one of my bigger gripes with HR fanfic (especially of the canon-divergent variety) is how ilya discusses irina’s passing. i know the “by accident” / “she accidentally swallowed a bottle of pills” is a beautiful moment in canon but it just comes across as flat in many fan interpretations. like im sorry, ilya is not double texting to make his morbid “by accident” comment.
i think it works in canon because the boys are finally comfortable with each other. there’s no pulling teeth — shane can ask about alexei and comment on ilya’s father and brother sucking and ilya will respond with his face cushioned on shane’s lap, lying beside a campfire outside of shane’s “favorite place on earth”. shane quite literally sets the stage for this vulnerability when they first arrive.
stripped of the cottage’s intimacy, the line just doesn’t work for me 99 times out of 100. and it sucks because it’s such a heavy emotional beat and appears in… so… many… fics…









