Exploring Rejected Mating Bonds and Non-Mated Relationships in the ACOTAR:
Delving into the prospect of rejected mating bonds and non-mated relationships in future ACOTAR books has sparked my interest. While this exploration might not be everyone's favoured avenue... humour me for a moment. I wanted to consider how three particular pairings—Helion+LOA, Jurian+Vassa, and Eris+Mor—stand out as potential candidates for this unconventional narrative.
LOA+Helion: Maternal Love Prevails that of a Mating Bond
There are numerous theories circulating that the Lady of Autumn (LOA) and Helion are potential mates (I don't think they will get a book). While the concept of either character enduring a rejected or incomplete bond is not what I would wish upon them, exploring such a dynamic could offer a compelling narrative angle. It could serve as an illustration of the idea that a mother's love surpasses even the powerful connection of a mating bond, highlighting the notion that the bond between a mother and her children transcends all other.
This incomplete bond wouldn't necessarily disrupt the overarching storylines but could be seamlessly integrated into the existing dynamics of the narrative, including Lucien's lineage as Helion's child, the escalating conflict with the Autumn Court, and the unexplored mating bond between Elain and Lucien. For instance, LOA might have chosen to sever her mating bond to shield her children from the wrath of Beron and the Autumn Court. Her willingness to endure further abuse to protect her children could provide an exploration of maternal sacrifice and the lengths a mother would go to protect her family.
Considering SJM own experience as a mother, the exploration of the power of a mother's love might be a theme she's interested in delving into.
As the series progresses and, if Eris were to succeed his father as High Lord, an intriguing aspect would be to witness LOA maintaining her title as the Lady of Autumn. This choice would signify her unwavering commitment to her children, even as they reach adulthood. Supporting Eris during his transition as High Lord would be a testament to her enduring love for her family and her dedication to the Autumn Court, which she considers her eternal home.
Now, you might wonder why not have Eris appoint her as High Lady? Considering Eris has three additional brothers (excluding Lucien) who may vie for the throne, he will require the support of every member of his court. Part of his reasoning for aligning with Rhysand is to secure this support. Given that Beron has held dominion over the Autumn Court as the oldest and most tyrannical High Lord, reigning with terror, the influential higher fae pivotal for Eris's rule may not yet be receptive to having an High Lady. Therefore, it wouldn't be politically savvy for Eris to bestow her with that title (Rhysand's been High Lord for 500 years, and the women of the Night Court are still getting brutalized. So, Eris not making his mum High Lady? Not exactly the be-all and end-all, is it?)
Head-canon: I also have this gut feeling helion is going to die in the series. Now, I don't have any evidence to back up this claim; call it intuition. However, if such an event were to unfold, it might entail Helion sacrificing himself for Lucien and the LOA. This sacrifice could occur after Lucien and Helion have already discovered their paternal bond and forged a meaningful relationship. As Helion and LOA share a heartfelt moment before his passing, he expresses understanding and admiration for her choice to prioritize her children. Having witnessed her centuries of sacrifice, Helion feels compelled to reciprocate in kind, ultimately sacrificing himself for both Lucien and her. (I'm not wishing for it, but my gut says it's happening.)
Jurien+Vassa: Fate-Woven Bonds Beyond Mates
A non-mated relationship between Vassa and Jurien presents a compelling avenue for exploration within future books, delving into the dynamics of a human connection forged by destiny rather than through a conventional fated mate bond. This narrative choice allows SJM to portray the nuances of a relationship where there isn't a direct link binding the soul of the couple together. Despite the absence of such a bond, fate has undeniably woven their paths together, leading to a relationship laden with complexity and depth.
Both Vassa and Jurien have endured sufferings at the hands of immortal beings, which creates intriguing parallels in their experiences. Jurien, a being over 500 years old, underwent merciless torment, including physical mutilation and the manipulation of his soul, culminating in his essence being imprisoned within a ring crafted from his own eyeball. This fate mirrors Vassa's own ordeal, where she was transformed into a firebird, cursed to spend her days trapped in avian form and her nights as a woman, bound to a lake. These shared encounters with immortals/fae beings not only serve as a foundation for their connection but also highlight a significant parallel in their suffering and transformation. In SJM stories couples often exhibit consistent parallels in their characteristics, trauma, and destinies, thus the mirrored experiences of Vassa and Jurien underscore the depth of their bond, emphasizing the intertwining threads of fate that have brought them together. Regardless of their mortality and a “mating bond.”
In ACOWAR's conclusion, Vassa invites Jurien to live with her and Lucien remarks that they are "two sides of the same coin" with a shared vision for the human territories. However, tensions reported by Lucien in ACOFAS suggest a charged dynamic between the two offering narrative space to explore fate's influence on human dynamics. Through Vassa and Jurien's connection, SJM can explore themes of resilience, redemption, and destiny's enduring impact on human lives.
Headcanon: Jurien pours out his heart to Vassa, declaring that every painful moment endured over his 400+ years was worth it, knowing that it led him to the possibility of spending the rest of his mortal life with her by his side, not just as a partner, but as his queen.
Furthermore, should their story follow an Elain + Lucien novel, it would provide an opportunity to solidify the foundation for their potential relationship. Lucien's pre-established relationship with the pair sets the stage, and I also see the potential for a close friendship with Elain. Their shared experiences of enduring transformations by immortal beings and a common human background could form the basis for a strong friendship, allowing Elain to maintain a connection to her past human life and mortality. (Plus more Elucien content!!)
Eris+Mor: Souls Bonded together but Hearts lie Elsewhere
The theory of a potential rejected mating bond between Eris and Mor is not one I particularly favor, as I would like for SJM to introduce mating bonds between 2SLGBTQIA+ characters. In response to a question about whether same-sex couples can be mates, SJM offered the following response in a 2017 interview:
“Sarah: Yes, and you can see some of that in both series. Don’t want to give anything away, but you may see this in ACOWAR when you read it. It’s also present in the Throne of Glass world. I’m super excited to write more about this, and already have a novel in mind about it." (https://emiesnook.wordpress.com/2017/05/12/meeting-sarah-j-maas-again/)
Therefore, I would like for her to follow through with this with a mating bond between Mor+Emerie (Eris+Balthazar, I said what I said... make Beron burn in his grave). However, if there were to be a rejected mating bond between Eris and Mor, I believe it would be an interesting concept. It would allow two 2SLGBTQIA+ characters to empathize with each other's inner turmoil and come to the realization that while their souls may belong to each other, they could never fully give each other their hearts. This storyline could illuminate the oppression and profound challenges endured by same-sex couples in a world where rigid societal norms and expectations frequently dictate the boundaries of love and relationships.
...
The relationships I've outlined above provide a compelling rationale for exploring rejected mates and non-mated relationships within the ACOTAR universe. These avenues offer non-stereotypical narrative exploration without directly causing further anguish/trauma to current main characters or disrupting the established plot dynamics and relationships. Allowing for the series to continue.
This is where I might lose some of you, but allow me to elaborate. SJM essentially wrote ACOWAR to establish Elucien and Nessian, and in ACOSF introduced two characters, Gwyn and Emerie, who serve as perfect parallels for the two unmated/single members of the inner circle (Azriel and Mor). Both characters introduced have strong parallels regarding their internal turmoil, history of abuse, self-image, interests/habits, and personalities.
It is NOT in the Night Court's best interest for a severed bond with Elucien to occur. This would end Lucien's role as the Night Court's emissary (Rhysand's "bitch"), as Elain could no longer be a persuading pawn. While Lucien himself may not object to Elain loving another (as he was willing to step back for Greysen), he cannot control the reactions and sentiments of other courts towards this development. Once Lucien's paternity is revealed, Night Court allegiance and relationships with other courts would be essentially terminated, as I believe Helion would do so to protect his son. Beron would have his reason to invade Spring, the Human Realm, or even the Night Court itself, or call for a blood duel, considering that although Lucien is not his biological son, Beron raised him and would have grounds to create a conflict.
The Night Court is not well-liked, which Rhysand is aware of, and he relies on Lucien to maintain connections with other courts. Severing contact with the Human Realm due to Lucien being the connection to Vassa and Jurien would further isolate the Night Court. Furthermore, given that Tamlin and Lucien were coworkers/friends for centuries, it can be interpreted that Tamlin would defend Lucien and not provide support from Spring. As we know, the Night Court is still reliant on Spring.
Severing the bond between Elucien would not only disrupt the intricate web of relationships and alliances within the series but also limit the exploration of numerous storylines introduced by SJM. It is crucial to analyze the plotlines beyond the narrow lens of mere smut and romance, as this limited focus undermines the depth of storytelling Sarah J. Maas has woven into the narrative. By broadening our perspective, we can fully appreciate the intricacies of the plot and explore how relationships would realistically integrate into the multifaceted dynamics that extend beyond the central romantic relationship between the main characters.
ACOSF: SJM introduces two characters who serve as perfect parallels for the last two unmated/single members of the Inner Circle.
Antis: No. No. No. Sunshine girl won’t end up with her mate sunshine boy. Clearly, the author known for fated mates won't be producing any more books centered around fated mates.
One of my favorite scenes in Bridgerton is the confrontation between Anthony and Kate in Season 2. It feels SO Elucien coded I have adapted it to fit Elain and Lucien.
Elain: I do not understand. Why are you suggesting this? All along, you have been intent on helping my sister as their emissary, and now you intend to cast her aside. Why? And do not talk to me of other opportunities, for we both know you do not have those. So, tell me, what has she done?
Lucien: She has done nothing. It is you. You have made this job impossible.
Elain: But I have kept my distance.
Lucien: And it is not far enough! Do you think that there is a corner of this world that I could travel to far away enough to free me from this torment? I am a gentleman. My mother raised me to act with honor, but that honor is hanging by a thread that grows more precarious with every moment I spend in your presence. You are the bane of my existence. And the object of all my desires. Night and day, I dream of you. And what I...Do you even know all the ways a lady can be seduced? The things I could teach you.
Elain: I did not ask for this mating bond. Hiding from my sisters. To be plagued by these feelings. Being driven to distraction every time you enter the room.
Lucien: Then you agree. It is unsupportable.
Elain: Impossible.
Lucien: If I continue serving as Night Court emissary, it will bind me and you together, and I will spend every day wanting you, dreaming of you, dreading the day when my last thread of honor finally snaps. Is that the future that you want for us?
I just couldn't help myself. This scene just gave me such gywn x azriel vibes (Queen Charlotte Episode 6, Netflix Time stamp: 07:00). It was too fun.
So if you take this transcript with the sound bite/clip (YT below)…
Gwyn: You seem more yourself. You look better. Do you... Do you feel better?
Azriel(Az): You should not have come.
Gwyn: I was most happy to come shadowsinger.
Az: No.
Gwyn: I am so sorry. I should have come sooner. Do not fear. I shall remain by your side...
Az: No. Berdara. Listen to my words. You should not have come. I do not want you here.
Gwyn: Azriel.
Az: Go back to the library or the house of wind, please.
Do you hear me? I said, "Go back to the library."
That is where you live. That is where you belong. Go.
I do not want you. I want never to see you. Leave.
(Shouts) Get out! I order you! (B/c she is under his command as spymaster or sm?? Lol)
Gwyn: No. No, Az.
Az: Gwyn!
Gwyn: You cannot force me away. I will not go.
Az: I command it! Go!
Gwyn: I will stay! I command it.
Az: Please, Gwyn. Please go.
Gwyn: No.
Az: Berdara, you're not listening to me.
Gwyn: I am. I have heard that you wish I had not come.
That you want me to go. That you do not want to see me.
Az: Berdara
Gwyn: What I have not heard is that you do not love me.
Gwyn: I have been suffering and alone and believing I am a failure as a spy and as your "friend" because you stay from me as though I am a disease.
And then today, it suddenly occurred to me that perhaps there is another reason.
A better reason.
Perhaps you stay away from me because you care for me.
Perhaps you stay away because you love me.
Do you love me?
Az: I'm trying to protect you.
Gwyn: Do you love me?
Az: I... I cannot. We cannot... This conversation is... I can't do this. I never deserved this. This bond.
Gwyn: Do you love me?
Az: Gwyn. Please, stop!
Gwyn: Is it because you do not believe that I could love you?
I do. I love you, Azriel.
I love you so much that I will do as you wish.
If you do not love me, all you have to say is that you do not love me, and I will go.
I will go back to the library.
And we can live our separate lives, and I will live with this bond alone, and I will make do and fill my days and survive.
All on my own. I will do that. But first, you have to say that you do not love me.
You have to tell me that I am utterly alone in this world.
Az: I am a madman. ( scoffs ) I am a danger (literal torturer). In my mind, there is darkness that creeps in. The shadows and stars collide. I do not know where I am.
Gwyn: Do you love me?
Az: You do not wish a life with me for yourself. No one wishes that.
Gwyn: Azriel! I will stand with you between the shadows and the stars. I will tell you where you are.
Do you love me?
Az: I love you!
From the mo... (Gwyn sighs) From the moment you left for your first mission with Nesta... I have loved you desperately.
I cannot breathe when you are not near.
I love you, Gwyn.
My heart calls your name. (Azriel sobbing quietly) (+kiss)
( softly ) I wanted to tell you. I wanted you to know.
This... madness, has been my secret my entire life. This darkness is... is my burden.
You bring the light.
Gwyn: Azriel. It is you and me. We can do this. Together.
(Tugs on bond+kiss)
When I watched this scene from Bridgeton I couldn’t help but picture Elain and Lucien
Lucien: "That is what happens when one burns for someone who does not feel the same!"
Elain: "It is you I cannot sacrifice."
"I burn for you"
Just imagine Lucien:
“Everything I told the was true. I cannot stop thinking of you. From the mornings you ease, to the evenings you quiet, to the dreams you inhabit… my thoughts of you never end. I am yours, Elain. I have always been yours.”
Mr. Fire in my veins Vanserra
Not the whole scene but you get the point...
I mean come on, the whole "why do you think I followed you into that garden" and "why do you think I went into that garden"
Summary: One shot of Elain's perspective through Ch 15 of ACOWAR and Ch 65 of ACOMAF. Elain's internal conflict and dialogue regarding the trauma from the cauldron and Feyre and Lucien's return to the Night Court following their escape from the Spring Court. (idk how to do this... sorry).
Word Count: 1.3k
Warnings: Canon compliant trauma and violence. Contains and explores concepts/ themes related to trauma response (depersonalization/derealization/dissociation).
A/n: This is what my brain comes up with in the middle of the night, when instead of sleeping, my mind is contemplating and theorizing. Not a writer, and never will claim to be writer. Rather, this is an attempt (at best) to capture the internal turmoil and emotions I imagine Elain might be experiencing. It serves as nothing more than an outlet for my introspections and speculations about her character. I also used "echo" way too much.
The world around her seemed distant, obscured by a haze that veiled her vision and dulled the vibrancy of light and colour. Though her sight was clouded, Elain's senses remained keenly attuned, capturing every sound and sensation that permeated her consciousness.
She basked in the warmth of the sun caressing her skin, the echo of his heartbeat resonating in her pointed ears— an ever-present reminder of his existence, transcending the expanse of Prythian. There was a familiarity to each rhythmic thud, a comforting assurance that he was near. She didn't need the bond to confirm it; his heartbeat coursed through her veins, igniting a fire within her that banished the shadows of her sorrow.
Every beat of his heart filled the void within her, casting aside the emptiness that had become all too familiar. The sun seemed brighter today with his arrival, its rays seeping through the window to illuminate her surroundings. Yet, amidst the warmth that circled her, the weight of the iron ring encircling her finger remained cold and heavy.
Running her thumb over the ring jolted her back to the present, away from the comforting throb of his heartbeat that had enveloped her soul. The iron band serving as a stark reminder of the life she had once imagined, the only path she had been permitted to envision—a final tether to the human lands that now felt impossibly distant.
--
Outside her chamber, the faint shuffle of Feyre's footsteps seemed to mingle with her scent of lilac and pear, yet the clouds still obscured her vision.
The return of her sister brought a sliver of relief. And he was alive. Elain had sensed his safety through the bond, an instinctual feeling that his demise would rend her soul apart. Yet, there was a stark difference between merely feeling his safety through their bond and actually seeing him in the flesh, unharmed.
As the door creaked open, breaking the silence of the room, Elain remained detached, her only connection to the outside world being the rhythmic thud of his heartbeat echoing through her.
She knew she appeared a mere shadow of herself, hair disheveled, clad only in her dressing robe, her complexion pale and weak. Yet, she couldn't bring herself to change it.
Feyre approached, encircling the chair where Elain sat. "Elain?" she called softly. He wasn't with her.
Elain remained silent. There were no words capable of capturing the depth of her ache, and she couldn't bear to burden Feyre further, not after all she had already endured. Not more than she already had.
"I'm back," Feyre said quietly, refraining from mentioning 'home.'
Feyre understood that this court held no solace for her, that she yearned for a life far removed from the one they now inhabited. Yet, she knew Feyre would try to integrate her and Nesta into their new reality in the Night Court, driven by either love or guilt—Elain couldn't discern which. Nevertheless, she couldn't shake the feeling that this place would not be her home—it was shrouded in darkness that seemed to seep into every corner, enveloping her in its bleak embrace.
"I want to go home," Elain confessed. She sensed Feyre's chest tighten as if she struggled to draw breath. "I know."
"He'll be looking for me," Elain added, her voice barely a whisper, as though she wished to shield the heart beating so closely from hearing her words.
Feyre's demeanor toward her remained tender, as it always had. But then again, so had everyone else. They were all gentle, sweet, and careful, as if she would shatter at any moment.
"We were supposed to be married next week," Elain uttered, the words heavy in the air. This time, she heard it—the subtle falter in his heartbeat, a brief interruption in its steady cadence. From the corner of her eye, she saw Feyre place a hand to her chest, as though she felt the delicate crack in the heartbeat that resonated between them.
"I'm sorry," Feyre murmured, but Elaine remained numb, the void of her pain consuming any semblance of response. An apology couldn't remedy the pain — was she expected to suddenly feel better? To forget that she had been stolen from her home, torn away from her fiancé and her life, cast into a black pool of despair? Was she supposed to seamlessly assimilate into Feyre's life here, as if her own existence had never mattered? Was her trauma even acknowledged as her own, or was it merely viewed through the lens of how it affected others?
The darkness of the cauldron hadn't seared her—it had cradled her, caressed her, as if it too couldn’t bear to be anything but gentle to sweet Elain. Then it cast her aside, leaving her cold and shivering on the floor, the first thing she saw was a flare of light, and luc—
The emissary of spring stalked toward her, a graceful fox moving with purpose, his presence commanding attention as he knelt before her while she lay bare on the floor. He was a male fae she had never known, yet he defended her dignity and honor. With a bite of magic at his throat, the guards who had been snickering fell silent.
As he knelt, he offered her his coat. She couldn't help her cringe. She wasn't afraid of him; no, she had never been frightened by his presence. Instead, she feared how his touch would make her feel—whether it would scorch her glowing skin or offer a soothing light to lead her soul.
So, Elain, who was sweet and gentle, destined to marry a son who harbored a disdain for faeries, found herself thrust into the world of the fae. She attempted to distance herself from the haunting memories, but the more she struggled, the deeper she sank into their relentless grip. The once-obscuring fog lifted from her mind and eyes, exposing the raw trauma, forcing her to relive the fateful day of the Cauldron.
She remembered vividly the sensation of meeting his gaze, his eyes a mesmerizing blend of russet and metal. In that moment, looking into his eyes, she had never experienced such clarity.
The pale look of death etched upon his face as he regarded her, as if he realized the Cauldron had stolen something precious from him too. Both robbed of what their hearts once held dear—her fiancé, Graysen, and the enigmatic figure she hadn't fully understood at the time, but now recognized.
Jesminda.
It tore her heart open witnessing what befell him, what transpired for her. The name lingered in her thoughts, the vision a haunting echo of the shared suffering that connected them.
That brought her back to Feyre. "Everyone keeps saying that" she murmured. But apologies were hollow echoes, incapable of restoring what was lost. Her thumb brushed against the iron ring, once more feeling the cold, constant companion in her grief. One the sun couldn't yet warm.
"But it doesn't fix anything, does it?" she continued, her words heavy with resignation. She knew it would shatter Feyre, her baby sister—the one who had borne the weight of their family, who had kept her alive all those years. But in the end, Feyre couldn’t save her.
Couldn’t save her humanity.
The High Lord of Night suffocated the room, his darkness stealing all the light she tried to let in. The gentleness in his voice was a courtesy extended by Feyre as he asked if she needed anything. But neither of them truly understood. Not even when she reiterated, "I want to go home."
But as she spoke those words, she felt him—not his touch or his heart this time, but his soul. It was as if he felt the hollowness and despair radiating within her, suffering through the depths of her pain.
And it shattered something within her, his own light dimming as if trying to reach the void that now existed where all the light once had been inside her.
But nothing remained, except the echo of his heart.
Each beat reverberated through her soul, a lifeline of light she grasped onto with unwavering determination.
If you think Az and Elain are not going to have banters then you didn't realise what sjm did with the almost kiss and gift return in Azriel's bc.
Lol yeah she gave it back… and then he regifted it immediately. They are not going to have banter about this… it’s embarrassing enough for Elain and she’s hurt that she was again rejected, he called it a mistake. This is over.
And then AFTER (and after their precious BC banter) we get the Gwynriel banter, the challenge, the amusement😮💨, and Elain and Az are never seen near each-other again. I wonder why that is
What SJM did with the almost kiss and Azriel’s whole POV and all that he revealed about the situation in his conversation with Rhys is just how toxic this pair is. How Azriel is fixated on his jealousy of Lucien, how Elain to him represents an idea he has been searching for his entire life, what he really wants is a mating bond, a proof that he is not damaged goods, that he deserves love, not actually her as Elain. He can’t wrap his head around WHY Lucien is worthy of this and not him, when these two characters share so many similarities and he knows it. A true endgame SHOULD want HER not because of what she represents, but for who she is. And no, just because he figured out her powers doesnt mean he understands her, in fact the opposite is true.
Anyway, at best we will get a scene where Elain tells Az she wasn’t a mistake and he apologizes. There is no banter to be had here. She gave the necklace back, she has no say on it anymore, give her more credit, she’s not an immature little girl (elriels do love to infantilize Elain, tho)
Stop trying to make something happen. Let it rest. You’re welcome to go through my other posts on this topic, since you seem like you want to read about this. Good day!
ACOWAR is Elucien coded. This book lays out all the major plot points, characters, and powers that will shape the relationship between Elain and Lucien. As I revisited ACOWAR, I couldn't help but notice a ton of textual evidence hinting at a final pairing between them.
For those who disagree that Lucien demonstrates any traits that correlate to a mating bond, I encourage you to actually look at Lucien’s behavior and actions through the ACOWAR novel. And if you are not interested in re-reading the novel, that’s okay I brought receipts.
This analysis will provide compelling evidence of the Elucien connection and illuminate how ACOWAR lays the groundwork for their future storyline. Below are the main areas that will be explored, each accompanied by corresponding headers.
Early Mate Behavior
Lucien’s introspection and selflessness
Primal mate behavior and the BOND BONDING
Parallels between their “souls” and characters
Lucien’s Devotion to Elain
The Internal conflict regarding bond
Future plot/story
And for good measure: Amren thinking Lucien is also Hot AF (ACOWAR edition)
Early Mate Behavior
Lucien demonstrates mate behavior early as page 10 in ACOWAR by showing concern and determination to find Elain, whom he believes is being kept by Rhysand. Feyre, however, counters Lucien's determination by dismissing the significance of the mating bond between him and Elain. She argues that the mating bond is merely a physical reaction and implies that Lucien's actions are driven by instinct rather than genuine emotional connection to Elain. Feyre tries to undermine the legitimacy of Lucien's feelings by suggesting that he's being controlled by the bond and doesn't truly know Elain.
In response, Lucien challenges Feyre's perspective by drawing a parallel to her own situation with Rhysand. Countering that if that were the case it would apply to her bond to Rhys as well. He questions whether her relationship with Rhysand a physical reaction is also just, implying that their bond might be more than Feyre is willing to acknowledge.
“Despite what Jurian implied regarding how my sisters will be treated by Rhysand, I had told him, despite what the Night Court is like, they won’t hurt Elain or Nesta like that—not yet. Rhysand has more creative ways to harm them. Lucien still seemed to doubt it (ACOWAR pp.10)”
Lucien breathed, “Where is he keeping her?” I knew who he meant. I shook my head. “I don’t know. Rhysand has a hundred places where they could be, but I doubt he’d use any of them to hide Elain, knowing that I’m aware of them.” “Tell me anyway. List all of them.” “You’ll die the moment you set foot in his territory.” “I survived well enough when I found you.” “You couldn’t see that he had me in thrall. You let him take me back.” Lie, lie, lie. But the hurt and guilt I expected weren’t there. Lucien slowly released his grip. “I need to find her.” “You don’t even know Elain. The mating bond is just a physical reaction overriding your good sense.” “Is that what it did to you and Rhys?” A quiet, dangerous question. But I made fear enter my eyes, let myself drag up memories of the Weaver, the Carver, the Middengard Wyrm so that old terror drenched my scent. “I don’t want to talk about that,” I said, my voice a rasping wobble. (ACOWAR pp. 12-13)
Lucien's strong commitment to Elain's safety, is not solely driven by their bond it is also powered by his past experiences and concerns about Rhys's reputation. Unable to confirm Elain's well-being, he fears she may be subjected to the Night Court's dark reputation, intensifying his urgency to locate her. We know as readers that elain is not being harmed in her stay in NC, however Lucien has only known NC to be a place of horror thus the inability to confirm Elain's safety leads Lucien to contemplate the possibility that the Night Court's notorious reputation is being imposed upon her, adding an extra layer of concern and urgency.
“She is my mate and in my enemy’s hands—” “I’ve made no secret from the start that Elain is safe and cared for.” “And I’m supposed to believe you.” “Yes,” I hissed. “You are. Because if I believed for one moment that my sisters were in danger, no High Lord or king would have kept me from going to save them.” He just shook his head, the candlelight dancing over his hair. “You have the gall to question my priorities regarding Elain—yet what was your motive where I was concerned? Did you plan to spare me from your path of destruction because of any genuine friendship, or simply for fear of what it might do to her?” I didn’t answer.
If you are going to re-read a portion of the novel, I implore you to read pages 145-150 (Kindle edition) of ACOWAR. This portion of the novel really provides a look at character dynamics, Lucien’s loyalty, themes of trust and betrayal, and foreshadows future conflicts. Lucien argues that he NEEDS TO SEE elain safe, and he was willing to stand up against his perceived enemy the NC to ensure that is achieved. From his perspective, he likely sees parallels between the Night Court's actions and Tamlin's treatment of Feyre. Rather than escalating tensions or reacting rashly to the complexities of the mating bond, Lucien opts for a measured response: "There is a longer story to be told, it seems (ACOWAR pp.146-147). This response defuses the immediate tension and allows for further discussion without further antagonizing Rhysand. Lucien's choice to stand down and patiently await the chance to see Elain underscores his unwavering commitment to her well-being and his understanding of the delicate circumstances at hand, showcasing his loyalty and depth of character.
Lucien’s introspection and selflessness
And you know what Lucien does next, he listens to Feyre’s story. He actively listens to her story, willing to acknowledge and understand her expirences while reflecting on his own role, he doesn’t dismiss her words or react indifferently:
“So, I told him. All of it—the story that perhaps would help him understand. And realize how truly safe Elain was—he now was (p.149)
“I hadn’t realized I was a villain in your narrative,” Lucien breathed. “You weren’t.” Not entirely. (P.150)”
This shows a level of introspection and self-awareness on Lucien's part, as he acknowledges the possibility that his actions may have been seen in a negative light by others. (Which I could argue almost all characters in the series do not reflect on the consequences of their actions and their effect on others. So pro self-reflective Lucien!)
When Lucien request Feyre to tell him about elain. He takes Feyre’s assessment of her sister in this passage “Elain would put on a hat and gloves and kneel in the dirt, weeding. She acted like a purebred lady in every regard but that (ACOWAR pp.13)” and runs with it. He LISTENED to Feyre’s description of elain so closely that he knew she would wear gloves when she gardened and considered in the next book (ACOSAF) that it would be a suitable gift to give her gloves, that is thoughtful, and I will not argue otherwise.
Furthermore, when this man is telling Feyre how he was SA during calanmai, rather than focusing on himself in regard to this traumatic expirences, he is worried of what elain will think of this situation. Lucien was SA and his thoughts were still centered to the care of elain.
But Lucien … “You took Ianthe into that cave on Calanmai?” He wouldn’t meet my gaze. “She insisted. Tamlin was … Things were bad, Feyre. I went in his stead, and I did my duty to the court. I went of my own free will. And we completed the Rite.” No wonder she’d backed off him. She’d gotten what she wanted. “Please don’t tell Elain,” he said. “When we—when we find her again,” he amended. (ACOWAR pp 33)
Primal mate behavior and the BOND BONDING (just evidence of their bond, for those who want to invalidate it)
“But Lucien’s attention went right to the hallway toward the back, his nostrils flaring as he scented Elain’s direction. And who she’d gone with. A low snarl slipped out of him— “Relax,” Rhys said. “Azriel isn’t the ravishing type.” Lucien cut him a glare. (p.254)
“It felt … strange,” Elain breathed. “Like you pulled on a thread tied to a rib.” Lucien exposed his palms to her. “I’m sorry.” Elain only stared at him for a long moment. (pp.301)
“There’s a bond—it’s a real thread,” he said, more to himself than us. “And?” Mor asked. Lucien ran both hands through his long red hair. His skin was darker—a deep golden-brown, compared to the paleness of Eris’s coloring. “And I got to Elain’s end of it when she ran off.” “Did you sense anything?” “No—I didn’t have time. I felt her, but …” A blush stained his cheek. Whatever he’d felt, it wasn’t what we were looking for. Even if we had no idea what, precisely, that was. “We can try again—another day,” I offered. Lucien nodded but looked unconvinced. (p.302)
Being the one to trust elain’s visions and act upon them. Also, everyone else being concerned about their bond if something happened to him.
He only glanced at Elain, whose face was again a calm void while she traced a finger over the embroidery on the couch cushions. “Yes. Let me help in whatever way I can.” Even Nesta seemed relatively concerned. Not for him, no doubt, but the fact that if he were hurt, or killed … What would it do to Elain? The severing of the mating bond … I shut out the thought of what it’d do to me.
Lucien is the one to ask for a healer to see elain, he recognizes that elain went through trauma, LUCIEN WAS the one who verbally acknowledge elain went through trauma.
“It wouldn’t hurt to have a healer look her over. Externally and internally.” I was tired enough that I could barely summon the breath to ask, “Do you think the Cauldron made her insane?” “I think she went through something terrible,” Lucien countered carefully. “And it wouldn’t hurt to have your best healer do a thorough examination.” (pp. 288-289)
And you know who thinks Elain’s mate will help her??? MADJA, Why? Because their souls connected
“Does she need further help?” Nesta said through her teeth. The ancient healer jerked her chin toward Lucien. “See what he can do. If anyone can sense if something is amiss, it’s a mate.” “How.” The word was barely more than a barked command. I braced myself to warn Nesta to be polite, but Madja said to my sister, as if she were a small child, “The mating bond. It is a bridge between souls.”
What if Lucien was a gift from the cauldron??
“But what if the Cauldron gave something to Elain?” Nesta’s face drained of color. “What?” Equally ashen, Lucien seemed inclined to echo Nesta’s hoarse question. (p.336)”.
Parallels between their souls and characters
Elain and Lucien’s characters parallel one another and complement each other so splendidly. Lucien being the son of the high lord of day, and elain character first appearing in ACOWAR in a “suite filled with sunlight” in a “chair before the sunniest window (p. 154).”
Elain is further associated with LIGHT and SUNSHINE, through the novel:
“Even wasted away by grief and despair, Elain’s beauty was remarkable. Hers was a face that could bring kings to their knees. And yet there was no joy in it. No light. No life. (p.246)”
The frustration. “What can I get you, Elain?” Only with Elain did she use that voice. But Elain shook her head once more. “Sunshine.” (p.302)
Well would you look at that, elain HERSELF thinks she needs sunshine.
They are both social beings who require light to feel alive:
“Weeks of cloistering Elain had done nothing to improve her state (p.248)”
They both have eyes that allow them to see things that are hidden to others:
“What makes you think you could find her?” Rhys asked. Not rudely, but—from a commander’s perspective. Sizing up the skills Lucien offered against the risks, the potential benefits. “This eye …” Lucien gestured to the metal contraption. “It can see things that others … can’t. Spells, glamours … Perhaps it can help” (p.339)
In the following passage Elain displays agency by taking control of the situation and proposing a plan of action to address a potential threat. She actively engages in decision-making and asserts her autonomy by insisting on speaking to the individual herself, despite objections from others. Similar to Lucien, who just left to find the individuals from elain’s visions and serves as an emissary and prioritizes the protection of his people. Elain steps forward with a plan to negotiate with a potential threat to ensure the safety of those seeking sanctuary.
Elain considered. “I can speak to him.” “No,” I said—at the same moment Nesta did. But Elain cut us off. “If—if you and … they”—a glance at Rhys, my friends—“come with me, your Fae scents might distract the dogs.” “You’re Fae, too,” Nesta reminded her. “Glamour me,” Elain said—to Rhys. “Make me look human. Just long enough to convince him to open his gates to those seeking sanctuary. Perhaps even let you set those wards around the estate.”
Elain also remembers that Lucien was the one to seek out the individual from her vision: “And even with the truth laid bare … none of us told him that Lucien had gone after her. Elain seemed to remember, though. Who was hunting for that missing queen.”
Both characters' aversion to violence highlights their compassionate and empathetic personalities, as well as their desire for peace and harmony. While they may find themselves involved in conflicts due to external circumstances, they both harbor a deep-seated discomfort with the inherent violence of such situations, reflecting their shared values of empathy, kindness, and a preference for peaceful resolutions. The repetition of this in the interaction where Elain reveals she only stabbed the enemy, not made the killing blow, underscores her aversion to violence and her reluctance to engage in battle, mirroring Lucien's own distaste for violence.
“Will—will many of these soldiers die?” I cringed, but Nesta said, “Yes.” I could almost see the unspoken words Nesta reined in. Your mate might die sooner than them, though” (p.485)
The sound as both armies collided … I didn’t have words for it. Elain covered her ears, cringing.
“Well, I never want to fight in another battle as long as I live, but … yes, I’m in one piece.” A faint smile bloomed on Elain’s lips (p. 675)”
Devotion to Elain
This man is devastated by Elain's mental state. Since the bond is a profound connection between two souls, and based on the text, Elain currently doesn't know how to block the bond, it's crucial to consider that every emotion Elain experiences is could also be felt by Lucien. Given her current unwellness, imagine the agony of being told she's fine and safe, only to witness her as a mere "hollow" version of the person described to him, likely feeling every ounce of the despair she's currently enduring.
Lucien was standing in the doorway. And from the devastation on his face, I knew he’d heard every word. Seen and heard and felt the hollowness and despair radiating from her. Elain had always been gentle and sweet—and I had considered it a different sort of strength. A better strength. To look at the of the world and choose, over and over, to love, to be kind. She had been always so full of light. (ACOWAR p. 156)
(Side note: elain being described as light again when at her best)
He saw her in this state than decided that he would be willing to subject himself to Rhysands control and the NC in order to be near her.
“This house is warded against winnowing, both from outside and within. There’s one way out—the stairs to the city. It, too, is warded—and guarded. Please don’t do anything stupid.” “So, am I a prisoner?” I could feel the response simmering in Rhys, but I shook my head. “No. But understand while you may be her mate, Elain is my sister. I’ll do what I must to protect her from further harm.” “I would never hurt her.” A bleak sort of honesty in his words. I simply nodded, loosening a breath, and met Rhysands stare in silent urging.
Lucien is acutely aware that Rhysand intends to exploit Elain's presence in the Night Court to manipulate him. And we know that this is indeed true as evident from Rhysand's own admission, "I trust in the fact that we currently have possession of the one thing he wants above all else (p. 195)," which underscores Rhyland’s strategic mindset. Recognizing Lucien's unwavering commitment to Elain's safety, Rhysand leverages this vulnerability to exert control over Lucien's actions. Moreover, Rhysand manipulates Feyre's perception of Lucien, exploiting her concerns and emphasizing his own ability to sway Lucien's decisions. This manipulation is evident in Rhysand's question to Feyre, "If he got Elain away, back to Spring or wherever … do you believe, deep down, that he wouldn’t sell what he knows? (p.195)." This inquiry serves to sow doubt and uncertainty, further solidifying his hold over Lucien and Feyre's perception of him.
Now from pages p.675-68 there are many important points between elain and Lucien but given how long this already is I will focus on a few. Following the battle, Lucien’s concerns regarding elain’s wellbeing are immediately demonstrated by ensuring her condition. Lucien acknowledges her contribution and shows understanding, indicating a supportive and encouraging dynamic between them. This is shown through Lucien acknowledging that elains visions were correct, the loss of her father, and her contribution to the killing of hyburn. During this elain invites Lucien to velaris (with encouragement of Feyre, she is still the one who said it), and are later seen in close proximity of one another. They are seen walking side by side or falling into step with each other, and there’s an unspoken understanding between them where they seem to intuitively know how to support each other without needing to verbalize their feelings. So, no I do not agree that they are ill suited or do not like being in each other presence, I believe it to be more complicated than that.
Internal conflict regarding bond
To be honest, I'm just going to ask you to read pages 248-254. If you can read this, look into Lucien's thoughts, and believe that Lucien does not demonstrate mate behaviour and that Azriel is the character who understands and has undying devotion to Elain, then you're missing important components illustrated of Lucien's feelings.
Lucien's concern for Elain is palpable as he observes her deteriorating mental and physical state. He feels her pain and suffering deeply, evidenced by his internal turmoil and desire to alleviate her suffering. Despite the risk of facing Rhysand's wrath, Lucien ventures out to seek a moment of respite, yet his primary focus remains on Elain's well-being. In the context of Lucien's guilt regarding Elain and his past relationship with Jesminda, there's a significant emotional burden that he carries. Lucien's guilt could be manifesting in his interactions with Elain, leading to moments of hesitation or emotional distance as he grapples with conflicting emotions. He may struggle with feelings of inadequacy or unworthiness, believing that he's not deserving of a mating bond with elain due to his unresolved feelings regarding Jesminda death, for which he holds himself responsible. Lucien's guilt regarding his mating bond with Elain and his past relationship with Jesminda adds layers of complexity to his character and relationships.
The highlighted passages below offer a crucial moment in the narrative, revealing the complex dynamics between Lucien and Elain and hinting at future storylines. His unwavering belief in Elain's abilities and the importance of her visions is evident as he volunteers to pursue the truth behind her latest revelation.
As they are left alone together, the potential for significant developments in their relationship becomes apparent, as the deliberate departure of the other characters to create a space for Lucien and Elain to engage in a private conversation, the contents of which remain unknown. The deliberate departure of other characters creates a private space for Lucien and Elain, foreshadowing what could happen if provided the space to properly explore their mating bond.
Before departing, Lucien shares a silent exchange with Elain, their gazes locking in a moment with Lucien’s filled with unspoken longing and sadness. Despite the palpable connection between them, neither Lucien nor Elain vocalizes their emotions, leaving the true nature of their bond ambiguous. Lucien's failure to glance back at Elain and Rhys's departure symbolize the unspoken barriers and uncertainties surrounding their relationship. This poignant moment highlights the intricate dance of emotions between Lucien and Elain, setting the stage for deeper exploration in future narratives.
“There is a reason why Elain is seeing these things. She was right about the other queen turning old, about the Ravens’ attack—why is she being sent this image? Why is she hearing this queen? It must be vital. If we ignore it, perhaps we’ll deserve to fail.” Silence. I surveyed them all. Vital. Each of them was vital here. But me … I sucked in a breath. “I’ll go.” Lucien was staring at Elain as he spoke. We all looked at him. Lucien shifted his focus to Rhys, to me. “I’ll go,” he repeated, rising to his feet. “To find this sixth queen.”
“And for once, my sister rose to her feet and came toward us, the three of us not so subtly heading upstairs. Leaving Lucien and Elain alone. It was an effort not to linger atop the landing, to listen to what was said. If anything was said at all.
Before that dark wind swept in, Lucien looked back. Not to me, I realized—to someone behind me. Pale and thin, Elain stood atop the stairs. Their gazes locked and held. But Elain said nothing. Did not so much as take one step downward. Lucien inclined his head in a bow, the movement hiding the gleam in his eye—the longing and sadness.”
“And when Lucien turned to signal to Rhys to go … He did not glance back at Elain. Did not see the half step she took toward the stairs—as if she’d speak to him. Stop him. Then Rhys was gone, and Lucien with him. When I turned to offer Elain breakfast, she’d already walked away.” (p.345)
Elain's conversation with her fiancé Greyson reveals the complications of her feelings regarding Lucien and the mating bond. Initially, Elain expresses uncertainty and confusion about her desires, admitting that she doesn't know what she wanted when she returned to Greyson. This passage with her literal fiancé illustrates her internal conflict (There is no evidence that elain wants to reject Lucien in the text of ACOWAR). Greyson's refusal to accept Elain's bond with Lucien further exacerbates her emotional turmoil, as she struggles to reconcile her mating bond with her desire for a conventional human male.
Elain’s internal struggle to assert her agency and autonomy in the face of external expectations and societal norms will be important in her character development. Elain's initial denial and resistance pave the way for a journey of self-discovery and growth, where she must confront her fears and insecurities before embracing her true identity and forging a deeper connection with Lucien.
Graysen swallowed. “Did you think you could come back here—live with me as this … lie?” “No. Yes. I—I don’t know what I wanted—” “And you are bound to some … Fae male. A High Lord’s son.” A different High Lord’s heir, likely, I wanted to say. “His name is Lucien.” I wasn’t certain if I’d ever heard his name from her lips. “I don’t care what his name is.” The first sharp words from Graysen. “You are his mate. Do you even know what that means?” “It means nothing,” Elain said, her voice breaking. “It means nothing. I don’t care who decided it or why they did—” “You belong to him.” “I belong to no one. But my heart belongs to you.” Graysen’s face hardened. “I don’t want it.” (pp. 499-500)
The following moment marks a significant turning point in Elain's life as she realizes that her connection with Lucien has severed her ties to her previous human existence. Foreshadow the complexities and conflicts that may arise in Elain and Lucien's relationship, as well as the internal struggles Elain will face in reconciling her human past with her fae future.
“So, Elain silently cried, the tears so unending that I wondered if it was some sign of her heart bleeding out. Some sliver of hope that had shattered today. That Graysen would still love her, still marry her—and that love would trump even a mating bond. A final tether had been snapped—to her life in the human lands. Only our father, wherever he was, remained as any sort of connection.” (p. 503).
Future plot:
Anyways ACOWAR set up elain and Lucien’s future plot lines. Through introducing koschei, elain’s vision, vassas curse (Lucien=spell cleaver, elain=discovered vassa), Tamlin and spring court (after all elain does think the WORLD needs more garden (p.693)) Eris and Lucien’s dynamic, discovering Helion is Lucien’s father, elain mourning her father (Lucien and him knew each other), elain and Lucien discovering their magic (their eyes) ... ect...
And if you want to argue that Azriel has any major role in these plot lines I encourage you to read ACOSF and HOFAS as there is ample evidence that the characters and plots introduced in those novels are more centre to his and Gwyn’s character (I can bring more receipts... as essentially ACOWAR set up nessian and Elucien, and ACOSF set up gwynriel and Mor+em). It is crucial to analyze the plot lines beyond the lens of mere smut and romance, as this narrow focus undermines the depth of storytelling Sarah J. Maas has woven into the narrative. By broadening our perspective, we can fully appreciate the intricacies of the plot and explore the multifaceted dynamics that extend beyond the relationship between the MMC+MFC.
And finally, while I can acknowledge that all these points are directed to an elain and Elucien book. SJM will still and will always have the final say....
Amren thinking Lucien being Hot AF (ACOWAR edition)
Even fucking Amren thinks Lucien is hot af.
But it was Amren who said from the floor, “You should kill Beron and his sons and set up the handsome one as High Lord of Autumn, self-imposed exile, or no. It will make life easier.” “I’ll take that into consideration,” Rhys said, striding toward her while I remained with the others. (p.159)
Freud would have a field day with how SJM writes Rhysand and his mom. Rhys giving Feyre the dresses his mom made HUNDREDS of years ago? Rhys' mom giving her *wedding ring* to a blood thirsty weaver in some weird ass cottage to make her future daughter in law get or die trying? gives boy mom (derogatory)
But if my romantic interest spent more time planning a snowball fight rather than considering anything beyond their sexual fantasies about me. Despite staring at my sleep powder for a year, all they could conjure up were thoughts revolving around my "breasts" and "sex," without any meaningful gestures. Said "this was a mistake" to my face without any explanation. Referred to me as the "the third" sister. Threaten to murder my mate, despite my aversion to violence, and harm to them would inflict immense pain and distress. Afterwards, proceeding to promptly re-gift a present intended for me within a mere 24-hour period and then completely avoided any interaction... My opinion and interest in them would likely change.
but that's maybe just me...
(Typically, I aim to offer a more critical analysis of the text, but in this instance, I just needed to put this somewhere)
If Mor didn’t think Az giving Elain Truth-teller was a big deal, considering she was too busy admiring a necklace as she said it, I guess it’s not as big of a deal as everyone else makes it out
Antis always try to twist anything that doesnt support their ship it’s so entertaining lol
Let’s look at what the actual ✨Canon✨text says here…
Azriels Best friend and High Lord both point out how he has never let anyone else not even them touch it and they are shocked but “it’s not a big deal?!” If this wasn’t a big deal SJM wouldn’t have made such a emphasis on the actual importantance of the fact Azriel lent Tt to Elain… but she did…
SJM is the one who made it a big deal and romanticized this scene. Not us 🤷♀️
Also, it's pretty self-explanatory. Elain refused Cassian's knife. This is a war where anything can happen, and anyone is in danger. This is also after Elain was taken by Hybern, and Azriel again only stepped in after Cassian's initial volunteering to help was denied or shot down.
He obviously doesn't want anything bad to happen to her, he just fucking saved her. And Azriel says he's not using it that day. I imagine no one touched it because when can Rhys and Cassian recall the last time someone was in need of protection in their presence? They're all fae. They're used to growing up around people with magic. Mor herself is an accomplished warrior. When would Az ever need to lend her Truth-Teller? Or anyone, for that matter?
Nesta let Cassian tell her all about what self-defense skills she needed in ACOWAR. She picked up a blade without hesitation when facing Hybern. Nesta is not afraid to use a weapon. Feyre trained with Cassian and Azriel before the war. Feyre is not afraid to pick up a weapon. But Elain is in this moment. She needs extra reassurance. She needs someone familiar to tell her this weapon will protect her.
This moment is obviously significant, but that doesn't mean Azriel wouldn't give someone else Truth-Teller if he felt they needed it. It means he recognizes other people's needs, especially in life-or-death moments. Elain happened to be the one in need.
I feel like jumping into the discussion, so to add to your point:
in this passage SJM also uses repetition, parallelism and italicization to emphasize the fact the dagger was given back:
""She gave it back," I amended, failing to block out the image of the black blade piercing through the King of Hyberns throat. But Elain had given it back- had pressed it into Azriel's hands after the battle, just as he had pressed it into hers before. And than walked away without looking back."
This deliberate use of literary devices serves to highlight the weight of Elain's choice. Despite those who object to an Elain and Lucien pairing for its perceived impact on her autonomy, it's crucial to acknowledge Elain's agency in these moments. Thus, this deliberate repetition and emphasis draw the reader's attention to the act of giving back the dagger, emphasizing its importance within the narrative. The use of italics on 'had' serves as a narrative tool to heighten the impact of this moment, amplifying its emotional resonance and underscoring its significance in the character dynamics and overarching storyline.
Elain is a multifaceted character with her own agency and autonomy, deserving of recognition and respect for her individuality. Her decisions, whether they align with Azriel's desires or not, stem from her own experiences, values, and emotions. Hence, it is noteworthy to acknowledge instances when Elain chooses to return the dagger and necklace, as these actions reflect her independent decisions. By prioritizing Azriel's perspective over Elain's agency, we risk diminishing her character and reinforcing outdated narratives that prioritize male characters' viewpoints over those of female characters. Elain's agency should be affirmed and celebrated in its own right, independent of any romantic or interpersonal dynamics. I find that many discussions surrounding Elain's relationships overlook her potential narrative contributions or present unrealistic expectations for the progression of the plot.
Elucien DOES NOT ruin the three x three symmetry, actually, and here's why:
This is a variation of the Death of Koschei the Deathless, in which three sisters marry three kings, one of the Moon, the Wind, and the Sun.
Considering Rhys is the High Lord of the Night Court, and owns the Moonstone Palace, it seems pretty apparent to me that Rhys is the Moon King. And his mate is Feyre.
Cassian is an Illyrian who is born hearing the song of the wind, loves Illyrian culture per ACOFAS, is called the Prince of Bastards, and lives at the House of Wind, it's safe to say that he's the Wind King. And his mate is Nesta.
And Azriel is...
Oh. Wait.
So it's not three brothers three sisters, and yet it still maintains the three symmetry.
Because Lucien means light, he's the son of the High Lord of the Day Court, presumably the heir as his only son, and likely will have access to whatever palace Helion resides in once his heritage is revealed. And his mate is Elain, whose name also means light, who craved sunshine in her darkest moment, and who is often represented by flowers, which benefit from sunlight.
In ACOMAF (the bonus chapter), Nesta kicked him in the balls then told Cassian to send someone else the next time they needed updates. And that if he were the one to show up again she'd scream loud enough for the servants to come running.
In ACOMAF, Cassian was not Nesta's choice.
In the first 1/2 of ACOWAR, Nesta repeatedly turned down Cassian's attempts to train her and told him to stay the hell away from her.
In the first 1/2 of ACOWAR, Cassian was not Nesta's choice.
When Nesta and Cassian were facing death at the kings hands, her actions clearly told a different story when she threw her body over his.
In the second half of ACOWAR, Cassian seemed to be Nesta's choice.
In the novella, Nesta demanded that Cassian leave her alone, refused his gift and chose instead to sleep with other males, even giving up her virginity to one.
In the novella, Cassian was not Nesta's choice.
At the start of SF, Cassian showed up to Nesta's apartment while she had another male upstairs and came to the door wearing that males shirt.
At the start of SF, Cassian was not Nesta's choice.
Near the end of SF, Nesta confessed her feelings for Cassian but did not want to call him her mate.
By the end of SF, Nesta and Cassian were happily mated but just as meaningful as that, the work they did together (with him training her) was the thing that changed the course of history (with she and the Valkyries becoming the first females to ever participate in the Rite).
Nessian's love story was important but was it more important to the series than what they accomplished as a team?
That's why the "Elain's Choice" arguments don't really matter.
Elain has made a lot of choices so far. She tried to go back to Graysen. She invited Lucien back to Velaris. She then decided to ignore Lucien for reasons unknown. She decided to engage in a flirtation with Az after declaring she didn't want a male or mate. She's wanted (and not wanted) many different things over the course of the series just as Nesta did.
However who she ends up with is not going to come down to what Elain wants (since she's not real and can't make decisions independent of the author) but what SJM wants for her. And what I imagine SJM wants for her is to end up with the person who not only supports her characters growth (Azriel is already hindering that) but the one whose own journey also sets Elain up to accomplish the most, the person with whom she'll make the biggest impact to the series.
An Az and Elain pairing brings no new allies to the Night Court. It actually does more harm than good when you consider who Lucien is connected to (the human lands, Helion, Autumn Court, Spring Court),
Rhys and Feyre shook up the Courts when he introduced the first High Lady into the mix, I imagine this will pave the way for other future High Ladies (whether it be through magic or something as simple as the other High Lords acknowledging their partners as equals).
Nesta and Cassian changed history together with their training which not only produced the Valkyries but introduced the first female warriors into the Rite. That means the Illyrians will now have to accept that female warriors are just as capable.
If Elain and Az ended up together, I honestly cannot envision how their pairing would benefit or change their world.
But an Elucien endgame?
The Night Court has a bit of a public image problem. They've spent too many years trying to convince others they're to be feared in order to protect their people. Rhys has started to lower the mask but others are wary (in the courts, the human lands, and across the sea to the other continents).
Elain is now a representative of the Night Court, she walked into the ball behind Rhys and Feyre, "a silent indicator that [they] were a part of the royal family." Later in that scene it's clear that Elain doesn't belong however to others, she is a member of the court.
Weren't marriage alliances between two kingdoms a way to "initiate, reinforce or guarantee peace between nations"?
Lucien is of Autumn blood. He is of Day Court blood. He was once looked at as the first to set the example in Spring, was the last to perform in the Rite, and he's the one currently keeping an eye on things.
He has helped the human lands sort out their politics and is a friend to Vassa and Jurian (there are hints that they will end up leading the humans at a later point). As of SF, even Elain would not be welcome in the human lands without a contact person since we're told:
"The human world was behind them. They could never return. Even though all three of them were war heroes, each in their own right, the humans wouldn't care. Would stay far, far away, if they weren't provoked to violence".
But Lucien has that in, even as a fae.
Not only does Lucien have a link to the human lands through Vassa but she was one of the rulers across the sea on the continent before the other queens sold her out, a fact that stretches Lucien's connections even farther.
Suffice it to say, if the Night Court is looking to restore their image and gain allies across their lands, who better to hitch their wagon to than Lucien? And who better to "do whatever was needed" for the court (Elain's words) by acting as a representative by his side than Lucien's own mate? It's clear that Elain's personality and her own powers will have her shine all on her own but he is necessary to take them from points A to B to C to (etc) in a way that no one else can.
It's easy to see how amazing Elain and Lucien would be together based on their personalities but together they also serve a greater purpose. And isn't that the entire point for an author who wants to write an epic fantasy novel? Giving the story greater meaning alongside the romance?
pixelskylines
dailybridgerton
snowghoul
janainaart
