ATTACK ON TITAN S4 SPOILERS
(No manga spoilers)
RANDOM THOUGHT
I know everyone was like “oh Gabi is just like Eren. This is just from the other perspective!”
Yes, that’s true. Gabi’s anger and brainwash from Marley made her kill Sasha but... what unnerved me was her smile.
We know Eren has killed. But rather than a sense of accomplishment, or pride, we get ... this.
He looks dead. There is “no emotion” on his face. Even after killing or fighting the other side he has never shown pride or joy in the death of a person. When Armin, who has technically went through the same thing as Eren. (An orphan, dream of seeing the world beyond the walls/feeling trapped, having a Titan role forced on you, seeing people you care about die in front of you or because of you, etc). He, also has no pride or joy for deaths he has caused.
But Gabi....
Yup. She showed pride and was smiling. She was thinking “I took down a devil who hurt people I care about”. That’s what differs her from Eren. Yes, she was brainwashed to believe they were bad people. But after experiencing the Braus’ kindness, as well as Reiners take on Paradis, she knows to some extent that they aren’t the devils she thinks. She even sees Niccolo, who is Marelyan, be kind the the Braus’.
And eren and armin saw the other side, Reiner, etc as enemies as well. But they did not take satisfaction in the deaths of their enemies, the only positive emotion they showed over their deaths was relief that the violence was over. Granted, the 104th grew up with Bertholdt, Reiner, and Annie, but they still showed their other enemies they did not know personally (like the Beast Titan, Kenny squad, marelyan citizens) any joy or sense of victory/pride over their deaths.
Notice how most of the survey corps celebrate over their victory? (Well some are crying rather than celebrating or smiling) but especially Floch leading that victory yell? Like Gabi. They are too blinded.
But Sasha, Jean, and Connie are just relieved to not have lost each other. They care about each other, not the “victory” of the war. Even Jean ponders if killing Gabi does anything to help the war, other than to spur on the circle of violence.
That’s why there’s such a grey area with AOT. It isn’t good or bad. Just innocent people controlled by bad intentions. There only this side of the war and that side of the war. The different factors that lead to some expressing joy while others just relief at a “victory”. I found it super interesting. This is why I love AOT. Also it was amazingly done, so stfu MAPPA haters.












