warnings: brand new day spoilers (but it's genuinely the smallest one you ever did see)
summary: you're avoiding the party that mj and ned wanted to throw, but that doesn't stop you from being found by a stranger. why can't you shake the feeling that he's familiar?
a/n: umm it's been eight years since i posted on this account? we're so back? saw brand new day in theaters (twice) and felt teenage me gnawing on the bars of her enclosure this one is for her (and for y'all). potential for a part two...
You didnât know exactly what it was. You didnât mind the music or the alcohol; even being around so many people was fun sometimes. Before everyone got drunk and started spilling things and yelling, obviously. But every single party youâd been to at MIT had feltâŠwrong. Like you were missing something. Like someone was supposed to be there with you, and they werenât.Â
Which didnât make sense. Ned and MJ had gone to a majority of the parties youâd gone to throughout college, and they were your closest friends. How could you feel like something important was missing when everything important was already there with you?Â
Either way, youâd started trying to avoid that gnawing feeling in your chest. Besides, you were growing out of the phase where going to every party and meeting every person you could fascinated you. Maybe one day that deep, dreadful sinking would go away. Maybe it would stop appearing at parties, on every birthday you turned a year older, on the small amount of dates youâd gone on where the feeling got so strong it made you nauseous.
Today, though, was an exception. Youâd graduated this past summer and moved back to New York with MJ and Ned, and they were determined to throw one last party with all the college friends that had wound up back in the city, too.Â
Well, Ned was determined. You and MJ were lukewarm about the whole thing.Â
Which is why you were in yourâabysmally smallâbedroom, working through this line of code that you were pretty sure was going to get you fired from your shiny new job if you didnât figure out why it wasnât working, with your door open to the noise beyond. It was to keep an eye on MJ and Ned, you told yourself, even as you eyed all the swaying people around the TV youâd just spent fifty dollars on from Facebook Marketplace. Ugh, you should have moved it before. If they broke it, you were totally making Ned buy you takeout for a week.
You went back to work, thankful everyone seemed to be too preoccupied with the party to worry about the weird girl staring at her computer screen on her bedroom floor. You couldnât figure this out. It was driving you crazy. You were sure it had worked yesterday evening, and then when youâd come into work this morning it was all wrong and every single test you did didnât fix it and you were going to throw your computerâ
A knock on your open door. A cleared throat. âUm, hey.âÂ
You looked up.
A guy around your age stood in your doorway. The first thing you noticed about him were his eyes, wide and expressive, looking at you as if you were the one whoâd shown up in his bedroom. ButâŠreverent too, almost in disbelief. He was looking at you like heâd never seen a girl before.Â
But he was cute. And something about himâŠ
He seemed familiar.Â
âAre you okay?â he asks you. His gaze starts to bounce around the room the second you meet it, avoiding your eyes. âYou looked, um, mad?â
âOh!â You laugh a little at yourself. âIâm just doing some work. Iâve been told I look mad when I canât figure something out. I donât even realize it.â But who had told you that? It wasnât your family, or Ned or MJ. But someone had told you. Who had it been?
The guy shifts on his feet. You realize heâs holding a bouquet of flowers, which is a weird thing to bring to a party, but you find it charming. He squints his eyes at you, but the corner of his mouth is lifting like he wants to smile. It makes something in your chest flutter. âYouâre doing work during a party?â
Heâs teasing you. You feel yourself smiling back. âYes, I am. Super important work, I might add.â
âOh, yeah?â He leans a shoulder against your doorframe, eyes on yours now.Â
You canât look away.Â
âYep. Keep an eye out because Iâm gonna dethrone Spider-Man from the first page of the Daily Bugle tomorrow with my amazing work on debugging this finance app that only has three hundred downloads. Really groundbreaking stuff.âÂ
He smiles fully, now. It makes you feel triumphant, nervous, and warm. âThatâs awesome because I loveâWhatâs the name of the app?â
âFinancipplyâ Stupid name. From the doubtful look he sends you, he agrees.
âThatâs perfect because I love Finacnipply. Canât wait to see you on the front page.â You roll your eyes, but you laugh. You both do, his shy and small, as if he hasnât done it in a long, long time. As if he shouldnât be laughing at all. But his eyes are bright. They turn towards the floor as your laughter dies, shy. âSo what canât you figure out?â
And you just canât stop looking at him. You motion towards your computer screen vaguely. âJust this code. I donât know whatâs wrong with it. Itâs just not working.âÂ
He takes a small step forward. âDo you thinkâŠCan IâŠlook at it?â
âFor real? You code?â
He shrugs, one hand in his pocket. Adorable. âIâŠdabble?â
âAre you sure about that?âÂ
Another flash of a smile. âYes, Iâm sure.â
âAlright then. Knock yourself out.â
He comes to sit next to you on the rug you found at the thrift store a couple blocks away, rubbing his palms over his jeans and looking intently at your computer screen. He smells like clean laundry and the rain the city had earlier in the day, and heâs looking at your code like he actually understands it. âOh wow. Cool.â He scrolls through it a couple times, up, down. Youâre entranced by his profile, so close. He stops to type. âDid you try this?âÂ
You blink. Look at the screen. âOh my gosh, no.â A simple line edit. You know when you see it that itâll work. âHoly shit. You did it. Holy crap. Thank you. Youâre, like, awesome.âÂ
âIt was nothing.â But he's ducking his head with a blush. âSeriously.âÂ
âWhatâs your name, anyway? Since you saved me from getting fired.â
âUm, May..nard.âÂ
âMaynard.â It sounds wrong. Youâve never had that thought beforeâthat someoneâs name is wrong. But itâs a sure feeling in your chest. The one you have when you know your code tests are going to work, and when you decided you wanted to move back to the city. Itâs really the only feeling you trust anymore.Â
âYep.â He leans back on his palms, and your eyes run down his arms unconsciously, tracking muscles and veins. You have a brief, overwhelming urge to curl closer to him, to run your hands down his biceps, to take his hands into yours and trace the lines of his palms. And it feels normal, to have that feeling. So normal, your body almost starts moving on its own accord. But his voice breaks you out of it. âSo, is this what you want to do? Program apps?âÂ
You tell him that your dream is to work on developing video games, and he nods like it makes complete sense and gets you to tell him that youâd love to make a game based off of Star Wars, which makes his eyes light up in a way that has your breath catching.Â
And thatâs how you end up talking to a cute boy on the floor of your bedroom for an hour, about Star Wars and your favorite video games and what got you into them in the first place. He makes you laugh, and talking to him is so easy. Itâs hard to believe you just met him now and not in high school. He would fit right in with MJ and Ned. You can almost see it for a moment; the four of you hanging around the diner MJ used to work at before college, laughing and teasing and studying. The image is so visceral that for a moment it feels real.Â
Youâre just about to invite him over sometime because youâre so sure that theyâd love him and that you want to get to know him better, when thereâs a crash from the living room.Â
Both of you turn, and your face immediately drops. That better not have been your TV.Â
You sigh. âI need to go make sure nothing important is broken.â You almost add on a desperate wait for me, but heâs already standing up and holding out a hand for you.Â
That would have been too weird to ask for, anyway. Right?Â
You let him pull you up. When your hands touch, itâs almost as if the warmth radiates from his calloused fingers, grips your heart, and drags it all the way down to your toes. He lets go quickly, as soon as youâre on your feet, but you stand there for a moment, disoriented. Feeling likeâŠfeeling like youâre right where you need to be. But also like youâve forgotten to do something. It pulls at your brain like a grocery item list you know you were thinking about five minutes ago, but no matter how far you reach, you can never remember what it was.Â
It shouldnât bother you this muchâyouâve been feeling it since you went to college. It hung over you during orientation, and move-in day, and every visit home. It reaches you in dreams, and weirdly, whenever Ned shows you the thousands of videos he gets of Spider-Man swinging across the city.Â
But youâd never felt this close to grasping it before. You can almost see an image in your brain, faded around the edges like an old photograph, a word floating just on the edge of your consciousness.Â
âYou okay?â Heâs asking you. Maynard. God, why does that name sound so wrong to think?
He looks about a second away from grabbing your hand again.Â
You want to let him.Â
But you hear MJâs voice from the living room, firm in the way she only uses when sheâs annoyed, and you know that your TV is probably done for. Maynard seems to be able to sense it too, because he urges you to go.Â
And your TV is broken, thanks to some idiot and his friend who decided to start play-fighting for no reason. He gives you a twenty from his pocket, but you canât even focus. Your mind is too busy playing back your night. Warm brown eyes, messy curls, soft smiles. You end up just waving it offâbut you keep that twentyâand rushing back to your room to find Maynard.Â
Only, heâs not there when you return.Â
Your laptop is closed and placed at the foot of your bed. On top, the bouquet he showed up with.Â
You stand there, in the middle of your tiny room, touching your fingertips to the carnations and grieving.Â
Grieving for what? You keep asking yourself. Why do I feel this way?
But you canât figure it out. It stays, stays, stays.Â
Later that night, his face comes to you in your dreams. Itâs younger, unburdened with the sadness youâd seen lying underneath. Heâs laughing, bright and beautiful, and heâs looking at you. Youâre on a rooftop somewhere, both of you golden in the sun, and heâs saying your name with a fondness that notches into your spine.Â
I love you, he says, and he means it. Itâs in his eyes, in the way his expression melts into softness, in the way he traces his fingers across your shoulder and pulls you into him.Â
Peter, your voice sounds just as yours does now, weighed down by adulthood. You run your fingers through the hair at the nape of his neck, and thereâs a peacefulness in your body that you know you havenât felt in years, even through the haze of the dream. Iâll always love you.
You feel the press of his lips to your hair, the curve of them as he smiles.
You wake up. Gasping, gripping the thin sheets of your bed, sweat gleaming on your collarbone.Â
Peter, your mind whispers to you in the dark.
âPeter.â You murmur it into the moonlight shining across your floor, to your heart beating against your ribcage, to the knot in your stomach that finally releases.Â
âPeter.â You say again. Taste it on your tongue, certain youâve said it a thousand times, in a million different ways.