looking at the commotion in the tags, it seems the remaining ons stans are also guilty of shipper bias. hating on mahiru for being a yapper is one thing but to say she's making shinya's death about herself is plain hypocritical. cuz isn't guren doing the exact same thing lmao?
yeah this is.. not it. the jarring self-hate aside, i find it weird how a death scene is lacking any memorial for the demised one. Shinya's death is a plot device, leading to what comes next.
This post is about fandoms' casual sexism but I want to address something deeper about the writing too. I enjoy this series but choosing honesty in reading the text and my own self awareness keeps me grounded.
Cue how Mika got the same treatment. Why is Yuu expressing his low self worth at a time like this? This debased level of co-dependency is annoying and needs to be worked on but the author is a strange man we all know. Yuu getting over his meltdown in one hour (ch99) to slobber over Guren's feet is further insult to Mika btw. What a horribly written mc and shit bestie, but because of allegiance to sexism, fans have to hate on Shinoa instead 🏃
For all that sympathy highlighted in the manga, Yuu severely lacks in the empathy department. Sticking to his obsequious devotion to Guren, he betrays Mika by not feeling jilted or feigning offense on his dead family's behalf. There's an entitlement he exerts in his dynamic with Mika which is very toxic too I should say. Even then he (and guren) resorts to self flagellation because of *pulls out plot convenient excuse* low self esteem developed due to traumatic childhood. You'd find this in any and every manga so shit's generic as hell.
Main point, the characterization of these two is laced with narcissism (kagami has some really flawed philosophy). There's one thing about being likeable but then there's this elevation which renders your closest companions to be your glazers and cheerleaders instead of equals. Kureto and Kimizuki are punished to the background because they dare to address their MCs with disrespect, so the deep male friendship kagami promised to show us is with the subservient guard dogs. It's why Shinya is not allowed to properly confront or rightfully defect from his bestie as the writing team has to depict him as a worrying housewife instead? Why is Mika narratively stitched onto Yuu as some helicopter parent doting on their infant? Why are these two supposed to show unconditional loyalty but stuck with plot dependence as a mark of epic bromance but Yuu/Guren get the privilege of being active participants of the bigger picture and receive more meaningful dynamics with others?
See, there truly is hypocrisy to address (among fans) in how the bishie besties' weak writing is shown leniency while the hiragi sisters are crucified for hmm being just like the former. Why is Shinoa's love (shed light on since chapter 14) invalidated and dismissed under faux alarm of misogyny while Mika's whole character getting revolved around "Yuu-chan" (reducing him into a slobbering pet dog, not some canon lover designation btw) is fawned over? "bUt eeT geh" your ship is bottom of the barrel queerslop which is thankfully been getting the no-homo clause for months now so have some shame and grow some standards in the meantime. Every complain on Shinoa I've found on the internet is actually quadruple applied to Mika but ofc misogyny is allowed when you all make an mlm ship the primary focal point of your reading comprehension.
Guide me on how to address a fandom-turned-cult that their engagement with the manga is in poor taste. Look, battle shonen is male centric and apt to this category, will rarely give you satisfying female characters, it all depends on your personal preferences though. You knew what you signed up for when you picked up OnS but there comes a limit to carelessly repeating how "kagami is a misogynist" when the actual problem is you might be miserable by choice and too fussy. Take a deep breath and relax, truth is this classic shonenslop is Not For You. Cuz bad news kiddos but the bois are ALSO poorly written, which naturally seeps on their female counterparts. This is one of those mangas where complains of gender discrimination don't fully apply btw; women being in love isn't a bad thing but men being emotionally stunted in response to them is however.
Yes, we have the token complex characters in the names of Guren and Ferid but that's it. Ok, Mahiru and Krul are multifaceted, there I said it. However, we seriously can't say the same for Yuu, Shinya, Mika, Crowley, Asheramaru etc. who're mere blank canvases. It's insane how the two main boys aren't ever given any room to be fleshed out under consistent development; blank canvas is meant to be projected on afterall. This is how Kagami takes advantage in switching up their personas every 20+ chapters or so, making their actions look forced and nonsensical in hindsight.
What's truly funny to me is that for all the desperate effort in comparing Mahiru with Mika (for ship validation again as always) it's insane how one is casually demonized as a bitch while the other, more blander variant yet a boy now, is adored as some uwu baby/malchik gay. Face it, a lot of yall conjure up delusional headcanons to make this 1 dimensional egg white more likeable anyways, but inability to do the same for the girls.. there's only so much you can blame on kagami when it's a more subjective bias at work here.
yes you are allowed to dislike and love whoever you want yadda yadda yadda but go work on your blatant sexism first ok?