully better.
part twenty
It’s been two months.
Two months since your trip to New York. Two months since Rafe stormed into your house, demanded to go through your phone, shattered it against the hallway floor- and then shattered himself right after, crying and begging for forgiveness. You didn’t let him back into your life the way he wanted, not fully. But you forgave him. You had to. For your own peace. For the baby growing quietly inside you.
The wind whips through your hair as you angrily type on your brand-new phone from the passenger seat of Becca’s new convertible, the sun beating down and the OBX air thick with salt and heat. The two of you had just left prenatal yoga -prenatal- somehow Becca had managed to slip in wearing a fake belly she bought off Amazon, stretched under a tank top like she belonged there. No one questioned it. You tried not to laugh throughout the entire class.
“I don’t understand why you won’t just go,” Becca says now, cutting the wheel sharply and unapologetically hopping the curb. You brace yourself, grabbing the side of the seat. Becca has never been a good driver, and somehow you always forget that until you’re already in the car with her.
You sigh, locking your phone and staring out at the blur of houses passing by. You’re being stubborn, you know that. Anyone with half a brain could see it. You and Rafe had talked. Slowly. Carefully. You’d smoothed over the worst of it. You’d even agreed to try being friends. But standing in Tannyhill again? Walking up to his door like nothing ever happened? You weren’t sure you were ready for that.
“I don’t think it’s necessary to go over to his house just to get my mail,” you say, crossing your arms. “What if he was a complete stranger and stole my package because it got delivered to the wrong address? USPS wouldn’t know that. They should just send me a new one.” You know it doesn’t make sense. You know the logic falls apart if anyone thinks about it for more than five seconds. But you say it anyway.
Becca deadpans. “Yeah. Totally their fault because you forgot to change the shipping address. Horrible customer service.”
“Shut up,” you mutter, rolling your eyes, still searching for literally any solution that doesn’t involve Rafe Cameron’s front porch.
“Just go get it,” she says. “I’ll come with you. Hell, we could swing by right now.”
You shake your head, then pause. “He’s out with Topper and Kelce right now,” you blurt, before you can stop yourself.
Becca glances at you. “Ew,” she says immediately. “I hate that you know that.”
“Ew,” you reply, laughing despite yourself. “So do I.”
She pulls into her driveway, the tires crunching over gravel. Your eyes immediately snag on the unfamiliar car parked behind your own- nice, sleek, very obviously rented.
“What the f-” Becca cuts herself off, exhaling slowly. Her anger management classes are clearly working.
You squint at the car as you both unbuckle and step out. Beau is still living with Becca- something about the business guy being tied up with other responsibilities and not being able to follow through on their little deal yet. You and Becca had both clocked it as suspicious, but neither of you had said anything.
“Beau probably just has someone over,” you say, shrugging as you climb the steps to the porch, trying to ignore the small, unfamiliar knot forming in your stomach. You reach for the door anyway.
The smell of pizza and wings hits you immediately when the door opens, warm and greasy and familiar. The baby gives a faint kick in response, like they smell it too. You instinctively rest a hand over your belly as you step inside.
Becca follows behind you, and your eyes drift toward the living room out of habit- and then you freeze for a second when you see him. The cute guy from New York.
Your heart does an annoying little leap before you can stop it. Immediately, you become hyper-aware of yourself- the post-yoga sweat clinging to your skin, your flushed cheeks, your hair pulled into a messy bun that gave up halfway through class. Of course today is the day you wore an oversized T-shirt and mismatched athletic shorts instead of one of the cute sets Becca convinced you to buy.
Jessie. That was his name.He’s sitting on the couch, a pizza box open on the coffee table, looking slightly caught off guard by your sudden entrance. Which would make sense- Beau probably didn’t bother to mention he was temporarily living with his sister. That felt very Beau.
Becca pauses just behind you, equally surprised. “Oh—hi?” she says.
Jessie stands quickly, wiping his hands on his pants as he walks toward you both, polite and a little unsure. He extends his hand. Becca shakes it first, then you do.
“Nice to see you ladies again,” he says.
His handshake is firm but you return it politely anyway.
“You as well,” you say with a small smile.
He turns back to Becca, then pauses when he notices the rounded shape under her shirt. His eyes flick briefly between her stomach and yours, clearly trying to process what he’s seeing.
“No, this was not here when we met,” Becca says immediately.
Jessie lets out a quiet, confused laugh.
“Why are you walking around with a fake belly again?” Beau calls from the couch, talking with his mouth full of pizza like a complete animal.
“I couldn’t sit in y/n’s prenatal yoga class without having something to show for it,” Becca says, already marching toward the coffee table. “Give me some pizza.”
She grabs a slice without hesitation, then turns to you and makes an exaggerated, high-pitched noise, silently asking if you want one too.
You hesitate, shifting your weight. “Actually… I’m gonna head out,” you say. “I need to figure out this package situation.”
Becca nods, already chewing. “Okay, love you.”
“Love you too,” you reply, smiling.
You turn back to Jessie. “Can you let me out? My car’s trapped.”
“Yeah- of course,” he says immediately.
You step back outside, grabbing your bag from Becca’s convertible before sliding into your own car. Jessie jogs over to move his rental, backing it out of the driveway so you can leave.
For a second, you watch him through the windshield- calm, polite, easy in a way that doesn’t demand anything from you. He gives you a small nod once the driveway is clear.
You lift your hand in thanks and pull out, heading back toward your house, the late afternoon sun stretching long shadows across the road.
You get home and head straight for your bedroom, dropping your bag and keys onto the floor without thinking. The quiet of the house settles around you like a heavy blanket. Your muscles feel tight, your skin sticky from yoga and the long day, and suddenly a shower feels less like a want and more like a necessity. You undress quickly and step under the hot water, letting it run over your shoulders and down your back. For a few minutes, you just stand there, eyes closed, breathing. Letting the steam soften the edges of the day. Letting your mind go blank.
When you finally step out, wrapping yourself in a towel, you feel lighter. You move through the rest of your routine on autopilot- lotion, coconut oil worked into your skin, undergarments, brushing through your hair slowly to avoid pulling. You stare at your reflection for a moment, noticing the subtle but undeniable changes in your body. The roundness of your stomach. The softness in your face. Then you dress. A once-perfect fitted graphic T-shirt that now sits like a baby tee over your belly, paired with jorts you never imagined yourself wearing until pregnancy comfort overruled personal style. After slicking your hair back into a bun, you add small touches of jewelry -earrings, rings, bracelets, a necklace- just enough to feel like yourself again.
Keys. Phone. Wallet. Post office. You get in your car and start driving.
The roads are familiar, quiet in the late afternoon. Your mind drifts somewhere between nothing and everything- Jessie in Becca’s living room, Owen’s steady voice in the coffee shop, the baby kicking at the smell of pizza, the conversation with Rafe two months ago.
You’re halfway there before you realize you’re not going to the post office. Your hands turn the wheel before your brain catches up. That turn. The one that has never led to anything simple. Before you can stop yourself, autopilot carries you all the way to Tannyhill.
You bite your lip as you pull into the driveway, nerves buzzing in your chest. The package was delivered days ago- obviously it isn’t still sitting on the porch. You don’t even know why you’re nervous. You’re just grabbing something and leaving. That’s all.
You cut the engine and sit there for a moment, staring at the house. Then you climb out and walk up the steps to the porch. You’re not staying. Just leaving a message on the camera.
You press the doorbell. The ring lights up. “Hey, Rafe. Um… you’re probably not home, but I accidentally had a package delivered here and I kind of need it soon. So if you can just… reach out when you have time to-”
The door swings open. Rafe stands there in a black T-shirt, chest rising and falling like he ran to the door. His hair is slightly grown out a little, his expression caught between surprise and relief.
“Oh- hey. I didn’t know you were here,” you say quickly, pointing toward the Ring camera. “I was just leaving a message.”
“It’s fine. Come in.” He steps aside.
“Actually, I just-”
“No, I insist.” His voice is soft. Tired. Not demanding like before.
After a small pause, you step inside.
The house smells clean -lemons and fresh cleaning supplies- like he’s been trying to keep busy. You step to the side so he can close the door behind you. He lingers there for a second, hand still on the doorknob, eyes closed as he pinches the bridge of his nose like he’s fighting off a headache.
You couldn’t lie- he looked really good right now. Softer somehow. Worn down in a way that made him seem more human than untouchable.
“You were, uh… leaving a message?” he asks, still standing there, voice slightly distant.
Your brows knit together instinctively. You almost ask if he’s okay. Almost. Instead, you answer.
“Yeah… I forgot to change my delivery address on Amazon to my place. My package got sent here instead.” Your hand rests automatically over your belly as you speak.
His eyes open, immediately drawn to the gesture. Then they shift around the house as he thinks.
“Oh…” he says, letting out a small laugh, eyes closing again for a second. It’s nice hearing that sound. After everything, it feels unfamiliar in the best way.
“Oh?” you reply, one eyebrow lifting.
“The crib?” he asks, blue eyes finding yours again.
You nod slowly. “Yeah… how did you know I ordered a crib?” You put a hand on your hip, pretending to scold him.
“I opened it. Come on.” He jerks his head toward the stairs and starts walking.
You scoff, but you follow. “You realize opening someone else’s mail is illegal, right?”
He glances back with a faint smirk. “You gonna press charges?” He knows you won’t. That’s the annoying part.
“I could,” you counter, climbing the stairs behind him, slower than you’d like to be. Your breathing gets heavier by the time you reach the top.
He turns to wait for you. “I could’ve carried you, y’know,” he says with a quiet chuckle.
“I’d rather not,” you reply seriously.
He doesn’t push it. Instead, he walks toward the room that was supposed to be the nursery.
“It’s in here,” he says, pushing the door open before scratching the back of his head.
You step inside. The room looks almost exactly like it did the last time you were here- the night everything fell apart. Same walls. Same everything. But not quite the same.
There’s a small blue stuffed animal sitting carefully on the mattress of the crib frame. The crib frame you bought. Your eyes slowly move from it to him.
“Rafe,” you say calmly, turning toward him with a tight, polite smile.
“Mhmm?” he replies, completely clueless, eyebrows raised with that innocent expression you used to love.
“Why is my crib frame… built?”
“Oh.” He walks into the room, placing a hand on it like he’s proud. “I thought I’d build it for you. Surprise you.”
He smiles down at it before noticing your expression. His posture straightens immediately. For a second, you see the easygoing version of him again- the one who annoyed you and charmed you in equal measure. The one who made everything feel simple, even when it wasn’t.
The only thing you can do is laugh. He laughs too, confused but relieved. Then reality returns. You groan, stepping into the room beside him. “I can’t get this home in my little convertible.”
He sighs, like that detail is only just now occurring to him. “Shit,” he mutters.
“You’re gonna have to break it down,” you say, hand resting on your hip.
“I’m not touching that shit again,” he replies immediately, dropping to the floor and leaning his back against the crib.
You shake your head, smiling despite yourself, and slowly lower yourself down beside him, one hand cradling your belly. The room goes quiet for a moment. Not uncomfortable. Just… full.
Rafe glances at your stomach again, more carefully this time. “She kicking today?” he asks softly.
You nod. “Earlier. At the smell of pizza.”
A small smile tugs at his mouth. “Sounds like her mom.”
Another pause settles between you- calmer than before, but fragile.For the first time in a long time, you’re sitting next to each other without fighting, without crying, without trying to fix something already broken. Just sitting.
“So how am I supposed to get this home?” you ask, looking from the crib to him.
Rafe scratches the back of his neck, thinking. “I can rent a truck and bring it to your place,” he says. “Or… you could come by another time and I’ll help you load it into whatever you’ve got.” He shrugs, casual but careful, like he’s making sure the offer doesn’t sound like pressure.
You nod slowly, considering it.
“That… works for me,” you admit.
It’s strange- how normal this feels. Sitting on the nursery floor together, talking about logistics instead of heartbreak.
“I’ll rent the truck,” he adds quickly. “Less work for you.” You glance at him, noticing the shift. The old Rafe would’ve turned this into an argument about control or pride. This version just… solves the problem.
“Okay,” you say. “Thank you.”
The words sit between you for a moment. He looks down at the floor, fingers tracing the grain in the wood again- that nervous habit you remember so well.
“I’ve been trying,” he says quietly.
You don’t ask what he means. You already know.
“I can tell,” you reply.
And you can. It’s in the way he keeps his voice level. The way he gives you space. The way he looks at you now- not like you’re something he might lose, but something he already did.
“I started therapy,” he adds after a moment, still not looking at you. “After… everything.”
That makes you turn. “Really?”
He nods once. “Twice a week at first. Now once.”
You let out a small breath you didn’t realize you’d been holding. “That’s good, Rafe.”
He shrugs again, but this time it’s smaller. “I didn’t like the person I was becoming,” he admits. “And I didn’t like that I hurt you. Or Sarah. Or anyone.”
The honesty lands gently instead of heavily. Months ago, this conversation would’ve been impossible.
“I’ve changed too,” you say, almost to yourself.
He looks over. “Yeah?”
You nod, hand resting over your belly. “I had to. I don’t get to fall apart from just anything anymore. There’s someone depending on me now.” Your voice is steady- not sad, not resentful. Just true.
“And… I stopped waiting for you to be who I needed you to be,” you continue. “That was the hardest part.”
He swallows, nodding like he understands. “You deserved better than who I was,” he says.
You don’t argue with him. That’s new too. The late-afternoon light filters through the nursery window, stretching across the floor between you.
“She’s gonna be really loved,” Rafe says quietly, glancing at the crib.
Your throat tightens. “Yeah,” you whisper. “She is.”
Another comfortable silence settles in — the kind that used to exist between you before things got complicated.
“You remember when we argued for like two hours about crib colors?” he says suddenly.
You laugh. “You wanted black.”
“It was matte black,” he defends.
“For a babygirl,” you remind him.
“It was modern.”
You shake your head, smiling. “We’ve grown up,” you say.
He nods. “Yeah. We really have.”
For the first time, it doesn’t feel like losing each other erased everything good you ever had. It feels like those good parts just… changed shape.
Not lovers anymore. Not strangers either. Something quieter. Something steadier.
Rafe slowly pushes himself to his feet, then offers you his hands again- gentler this time, waiting.
You take them. And when he helps you up, it feels different than before. Not electric. Not painful.
Just familiar.
The walk to the front door is quiet, but not awkward- the kind of quiet that settles easily between two people who no longer feel the need to fill every space with words. Your footsteps fall in rhythm beside his, the soft creak of the wooden floor and the distant hum of the refrigerator the only sounds in the house.He reaches the door first, pulling it open for you without thinking. The late afternoon air drifts in, warm and salted from the ocean.
You turn back to him, lingering in the doorway. “Saturday work for you?” you ask.
Rafe rubs the back of his neck, leaning one shoulder against the doorframe. “Uh… I have a few clients I need to deal with, but I’ll try to clear my schedule for it.”
He says it casually, but there’s something underneath- an effort that didn’t used to be there. Once upon a time, he wouldn’t have adjusted anything for you. Now he does it without announcing it. Your feet don’t move. You stand there, fingers loosely wrapped around your keys, like you’re remembering how to leave.
There’s a small pause before you speak again. “Uh… sorry for the interruption again,” you say quietly.
He shakes his head immediately, almost too fast. “No- no. It’s okay. I was just laying down anyway.”
You nod, looking down for a second, then back up at him. The moment stretched- not uncomfortable, just unfinished.
“Well…” you say, drawing in a small breath. “I’ll see you Saturday.” Your feet finally cooperate, stepping backward onto the porch. Slowly. Like you’re giving him time to say something else if he wants to.
“Yeah…” he says, softer now. “Saturday. I’ll see you.”
You turn and walk toward your car, gravel crunching beneath your shoes. You can feel it -the weight of his gaze following you- but it doesn’t make you anxious anymore. It just feels… steady. Safe.
When you open your car door, you glance back without meaning to. He’s still standing in the doorway.
Not tense. Not guarded. Just watching. You give him a small, almost shy smile before getting in and starting the engine. Rafe stays there until your car disappears down the road, the screen door slowly swinging shut behind him with a quiet click. For the first time in a long time, the silence doesn’t feel like distance. It feels like patience.
-
Days later, you step onto the beach just past your backyard path, sandals dangling from your fingers. One of the biggest selling points of this place had been the proximity to the water- the idea that you could walk out here whenever your mind got too loud.
Today, though, the waves are loud enough for everyone. It’s a swell day. The kind surfers wait weeks for. Which means there will be no solitude. No quiet meditation. Just music, laughter, engines, and the occasional whoop from someone catching the perfect wave.
Your white midi dress sways around your calves as you settle into the sand. The sun warms your shoulders immediately. A few teens are already setting up- towels shaken out dramatically, coolers dropped, speakers blasting something bass-heavy and careless. You don’t mind. There’s something comforting about watching life happen around you. You’re halfway through absentmindedly drawing circles in the sand when you see it.
The orange and white camper van. You don’t even have to squint to know who it belongs to.
It rolls up not too far from where you’re sitting, tires crunching over loose shells. You consider moving -just to avoid awkwardness- but you don’t. You’ve done enough avoiding in your life. The van door slides open and they spill out like they always do- loud, overlapping, alive.
Pope first, already mid-sentence about something that sounds mildly educational. JJ right behind him, jumping down like gravity is optional. Cleo smooth and observant. Kiara pushing her sunglasses up into her hair. John B climbs out of the driver’s seat like he owns the sand itself. And then Sarah. She steps out of the passenger side, blonde hair catching in the wind. She’s the first to notice you.
You don’t look away this time.
You offer her a small smile, pulling your feet closer into the sand. She pauses for half a second -like she’s surprised- then smiles back. A real one. Soft. Almost relieved. She lifts her hand in a wave.
Before she can say anything, John B calls her name, gesturing to the surfboards strapped to the roof. “Babe, I need you.” She rolls her eyes affectionately and jogs over to him, and you turn your attention back to the water.
Not because you don’t like them. But because you don’t want them to feel obligated. You know what it’s like to be the outsider orbiting someone else’s center. You won’t make them shift their gravity for you.
The waves crash, blue and endless.
You’re tracing the outline of a small heart in the sand -not thinking about why- when a shadow falls over you. You squint up against the sun.
Sarah. Her hair whips across her shoulder. She’s wearing a blue plaid crop top and white shorts, barefoot already, anklet glinting.
“Hey,” she says, smiling that classic Sarah Cameron smile — the one that’s disarming and warm all at once.
You smile back instinctively. “Hey.” You dust the sand from your hands, shielding your eyes from the glare.
“Mind if I sit?” she asks, pointing to the empty space beside you.
You hesitate only because you didn’t expect it. “Not at all,” you say quickly. “Please.”
She drops down beside you, tucking one leg under herself. For a moment, it’s quiet. The kind that isn’t awkward- just new.
“How are you?” she asks, eyes on the horizon.
You think about giving her the easy answer. “I’m… okay,” you say instead. Honest. Not dramatic. Just real.
She nods like she understands more than you’re saying. “And the baby?” she asks gently, finally glancing down at your stomach.
You soften immediately. “She’s healthy.”
Sarah’s entire face lights up. “A girl?” she gasps, turning fully toward you. “Are you serious?”
You nod, laughing a little at her excitement.
“Oh my God,” she breathes. “That’s- that’s amazing.”
Her hand lifts instinctively toward your stomach, then hesitates mid-air. “Can I?”
You shake your head immediately- not no, but disbelief that she’d even question it. “Of course.” You guide her hand to your belly. Her palm is warm. Careful. Almost reverent.
She goes still. And right on cue -like she knows she has an audience- your daughter kicks. Once. Sarah’s eyes widen. Twice. She lets out a little surprised laugh. Three times.
She gasps, looking up at you like she’s just witnessed something sacred. “Oh my God,” she giggles. “She’s strong.”
You laugh with her, your hand covering hers instinctively. “She’s been like that all morning.”
Sarah keeps her hand there a second longer, her expression softening into something quieter. “She’s gonna be so loved,” she says without thinking.
It hits you harder than it should, reminding you of Rafe saying the same thing the other day. Before you can respond, you hear JJ shouting something about sunscreen and Pope arguing back about SPF levels.
“Sarah, come on!” John B calls. “We’re setting up.”
She looks back over her shoulder- then back at you. There’s a flicker of hesitation. Like she doesn’t want to just walk away.
“You don’t have to-” you start, nodding toward them.
“I’ll be right back,” she says quickly, standing. “We’re grilling later. You should hang out with us.”
You blink. “I don’t want to intrude.”
“You wouldn’t,” she says immediately. No hesitation. No politeness. Just truth. “You’re not intruding.”
There’s something intentional in the way she says it. She jogs back to them, and this time when she reaches the group, Kiara glances over at you. Then Cleo. JJ shields his eyes dramatically like he’s scouting enemy territory.
You almost roll your eyes.
A minute later, JJ jogs halfway over and calls out, “You just gonna sit there or are you eating with us later?”
You raise an eyebrow. “Is that an invitation?”
“It’s a warning,” he shouts back. “I’m cooking.”
You laugh despite yourself. “Then I probably should settle with anything you’re not cooking,” you reply.
He points at you like that’s acceptable. You sit with your knees pulled to your chest, watching them from a distance at first. The waves are good today -tall, clean, rolling in steady lines- and they take full advantage of it. John B and JJ paddle out first, shouting over the wind, while Pope and Kiara wrestle with the grill behind the van. Cleo stands near the shoreline, arms crossed, laughing every time JJ wipes out dramatically.
You don’t realize how long you’ve been watching until Sarah jogs past you again, barefoot in the sand.
“You know,” she says, slowing to a stop, hands on her hips, “it’s kind of weird that you’re sitting over here like a lifeguard instead of with us.”
You smile faintly. “I didn’t want to intrude.”
Sarah snorts. “Intrude? Please.”
Before you can protest, she reaches down and takes your wrist, tugging gently. “Come on.”
You let her pull you to your feet, brushing sand off your dress as she leads you toward the van.
JJ is the first to notice. “Well, look who finally decided to join civilization,” he says, pushing wet hair out of his face.
“She was spying on us,” Sarah announces.
“I was not spying,” you laugh.
John B immediately stands and grabs a folding chair, planting it in the sand near the grill. “Here,” he says casually. “Sit.”
You hesitate, but he’s already walking away like it’s not a big deal, so you sit. It feels… strangely easy. Like you’ve done this before.
Cleo hands you a paper plate with watermelon slices and chips without asking. “You gotta eat,” she says. “Pregnant people are always hungry, yeah?”
“Constantly,” you admit with a small laugh.
JJ walks over and hands you a can without looking. “Drink?”
You take it automatically, then pause. Beer.
Pope immediately smacks JJ in the back of the head. “She’s pregnant, dumbass.”
JJ’s eyes widen. “Oh- shit. Sorry. Sorry!” He snatches it back and replaces it with a can of juice from the cooler. “Here. Non-irresponsible beverage.”
You laugh -really laugh- and it surprises you. “It’s okay,” you say. “Honestly, that tracks.”
Pope shakes his head. “He’s been like this.”
“Since birth,” John B adds.
“Rude,” JJ mutters, dropping into the sand.
The conversation flows around you easily after that. Nobody makes it weird. Nobody treats you like glass. Kiara asks how far along you are. Cleo asks if you’ve picked a name. Sarah keeps smiling every time you talk about the baby. And somehow, you find yourself talking more than you expected. About the house. About prenatal yoga. About how you didn’t think you’d end up back here.
Cleo leans back on her hands, studying you. “You’re tougher than you look,” she says casually.
You raise an eyebrow. “What’s that supposed to mean?”
“It means you’ve been through some stuff,” she replies. “And you’re still here.”
Kiara nods in agreement. Sarah bumps her shoulder into yours.
“Yeah,” she says softly. “You are.”
Your throat tightens unexpectedly. You glance out at the water where John B and JJ are paddling back toward shore, shouting to each other like nothing in the world has ever gone wrong.
By four-thirty, the sky starts shifting. It happens subtly at first -the bright blue fading into something heavier. The wind picks up, stronger now, tugging at towels and whipping loose sand against bare legs. The waves grow darker, angrier. You notice it before they do. You’re mid-conversation with Kiara when a distant rumble rolls across the water.
JJ, of course, cheers. “Storm swell!” he yells toward John B like this is Christmas morning.
“That is not storm swell,” Pope shouts back. “That is lightning.”
Another rumble follows, closer this time. Sarah looks up at the sky and winces. “Okay… maybe we should start packing.” The shift from relaxed to rushed happens instantly. John B jogs toward the van. JJ grabs boards. Kiara starts folding chairs. Cleo is already stuffing towels into a bag with military precision.
You stand too, instinctively helping- gathering paper plates, stacking empty cans, shaking sand off blankets.
“You don’t have to-” Sarah starts.
“I’m not helpless,” you reply lightly. You bend to grab the cooler at the same time Pope does.
He freezes. “You are absolutely not lifting that,” he says firmly.
“I can carry things,” you argue.
“You can carry a baby. That’s enough.”
Before you can protest, he takes it from your hands and motions for you to step back. “You supervise,” he adds.
You blink. “Supervise?”
“Yes,” Kiara chimes in, tossing you a blanket that was left out. “Stand there and look important.”
JJ runs past with two surfboards under his arm and nearly collides with you. “Whoa, future mother of the year, careful!”
Pope smacks him again. “You’re going to give her high blood pressure.”
“I don’t even know what that means!” JJ defends.
The first fat drop of rain hits your shoulder. Then another. Then the sky opens. It’s sudden and dramatic- sheets of rain pouring down, wind howling, sand sticking to wet skin. Everyone yells at once.
“Get the grill!”
“Close the back!”
“JJ MOVE!”
You laugh despite yourself as you jog toward the van, white dress now clinging slightly to your legs.
They pile inside in chaotic layers- wet limbs, tangled towels, JJ arguing that he absolutely should be the one to drive because he “drives better under pressure.”
“That’s literally when you drive worst,” Pope snaps.
John B tosses him the keys anyway.
“Shotgun!” JJ shouts.
“You’re driving!” Kiara yells.
You stand just outside the sliding door, rain soaking your hair now, heart pounding from the sudden energy of it all. “Where are you going?” you ask over the storm.
Everyone pauses. There’s a collective look between them.
“No one wants to drive back to the Chateau in this,” Sarah mutters.
“I’m not hydroplaning into the marsh,” Cleo adds.
JJ leans forward between the seats. “Unless we die. That would be kind of iconic.”
“Shut up,” Kiara says.
You hesitate for half a second. Then- “You can come to mine.”
They all turn to look at you.
“It’s literally right there,” you say, pointing vaguely toward your house through the curtain of rain. “You can dry off. I have a fireplace.”
“A fireplace?” JJ repeats.
“Yes.”
“Kook shit,” he mutters.
Sarah smiles immediately. “Are you sure?”
You nod. “Yeah. It’s fine.”
There’s another crack of thunder, closer this time, and that settles it.
“Okay, we’re rerouting!” John B declares.
JJ grins. “To the pregnant sanctuary!”
You roll your eyes, climbing into the van with them, heart oddly warm despite the cold rain soaking through your dress.
As JJ pulls away, windshield wipers struggling against the downpour, you glance at Sarah. She bumps her shoulder lightly into yours. “Thanks,” she says quietly.
You just smile. The storm rages outside, but inside the van, it feels loud and alive and safe. By the time the van pulls into your driveway, the rain is coming down in sheets so thick you can barely see the dunes behind your house.. JJ cuts the engine and everyone just sits there for a second, listening to the storm hammer the roof of the van.
“Well,” Cleo says. “We live here now.”
You laugh, pushing the door open. “Come on.”
They spill out of the van in a messy, soaked cluster, sprinting across the short stretch of sand toward your front porch. Your dress is completely damp now, clinging to your knees as you fumble with your keys.
“Okay, okay,” you say, pushing the door open. “Shoes off- I’m serious.”
“You sound like Kie,” JJ mutters, already kicking off his sneakers.
They file inside, dripping water onto the entryway tile, shaking rain from their hair and clothes. The house feels instantly smaller -fuller- louder. Warmer. You flip on the lights.
“Wow,” Sarah says quietly, looking around.
It’s not a mansion. Not Tannyhill. But it’s beautiful in that lived-in, beach-house way- soft lighting, pale wood floors, cozy furniture, big windows looking out toward the ocean.
“Okay,” you say, moving into autopilot. “Sit. Anywhere. I’ll grab towels.”
You disappear down the hallway and return with an armful of towels, nearly dropping them as you reenter the living room. “Here,” you say, handing them out one by one. To Sarah. To Kiara. To Cleo. To John B. To Pope. To JJ, who dramatically wraps himself like a burrito.
“You look like a wet raccoon,” Kiara tells him.
“Sexy raccoon,” JJ corrects.
You toss a towel over your own shoulders, finally noticing how cold you are now that you’re out of the rain.The storm cracks loudly overhead, and everyone instinctively looks toward the windows.
“Fireplace?” you say. Six heads turn toward you. You point at it. “I don’t like lighting it.”
JJ stands immediately. “Say less.”
“Absolutely not,” Pope says, grabbing JJ’s hoodie and pulling him back down. “John B, come on.”
The two of them move toward the fireplace while you head for the kitchen. You fill the kettle with water, the familiar domestic motion calming your nerves.
Behind you, the living room fills with noise again- JJ narrating instructions, Kiara correcting him from the couch, Cleo laughing, Sarah asking if you’re okay.
Then- the click of flame. A soft crackle. Warm orange light spills across the living room walls. You turn to see it glowing. For a moment, you just stand there watching it. Something about it makes your chest tighten in a good way.
“You want help?” Sarah asks gently, appearing beside you in the kitchen.
“I’ve got it,” you say with a small smile. “Tea?”
She nods. Soon you’re moving around the kitchen, pulling mugs from cabinets, setting them on a large serving plate. The kettle whistles softly as the storm continues outside.
One by one, they gather around the living room again- wrapped in blankets now, sitting cross-legged on the floor or piled onto the couch.
JJ sits closest to the fire like a lizard seeking warmth. “You have a cool -storm night in- house,” he says.
“Thank you?” you reply, handing him a mug anyway. You pass tea around to everyone. Last one for yourself. Then you lower yourself carefully onto the couch, blanket around your shoulders, one hand instinctively resting on your belly. The room is quiet for a moment. Rain. Fire crackling. Mugs clinking. Home.
Kiara nudges your shoulder. “Your house is really nice.”
“Thanks.”
Cleo lifts her mug. “Best emergency shelter on the island.”
Sarah smiles at you from the armchair across the room. “Yeah,” she says softly. “It is.”
And you realize something quietly, deeply: You’re not hosting strangers anymore. You’re hosting friends.
Outside, thunder rolls across the ocean. Inside, you feel safe. The storm doesn’t let up. Rain rattles against the windows while the fire pops softly in the hearth, throwing warm light across everyone’s faces. The blankets you handed out are already claimed- JJ cocooned on the floor, Cleo leaning against the couch, Pope sitting cross-legged with his mug cradled in both hands. Kiara has tucked her feet under herself, and Sarah sits curled in the armchair like she belongs there.
You didn’t expect this. Not the comfort. Not the ease. JJ squints into his mug. “What kind of tea is this?”
“Chamomile,” you say.
He makes a face. “This tastes like warm grass.”
“It’s supposed to relax you,” Pope says.
“I don’t want to relax. I want pizza.”
“You just ate,” Kiara says.
“That was before the trauma of surfing in a hurricane.”
“It was not a hurricane,” John B says from the floor, leaning back against the couch.
“Speak for yourself, Captain.”
Cleo laughs, shaking her head. “You Pogues complain more than rich people,” she says.
“Impossible,” you reply automatically. That gets a laugh from everyone. You feel your shoulders drop a little more.
Sarah leans forward slightly, eyes flicking to your stomach. “Can she hear all this?” she asks.
You glance down at your belly, rubbing it gently. “I think so,” you say. “She kicks when there’s a lot of noise.”
JJ lights up immediately. “Oh, she’s gonna be a Pogue then.”
Pope groans. “Please don’t encourage him.”
“What?” JJ says. “We’re clearly her cool aunts and uncles.”
“You are absolutely not,” Kiara says.
“Too late,” JJ says. “I already decided.” He scoots closer, stopping a respectful distance away from you.
“Okay, listen, Baby Cameron,” he says toward your stomach. “If your mom ever says no to something, you come find Uncle JJ.”
You laugh before you can stop yourself. “She’s definitely not doing that.”
Sarah is smiling now too- a real smile, not the careful ones she used to give you.
“What names do you like?” Kiara asks.
You hesitate. “I don’t know yet,” you admit. “It feels… big.” You don’t tell them about the name rafe gave you. Quinn.
“Yeah,” Sarah says softly. “I bet.”
Pope points his mug at JJ. “You are banned from suggesting names.”
“I wasn’t going to,” JJ says defensively.
“Liar.”
“Okay fine. Maverick.”
“No.”
“Storm.”
“No.”
“Boat.”
“Absolutely not.”
Cleo leans over. “Boat Cameron is crazy.”
John B stands and stretches. “Alright,” he says. “Storm’s slowing down.”
Everyone listens. The rain has softened to a steady drizzle. The sky outside is still gray, but calmer now.
Kiara checks her phone. “It’s almost six.”
Sarah stands slowly. “We should probably go.”
And something in your chest tightens a little at that. Not sadness. Just… noticing. JJ unwraps himself from the blanket dramatically.
“Your house is officially Pogues-approved,” he says.
“You’re welcome anytime,” you reply, and you mean it.
Pope points at you. “Next time we bring real food.”
“Please do,” you say.
Cleo squeezes your shoulder as she passes. Sarah lingers. Just for a second. “Thanks,” she says quietly. “For today.”
You nod. “Anytime.”
She smiles again, then follows the others out. The door closes behind them. The house goes quiet again. The fire still burns. The tea mugs sit half-empty. The blankets are draped everywhere. And the silence doesn’t feel lonely anymore. It feels peaceful. Tomorrow is Saturday.
-
When you wake up on the couch the next morning, the fireplace is still glowing faintly -embers instead of flames now, but warm enough to keep the room from feeling cold. A blanket is tangled around your legs. You blink toward the coffee table and grab your phone. 5:56 a.m.
Outside, the sky is a soft gray, the kind that makes the world feel hushed. Rain still falls, lighter now. Not the violent sheets from yesterday- just a steady, calming morning drizzle. The kind you’ve always liked. The kind that makes everything feel clean.
You sit up slowly, hand instinctively resting on your stomach.
“Good morning,” you murmur softly.
Upstairs, the house creaks the way it always does when the weather shifts. Familiar. Yours. After your shower, steam curling around the mirror, you towel off and dress in a simple sleep set- a baby pink tank and matching gauchos that skim comfortably over your growing belly. You brush through your curls and slick them back, letting them air-dry naturally. Slippers. A house coat. Skincare done in quiet, practiced motions.
You move through the house unhurried. A bowl of fresh fruit in one hand, you start straightening up downstairs. Sweeping stray sand from the hardwood floors. Mopping the entryway where everyone tracked in rainwater. Vacuuming the carpet where more sand somehow managed to hide. Gathering towels and blankets into the laundry basket.
There’s something deeply satisfying about cleaning up after a night like that. Proof people were here.
Proof you weren’t alone. You place the last abandoned tea mug into the dishwasher when the doorbell rings. You glance at the stove clock. 7:18 a.m.
Right on time. You dry your hands on a dish towel and make your way to the door. Through the peephole, you spot him- dark raincoat, hood up, shoulders slightly hunched against the drizzle. You pause. You’ve never seen him in a raincoat before.
Pulling back, you unlock the door and swing it open. He’s halfway through brushing rain off his sleeve when he looks up. Drops cling to the edges of his hood. His boots are damp. His face is neutral -almost guarded- until he registers the fact that you’re trying not to laugh.
“Hey- what?” he asks, brow furrowing.
You can’t hold it in. “I’ve never seen you wear a raincoat,” you say, reaching up to tug lightly at his hood. “You look kind of funny in it. You’re too tall. It makes you look like… a giant middle schooler.”
He blinks at you. Then huffs out a quiet laugh. “Wow. Good morning to you too.”
You step aside to let him in, still smiling- until your eyes drop. He doesn’t have the crib. Instead, he’s holding a suspiciously large rectangular box.
Your smile falters. “What happened to the bed?”
He steps inside, wiping his boots carefully on the mat before shrugging off the raincoat. His hair is slightly damp at the edges. “Couldn’t get it out of the doorframe,” he admits. “Measured wrong.”
You stare at him. “You measured wrong?”
He ignores that part. “So,” he continues, nudging the box upright against the wall, “I just bought you another one. Same brand. Very similar. Easier assembly. Figured I’d build it at your place instead.”
You blink. “You… bought another crib?”
He shrugs like it’s nothing. Toes off his boots. “Yeah. It’s fine.”
It’s not fine. It’s generous. It’s thoughtful. It’s something old Rafe would’ve complained about and new Rafe just… handled.
“Rafe-”
“If you don’t mind,” he adds quickly, glancing at you. “I won’t open it if you don’t want me to. I just thought- it’d be easier.” There’s no ego in it. No attitude. Just a quiet offer. You look at the box. Then at him. He looks tired. Not in a chaotic way. Just… worn.
“Yeah,” you say softly. “That’s fine.”
“Upstairs?” he asks.
“Yeah. No point building it downstairs and hauling it up.”
“Good. Because I wasn’t carrying this twice.”
“You absolutely would’ve.”
He smirks. “Don’t push it.”
He carries the box up while you follow slower. When you reach the nursery, he sets it down in the middle of the room and looks around like he’s trying to picture it finished.
“Okay,” he says, clapping his hands once. “Let’s see how bad this is.”
He opens the box. Pieces. So many pieces.
You stare down at them. “That’s… excessive.”
“It’s wood and screws,” he says. “How hard can it be?”
He pulls out the instruction manual. You raise your eyebrows.
He glares at you. “I’m not guessing.”
“Oh, I was hoping you would. I love chaos.”
“Yeah, I know you do.”
You move closer and sit carefully on the rug while he spreads everything out.
“You’re not just supervising,” he says, glancing at you. “You’re helping.”
“I’m pregnant.”
“You can hold things.”
You gasp dramatically. “Manual labor?”
He slides a wooden rail toward you. “Hold that.”
You take it, pretending to struggle. “This is so heavy. I might faint.”
“If you faint, I’m leaving.”
“You wouldn’t.”
He pauses. “…I wouldn’t.”
You both feel it. But neither of you say anything about it. He kneels across from you, lining up one of the panels. “Okay, we need screw B.”
You look down at the pile of hardware. “Which one is screw B?”
He checks the manual. “…The one that looks exactly like screw A but slightly longer.”
“Helpful.” You start sorting them anyway.
“Don’t mix them up,” he warns.
“I won’t.”
Thirty seconds later. “These are definitely mixed up.”
He closes his eyes briefly. “Unbelievable.”
You grin. “You said they look the same.”
He crawls closer, shoulder brushing yours as he inspects the screws in your hand. You’re suddenly very aware of how close he is.
“That’s A,” he says, taking one gently from your palm. “That’s B.”
“They’re twins.”
“They are not.”
“They are.”
He shakes his head but there’s a faint smile pulling at his mouth. You hand him the right one this time. He starts tightening it, but the angle’s awkward.
“Wait,” you say. “Let me hold it straighter.”
You shift onto your knees carefully, steadying the panel while he works. Your fingers brush his wrist for a second. Neither of you pull away immediately.
“Don’t strip it,” you murmur.
“Relax. I know how to use a screwdriver.”
“That didn’t sound convincing.”
He shoots you a look. “You’re talking a lot for someone who almost mixed up the screws.”
You grin. “Team effort.”
The first side finally stands upright. You both lean back slightly to admire it.
“It’s crooked,” you say.
“It’s not crooked.”
“It is.”
He squints at it. Steps back. Tilts his head. “…Okay, maybe a little.”
“I told you.”
“Don’t get smug.”
“I’m getting smug.”
He adjusts it carefully this time. You steady it again, closer now, both of you focused. The room is quiet except for the soft sound of rain beginning outside and the occasional clink of metal against wood.
After a few minutes, you sit back against the wall, catching your breath. “Okay,” you say. “Break.”
“We just started.”
“I’m morale support.”
“You’re complaining support.”
You reach over and lightly shove his shoulder.
He pretends to stumble dramatically. “Assaulting me now?”
“You’re so dramatic.”
He laughs- a real one. Not forced. You haven’t heard that in a long time. He looks around the nursery again while you rest.
“You picked this color yourself?” he asks casually.
“Yeah.”
“It’s good.”
You glance at him. “That’s high praise.”
“I have taste.”
“You have opinions.”
“Same thing.”
You watch him for a second while he organizes the remaining pieces. He’s focused, patient, not rushing.
“You’re weirdly calm about this,” you say.
“It’s a crib,” he shrugs. “Not a jet engine.”
“You got mad at one ikea shelf.”
“That shelf was defective.”
“It was not.”
“It absolutely was.”
You laugh softly. He finishes attaching the second side and motions for you.
“Come here.”
You move closer again.
“Hold that while I tighten this.”
You steady the rail and he leans in, careful, slower this time. When he’s done, he gives it a small shake to test it. Solid. You both look at it at the same time.
“That’s… actually good,” you say.
“Obviously.”
“Don’t ruin it.”
He smirks. You sit there for a moment, side by side on the nursery floor, looking at the crib like it’s something bigger than wood and screws.
“We built that,” you murmur.
“Yeah,” he says quietly.
And that’s it. Just the two of you on the floor, hands dusty with sawdust, rain tapping at the window, something steady taking shape between you- even if neither of you are naming it yet.
Once the crib is finished, tightened, and tested for the third time -because he doesn’t trust anything after the first try- the two of you sit back on the nursery floor and just… look at it. It stands solid in the center now below the widow. Pale pink wood against soft walls. Real.
You exhale slowly. “We ate that,” you murmur.
“Mostly me,” he corrects lightly.
You roll your eyes. “I held things.”
“Heroic.”
You shift carefully, reaching toward the woven basket near the door- your so-called “basket of comfort.” It’s filled with folded throws and extra pillows you’ve been collecting, telling yourself they’re for her. Just in case. You pull one out now.
“Hey,” he says, watching you. “What are you doing?”
You pat the pillow before lowering yourself down onto the rug, easing it under your lower back with a quiet sigh of relief. “Getting my fifteen minutes of mandatory bedrest,” you say, already adjusting your hips slightly. “Doctor’s orders.”
He quirks an eyebrow, a smile threatening at the corner of his mouth. “On the floor?”
“It’s comfortable.”
“It’s hardwood.”
“There’s a rug.”
He shakes his head faintly but doesn’t argue.
You close your eyes, one arm resting loosely over your stomach. The nursery is quiet except for the faint tap of rain against the window. A few seconds pass. You can feel it. His stare. “You’re staring,” you say, eyes still closed, a small smile pulling at your lips.
He huffs a soft laugh. “Sorry.”
You crack one eye open. He’s still sitting cross-legged across from you, forearms resting loosely over his knees. His gaze isn’t on your face.
It’s on your stomach.
“Just…” He trails off, glancing away for a second like he’s trying to find words that won’t sound wrong. “A year ago I never would’ve…”
You open your eyes fully now. “Never would’ve what?” you ask gently.
He exhales slowly, looking around the room -at the crib, the half-open box, the scattered instruction manual- anywhere but you.
“I just didn’t think…” He pauses. Tries again. “I didn’t think this would be my life.”
There’s no resentment in it. No panic. Just disbelief.
You shift your arm so your hand rests fully over your belly now, thumb tracing absent circles.
“That’s not a bad thing,” you say quietly.
“No,” he answers immediately. Then softer, “It’s not.”
He looks at you again. At the curve of you. At the place where your body has changed in ways neither of you can ignore.
“It’s just weird,” he admits. “We’ve been through so much crap. And now there’s… this.”
You glance toward the crib. “This,” you echo.
He nods once. Silence stretches again- but it’s not tense. It’s heavy in a thoughtful way.
“You can touch if you want,” you say after a moment. Casual. Like it’s not a big deal. “She’s yours too, y’know.”
His eyes flick up to yours, surprised by how easy you said it. “Yeah?”
“Yeah.”
He hesitates- not because he doesn’t want to, but because he’s careful now. Like he’s afraid of doing something wrong even in something this simple. Slowly, he shifts closer. Not hovering. Not crowding. Just enough. He reaches out, hand pausing a few inches above your stomach before finally settling there.
Warm. Steady. You watch his face instead of the contact.
He swallows slightly. “She’s bigger,” he murmurs.
“Yeah.. that happens.”
His thumb moves unconsciously, barely brushing the fabric of your tank. For a moment, nothing happens. Then- A kick. Subtle but unmistakable. He freezes.
“Did you feel that?” you ask, though you already know.
His eyes widen just slightly. “Yeah.”
Another small movement under his palm. He lets out a quiet breath that almost sounds like a laugh.
“She’s strong.”
“That’s what Sarah said,” you reply without thinking.
He glances up at you, not bothered- just taking it in. “Good,” he says.
His hand stays there. Not possessive. Not claiming.Just present. The rain continues outside, steady and soft. And on the nursery floor, surrounded by half-folded cardboard and the faint scent of new wood, the two of you stay like that for a long moment- quiet, grounded, connected by something neither of you are trying to control anymore. Just parents. The two of you sit there for a few moments longer, neither of you speaking. Eventually, the moment runs its course.
You press your palms into the floor and start to sit up.
“Careful,” Rafe says immediately, already moving. He stands first, then offers both hands. You take them, letting him pull you to your feet. He dusts his palms on his jeans before touching you -a nervous habit you don’t remember him having before- and only then do you notice how damp they are.
He’s nervous. That realization sits quietly in your chest. You walk him downstairs together, slow and unhurried. The house feels different now- not heavy, not tense. Just quiet. At the door, he bends to pull his boots back on. You reach for his jacket hanging from the hook and hand it to him.
“Thanks,” he says softly. He slips it on, adjusting the collar. Then, like he’s debating whether to ask, he hesitates. “Are you… going to Midsummer’s this year?”
You blink. You hadn’t planned on going this year- even with Becca insisting for weeks. She’d been trying to drag you there before announcing she’d actually be out of town visiting her grandmother in Charleston anyway.
You shrug honestly. “I don’t know. I just… don’t think I want to be around all those people.”
He chuckles lightly, tugging his coat into place. “You mean the people you grew up with?”
“Yeah,” you reply. “Those people.” Another small chuckle escapes him, but he doesn’t argue.
You lean against the wall near the door, arms folding loosely. “Becca’s going to Charleston this weekend,” you continue. “And the only people I’d even know there would be my parents, Beau, Becca’s parents… and a bunch of rich kids pretending they’re important.”
He smiles faintly at that.
“And honestly,” you add, “meeting people outside the OBX has made the whole kook-versus-pogue thing here feel really… stupid.”
The silence lands easily between you. Then, after a second: “Well… I’ll be there,” he says, voice softer now. “You don’t have to hang out with anyone else. You could just… hang with me.”
Your stomach flips instantly. And right on cue- a kick.
You place a hand over your belly, pretending you’re just resting it there. “Um…” You look down at the floor instead of at him. “I don’t know, Rafe.”
He nods quickly, backing off without hesitation. “No, yeah. That’s okay. Just… think about it, alright?”
He reaches for the door and opens it.
You nod once. “Okay.”
He gives you a small, understanding smile. Then, before stepping out, he kneels down in front of you. The motion catches you off guard. He looks at your belly, expression softer than you’ve seen in a long time. “Bye, little one,” he says gently. “I love you.”
Your throat tightens. He glances up at you for just a second -like maybe that sentence carried more than one meaning- but you don’t acknowledge it. You don’t trust yourself to. He stands, pushes open the storm door, and steps out into the damp morning air.
You watch from the doorway as he walks to his SUV, rain mist still hanging in the air. He pulls the door open, pauses for half a second like he might turn around again- but doesn’t. Then he gets in and drives off. And you’re left standing there, hand still resting over your stomach, the house quiet behind you. And your heart… not nearly as settled as you thought it was.
-
“I told you,” Becca says, trailing beside you as you scan a rack of infant clothes. “Even your baby dad wants you there. Even though you’re right about not being with his crazy ass while you’re there. And I’m pretty sure Beau is going. That’s at least one safe person.”
You pause mid-reach and give her a look. “First- please don’t call him that,” you say, sliding a tiny cotton onesie back onto the rack. “Second… I don’t know. I’d just be standing around a bunch of people with superiority complexes for like four hours.” You shrug. “I want to do something fun.”
Becca watches you for a moment. “What happened to you, y/n?” she asks. “You used to love Midsummer’s. We could barely make it to spring before you were planning what dress you were gonna wear.”
She grabs a pair of baby shoes from a nearby shelf and drops them into your basket without asking. They’re adorable, so you don’t protest.
“Is this about you and Rafe not being together?”
“God, no,” you answer quickly. “I’m over that.” Mostly. It isn’t heartbreak you’re worried about- it’s the looks. The whispers. The quiet disappointment wrapped in politeness. Your family’s name carries expectations, and showing up pregnant, unmarried, and newly single feels like walking into a room where everyone already knows the headline version of your life.
You push the cart forward slowly. “I just… can’t stand being around people like them anymore.”
“We are like them,” Becca counters.
“I’m not,” you say firmly- emphasizing the I’m in a way that makes the distinction clear. Becca can still slip into that world easily when she wants to.
She rolls her eyes but lets it go, picking up a tiny baby bucket hat and inspecting it. “Whatever. So what are you gonna do? Sit at home all weekend?”
“I don’t know…” you say, guiding the cart down the aisle. “Maybe I’ll find someone. Or… some people.”
Your mind drifts immediately to the beach. The bonfire warmth of the fireplace. Sarah’s laughter when the baby kicked. JJ being JJ. Kiara handing you tea like you’d always belonged there.
Becca doesn’t notice the shift in your expression.
“Define some people,” she says absently, still browsing.
You hesitate. Then say it anyway. “On Saturday I hung out with the Pogues. That was… actually really fun. Maybe I’ll hang out with them again this weekend.”
You keep your eyes on the cart, already knowing Becca is staring at you now. “Can you please define which Pogues we’re talking about here?” she asks slowly.
“You know,” you say casually, pretending to study a rack of bibs. “John B. Sarah-”
“Ohhh god, y/n,” Becca groans, closing her eyes and pressing her fingers to her temples like she’s developing a migraine. “It’s one thing to stop by their shop and grab napkins. It’s one thing to let your new york friends play tourist there. But actually hanging out with them?” She looks at you like you’ve just announced you’re moving into the Cut.
You shrug. “They’re not bad. Like… at all.”
And that’s the part that surprises you most. Not just that you had fun- but how easy it felt. No expectations. No reputation to maintain. No one looking at your belly like it was a scandal. Just people who treated you like a person.
Becca studies your face now, realizing this isn’t a joke. “You actually like them,” she says.
You nod once. “Yeah. I do.”
And for the first time since the Midsummer conversation started, the idea of skipping it doesn’t feel like avoidance. It feels like choosing something better.
“You should try to get to know them,” you say, nudging the cart forward as the two of you approach the register. “They’re really nice kids.”
The teenage cashier behind the counter barely glances up as she starts scanning items, clearly uninterested in anything beyond finishing her shift.
Becca folds her arms loosely across her chest, watching the total climb on the screen. “I’m sure they are,” she says, unconvinced. “But… I don’t know, y/n. It just doesn’t seem like you.” She pauses, then adds, “If you want, I can push my visit to my grandparents back a weekend. We can hang out instead.”
You look at her, surprised. “You’d do that?”
“Yeah,” she shrugs. “It’s only a weekend difference.”
The cashier reads the total aloud, and you reach into your wallet, pulling out one of the many credit cards tucked inside. As you swipe it through the machine, an idea sparks in your mind- sudden, simple, and kind of perfect.
Becca doesn’t actually know them. Not really. She only knows the version of the Pogues everyone in your world talks about. She hasn’t seen Sarah giggle when the baby kicks. Hasn’t watched Pope gently take things out of your hands when you try to help. Hasn’t heard Cleo’s easy warmth or Kiara’s quiet kindness.
She hasn’t seen them treat you like you belong.
“That actually sounds fine,” you say, trying to keep your voice casual while the receipt prints. “Are you sure about ditching your grandma though?”
Becca rolls her eyes.
“I’m not ditching her. I’m postponing. She’ll survive.”
You laugh softly, tearing the receipt from the printer and dropping it into the bag without looking.
“Okay,” you say. “Then hang out with me this weekend.”
Becca raises an eyebrow immediately. “That sounded suspicious.”
You grab the shopping bag and hook it over your arm, steering the cart away from the counter. “It’s not suspicious,” you say lightly. “Just… trust me.”
Becca narrows her eyes but follows you toward the exit anyway. “I don’t like when you say ‘trust me.’ That usually means you’re about to drag me into something.”
You push open the store door, the late afternoon air brushing your skin. “Relax,” you say with a small smile. “Worst case scenario, you hate it and leave.”
Becca studies your face for another second -trying to read you- before sighing. “Fine. One weekend.”
You nod, satisfied, already picturing the beach again. The van. The music. The way it felt to sit in a circle where nobody expected anything from you.
“Good,” you say. “One weekend.”
And for the first time, you’re not nervous about mixing the two parts of your life. You’re actually excited.
-
Sunlight spills through your bedroom window, warm and golden against the sheets. You stretch slowly, one hand instinctively settling over your stomach as you blink awake. The house is quiet. Peaceful. You look down at your belly and smile. Life feels… right. For the first time in a long time, it isn’t chaotic or heavy or unpredictable. It feels steady. Like a boat that’s finally found calm water after months of rough waves.
“Good morning, baby,” you murmur softly, thumb brushing over the curve of you. “Mommy loves you.”
You push yourself upright and shuffle toward the bathroom in nothing but your tank top and underwear, not bothering to throw anything else on. You catch your reflection in the mirror. Your belly is rounder now. Undeniable. Your skin has that soft glow everyone keeps commenting on. Your hair falls messy around your shoulders, but there’s something else in your reflection that wasn’t there a year ago.
You look happy. You are happy. You tilt your head, playing with your hair absentmindedly while brushing your teeth, debating whether to wear it up or leave it down. A shower sounds productive. A bath sounds indulgent.
You choose indulgent. You pad more into the bathroom and turn on the clawfoot tub, squeezing in a generous amount of soap before adjusting the water temperature. Just as the water begins to rise-
The doorbell rings. You freeze. Your brows pull together. You weren’t expecting anyone. You quickly tug on a pair of gauchos that hang over your dresser chair and head downstairs, bare feet quiet against the wood floors. Peering through the peephole, you blink. Then blink again. Nope. Still there.
Rafe Cameron stands on your porch holding a pink bakery box. You open the door.
He’s looking down the street, hands shoved awkwardly into his pockets, dressed more casually than usual- fitted polo, khaki shorts, dress shoes. Work clothes, but not the polished business version. He turns at the sound of the door and offers you that unfairly handsome smile.
Your stomach growls at the sight of the box. “Rafe… what are you doing here?” you ask.
“Oh-” He glances past you like he’s waiting for permission to exist inside your house.
You sigh and step aside. “You’re lucky you’re holding sugar,” you mutter.
He steps in, and you close the door behind him.
“I, uh…” He clears his throat. “Had a crap day yesterday. And Beau told me that Becca told him that you told Becca that she kicks whenever you eat donuts.” He gestures to the box. “So I figured I’d give myself a little morning pick-me-up before work.”
He’s over-explaining. You know that tone. “Rafe,” you say, crossing your arms gently over your belly. “I love that we’re working on the co-parenting thing. I really do. But you can’t just show up here whenever you feel like it.”
“Yeah. No. I know.” He nods quickly. “I just wanted to ‘see’ her before work.”
He says it casually, but his eyes drift to your stomach immediately. You hold out your hand. “Give me the box.”
He passes it over obediently. You head into the kitchen, and he follows like he’s not sure whether he’s allowed to but doesn’t want to risk leaving.
You open the box. Glazed. Chocolate frosted. Pink frosted with sprinkles. Jelly-filled. Powdered. You weren’t hungry five minutes ago. Now you absolutely are.
You grab a glazed one and take a bite before even grabbing a napkin. “Unbelievable,” he mutters, watching you. “You didn’t even pretend to think about it.”
“You showed up unannounced,” you say through a mouthful, pointing the donut at him. “You don’t get judgment rights.”
He leans against the counter, arms folding.
“You really should text before you come over,” you continue, softer now but still firm. “What if I wasn’t decent?” only realizing he’s seen you completely naked after you’ve already spoken.
He glances down at your gauchos and tank top. “You’re not exactly dressed for company now.”
You narrow your eyes. “Don’t start.”
He raises both hands in surrender. “Sorry. Sorry.”
You take another bite. A few seconds pass. Then- A flutter. You pause. Rafe notices immediately. “Did she-”
“Wait,” you whisper.
Another kick. Stronger this time.
Your eyes widen and you grab his wrist before he can even ask, pressing his hand flat against your stomach. He stills instantly. Another kick. His breath catches.
“There,” you say quietly.
He doesn’t speak. Just stares down, completely frozen, like if he moves he’ll miss it. And then she kicks again- firm and unmistakable. A slow grin spreads across his face, softer than you’ve seen in a while.
“She likes glazed,” he murmurs.
You laugh quietly. “Or she likes sugar.”
He keeps his hand there a second longer than necessary. And then-
From upstairs- A faint but very clear sound. Water. Running. Too much water. Your eyes widen.
“Oh my God.”
You pull away from him suddenly and bolt toward the stairs as fast as a third-trimester waddle allows.
“The tub!” you shout.
Rafe swears under his breath and runs up after you. By the time you reach the bathroom, water is spilling over the edge of the clawfoot tub and pooling across the tile.
“Oh my God,” you repeat, rushing forward to shut off the faucet.
Rafe grabs towels from the rack and drops to his knees without hesitation, pressing them against the spreading water. “You left it running?!” he calls out.
“You showed up unannounced!” you shoot back.
“This is my fault now?!”
“Yes!”
He huffs out a laugh despite himself as he soaks up the water. Within minutes the crisis is mostly contained- damp but manageable. You both sit back on the tile floor, slightly breathless. He looks at you. You look at him. And then you both start laughing. Because really- Of course this is how the morning went. Donuts. Kicks. Flooded bathroom.
And somehow… it doesn’t feel overwhelming. The bathroom still smells faintly like soap and warm water.
You’re both sitting on the tile floor, damp towels piled between you, the small flood mostly under control. Rafe wrings out one of the towels into the tub, then stands and reaches for another from the cabinet like he belongs here.
“You missed a spot,” he says, nodding toward a thin line of water near the doorway.
You squint at it. “I did not.”
He grabs another towel anyway and drops to one knee, wiping it up.
“You don’t have to keep cleaning,” you tell him, leaning back against the wall. “It’s handled.”
“Yeah,” he says casually, not looking up. “Just making sure.”
You watch him for a second, recognizing the excuse for what it is. “You’re stalling.”
“I’m not stalling.”
“You are.”
He smirks but keeps wiping the floor. When he finally stands, he tosses the damp towel into the tub and rubs the back of his neck like he’s deciding whether to say something.
“So… Midsummers is this weekend.”
There it is. You look down at your hands, pretending to inspect a hangnail. “Yeah.”
“You going?” he asks, trying to sound neutral.
You shake your head. “No. I think I’m just gonna stay home. Take it easy.”
Which isn’t technically a lie- you will be taking it easy. Just not alone. Becca, the pogues, food, probably sitting in your living room laughing until your stomach hurts. He nods slowly.
“Yeah,” he says. “That makes sense.” His voice is calm, understanding- exactly how it should be. But you know him well enough to see the small flicker of disappointment he doesn’t let turn into pressure. “Big crowds, long night… probably not fun when you can’t drink,” he adds with a shrug.
“Exactly,” you say.
A small silence settles between you. Not awkward. Just full of things neither of you are saying.
“Well,” he says finally, clapping his hands once against his thighs. “I should head to work.”
You both make your way downstairs together, slower this time. At the front door, he slips on his shoes while you lean against the wall, arms resting over your belly again.
“Thanks for the donuts,” you say.
“Anytime she needs convincing to kick,” he replies.
He opens the door, then hesitates. You see it coming before he even moves. He bends slightly, reaching toward your stomach.
You immediately put a hand on his shoulder to stop him. “Don’t push it.”
He freezes, then looks up at you with a crooked grin. “I wasn’t pushing it.”
“You were absolutely about to kiss my stomach.”
He laughs, straightening. “Okay, yeah. Maybe.”
You shake your head, smiling despite yourself. “Goodbye, Rafe.”
He lingers half a second longer, then nods. “Bye.”
He steps outside, turning back once before heading down the porch steps. You close the door gently, resting your hand over your belly again. Right on cue- A small kickYou smile. “Yeah,” you murmur. “That was your dad.”
PLOT Years after their messy breakup, Y/N, now a rising documentary filmmaker, is assigned to direct a film about Saint Halo, the world-famous band fronted by her ex, Rafe Cameron. What starts as a professional reunion turns into an emotional collision, as old wounds resurface under the lights of fame and the camera starts catching more truth than either of them planned.
CONTENT CHAPTER ONE, strong language, emotionally charged intimacy, emotional infidelity, & me overdoing this whole thing and writing way too much. i lowkey dont check my taglist app so just dm me or comment underneath !
MAIN MASTERLIST | SERIES MASTERLIST
you sit in the back of the conference room with your coffee going cold. your producer for the documentary, mae, is standing at the front beside a whiteboard that’s already crowded with color-coded notes: names, dates, arrows, scribbles about logistics, flights, permissions. somewhere between week 2 and week 5, she’s managed to fit a doodle of a little guitar.
her handwriting is almost too neat for what she’s saying. “access to saint halo will be limited at first,” mae’s explaining, marker cap clicking in her hand. “they’ve had issues with press, and management is being cautious. we’ll need to be careful about tone early on. don’t push for anything too personal until they trust us.”
you nod automatically. your pen is between your fingers, but you’re not taking notes, mostly because you don’t need to. you could do this half-asleep and still nail it. and honestly, part of you probably is half-asleep, if not physically then somewhere in your head.
mae’s voice blurs into the background. she’s walking through the plan: week one is sit-down interviews, week two is live tour footage, weeks three through (hopefully) six is studio and off-days.
it’s all textbook. you’ve done this a dozen times before with politicians, small-town artists, even that surfer doc that got you the sundance shortlisting, but this one’s different. you’re not sure if it’s the subject, or the subject of the subject. saint halo, of all the bands in the world.
you try to tell yourself you’re lucky. it’s a high-profile project with real budget, real eyes on it. the label’s backing it, the production company’s been trying to get in with the music industry for years, and now they have their foot in the door because of you. your name carries weight. mae knows it, the executives know it. they all trust you.
but your stomach still twists when you think about what that means. you swallow hard, tune back in just in time to hear mae’s voice.
“we’ll be traveling in the next few days,” she says, flipping through her clipboard. “they’re still on tour, so we’ll meet the band at one of their gigs first. we’ll get permission for backstage access and maybe some audience shots. it’s a good chance to get performance footage early - kill two birds with one stone.”
you blink, forcing yourself to focus. performance footage, early material, travel prep. got it. you underline something meaningless in your notebook just to look busy.
mae continues, “i know the idea of filming on-site can be chaotic, but it’s good energy. it’s raw. we want the audience to feel the noise, you know? that’s what makes the music documentaries land.”
you nod again, even though she isn’t really looking at you anymore. your eyes drift back down to your laptop, to the corner of the screen where your email is still open, but your cursor hovers over the imessages icon instead.
you shouldn’t, but your fingers move before you can stop them. it’s like muscle memory, almost.
the chat window pops up with a list of names you know too well. you see the cinematographer from your last film, the sound designer who’s been wanting a chance to work with you again, even that editor who worked with you on a hurricane doc. she still calls you “boss” even though you hated it.
and then, somewhere near the bottom, rafe cameron.
his name looks wrong in the context of work. the little profile circle is just a gray placeholder now. there’s no photo or last activity timestamp, but the thread is still there. the scroll bar is small, a testament to how much you once texted.
you deleted your old messages from your phone years ago. it was an act of cleansing, but the laptop kept everything.
you exhale slowly and scroll up anyway, eyes moving over fragments you’d forgotten were still here. there’s jokes about lyrics, him sending you a rough demo at two in the morning, ‘don’t laugh if it sucks,’ and pictures from nights you barely remember.
your reflection stares back at you from the black edge of the screen. you can hear mae still talking in the background about shooting permits and camera setups. you should be listening. you want to be listening, but instead you’re typing. your fingers move on their own.
no, too casual. delete.
no, he knows who you are. delete.
you breathe in through your nose, try again.
the words look too bare, too defensive for a first message after, what, two years? three? you stare at them for a long time, the blinking cursor pulsing.
you imagine him seeing it. the unread notification, the way his brow might furrow, the possible what now he’d mutter under his breath. you imagine him ignoring it. you imagine him answering. neither version even feels survivable. your thumb hovers over enter.
then, slowly, you backspace. each letter disappears until there’s nothing left. no message, no start, no chance to ruin or repair anything. you shut your laptop gently, the click of it closing louder than it should be.
around you, the meeting wraps up. mae’s saying something about the call sheet, about flight times. the crew’s laughing softly as chairs scrape against the floor. someone tosses a marker into the bin.
you nod when mae passes by and says, “we’ll touch base tomorrow.”
you land in chicago a little after noon. the flight itself was . . . fine, except for the hour you spent stuck behind a group of drunk bachelor-party guys arguing. by the time you finally got off the plane, your patience was thin, your earbuds were dead, and your iced coffee had melted into something closer to literal dishwater. still, you made it, and that’s what matters.
you pick up your luggage, check into the hotel mae booked for the crew and drop your bags at the foot of the bed. the white comforter looks tempting enough to dive into, but mae’s text pops up before you can even think about sitting down: van leaves in 20. wear something casual. soundcheck at 4.
so much for rest. guess you should’ve done more of it on the plane. but now, twenty minutes later, you’re squeezed into the middle row of a black sprinter van with mae and three other crew members. mae’s at the front, laptop open, talking to the driver about the route to the venue while she sips her third cold brew of the day. she’s good at multitasking, she always has been.
“we should get there right as saint halo’s starting soundcheck,” she says over her shoulder. “perfect timing to get some behind-the-scenes footage before the crowd fills in.”
you nod, even though you’re not sure she’s talking directly to you. the city slips by through the tinted window, and the closer you get to the venue, the heavier your chest feels. you tell yourself it’s nerves or excitement. or maybe it’s just the cold pressing through the glass. the venue’s big, but you’ve seen enough arenas from concerts you’ve been to in your freetime.
you step out of the van with your camera bag slung over your shoulder and take it all in. mae’s already directing traffic, telling the camera crew where to unload, which doors to use, what permissions they have. the venue’s front-of-house staff points you toward a side entrance, wristbands waiting for you at check-in.
entry’s been covered by one of the documentary’s major backers. you’d read their name enough times on contracts and funding proposals that it feels weird to finally see their logo plastered on the laminate around your neck.
you move with the rest of the crew through the back corridors of the venue. someone’s already doing a mic check in the distance.
there are equipment cases stacked against the walls backstage, crew members in all black darting between sound techs and lighting rigs. mae stops every few steps to talk logistics with someone, while you find yourself wandering toward the stage area.
a man spots you first, nate ellison, saint halo’s manager. he’s in his mid-40s, beard going silver, wearing a vintage tour tee and a headset like he’s been doing this since the literal dawn of time.
“you’re with mae’s team, right?” he says, smiling as he wipes his hands on his jeans. “y/n, yeah? we’ve been expecting you.”
you nod, offering a polite handshake that he returns with the kind of practiced friendliness of someone who meets too many people in a day.
“they’re just finishing soundcheck,” nate explains, tilting his head toward the stage. “i’ll take you over to meet them real quick. won’t keep you long.”
you follow him up the steps to the side of the stage and notice wide lights, the empty stretch of seats and railings, a few fans scattered near the barricade, phones already up. apparently, saint halo allows a handful of people to buy early-access passes to watch soundcheck.
on stage, the band’s finishing a run-through of a song. instruments hum, and you can feel the vibration through the floorboards. nate lifts a hand, gesturing for them to wrap up.
“hey, guys,” he calls out. “come take a second, this is y/n. she’s with the documentary team.”
the noise quiets. the drummer stops first, setting her sticks down on the snare, followed by the bassist leaning back against his amp, and then, finally, the lead singer turns.
your heartbeat doesn’t care that this is a work assignment. it doesn’t care about professionalism or posture or how many years it’s been. all it knows is that he’s here.
the band gathers at the side, sweat still shining under the stage lights, the early-access fans in the audience murmuring behind their hands. you can’t look away, not yet, and he doesn’t either.
nate’s voice fades into the background as you step forward. the first one to reach out is this tall, lanky guy with a grin and a sweat-darkened shirt. he takes your hand in his, eyebrows raising almost immediately.
“no offense,” he says, his tone somewhere between amusement and disbelief, “but you look kinda young for the gig.”
before you can even think of a response, another voice cuts in, a deeper laugh from just beside him. “i was gonna say the same damn thing,” the other guy adds, shaking his head.
you let out a small, polite laugh, giving the first one a nod. “i’m twenty-five,” you say simply. “and i promise i know what i’m doing.”
that earns a few chuckles from the others. they’re not being mean, they’re just curious. you’re used to it. people expect the kind of person who directs documentaries to be older, more jaded. not . . . well, you.
the first guy is luca if you remember correctly. he still looks half-surprised, half-impressed. the bassist, the one every article called “the glue” or whatever. he’s pretty, that’s for sure.
next is orion, their synth and guitarist. seems like a nice kid. he’s got that restless energy you’ve seen in so many artists. his hand is warm, his grin crooked. the profiles you read called him the “spark” of saint halo, the one who starts ideas that everyone else eventually shapes into something bigger. you can see why.
then comes nox, the only girl in the band. she’s quiet at first, her handshake firm. her dark hair is pulled back, a faint sheen of sweat from soundcheck still clinging to her temples. articles always called her “the backbone of saint halo,” and it fits. she’s presence before she’s sound.
and then rafe. you knew this part was coming, but no amount of bracing can soften it.
he steps forward, slower than the rest, wiping his palm on his jeans before offering his hand. his eyes meet yours like it’s the most natural thing in the world, like he hasn’t been the ghost sitting at the back of your mind for months, maybe years. his hair’s a little shorter, his jaw sharper, but the way he looks at you hasn’t changed at all.
you inhale through your nose before taking his hand. his grip is steady. there’s a flicker of something in his eyes. maybe amusement. “so you’re the director?” he asks. it sounds like he’s teasing you and testing the air between you at the same time. you know that he’s known you’re the director for this project.
you squint at him, a slight curve at the corner of your mouth but it never really turns into a smile. “mm,” you hum, then you drop his hand.
nate clears his throat somewhere off to the side. “alright,” he says, clapping his hands together once, “we’ll keep this quick. they’ve still got a couple things to run before doors open.”
the words are mostly for you, though his tone is light, almost apologetic, like he’s trying to usher the moment along without stepping on it. you nod, stepping back a little.
luca adjusts the strap of his bass. orion twirls a pick between his fingers, and nox has already turned away, reaching for her sticks. rafe doesn’t really move.
his hand falls back to his side, fingers flexing once. his gaze stays on you, not intense exactly, just more curious, like he’s trying to reconcile the person in front of him with the one who used to exist beside him.
“this way, y/n,” nate says, gesturing toward the stairs that dip backstage. you follow, the soles of your boots scuffing lightly against the stage.
as you descend, you feel his gaze again, but you keep your expression neutral, professional. behind you, a chord rings out. nate says something about schedules, about how tomorrow will run smoother once everyone’s comfortable. you nod along, eyes on the narrow hallway ahead.
you don’t look back. but if you did, you’d see rafe still standing where you left him, one hand on the mic stand, watching until the curtain swallow you whole.
the rest of the setup moves like clockwork. sound techs darts across the stage, crew members crouch over cables, lights flicker in bursts as the rigging adjusts. the band slips back into their rhythm, instruments tuning, mics checked.
by the time the house lights dim, the venue’s a different animal. it’s crowded, people are sweating already. you’ve got your walkie in hand, headset on, threading yourself through the barricade gap where the cinematographers are already stationed. the pit smells like warm metal and adrenaline. you speak low, guiding them like it’s instinct.
“camera two, hold that wide. three, pan left when rafe hits the chorus. stay on the drummer when the bridge hits. there’s a rhythm shot there i want.”
they nod. you move between them, just close enough to see the flicker of the stage lights bouncing off the lenses. you tell one of the crew to grab a side angle, another to get close on rafe’s hands. you don’t have to think too hard.
after about an hour, though, the volume starts pressing against your skull. you step away, slipping behind the curtain and down the narrow hall that leads backstage. mae’s there at a folding table with an open bag of chips and two monitors showing the live feed from your cameras.
“you’re a machine,” she says, mouth full.
you snort, sitting beside her and grabbing something off the snack spread. the monitors flicker with alternating shots, like the band bathed in red light, sweat on their necks, the crowd’s hands reaching like waves.
you lean forward, resting your chin on your hand as you watch. every so often, you murmur something into the walkie: “tighten the frame. yeah, that’s better,” or “hold that shot until he turns.”
mae chews, glances over. “this is gonna be good. i can feel it.”
you don’t answer. you’re too focused. the concert stretches on for another hour or so, long enough for the monitors to turn from blue to gold to near-black as the lights shift for the encore. when it’s finally over, the band jogs offstage, laughing, breathless. one of your cameramen follows close, capturing luca wiping sweat with a towel and grinning, orion shouting something about “that last chord,” nox raising her drumsticks like a victory flag. rafe’s there too, grinning wide, a flash of teeth, his eyes briefly catching the lens before he disappears past it.
you stand, tucking your headset off, nodding to mae. “alright,” you say softly, almost to yourself.
the rest happens smoothly. the makeshift interview room is already cleared backstage, low lights and two chairs facing each other with a single camera trained between them. someone’s placed bottles of water and towels in the corner.
it’s time to start the diary footage. mae hovers nearby, letting you handle the first round. you glance over at the others in hair and makeup, each one waiting their turn, fiddling with phones or headphones, shooting little glances toward the monitors where you’ll later sync everything.
the first one is luca, hands folded loosely in his lap, legs bouncing just a little as he smiles easily at you. he leans forward in the chair the second you gesture for him to start.
“we didn’t think anyone would care about four kids playing in a garage,” he says. he laughs softly, like the memory is both funny and unbelievable. “i mean . . . it was just us, instruments no one wanted, riffs we ripped off from old bands we loved, and a lot of late nights arguing over chord progressions and lyrics that didn’t make any fuckin’ sense—am i allowed to swear?”
you tilt your head, letting the camera roll as you ask the first few guiding questions, “so what made you stick with it? why keep playing together?”
he shrugs like it’s obvious. “i don’t know. we just found a rhythm. rafe had that spark, ri could turn any random idea into something that actually worked, and i guess someone had to keep us from completely losing it long enough to actually get a song finished. that ended up being me.”
you nod, scribbling a few notes in your pad while watching his eyes light up as he talks. the way he gestures, it’s clear he loves sharing this story, loves that someone’s actually listening. you ask him about his background, like how he grew up, what drew him into music.
“my parents moved from puerto rico when i was ten,” he says, “so, like . . . everything felt new, like different language, different beaches, different vibes. i had to figure out who i was really quick, and music was my thing. i had a landscaping job one summer to make enough for strings and gas on my own. didn’t matter what anyone else thought, i just wanted to play. like it wasn’t rebellion, not really. it was more like boredom, or pressure. figure eight’s full of money but short on air, you know? you can’t breathe unless you build your own world.”
you ask about their first gigs. he leans back, thinking, hands drumming lightly on his knees. “some house parties, random bars, once at a friend’s dad’s warehouse. nothing fancy. mostly just to see if people would show up. and when nox joined? that changed everything.”
orion’s calmer and quieter when he comes in for his interview. he adjusts the collar of his shirt.
“saint halo really started to make sense once we realized we wanted more than noise,” he says. “i grew up around music my whole life, classical piano, jazz, the whole thing. rafe and luca were kind of . . . chaos incarnate? they could make this messy, emotional stuff, but it needed structure. i provided that. added synth, layered guitars, textures. it was the first time i felt like someone else really understood what i wanted to hear.”
you ask him how they all came together.
“we knew each other in school,” he says carefully, “but we didn’t really hang out ‘til after graduation. different circles, i guess. our parents all had these plans for us. college, finance, business degrees, whatever. but none of us wanted that. we just wanted to play.”
you nod, smiling softly. then nox takes her turn a few questions later. she slides in like she’s only half-interested, but there’s still this carefulness, a hint that she’s clearly media trained. she’s moody, but it’s contained.
“their old drummer bailed before the first gig,” she says bluntly, like that explains everything. “i read the sheet once, figured i’d just play it by ear after. i played it close enough to near-perfect the first try. they asked me to stay. i didn’t really think about it beyond that.”
you raise an eyebrow, letting the camera capture the slight shrug she gives. “so you knew them before the band?”
“yeah, school,” she says casually, tapping the side of the chair. “but we didn’t really . . . hang out until after i graduated. they graduated before me.”
you nod. you don’t need the extra drama on camera, just the essence of it. “so you were kind of the final piece?” you ask.
“i guess,” she says. “kept the rhythm.”
and now, all four of them are backstage in hair and makeup again to regroup and wait for each to finish.
you glance at the monitors again after nox is done, and you see rafe pacing slightly. it’s not anxiety, probably just passing time. he catches your eye for a moment through the reflection of a mirror and then looks away.
you’re still hunched slightly over your notebook, pen scratching as you jot down notes from the last interview. the pages are crowded with observations, like little personality quirks, things to remember for continuity, moments you might want to reference when editing. your head’s down, focused.
mae appears beside you quietly, hands folded in front of her. she stands there for a beat, watching you, tilting her head slightly as if measuring your mood.
“you ready for rafe?” she asks finally.
you barely lift your eyes, still scribbling, fumbling slightly with your pen. “uh, yeah, yeah,” you murmur, distracted. your free hand smooths down your shirt as you shift, trying to get comfortable on the chair again, uncrossing and recrossing your legs to prepare yourself for the next one.
mae nods once and slips away toward the hall to call rafe in. you barely register any of the murmurs over walkies, someone checking the camera, the faint scratch of a notepad on a clipboard.
you don’t pay any mind when rafe enters. mae and nate are speaking with him a few feet away, hands gesturing, heads nodding, giving him quiet instructions on how to act for the cameras, what to expect, how to settle into the room like they did with the others. you catch only fragments of movement, like him nodding, his hesitation on whether they’re done talking to him so he can finally sit, but you don’t look up.
mae’s voice floats over to you, calling your name. you glance up slowly, placing your palms flat on top of your crossed legs, feeling the cool edge of the chair beneath your fingers.
he’s there, sitting across from you. the chair swallows part of his frame, but he leans just enough to the side. his cheek rests against his index finger, his thumb tucked beneath his chin.
your pen hovers over the notebook again, but you don’t write. you glance at him one last time. “you ready?” you ask softly.
he tilts his head, smirking slightly, and gives a slow nod. you exhale quietly and turn toward your crew, a subtle motion with your hand. they nod back, red dots blinking on the sides of cameras, microphones clicking to life. they’re recording.
you clear your throat, “so, let’s start with the obvious. how did saint halo first come together?”
he leans back just slightly, but he answers. it’s the same as the others, just worded differently. the first gig with nox is the same deal.
you nod, letting it sit. you shift slightly, leaning forward, curious eyes tracking his gestures. “walk me through a typical writing session with the band. how do songs start? what’s your inspiration?”
he tilts his head, thoughtful now, fingers drumming lightly against his knee. “depends,” he says slowly. “sometimes a riff hits, someone hums a melody, a word pops into someone’s head. sometimes we sit in silence until someone cracks. most of the time, the inspiration is regret. sometimes love. mostly the same thing, just dressed up differently.”
your pen scribbles furiously, but your eyes flick up at him unconsciously. he watches you, just enough that it feels deliberate, almost teasing. “and,” he pauses, casual, “every now and then, someone or something inspires a line, a hook. you wouldn’t even notice unless you’re listenin’ close.”
you clear your throat, humming. “so then how do you manage creative disagreements? does it get messy?”
he laughs quietly, “all the time. we argue, we mock each other, we literally threaten to quit mid-song. but it works! it works. we need the chaos, honestly. without it, we’d be boring.”
you nod. “there will be new listeners after this, there are currently people who’ve never exprienced saint halo. how would you describe the band’s sound to someone who’s never heard you before?”
“rough around the edges,” he says, almost smiling. “but it’s personal. like, if someone played their diary through a speaker, that’s basically us.“
you hum with a half-smile. you actually hate that you like the sound of that. he leans back again, hands resting lightly on his thighs, gaze drifting to the ceiling for a moment before snapping back to you.
you pause your notes for a moment, and decide to go for something a little heavier. “so do you have any regrets going into this career? anything you’d do differently?” your voice is careful.
he tilts his head, eyes narrowing as if weighing how much to give. he lets out a long breath, fingers brushing across his knee, tapping lightly. “regrets . . .” he starts slowly, almost like the word tastes funny on his tongue. he exhales lazily, having to think about it at first. you almost think he doesn’t have any until he continues. “i mean, sure. everyone has them. maybe some songs i wish i’d never written, shows i could’ve skipped.”
maybe it’s because of your history, but it isn’t exactly the answer you’d hoped for. as the manager of this project, it’s a solid answer. you nod, pen moving again, jotting down a few more notes as he watches you intently.
“maybe a few decisions that burned bridges i shouldn’t have.”
you scribble, but your eyes flick up to him briefly. it’s deliberate, the way he avoids naming names, avoids specifics. you almost, just for a moment, assume that’s actually aimed at you, but you’d be stupid for thinking so. maybe. most likely. you brush over it, not thinking about what that could even mean.
he leans back, crossing his arms lazily as if he’s done with the topic. “but honestly?” he says, shrugging. “every mistake led here. every late night, every chord, every fight got me to a place i can stand on stage, play my music, ‘n actually mean it.”
your stomach sinks a little, a faint knot forming. not because he’s lying, not exactly, but because you know him. you’re grateful he’s found his place. you shouldn’t be upset about anything else.
you scribble a note anyway, trying to capture what he actually said, not what you wanted him to say. “got it,” you murmur quietly and glance back at the cameras to ensure the framing catches everything perfectly.
he’s charismatic. he’s effortless. he’s captivating. but he’s not giving you that one answer you’ve been wondering about for years. not yet, you don’t think, anyway.
the cameras roll, capturing the frontman of saint halo in his element, and you let the disappointment settle quietly in your chest, tucked away beneath your notes and your carefully curated professionalism, and you move on.
➤ summary: your and the girls' little trip into nature ends up in you getting hurt and having no other option but to call Rafe
➤ w/c: 4.3k
➤ warnings: fluff, mild injury, lots of tension, grumpy Rafe, protective and soft Rafe, best friend's brother trope
masterlist taglist
It was already past afternoon when the sun started getting lower and setting the wild trails far away from Figure Eight in that warm and golden color. The trees all around you looked giant and intimidating with the way they were moving softly high in the sky with the soft breeze.
You, Sarah, and Kie decided on a whim to hike out to the old lookout point near the bluffs—a spot Sarah swore had the best view of the sunset and where she and Rafe used to go when they were younger and the world didn’t set them apart.
JJ, John B, and Pope needed to do something they swore was mega important on almost the other end of the island, and knowing them, Cleo volunteered to go there and make sure that they stayed out of trouble. So there were the three of you, almost in the middle of nowhere, with backpacks full of snacks and water and, well, just too much optimism about the “easy” trail and a promising view at the end.
You all walked at a steady pace, talking about Sarah’s latest little fight with John B, while you looked around with awe and relished the peace and fresh air. The path turned rocky; the big roots of the old trees peeked out from the ground here and there. You tried to step carefully, looking down and not rushing to not trip over your own feet, but in one moment something went wrong.
You didn’t even know what actually grabbed your attention or why you suddenly got distracted, but the second you did, you felt your feet sliding down the slippery and moss-covered root, making your ankle twist in a way that shot a hot-white pain through you.
“Shit— ow, ow, ow!” You gasped when your body fell on the ground, almost in agony. Reaching out for the source of pain instinctively, you hissed when your fingers trailed the already swelling place on your leg. The girls turned at the sound, instantly crouching in front of you with worried and scared eyes.
“Oh God, what happened?” Sarah reached out carefully, hand hovering just above your leg so as not to hurt you.
You blinked away the sudden tears in your eyes, which appeared before you could even notice it. “I— Fuck, I slipped on something. It hurts so badly, and I think it’s starting to swell.”
Kie twisted your leg carefully, examining the damage. “Can you put a weight on it?”
You tried to place your foot on the ground, barely even touching it, yet your vision instantly blurred from the pure and agonizing pain.
“Nope. Nope, definitely not.”
The three of you stared at each other in dawning horror. The trail back to the main road was long, not to mention that then you had to find a way to get back home because you decided that a half-hour walk from Tanneyhill to here would be a great warm-up. A stupid decision, you now thought. The boys would probably take forever to get there, and by the time they would be able to find you in an unknown territory, it would already be dark.
Sarah stood up, pulling out her phone and biting her thumb while she was thinking. “I could call dad, but he said he has a meeting today. Rose… she’s like totally useless.” She hesitated, before looking at you with expression that you though was somewhere between guilt and pity. You didn’t like that. “There one other person, who can get here fast and who know the place…”
“Rafe.” You said it flatly, and she nodded, while Kie scoffed and rolled her eyes beside you.
Sarah winced. “He owes me, and he knows these paths better than I do since he liked to hide here all the time. Plus…” Her voice dropped, like she was not sure whether it was okay to say it or not. “He’s weirdly not awful to you. Like, he tolerates you more than anyone else.”
“Tolerates. Such high praise.” You snorted despite the throbbing feeling in your ankle.
But you knew that there was truth behind it. You and Sarah were inseparable since you both were twelve, and all that time Rafe had no other choice but to have you around, especially during sleepovers at Tanneyhill. He had grown up watching you two, always grumbling something about you being insufferable together, yet… not actually doing anything to avoid you or scare you away. Instead, over time he started watching his tone when you were around. When the random dudes got too handsy and weird at the parties, he told them to fuck off. Once, he gave you his hoodie when someone spilled a drink all over your shirt. Another time he gave you a lift when you had no other way to get back home.
He watched out for you—subtly, carefully, never letting you know that he was caring or paying attention.
He never explained himself, and you never asked.
So asking him, of all people, to come and play some kind of savior for you? Yeah, that seemed totally ridiculous.
“He will be angry. Or just laugh and ignore it.” You sighed, dropping your head back and trying to even your breathing when the pain mixed with the sudden anxiety started pooling low in your stomach. “Or probably both.”
“Yeah, he literally called me a weirdo hippie the last time we saw each other.” Kie rolled her eyes, plopping down beside you with a grunt.
You laughed. “And before that you called him a freak because you thought he was following us.”
“Okay, I’m calling.” Sarah merged in while she was walking around you with an extended hand and trying to find a better signal.
A few long minutes had passed before you heard long dials, feeling suddenly sick and, if it was possible, even more nervous about the whole situation.
“What?” Rafe’s voice came out sharply, like he was already annoyed with Sarah’s call.
“Hey, Rafey.” Sarah said sweetly, using the nickname he absolutely despised. “We need a favor.”
“I’m busy.” He said after a long pause, and you could imagine him rolling his eyes or pinching the bridge of his nose.
“We’re kinda stuck on these trails away from the Figure Eight. Y/N twisted her ankle, like pretty badly, and she can’t walk. Me and Kie can’t carry her.”
Silence, then a long sigh. You bit your lip, wincing and waiting for the worst. “You idiots. Why the hell did you even go there? After the fucking rain and without telling anyone?”
“Can you come? Please?” Sarah ignored his lectures, using her best not-annoyed voice. “We’re like… two miles away from the east access point.”
“Fine.” He muttered. “But if it’s a joke, I swear—“
“It’s not.” Sarah interrupted. “Thanks.”
He hung up the phone.
You looked down at the ground, weirdly interested in the grass near you, feeling that your face was burning with embarrassment.
Probably almost an hour later, when you already couldn’t feel your ass from sitting on the solid ground, while girls tried to distract you and cheer you up, you finally heard solid steps somewhere not too far away.
Rafe appeared around the bend, wearing faded gray shorts, a blue shirt, and that perpetual scowl. His hair was messy from the wind, and he looked like he’d been interrupted mid-workout—or mid-nap—and wasn’t thrilled about it.
He took one look at the three of you and shook his head. “Un-fucking-believable. You three couldn’t go for a walk in the neighborhood like normal people?”
Sarah stood up. “Hi to you too.”
He ignored her, looking straight at you, and you swore you saw the instant change in his eyes—maybe concern, maybe relief—but you could’ve just imagined that. He walked closer, crouching in front of you.
“Show me.”
You hesitated, but his eyes weren’t angry or accusing; you slowly and carefully lifted your injured leg off the ground. Rafe’s fingers, surprisingly gentle and careful, examined your ankle, touched the swollen place, then ever-so-slightly twisted it. You hissed, nails digging into your thigh from the pain.
“Easy.” He murmured. “Don’t think that it’s broken, probably just a bad sprain. You tried putting something cold on it?”
“No ice in the wilderness, Rafe.” Kie scoffed from behind him.
“No shit. There’s no ice when you’re irresponsible enough to go out here without a fucking first aid kit.” He looked back over his shoulder at Kie and his sister, making them both roll their eyes. Probably for the hundredth time. “Where are your other Boy Scouts, anyway?”
“They are busy on the other side of the island and couldn’t come.”
“Of course. Useless per usual.” He gently placed your leg back on the ground, standing up. “What if a storm rolled in? Or if there was no service?”
“Okay, we get it, Dad.” Sarah sighed, pointing back at you. “Are you gonna help us or what?”
“Not “us”, but her. You two can figure it out yourselves.”
“Asshole.” Kie grumbled.
“Shut up.” Rafe snapped back, but there was no actual heat in it.
Then he crouched again, turning his back to you and looking at you over his shoulder. “Get on.”
You blinked stupidly. “What?”
“Get on my back. Before I change my mind and leave you here.”
Your heart slammed against your ribs, mouth suddenly dry. Rafe Cameron—Rafe—was offering to piggyback you. The same Rafe who once called you “Sarah’s annoying shadow.” The same Rafe whose hand you’d accidentally brushed in their kitchen once and felt like it electrocuted you—you were scared to even look at him after that.
You swallowed. “I… I don’t want to hurt you. Or make it weird.”
He glanced over his shoulder again, blue eyes narrowed but softer than usual. “You’re not heavy. And it’s already weird. Just get on before I drag you.”
“I thought you were going to just…” You stopped yourself.
“Going to what?”
“…I don’t know.” You mumbled after a few seconds because, literally, what else were you expecting to happen? Him teleporting you back home?
“Mhm, exactly. Now move.”
You looked back at your friends, Kie with a frown on her face and Sarah looking like she was trying to hold back a smile and failing miserably, who then nodded in agreement with Rafe.
With a shaky breath and a grunt of pain you tried to swallow down, you shifted forward. Your arms tentatively landed on his shoulders, your chest just barely touched his back, trying to keep space in between your bodies. Rafe’s hands touched your thighs, then slid under your knees when he tried to place you comfortably and gently on his back to not disturb your foot.
He stood up easily, readjusting your position and gripping your legs a little bit tighter. You tried to stop the fluttering in your chest that made your neck and face burn from the skin-on-skin contact.
He made a frustrated groan. “You’re gonna fall off like that. Lean in, dumbass. I’m not gonna drop you.”
That was actually the last thing you were thinking about.
“I—okay.”
You pressed a big closer. Your chest meeting the solid warmth of his back. Arms slid just a bit lower—enough to loop around his neck, but not enough to choke or make too much contact.
Rafe nodded like he was still not satisfied with your position but let it slide just for now. He told the girls to carry your bags, follow him, and look where they were stepping in that annoyed yet protective way only Rafe Cameron could master.
He started walking, moving steadily like there was no weight on his back. Carefully enough to not disturb your leg or let you hit any low-hanging branches. Sarah and Kie were somewhere behind you, seemingly far enough that you could barely understand what they were talking about. The pain in your ankle was a bit duller now, or maybe you were just too aware of the situation, and your mind pushed it somewhere aside just for now.
The heat of his body seeped to you through the thin material of your clothes. The unmistakable smell of his cologne—something warm, woody, and expensive—invaded your senses. With the way you were seated, you swore you could see and feel the way his muscles moved with every step, making it way too hard to focus on anything else.
You tried to hold yourself still, your posture stiff and detached, to not make it seem too weird or too intimate. Because touching Rafe Cameron, being so close to him, wasn’t something that you allowed yourself to think about. And this was just a favor—nothing more, nothing less.
Just a few minutes after, your back started killing you from an awkward and way too rigid position. You wiggled slightly, pulling backwards, making Rafe adjust and grip under your legs tighter to hold you still.
“Stop fighting it.” He grumbled low enough that only you could hear it. “You’re yanking me off balance.”
“Sorry.” Your voice sounded small and hesitant.
“Just… relax. Lean against me properly. Wrap your hands tighter if you need to. I got you, I promise.” He said it a bit softer, barely slowing down his rhythm.
Your heart stuttered. Slowly, you forced your body to comply—you leaned forwards, now fully leaning against his back, letting your hands wrap a bit tightly around his neck with your fingers feeling the solid muscles on his shoulders. Your cheek rested on your own forearm just mere inches from his own face, in a position that gave you a perfect opportunity to stare at his side profile up close.
You exhaled deeply as the last remaining tension bled out of you.
“There.” He hummed, almost gently. “That’s better.”
You nodded. “Yeah. Thanks, Rafe.”
He didn’t reply right away. Just kept walking, pace steady. Sarah and Kie trailed behind, talking softly, giving you space. You felt yourself getting sleepy from the motion and smell that fully enveloped you until Rafe just barely turned his head. His soft blue eyes caught yours instantly, and with the way your heart started pounding against your ribs, you swore he could feel it too, because he was close—way too close to be innocent and normal.
“How’s your leg?” He looked away, focusing back on the trail.
“Um, it’s okay. Pulsating, but bearable.”
“You scared me there.”
“I did?” You furrowed, stunned.
“Yeah.” Rafe nodded once, voice lower. “When Sarah called me and said you couldn’t walk.”
“Oh… I thought I annoyed you.” You laughed even if admitting it out loud stung something deep in you—something you couldn’t name. “I thought you would be mad and tell us to deal with it ourselves.”
“You do annoy me, but like… in a good way. I wouldn’t leave you here, especially hurt, you know that?” Rafe’s voice suddenly sounded serious when he side-eyed you to catch your reaction.
You hesitated. “I guess now I do.” Your fingers tightened on his shoulder ever so slightly, and you swore you saw a soft smirk forming on Rafe’s lips before silence fell around you again.
When fifteen minutes later you saw a familiar view of the parking lot, Rafe suddenly shifted you slightly higher on his back, grip steady and firm on your legs. Protective.
“You owe me.” He said gruffly.
“Name it.”
The silence seemed heavy when Rafe hesitated to say something back to you. Your eyes studied the side of his face again, now a bit more openly, seeing the way he stared right ahead of him, yet it seemed like the answer sat heavy on his tongue and he couldn’t bring himself to say it.
The trail slowly flattened out into the gravel of the parking lot, and you finally saw Rafe’s dark blue SUV sitting lonely under the tree and the fading orange light of the sky.
“Dinner.” It came out so suddenly you thought you imagined it. Your breath caught.
“Not like some fancy bullshit at the Figure Eight or whatever.” He added quickly, suddenly almost tripping over his own words. “Just something nice. Without others. You can pick any place if you want. Or I can. I mean—whenever you’re not hobbling around like a baby deer.”
It wasn’t a question, and it wasn’t a demand either. Like Rafe said it in a way that made an easy escape just in case you said no or laughed at the idea. Your mind just went blank for a moment, because there was no way he actually meant what you just heard.
Your face went hot, your brain suddenly very aware of how tightly you were pressed against him and how his fingers twitched under your legs as if from nerves.
“…Diner.” You repeated, slowly, catching the way his jaw clenched.
“Yeah.” He shrugged one shoulder like it was no big deal, but you felt the tension in his frame. “You owe me. That’s the price.”
You bit your lip so hard you tasted blood. “Okay.” You said before you could overthink it into oblivion. “Dinner. Deal.”
Rafe didn’t say anything else, but you felt the corner of his mouth twitch against your forearm.
When you finally reached the car, Rafe let you carefully slide off his back. You landed on your good leg, but the moment you did, he turned around and lifted you up again—this time in bridal style.
You tried to protest, but the girls came into the view, talking about him being way too fast while they got in the back seat of the car, seemingly not paying attention to the position you were currently in.
Rafe maneuvered you slowly, opening the passenger door with one hand and placing you down carefully. He crouched beside you, adjusting your leg and making sure that you were comfortable.
“Try to not put any pressure on it.” You just nodded, because the words were stuck in your throat.
To make things worse, Rafe leaned over you, his shoulder brushing your chest, when he reached for the seatbelt and clicked it into place, his fingers brushing your thigh. Your eyes flicked up when your breath caught in your throat, and for a second he froze too, just looking down at you.
Your heart dropped into your stomach, face heating under his gaze once again. When Rafe finally moved away and closed the door, you closed your eyes just to pull yourself together.
He sat in the driving seat, and the car roared to life. The girls were whispering something in the back, completely oblivious to the tension between you and Rafe.
He tried to keep his focus on the road, not letting himself get too distracted with you. But your presence affected him in a way he couldn’t explain, and his eyes flickered to you every few minutes.
Your hand rested near the console in between your seats. Rafe’s hand, restless, found a place there too—close enough that you could feel his warmth. You stared straight ahead, pretending to watch the trees blur past. Your fingers twitched, and the next moment his hand touched yours—barely, way too timid at first. But when you didn’t pull away, his pinky wrapped around yours.
You still looked out of the window. No reaction on your face, even if inside everything was burning.
Ten minutes later he pulled outside of your house, and before Rafe could even kill the engine, Sarah leaned forward in between two front seats, looking at Rafe with a twinkle in her eyes. His hand shot away from yours.
“You should take her home, Rafe. Me and Kie will wait here, yeah?” She looked back at Kie encouraging her to agree. Rafe’s eyes bored into yours, looking at your reaction.
“Fine, but don’t touch anything in here. Don’t want you two rummaging through my shit.” He grumbled, unfastening his seatbelt.
“Bruh, wouldn’t touch anything with a three-foot pole. Don’t even want to know what freaks like you even do in their cars.” Kie’s face twisted when she folded her arms, trying to take up as little space as possible.
Rafe’s jaw clenched. “Shut up before I drop you off on the street and make you walk back home.”
“Could you both stop?”
Rafe glared at you, but neither of them said anything else. Rafe hopped out of the car, while you opened the door and tried to step on the ground safely, but he was at your side in a second—sliding one of his hands under your legs and placing the other one on your back.
You made a soft gasp, hands wrapping around his neck involuntarily to hold yourself back from falling.
“Rafe… I can do it myself. It’s not that far.” You protested, embarrassed that he had to carry you around for the third time today.
“Don’t want you to hop around like a flamingo.” He pressed your body closer to his, leaving no room for any protests from you. Your head dropped lazily against his shoulder in surrender, as you used an opportunity to stare at him again, and from this position you were able to notice the faint freckles on the bridge of his nose and cheeks. You nuzzled closer, hiding a smile.
Rafe reached the door in a few long steps, taking your keys and fidgeting with the lock until the door opened in front of you.
The house was dark and quiet; your mom was still probably at work and oblivious to your little trip; the soft scent of candles and something weirdly yours filled Rafe’s lungs, and he breathed in deeply like he couldn’t get enough. It was the first time he went further than the front steps when a few times he dropped things that you accidentally left in Tanneyhill.
You guided him through the house, insisting again that you can go upstairs yourself and meeting with the same response as before. Rafe finally entered your room, carefully placing you on the bed and looking around for a pillow to rest your foot on, but also stealing glances at the interior around. The books on the table, your heels on the floor near the dresser, a giant mirror with photos tucked into the corners of the frame, and plushies all over your bed. It was cozy, warm, felt so lived in, and tugged at something deep inside him—something that made him want to stay just a bit longer.
Rafe got the ice from downstairs, towering over the bed to arrange everything.
“Here.” He murmured, covering your ankle with a packet of ice that made you wince but feel some kind of relief at the same time. “Keep it elevated. Ice for twenty minutes. Don’t put any pressure on your leg, okay? You can text me if you need anything.”
“Okay.” You looked up at Rafe, your voice barely above a whisper. He nodded, his hand lingering on your leg a few moments longer than necessary before taking a few steps back. “Thank you.”
The tension was so heavy when your eyes were locked on each other. You knew he wanted to say something more, seeing the way his lips parted and his hand flew out almost nervously to rub the back of his neck.
But then he just nodded, jaw tight, and turned away to leave.
Fuck it.
You moved before your brain could scream at you and convince you to stop. Rafe’s name slipped softly from your lips, the ice pack falling down on the floor with a heavy thud when you jumped up on one leg.
“What the hell are you—” Your hands grabbed his shirt the moment Rafe turned around, tugging him closer and down to your level.
Your lips touched his. Rafe groaned in surprise, stiff as steel against you, but the moment you pulled away and looked at him—embarrassed, mortified that you read it all wrong—he moved forward.
Rafe’s right hand held your face, the other one steadied you at your waist to help you stand on one leg. He loomed over you, fully enveloping you with his broad form, and finally kissing you the way he meant to for a long time—greedily, messily, like it was still not enough to satisfy him.
You both pulled back after a while, staring at each other and smiling the moment the reality hit you. Rafe tugged you closer, for the first time feeling he had permission to hold you against him and relish the moment.
“I don’t mind this type of payment, but you won’t wiggle your way out of the dinner, y’know?” He teased, smiling, against your temple. Your hands found their place on his shoulders and squeezed softly.
“Yeah, just… felt like doing it.” You whispered.
Rafe finally laughed, backing you softly towards the bed with a strong hand around you. He arranged everything again—your foot up on the pillows, ice pack—and then leaned over you, hands pressed on both sides of your hips, face just inches away from yours.
“Next time, just ask.” He murmured before kissing you again—now, slowly, tenderly, taking his sweet time to taste you. “I’ll text you later.”
“Okay.”
When he left, you fell back against the pillow, staring at the ceiling of your room and feeling like it all was a fever dream. The pain in your leg was now the last thing you thought about.
Your phone pinged beside you with a notification.
Sarah: you two TOTALLY kissed
Sarah: he’s trying to hold back a smile, i swear
You threw the phone down without an answer, covering your face with both hands and feeling that you couldn’t hold back a smile either.
Maybe the day wasn’t as bad as you thought at first.
pairing: rafe cameron x pogue!f!reader, (not au, both are early 20s)
word count: 4.3k
summary: maybe you're not as special to rafe as you think you are
warnings: SUGGESTIVE (read at ur own risk, minors dni), slow burn???????, angst???????, kook!rafe x pogue!reader, fratboy!rafe x goodstudent!reader, mention of drugs, alcohol, and nicotine [vaping], injury, i made up a university, reader is friends with sarah, reader is on the anxious side, pining!reader???, not proofread
a note: i may or may not have based some of rafe's actions off of the guy i've been seeing
please reblog and like, it means a lot! let me know what you think!
The party is so loud, even from across the street.
You cling to Sarah, hand clasped into hers as she leads you through the lawn up to the frat house. Not just any frat house, Kappa Phi Alpha, the most prestigious fraternity at the most prestigious and expensive Kook-ridden campus, Helios University. You were new, ish, a late transfer student with only a year and a half left, having done your first three and a half years at a community college across the thoroughfare to the mainland. You had applied on a whim to please your parents, staring in awe at the acceptance letter you received months later. They had even accepted your financial aid. You were a lone Pogue fish, lost in a sea of Kook sharks, and they were out for blood.
Sarah shoves past drunk guys, all standing huddled in circles passing around a vape, trying to suck the plastic dry. She looks at you over her shoulder. “You look terrified. I told you we should’ve pregamed.”
You immediately shake your head. “I don’t want to get too drunk. I have class in the morning,” You nearly trip as a group of girls pushes past you, eager to get to the front of the line. “And so do you.”
“You can skip one class,” Sarah says, pulling you closer as you approach the front of the line. The frat boy standing guard goes to shoo you away, towards the back of the line, but she interrupts him before he can get the words out. “I’m on the list. I’m Sarah, Rafe’s sister,” The frat boy eyes you suspiciously, looking you up and down. Sarah rolls her eyes. “She’s with me, dummy. Rafe told me he put both of us down.”
The frat boy checks his phone, thumb scrolling through his notes app before nodding, bringing his vape to his lips. “Right. Sorry. Have fun, you two. And don’t take any bottles home, alright?” You and Sarah both nod as she leads you inside, hand still gripped tight in yours. She pats the frat boy on his shoulder, sticking one arm out to weave through the crowd. You instinctively shrink in on yourself, shoulders moving up to your ears as you make your way into the living room.
Sarah tugs you close once you reach an empty spot, nestled against one of the large bay windows that looks out to the pool in the backyard. “Alright, we made it in!” Her tone is excited, a giant smile on her face, until she sees the sour look on yours. “Please, at least try to have fun. You don’t have to drink, I guess, but just…” She sighs, cupping your face. “Just let loose a little. Chat up some guys. Or some girls.”
You cover her hands with yours. “Fine. I’ll try.” And you would, at least a little bit.
“Good,” Sarah lets go of your face. “I gotta say hi to some girls from my Fashion Design class. If you need anything, just come get me, okay?” She’s already walking away, looking at you over her shoulder.
“Okay.” You give her a thumbs-up, forcing a smile.
Sarah smiles and nods, turning around to keep walking when she suddenly stops, whipping her head back around. “Oh! And don’t drink a drink that you didn’t see poured!”
You nod, giving her another thumbs up, watching desperately as she practically skips away towards a group of girls on the other side of the living room, phone propped up on the dining table as they film a TikTok. You try to relax, forcing your shoulders to drop as you take a deep breath. Your hands flex and unflex, and you fight the urge to fidget.
You head into the kitchen, grabbing one of the last Coke Zeros from a bright blue cooler on the counter, wiping the condensation off on your jeans. You open it before taking a generous sip, slipping out of the kitchen as a large group comes in, chanting to themselves about tequila shots.
And that’s when you see him.
Rafe Cameron, Kook prince of Kildare, climbing on top of the rickety coffee table in between three dingy, beer-stained couches, stabbing the bottom of a beer can with a pocket knife before bringing it to his lips, opening the can with his right hand, head tilting back. Frothy, amber liquid travels down his neck, over his chain, and underneath his polo.
You feel your face grow hot as shameful desire grows in your gut. Not only was he the president of his fraternity, apparently the biggest asshole on the planet and renowned player, but he was Sarah’s brother. You’d never spoken to him, only hearing rumours from some girls in your class and stories from your roommate as she anxiously awaited a text back from him. You heard enough, you thought; he was a douche, a player, and only kept girls around that he considered a good fuck. You had decided, then, that you didn’t want anything to do with him.
It didn’t matter how pretty he was or how hot he looked as he pulled the beer can away from his mouth, crushing it between his strong fist as he sticks his arms up above his head in celebration as his friends and admirers cheer him on, biceps bulging deliciously out of his polo sleeves, smirk plastered on his sculpted face, you couldn’t have him. You shouldn’t want him this bad.
There was a reason he was given the title of Kook Prince, and he knew it. Rafe thrived off of the attention. There was never a time when he wasn’t the most desired man in the room, and tonight was no different. He was the most popular guy in your entire university, and he looked the part. His gaze suddenly lands on you, eyeing you from the spot you stood in. His gaze sharpens, lips curling up more at the corners. His gaze doesn’t leave yours, even as his friend, Topper, you think Sarah called him, pats his shoulders, shoving another Coors Banquet can into his hand. His gaze flickers between you and Topper before he smiles, saying something you can’t hear as he shotguns the second can.
The cheers and claps from the group surrounding him snaps you out of whatever trance Rafe put you in. You look around, trying to appear casual as you take another sip of Coke Zero, the can slightly squished from your tight grip. He finishes the beer easily, crushing it between his fist before Topper shoves a third one into his hand. Rafe doesn’t look away from you. He pops it open, raising it to his lips and taking a deep drink, his Adam’s apple bobbing in his tan throat. His gaze is unwavering, and he doesn’t take any opportunity to move towards you, just keeping his blue eyes on you as you squirm uncomfortably.
Rafe had you right where he wanted you, even if you didn’t know it yet.
You try to distract yourself, try to keep yourself from looking over in Rafe’s direction, and try to ignore the feeling of his eyes boring into your back. You join Sarah and her friends, and you try to join their conversation before you eventually go quiet after you realise no one is listening. You opt to nod along, laughing with the rest of them, trying to appear as casual and normal as possible, like your heart isn’t racing at the thought of your best friend’s brother, like you aren’t digging your nails into your palm to keep yourself from asking her if he’s single.
The flash is bright in your face as you join in on one of the group’s TikToks, lip-syncing to a song and doing a dance you had to learn on the spot, hoping you don’t look like an idiot swaying around in the outfit you borrowed from Sarah. You peer over her shoulder as you watch the TikTok back. Your part in it is relatively short, and thankfully you don’t look too idiotic. Your eyes immediately find Rafe in the background, as he occasionally glances over at you. You’re sure he’s only looking because you’re filming a dance trend in the middle of a party, and because Sarah’s with you, but there’s a small part of your heart that hopes he was looking at just you.
Cheers erupt from the living room, and you look up, you can’t help it, eyes immediately drawn to him as he climbs up on the coffee table. Rafe says something you can’t make out before he does a handstand, his polo falling partially down to reveal his toned stomach as his other friend, and Kelce (you think), holds a keg stand tube up to his mouth, Topper holding the keg up high in the air.
Everyone’s eyes are on him as he chugs, including yours, although you’re too busy staring at his abdomen and the faint happy trail that leads into his waistband to notice the beer spilling out of his mouth and onto the coffee table. He immediately lowers his feet and stands back up, grabbing the bottom of his shirt to wipe his mouth as his eyebrows furrow. He says something else you can’t quite hear to one of his fraternity brothers, gesturing wildly to the spill now dripping onto the carpet. Rafe’s jaw clenches before he flips his fraternity brother off, everyone moving to follow him as he heads out to the backyard. One of the girls that was helplessly clinging to him all night starts to clean up the spill, shouting after him to wait up.
“What a show-off,” Sarah mumbles, bringing the mango Cutwater to her lips. “He just has to keep the attention on himself at all times.”
One of Sarah’s friends, Alaina, scoffs as she steals the can to take a sip. “Can you blame him? This party wouldn’t even be happening if he weren't here.”
Sarah grabs her drink back from Alaina, giving her a gentle smack on the arm. “Yeah, but that doesn’t change the fact that he’s an attention-seeking dick.” She sighs, leaning against the wall. She doesn’t want to be concerned, but she is, eyes anxiously heading towards the backyard.
Alaina laughs softly. “A dick that the whole campus wants. You can deny it all you want, but you can’t deny the fact that he’s hot.”
“Can we please not talk about how hot my brother is?” Sarah asks exasperatedly, eyes going wide as she pushes off the wall. “Jesus. You guys are disgusting.”
You can tell Sarah is irritated by the way her jaw clenches and the way she chews on her bottom lip, shoulders tensing. You put a hand on her forearm, rubbing it with your thumb. “Wanna go check on him? We can get some fresh air, too.”
She nods, shoulders relaxing a bit as she sets her Cutwater on the table next to your empty Coke Zero can. “Yeah. I should make sure he didn’t fall and give himself a concussion.” She doesn’t even bother saying goodbye to her friends as she links her arm with yours, pushing through the crowd to head to the sliding glass door. She pushes it open with one hand, lagging back to shut it behind you as you head into the backyard.
The air is cool on your skin, the breeze leaving goosebumps in its wake as it travels over you, brushing through your hair. It’s just as crowded outside as it is inside; most of the party goers sitting on the edge of the pool with their feet dangling in it, drinks in hand as they pass a joint around, careful not to drop it into the chlorine. Some people are just mingling around, drinks in hand as they chit-chat, occasionally swaying to the music blasting out of the large JBL speakers a frat boy set up on the deck, and there’s a group of girls you recognise sit cross-legged in the gazebo, passing a bong around, phone flash on as they record each other.
Sarah stands up on her toes, looking through the sea of people, squinting slightly as she tries to find her brother in his coral polo shirt. “I swear, this dumbass is never in one place for too long, it’s like he’s—“ She immediately stops once she hears his voice, cutting her eyes to the left, finally finding him.
Rafe is climbing up on a fold out plastic table, knocking over a long forgotten game of beer pong. The table wobbles under his weight as he stands up straight, a large smile on his face as he turns to Topper, throwing up a middle finger at the camera pointed at him. Topper laughs, taunting him as Rafe moves the top of his body down to do another handstand. The table wobbles again, but everyone ignores it as Kelce brings the tube back to Rafe’s lips, Topper’s phone being shoved back into his pocket as he holds the keg up high.
Sarah sighs to herself, shaking her head as she leads you through the crowd and towards her brother, who was now upside down, polo falling over his face and revealing his toned stomach. You try to keep yourself from looking, to keep your eyes away from the way his shoulder blades were shifting, how the muscles in his arms were flexing with the weight of his body, how the veins in his biceps were protruding, but you couldn’t. She stops a few feet below him, calling up to him. “Are you trying to give yourself a concussion? Get down from there, dumbass.”
Rafe hesitates before shifting his weight onto one hand, shooing her away with the other. He steadies himself again, hands slightly shifting under him as he tries to keep up with the keg stand. His fraternity brothers and admirers shout at him, encouraging him to keep going, to keep on chugging. Kelce holds the tube tightly as Topper films, and you can slowly see Rafe starting to falter, hands trembling a little. The muscles in his shoulders were straining with the effort of holding himself up, veins in his biceps and in the side of his neck becoming prominent as the seconds went on, and you could tell that Sarah was getting more and more irritated the longer he kept himself upside down. Her foot was now tapping at the ground, arms crossed firmly over her chest. She calls up to him again, a little more aggressive this time. “I swear to God, if your dumbass falls, and you crack yourself in the head, I’m not taking you to the hospital.”
Topper lifts the keg higher, tilting it so more beer pours out into the tube. Rafe’s eyes widen slightly before he roughly pulls back, sputtering and coughing as he tries to stable himself again, beer spilling onto the grass as Topper quickly pulls the keg down, grabbing the tube at the base. The table creaks and groans before it breaks, splitting right down the middle. Everyone stares, Sarah included, waiting for the familiar sound of Rafe losing his cool, waiting for him to jump up and yell at Kelce and Topper, blaming them for holding the keg at a weird angle, blaming the guys who built the table for doing such a shitty job. Instead, he just… lays there.
You’re the first to help him, hesitating for a second before your hand connects with his shoulder blade, slowly running over his taut muscles. He’s laying face down, forehead resting on the grass. He’s definitely awake and breathing, but he hasn’t said anything or even moved. You clear your throat, your voice soft as you gently shake his shoulder. “Are you okay?”
Rafe groans, the sound muffled by the grass his face was currently pressed against. He tries to push himself up, but his arm immediately gives out. He groans even louder, fingers grabbing at the blades of grass as he turns his head to the side to look up at you. He squints, blinking furiously, trying to get the blood to rush to his head again, for the black dots to fade away, for the dizziness to subside. He grunts softly. “Yeah… yeah, I’m totally fine. Super fine.”
You step back as Topper and Kelce move in to grab him, helping him get to his feet, even though his legs are shaking. He has one arm wrapped around either of his friend’s necks, head hanging, as they gently carry him over to a pool lounger. The table is long forgotten as everyone quickly rushes him, all clamoring to make sure he’s okay, talking over each other. Rafe waves one hand, trying to get them all to shut up and stop talking, but they all keep going, some of the girls even moving to grab him. “Enough!” He snaps, even though it hurts his head, one of his large hands going to cup it. “Everyone just shut up!”
The crowd immediately quiets, everyone shrinking back sheepishly. Some people take that as their cue to leave, slinking back and sneaking away from the group. Topper and Kelce get him stabilised on the lounger, and he puts his head in his hands, thumbs pressing into his temples. Someone tries to speak, barely getting out a squeaked ‘Rafe’ before he sticks one hand up to stop them. “Stop. Just shut up. Everyone just leave me alone.”
The group scatters, running off to act like it never happened. Topper pats his back and leaves, dragging Kelce along with him. Sarah stands there, arms still crossed, shoulders still tense. She swallows thickly, almost hesitating, before finally speaking. “I told you to get down. You never listen to me.”
“God, shut up, Sarah,” Rafe’s voice is muffled by his rough palms. “You’re the reason I fell.”
“I am not!” Sarah says, her arms falling to her sides. She purses her lips. “You fell because you climbed on top of a fold out table.”
“You distracted me,” he says. “I was focusing on balancing until you started fucking talking.”
“You were going to fall either way!” Sarah insists, taking a slight step forward.
You dig your nails into your palms. “Guys.”
“Shut the fuck up, Sarah!” Rafe snaps, looking up at her. “Can you just shut the fuck up? For once in your life?”
“Oh, fuck you, Rafe!” She crosses her arms again. “You’re just mad because you embarrassed yourself.”
When Rafe suddenly stands up, fists clenched, you slide between the two of them. “Guys, come on. Let’s just chill out, okay?” You look between the siblings, hoping they would listen to reason and not cause another fight in the middle of a party.
He seems to relax, shoulders dropping slightly as he sits back down, head going back to rest in his hands. “Can you just leave me alone? Please?” Sarah keeps her arms crossed, lips pursed as she glares at him, eyes narrowed. She opens her mouth to say something before scoffing, muttering ‘whatever’ before turning around and stomping away, back towards the house. You move to follow her, giving him one last look over your shoulder, already a few paces away when he speaks again. “Not you. You can stay.”
You turn to face him in surprise. “Are you sure?”
“Yeah,” he mumbles, rubbing his eyes. “You’re quiet. You can stay,” You mumble a quick ‘okay,’ and after standing in front of him in stunned silence for a bit, he looks up at you, blue eyes piercing into yours. “You can sit down, you know,” And you do, obediently sitting down on the lounger next to him. You look around at the party, hands moving into your lap. Everything seems to be business as usual, even after Rafe’s fall, but a few of the partygoers shoot a curious glance your way. He lets out a soft noise before putting his head back in his hands. “I think I have a concussion.”
“Do you wanna go to your room?” You ask, trying to keep your voice as soft as possible. “I can get you some water and some Advil,” There’s a long pause, and you begin to worry that you’ve overstepped, an apology already on your tongue before he nods, his left hand reaching out to grab your shoulder as he shakily stands.
You struggle to walk him through the backyard, back through the house, and upstairs to his room, the only single bedroom in the entire house. It’s bigger than you thought, and you take in the decor (or lack thereof) as you help him onto his bed. His bed is pressed up against the wall in the corner, adorned with navy sheets, a crumpled-up duvet in the middle. He has no posters on his walls, just clothes littering his floor and an equally messy desk crammed up against the same wall his bed is on. He immediately lies down, throwing his arm over his face as you head into the bathroom down the hall, finding a few packets of Advil inside a Helios University branded first aid kit.
You sit on the edge of his bed awkwardly as he takes the Advil, drinking the remnants from the water bottle on his bedside table. He crumples it up in the same manner he did to the Coors Banquet cans, tossing it aside as he looks over at you through the gap in his arms. “Thanks.”
“Yeah, no problem.” You say, smiling softly.
Rafe looks you up and down. “You’re Sarah’s friend?”
“Yeah.” You sit on your hands to keep yourself from fidgeting.
“Cool,” He closes his eyes for a split second before opening one of them, peering at you. “You can lay down next to me, you know. I don’t bite.”
Your face flushes, and you almost decline, ready to spout some lie about needing to go back downstairs, but when you look at him, biceps bulging out of his polo and his shirt riding up slightly, the words die in your throat.
It all happens so fast. One second you’re just Sarah’s friend, the next you’re his friend, and the next you’re in his bed, face down, ass up as he fucks you. At first you revel in his attention; after all, you text practically all day every day, and you’re in his room almost three times a week. Nothing makes you feel as good as being wanted by him. Sometimes he even takes you out, showing you around Figure 8, showing you all of his special spots (you especially love the cove he showed you just outside The Island Club), and paying for your outings. You don’t call them dates because you’re not sure if that’s what they are, and Rafe doesn’t call them anything.
The more you talk to Rafe, the more you’re certain that the rumours are wrong. He’s not an insufferable jackass who only thinks about himself; he’s actually a sweet and caring guy underneath the layers of self sabotage and insecurity. You feel foolish for ever believing the rumours in the first place, and although you can’t brag about him to your roommate, you wish you could, just to see her face.
Then you start to wonder if Rafe liked you. You liked him, a feeling you felt was glaringly obvious. You couldn’t hide your eager replies, often responding immediately while he took hours, or the way your eyes light up when he opens the front door of the frat house, or the way you continue to nervously stumble over your words as you settle onto his bed as he picks a movie. You never end up finishing them, usually ending up on your knees in front of him five minutes in, cock in your mouth as you try to push the feelings of dread aside.
Forget whiplash; Rafe’s actions left you feeling motion sickness. When he’s pushing your face into one of his flat pillows, hand gripping your hair at the root, you are certain he was only using you for sex, and it wouldn’t be long before you ended up thrown away like trash, just another conquest in his book. But after he cums inside, always inside, he pulls you close, rubbing your back and giving you soft kisses, usually behind your ears but sometimes covering your whole face, and he starts telling you about his dad, you start to second guess yourself. Maybe Rafe did like you, and he was just nervous. Maybe he knew that his reputation preceded him. Maybe he thought you didn’t want anything more, and you just wanted to be friends with benefits. Casual. The word tastes like bile in your throat.
After two months of being Rafe’s something, you’ve made a pact with yourself; the next time you (eagerly) accept his invitation to come over, usually already dressed and ready just in case he messages you, you convince yourself that you’re finally going to have the talk, finally going to confront him about your feelings, making it clear that you just want to know what he wants and you’re in no way pressuring him. You couldn’t risk scaring him, after all. You didn’t want him running into the arms of another woman.
But as you sink onto your knees, yet again, you try to convince yourself that you’re okay with it. That something was better than nothing. That he clearly liked you enough to keep you around. That if you just waited patiently, he would come to you, a bouquet of flowers in his hand as he asks you to be his girlfriend, officially. You didn’t know how long that would take—two more weeks, three more months, or even years—but you would wait. You’d push your expectations aside and wait obediently at his feet.
Maybe he’s your dream boy. Maybe you’re not his type.
Hiii! I have this idea what if there’s a singer or an actor who is very openly crushing on y/n and keeps mentioning her on concerts, interviews, or posts because they think she’s single but in reality she’s with Drew? I wanna see his reaction to it omg
Read the room
Pairing: Drew Starkey x fem!reader.
⟡ Main Index | ⟡Archive for Earth-1104
Classification: fluff
Word count: 0.9k
Divider by me ;)
By the time the Netflix awards rolled around, you were already braced for chaos.
These shows were always loud, overstimulating, a blur of flashing lights, curated jokes and reactions cut perfectly for social media and you’d learned long ago how to settle into the rhythm of them without letting it rattle you too much. You sat with the rest of the Outer Banks cast in your row, legs crossed neatly, fingers absentmindedly tracing the seam of Drew’s suit where his arm brushed yours, a small grounding habit neither of you acknowledged out loud anymore.
Drew looked unfairly good, calm and composed in that effortless way he had, posture relaxed, jaw set just loosely enough that only someone who knew him well would clock the tension sitting underneath. His hand rested on his thigh, close enough that your knees touched, close enough to be reassuring but still neutral in a room full of cameras that loved to linger and speculate.
The singer was announced midway through the show, the crowd erupting as he walked onstage with an easy grin and the kind of confidence that came from knowing people were already obsessed with you. You recognized him instantly, how could you not? because he’d been…enthusiastic online lately. In interviews where your name slipped out a little too casually, lyrics fans were convinced were about you and even a concert clip that had gone viral after he’d laughed into the mic and said, “Yeah, I mean, if she’s out there somewhere, I’m still waiting.”
You hadn’t addressed it publicly, you never did just like Drew hadn’t either.
Onstage, the singer thanked the audience, cracked a few jokes and then, smoothly and far too intentionally, his gaze swept the crowd before landing exactly where you sat.
“And,” he added, voice warm and teasing as the camera cut to him, “sometimes you just gotta shoot your shot, you know? Life’s short. If someone inspires you, if someone lights something up in you… you shouldn’t wait around.”
There it was, the cutaway was immediate.
The camera panned straight to your section, catching you mid-blink, your polite smile faltering for just half a second before you recovered,and then, almost cruelly, lingered long enough for the audience to notice the way the rest of the cast shifted.
Madelyn and JD’s eyes flicked to Drew without thinking. Chase bit the inside of his cheek and Rudy straight-up turned his head while both Madison and Carlacia groaned quietly, almost bracing for impact.
Drew didn’t move, at least not at first.
His expression stayed composed, mouth neutral, eyes forward but you felt the subtle tightening of his jaw, the way his shoulders squared just slightly and the breath he took through his nose like he was steadying himself. He glanced at you then, quick and searching, not jealous exactly but protective in a way that made your chest warm despite the absurdity of the moment.
You leaned in just enough to murmur, “You okay?” out of the corner of your mouth, keeping your smile intact for the cameras.
He nodded once, lips curving faintly as if amused rather than threatened. “Yeah,” he said quietly. “I’m fine. Bold choice, though.”
The audience laughed at the singer's comment, unaware of the undercurrent humming beneath the moment and the show rolled on like nothing had happened but online, it detonated.
Within minutes, clips were everywhere.
Twitter lit up first, fans posting slowed-down videos of the cast’s reactions, zooming in on Drew’s face and replaying the exact second his jaw clenched.
“WHY did the camera immediately cut to Drew 😭”
“Nah the OBX cast looking at him SENT me”
“Tell me why Drew Starkey looked like he was choosing peace”
“Sir that is a MAN who knows something we don’t”
TikTok followed, edits set to dramatic music, captions screaming:
“The way everyone glanced at Drew like ‘you gonna handle ts?’”
“He did NOT flinch. I’d be sick.”
“Y/n smiling through it like a professional but Drew?? HELLO???”
Instagram reels zoomed in on your hand brushing his arm as the moment passed, fans analyzing body language with forensic dedication.
By the next morning, the singer posted. A black-and-white photo from backstage, mic in hand, head tilted down like he was mid-thought before his appearance.
The caption read: “There’s still more people to meet, more opportunities to come and more chances to try. Live, learn, apply.”
The comments were already a mess.
“THIS IS ABOUT HER. Imagine being SO fine you got people trying to serenade you.”
“Bro just log out atp.”
“He shot his shot and accepted the L.”
“Okay but why is Drew Starkey liking this???”
Because there it was as one small, devastating detail.
Drew, who hadn’t posted in months, who barely acknowledged Instagram unless tagged by his mom or a charity, had liked the post.
He left no comment or followed his account, nor had he previously engaged with it before, just the like on that one post.
Of course the internet lost its mind and screenshots spread like wildfire.
“DREW STARKEY LIKED IT. I REPEAT. HE LIKED IT.”
“That’s not a coincidence, that's a STATEMENT.”
“Man said ‘Good choice, now keep it moving.’”
“This is the quietest loud response I’ve ever seen.”
When you showed him the chaos later that night, curled up together on the couch with his arm draped lazily around your shoulders, he glanced at your phone and scoffed softly.
“What?” he said, amused. “He was respectful.”
You looked up at him, smiling. “You never like posts.”
He shrugged, pressing a kiss to the top of your head, voice low and easy. “Felt appropriate.” And somehow, that one tiny tap on a screen said more than any speech or official statement ever could.