Heated Rivalry Analysis and Discussion: Autism
I'll start off by saying this is all my opinion. As a person with a touch of the tism the representation in this show meant a lot to me and here's why.
By now I think it's safe to say most people know that autism is a spectrum, unfortunately that is so often overlooked in media. It's either the viewer seeing how the character behaves and reading them as being on the spectrum (usually not what the writer was going for) or being towards the extreme end. What makes Heated Rivalry so good on this topic is that Shane was purposefully written/acted to be autistic, it wasn't just chance. The team put in the work to represent the community without ever making it into some kind of joke. Usually when people purposefully add an autistic character into their stories their presentation of it is dialed up to 11. So often the character can't function in society on their own and need a "straight man"/caretaker. Heated Rivalry doesn't do that, does Shane have challenges due to his autism that make life harder for him? Yes, at times, but he is never seen as incompetent or unintelligent.
Another thing common in the few autistic characters we do get is that it's treated as some type of super power. It automatically makes you a genius (Big Bang Theory, Good Doctor, Rain Man, Ect) but it doesn't. That's not to say you can't be a genius and autistic but they don't automatically go hand in hand like so much media portrays it to be. It is often treated like some kind of cheat to greatness.
The real "Super Power" of Autism is that it can lead to a person having hyper fixations (you can have them without being autistic or due to other neurodivergances). This causes a person to focus and invest more time/energy into a subject or skill. And as the saying goes "Practice makes Perfect". They are still putting all the time and dedication it would take anyone else but their brain has an easier time finding joy/curiosity in a task related to said fixation.
Autism also sometimes presents as a love/need for strict routines/schedules. And if you know anything about top level athletes is that they need such discipline to be at the pinnacle of their sport.
So yes, Shane Hollander does likely have a hyper fixation on Hockey but that's not a cheat for greatness. He still put in the blood/sweat/tears to get to where he is and it's not because he's autistic, that's just a small part of who he is and factors into how he interacts with the world around him.
So often autistic characters are written to be physical weak (nerd stereotypes ect). Another thing that makes HR so good is that Shane is a very strong man. I can only think of a few characters who were written to be autistic who were physically strong and even then most of those characters were "too strong for their own good" or "didn't know their own strength" and often lead to them hurting people. That's not the case here. Shane is an elite athlete in peak health, he also 100% knows just how strong he is. He also is completely capable of controlling himself and we never see him using that strength to hurt someone.
This section ties into my earlier point on characters only ever being seen as high on the spectrum or viewers attributing autism onto a character.
Autism is probably far more common than we know and many people go undiagnosed until they are adults or are never diagnosed at all. So the choice to have it never be brought up in the show was a good mirror for real life while still providing true representation by having the crew/cast/producers openly say that Shane is autistic.
His portrayal represents so much of what is many autistic people's reality. While Shane does have certain challenges/struggles surrounding his diagnosis because no one knows he is autistic (some might suspect) other characters' understanding that comes with knowing someone is struggling is absent. Where he might just have a hard time connecting with other people, other characters might see him as cold and standoffish.
Being undiagnosed means that no one makes accommodations for him. We see this in how characters tend to jokingly make fun of his dislike for going out. I can't say for sure but if some of the characters around him knew what he was going through they might have gone out of their way to make such meet ups easier on him.
The few characters we see who seem to truly be Shane's friends go out of their way to make life easier for him (Both Ilya and Hayden having ginger ale for him, for example).
The few times we do see Shane openly struggle with his autism they aren't overplayed. They aren't these huge screaming/crying/hurting yourself things. Yes, there are autistic people who experience such extremes but once again autism is a spectrum. When Shane does get overwhelmed it is something only characters who are really paying attention/care for him notice. A great example of this is at the end of The Cottage where he puts his head down on the table. It's not made into this huge dramatic scene, it's still happening but the people who love him know how to help him and do.
This is probably the most important point in my eyes. I don't think I've ever seen a purposefully portrayed autistic character who is allowed to be a sexual being. So often autistic characters are infantilized and/or seen as too socially inept to have sex and when they are it is made into this weird joke (Sheldon and Amy's sex life in the Big Bang Theory for example). HR allows Shane to be a person who has sex but also is autistic instead of an autistic person having sex. The difference is extreme.
Yes I've heard HR described as just smut (I strongly disagree) but even if it was I would praise it to high heavens just for the fact it let's Shane Hollander be the sexual icon he is. His character is allowed to have sex, allowed to feel sexy and have other characters see him as sexy and most importantly we are allowed to see him as sexy. Hell, we are encouraged to.
In his first sex scene we see him fold his pants and then walk towards the bed like he knows he's the shit. Ilya laughs at the pants folding not in mockery but in fondness and he still thinks that man is hot like burning.
In Summary: Let autistic characters get their freak on.
Episode Analysis Master List
Discussion: Disordered Eating
Discussion: Yuna Hollander