Honestly Iām seeing a bit of assumptions on both sides I want to address.
I think all these scenes are very important but I notice theyāre being either waved off and undermined or interpreted in some ways that honestly are confusing to me based on what we know about canon.
I specifically think the Cloud and Aerith dream is one that either gets grossly undermined as if he rejected her or it doesnāt matter. Or it gets weirdly interpreted like he just confessed his love to someone he has known for all of three days. Both of these views I think are a little extreme hereās va middle ground.
Basically Cloud wavers between the two. He has obvious feelings for Tifa but they are tied to his identity crisis and buried along with his memories and true self. And he has emerging feelings for Aerith. However itās obviously not a love confession to Aerith. Cloud is oblivious. Cloud is mentally 16. Cloud sucks at feelings, is inexperienced doesnāt really understand how to express himself.
Heās not rejecting Aerith either. Basically we have seen him get worked up before because sheās always acting like she knows him. Which based on her situation she does. Heās always seeing that no matter what he says she will also have her say.
But now he needs to have a say. Aerith is here talking like theyāll never see eachother again. Sheās saying embrace this moment, sheās talking about dying, sheās talking about being thankful for all their memories. This girl is saying goodbye. And then she says no matter what happens you canāt fall in love me itās depending on your translation choice not real or in your imagination.
Ā Once again she has decided everything for him. And heās not going to let her just say goodbye.
Doesnāt he get a say? He probably has a crush on her by this point but heās only known her for three days or so. So this is a not a full out love confession or rejection. Heās saying isnāt that for him to decide? Arenāt his feelings his own? Feelings he probably hasnāt thought of considering his face here. Thatās not a I already have face.
Ā Like it does look like heās embarrassed, but if sheās rejecting him heās only seen her for 36 hours, heartbroken would be a bit much. Also being sure he loves her after such a short timeĀ it would not be very Cloudlike and also be a bit much.
Ā It looks more like a bit of shock. He gasps twice, looks away like heās trying to be cool about it.Ā
But I donāt think heās in love right here.
Thatās a ā*gasps* Pretty girl just said love. Why does she think I would? *Looks away* She just grabbed my face. Sheās touching me ā what is thisssss reaction.
Heās an awkward dork whose mentally a young boy what the heck do we expect here?
She says even if you think you have though and it gets him thinking: Why is she saying this? sheās so close I donāt not like this *reaches*Ā
Then he snaps out of it. Donāt I get a say in all this?Ā
In Japanese he says thatās all really one sided.Ā
Sheās deciding things on her own again.Ā
He probably likes her, sheās charming and loveable he obviously finds her attractive based on how he reacted to her in a dress.Ā
But as someone pointed out itās only been 36 hours, thereās a lot on his mind. Heās in an identity crisis, his home just got destoyed again, sheās been kidnapped.Ā
Feelings of any sort are not something heās actually considered because we know canon Cloud is oblivious.Ā
We know canon Cloud sucks at feelings and heās probably really confused now. And he doesnāt really have time to piece it together so we get him being embarrassed and having this weird feeling of what is this as subtly as possible. He does this with Jessie too on his bike ride (girls are an enigma) but unlike Jessie Aerith is looking right at him and sheās saying things he canāt ignore. He canāt play it cool.
And I do think deep down heās starting to fancy her. Obliviously.
Remember the devs have him waver between the two heroines. His feelings are doing that wavering. Itās not a direct yes or no.
But I donāt think he is in mind to realizeĀ that to piece together any confessionsĀ
And why is she here saying all this goodbye stuff?
He is caught off guard and confused. But he knows one thing definitely. Heās going to save her. Doesnāt matter what she says.
Thatās a big character moment for him. And Aerith is central to the plot vas well as what she knows about herself and Cloud.
So I think it makes a lot of sense it would be highlighted in the credits. Though as it has been pointed out so are optional scenes.
And yes it can be seen as romantic but itās because itās showing the possibility he is open to figuring out his feelings not because he expressed his love from the rooftops like people act.
I think thatās an important distinction people skip over.
Now the Tifa scene which mostly gets criticized for being too platonic looking when obviously itās not. Or thereās this idea that Tifa is expressing Cloud and her possible future relationship with him are dead and buried. Or sheās jealous of Aerith. Or Cloud hugging her means heās chosen her over Aerith ā¦I think they all miss the mark.
This scene with Tifa is equally romantic. Thereās nothing platonic about it. We know canon Cloud and Tifa have feelings for eachother they just donāt know it and so they kinda dance around it. Tifa mentions Aerith because that explains why Cloud would ever have a flower. Sheās also acknowledging that Aerith whoās currently kidnapped right now is on her mind. And she has had a bit of an impact on Cloud making him of all people buy flowers. Thereās no jealousy there. Just acknowledgment.
Cloud isnāt saying much here because remember Marle told him to be a real friend and listen, really listen. So thatās what heās doing. But then she starts crying. She tells him how hard she tried to keep this flower alive how much it meant for her. But itās gone now.
The flower being dead and buried is her way of saying she had finally reunited with him a few weeks later, she finally had a place to call home she thought things would all work out but sheās lost everything again. This doesnāt mean her feelings for Cloud or Cloudās feelings for her are dead and buried.
They are both in canon unaware of eachothers feelings for eachother until the LifeStream scene, they however both lost their home again. Thatās what this signifies. Reunion they reunited but again their home is gone everything is crumbling for her.
If she feels sheās going to lose him too this is the moment he lets her know heās still right here for her. Like he promised. Like he said he would do he will listen.
The devs say Cloud wanted to hug Tifa all this time since seeing Barret do it. His True self the buried one with feelings for Tifa break through.
Yes itās romantic, but itās also not a love confession either or him deciding Tifa is more important than Aerith or anything. Because he is probably unaware of why he did that he doesnāt know how this feeling thing works all he knows is one thing he wants to comfort her.
In both scenes we see Cloud canāt express his feelings well but he is resolute in being there, in helping in savings either girl.
Thatās a very good sign the lessons he has learned up to now are sinking in. Heās losing that hard edge heās willing to do things for others not himself. And both have canon romantic undertones as the devs say the hero wavers in his feelings between both girls. Itās also canon he is oblivious to both and feelings confuse him.
As for Aerith looking forward not back. If she is the OG Aerith then obviously she will have feelings for Cloud from the get go. She already has fallen for Cloud but sheās still seeing how he reminded her of Zack. This time she asks for more information about Zack from him but he doesnāt realize it. She brings it up again and sees as she suspected he doesnāt know and catches herself when she realizes sheās dwelling on Zack. Why dwell? Because heās obviously important. And she tells herself she needs to look forward not back. She has things to do, she needs to embrace this moment. Itās a very important scene for her and it doesnāt discredit her feelings for either Zack or Cloud.
Also can we just stop with the only Aerith brings out Cloud because of the flower scene? Or saying it makes no sense and ignoring it?
He is slowly losing his hard edge already through his bonds with Avalanche. He also says tell me anyway about Jessie. Cloud is learning slowly how to listen to people like Marle told him to, he is learning to be more soft so it makes sense his adorable childlike self would want to open up to someone like Aerith and learn more about her. Especially with how sad she is in the scene.
Heās trying so hard and itās adorable. Heās obviously not true Cloud yet because thatās a whole identity crisis he has to solve in the LifeStream by unlocking memories but heās starting to see he can be there for others even if he himself isnāt ready to open up
So his bonds here with everyone are important and no scene should be dismissed.
As for Hollow I think it applies to the loss everyone in this game is going through and might as well be the theme song of the slums.
Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
I donāt know why either side undermines character moments. But especially the Clerith side keeps undermining scenes with everyone except Aerith. Being a Clerith lover myself who is respectful of canon it really bothers me. And even though I also love Cloti because I didnāt get it at first (I saw it was canon but thought the devs pushed it on me at first) but have seen the devs intentions time and time again, seeing people say Cloud and Aerith have absolutely nothing romantic in canon or his scene with her is just the devs being meta talking to the fan base about his feelings being his own takes away from what this means for him in the actual story also bothers me.
Anyway I think the remake did a great job of giving Cloud Tifa and Aerith their character development and these scenes sum them up perfectly.
Leave no scene behind, theyāre all precious and important unfortunately they donāt all fit into the credits.
āāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāāā
Source: My interpretation based on story beats. Mileage may vary
Allegiance: Entered the LTD in 2007 and was active in 2010ā¦Originally a Clerith who felt annoyed by Tifa and felt offended at getting her Highwind Scene.Ā
Present day status: Clerith in Denial. Hesitant Cloti. Zerith Intruigued.
I just want everyone to be happy, Nomura! why canāt they just be happy?!!