nobody is saying female privilege. unless you think like 3 obscure blogs you can look for is like, Everyone Ever.
also, you can't even accurately define what group you're trying to strawman*, which is also another red flag with this whole thing & something I wanna point out because it will ruin any hot take or conversation you're attempting to have with your posts.
"Trans Rad Fem"= similar to TMRA, made up & nobody called themselves that unless it's a retroactive reclaimation. Made specifically to make a group of trans people look akin to the oppressor. discourse-maxxing /neg
"Radical Transfeminist" = a real word SOME people use to refer to themselves with SPECIFIC beliefs [cant go in depth, i hardly see them so idk much but also if i were to talk about this group i'd do that research FIRST.]
"Radfem" = also aa group with specific beliefs, doesn't just mean "transphobic". radfem beliefs have a lot more stuff than just trans people.
TERF = 99% of the time people use this to say "transphobic" - no. again? specific beliefs and rhetoric and you shouldnt use it unless they are actively spewing TERF rhetoric
TIRF= doesnt just means "i wanna call u a terf but ur trans / supporting trans people kinda in other areas so ima call you this" - this was a legitimate movement! idr a lot of the history there sorry, but most died out. they had SPECIFIC rhetoric, too, tho.
Baeddel = OG baeddels were a specific group on tumblr a while ago that not a lots known about that a lot of people have trauma relating to, most baeddels nowadays have never been in that group - and only some want to return to that kind of community. Don't call people this ESPECIALLY unless you know what tf they believe cuz its a SLUR.
Now i KNOW that was a bad explanation but i wanted to outline different groups you (general you) may use/see used as buzz words in conversations, and when that happens it makes anything said wholely inaccurate and a waste of time. You need to actually know FIRST OFF what group you're talking about, then define the actual belief you're talking about, THEN make an accurate criticism/commentary on it. Lest everything you say is garbage clogging our tags and taking away from genuine discussions that matter.
Saying "[buzz word term nobody uses] believes [thing someone maybe said once] because [weirdly transphobic thing]" is weird. Point blank.
And ik you may be like "well what if they don't believe any of those ideologies or ID as any of that? or ONLY use transfeminist?" then you have to do even more hard work to accurately define the group. Go, "people who believe X". But, of course, when you're working with what's essentially a straw man it doesn't give that much punch as it does lumping in people you already don't like with some ludicrous claim.
If you cannot accurately identify who would even say this, it probably isn't being said.
*unless the word strawman has to be intentional, then i wouldnt call this a strawman. i do believe you genuinely think people en masse are saying this and theyre all One evil group on tumblr you're making a valid point about. i do believe you believe what youre saying.
-
> You being jealous of someone does not inherently make them more privileged than you and certainly does not give you the right to harass them and diminish their very serious societal struggles
You presumed a conclusion under false pretenses, and now are treating it as undisputable fact. This is another error. Nobody is saying "im SO jealous of your vagina! you're privileged!" jfc what's with people saying this disgusting shit. Reminds me of that honeybee confession blog, "ermm all these amab transfems hate me because im female and so afab and have a vagina so i will always pass better than them" <- what they say & nobody calls it out.
Idk it's just disgusting to force trans women into some caricature of "PENIS HAVER who's just soooo obsessed with my vagina and is so jealous they cannot have one so they think i'm PRIVILEGED." <- literally what lies TERFs have been feeding younger transmascs for ages. Trans women are just men who will prey on your poor uwu body's because we are so male and so jealous and wish we can have one too and we will deny your oppression and the only way for your oppression to be recognized is to embrace femaleness and understand trans woman oppress you.
^ What TERFs say. Not saying YOU believe that, but you are perpetuating a diet version of that.
Additionally, have you ever actually researched into WHY people say non transfeminized people are more privileged than transfeminized people? Or are you entirely informed via discourse? I promise you, it has nothing to do with you having a vagina. Nobody cares about your shit. There's genuine reading to do to understand these beliefs you disagree with but instead you wanna take the lazy way out and say this gross shit, and it's sad. Do better. You make people who actually wanna discuss this topic genuinely look bad
..... also peep how transmascs use this rhetoric too and theres people "on both sides" of all genders, but TRF is being used exclusively to mean trans woman here. gross. weird. why. its a symptom of discourse brainrot. fortunately, it's never terminal.
Also are we forgetting that most trans men want to have male genitalia?
Are we forgetting trans women may already have vaginas or not even want them? What's the point of the "you think i'm privileged because youre AGP" esque argument? This argument is 'penis envy' mixed with AGP. In my eyes. Idk someone can disagree and analyze this post separately, but first glance this is what this is.
Your gender does not equal your social class, and trans men are viewed as women by the patriarchy even though they are not women. Female privilege is not real and trans men do not have the privilege of being a cisgender female because they’re not??? Fucking???? Cisgender????
What a good argument! Not for anything close to what you are trying to say, but a good argument!
This argument, "your gender is not your social class" is better afforded to if people are saying trans men have a patriarical status. I have seen a few say that, so keep ahold of this in your back pocket for when one does. But 'youre a patriarch' and 'female privilege' are not the same claims at all. Another reason you need to accurately define the claim, who believes it, and your arguments BEFORE you start writing!
Anyways, again, people are not saying this. And people who do say you have privilege do not typically believe you have patriarchal status nor cis privilege. They believe you are not transfeminized, thus are in a privileged state. I haven't seen many writings go in depth on this cuz idk I suck at looking, but if you are this bad at understanding the concept of what 99% of people are saying that you're labeling as the same as (contradictory) beliefs almost nobody has ever said - I can sent you a post that kind of goes into the belief a bit.
Most trans men wish they were born in the body that most trans women are born with and vice versa. It’s an unfortunate fact of life and there’s nothing anyone can do about it.
Still don't like this weird argument. So bold, but unfortunately just a wrong premise all together.
Jesus fucking Christ, people, transmisogyny and transandrophobia are both incredibly damaging forms of bigotry, why are you inflicting them on each other????
Again, changing the topic.. Tsks Tsks :/
You yourself are inflicting harm against trans women+ with this gross, irresponsible argument you decided to post publicly. I suggest you do some more research and some soul searching as to why you choose to speak without accuracy. Learn to love discussion, not be trapped by discourse.
#sorry for the rant this is all literally so stupid to me #it feels like some psyop bullshit
because it is. Nobody is actually saying this. You have fallen for a pysop that infested the transandrophobia discussion side of tumblr probably over a year ago now; and turned it into a discourse as well so nobody cares to check statements and such. It's sad.
romaincrisis
baratheonpilled
discoholicmusic
prguitarman
andulkaphoto
areudirty
dededos
