https://www.tumblr.com/yusiyomogi/819425836279185408/httpswwwtumblrcomyusiyomogi81942218044512665
No, you didn’t sound like that at all. I was just sharing some thoughts I had because I had the same initial reaction that it seems like Louis’s is being kinda provocative and I had to track back and consider why he would
I agree that the writing is not up to par but I’m approaching it from a character perspective and what lines up with these characters overall in their storylines. Even if the writers don’t remember Louis’s trauma and the fact that he also has valid complaints against Lestat and even if they don’t give him the agency to actually bring that up (especially the fact that he did the interview still thinking he was talking about Claudia’s murderer) I will remember all that
I do think Louis is overall conflicted but I also see very narrow POV elsewhere that he should be feeling regret, remorse etc with no regard for any resentment or fear of getting close to Lestat again that he might be feeling himself
And I’m of the belief that his apology for the drop was irrelevant because there’s no space for real dialogue or for the wounded individual to fully express themselves and their hurt when they are in the middle of being lynched and threatened with violence if they dare speak out of turn so even the drop is still relatively unaddressed to me. Until Louis is allowed to speak his piece, it was not an apology but just a monologue of Lestat crying about how bad HE feels (I do believe he was 100% genuine but the point still stands that only he was allowed a voice with regards to that issue)
And I fully understand why Louis would feel resentful and even angry because if I stuck it out through DECADES of Antoinette, being mocked through my depression and then being violently assaulted, I’d be pretty damn pissed to not even be given the grace of a conversation for the crime of telling my story and then being betrayed and having my consent stomped on
Like I understand Lestat’s psychology and why we’re seeing him act this way but I also understand Louis’s side too and it feels like we are few and far in between in doing so
I don’t blame anyone for feeling disappointed or wary. The writers do not have a perfect track records when it comes to race and abuse, although they have done a lot right and that’s the only reason I’m still giving this season a chance as they do have a tendency to let things simmer before we see the clear picture but it’s still wise to keep your guard up and step back when you feel the need to ❤️
thank you for this thoughtful reply! once again, i agree with everything. the way this fandom talks about louis and always focuses on the way all other characters were hurt except for him tends to be extremely frustrating.
i think i probably talked too much about it on my blog, but here are some thoughts i had about the way people wanna louis to "apologize" to lestat (x x), what i think about lestat's reactions to the book (x x) and what i think about the idea that louis should be "humbled" this season (x x). tldr: fuck everyone, i'm always on louis' side (except when it comes to claudia because come on).
and i couldn't agree more about the apology at the trial! i only count this as apology because it was genuine and it feels like the show won't return to it, at least in the context of the drop. it was an awful time and place for it and louis deserved to hear a proper apology from lestat that wasn't forced from him in some stressful situation (since lestat wasn't sure if he sees louis again). and particularly in environment where louis was held against his will and couldn't even properly respond, so it feels like just another layer of the performance where louis is the only person watching (except he doesn't even have a choice if he wanna watch it or not).
but more than anything i want a proper apology for everything else. lestat needs to figure out his shit before he can apologize properly, but at least i need it to be acknowledged by the show itself that it's not louis who owes anything to lestat, it's lestat who still owes so many things to louis. i'm tired of endless abuse apologia in the fandom, and this season doesn't give me hope that it's different in that regard.
anyway, thank you again for your analysis!