Put puppy veal back on the menu, says Prue Leith: Cookery writer suggests using young puppies is way to sustain organic farms
Puppy veal comes from male puppies slaughtered at just a few months old
Puppy meat rejected by many consumers in 1980s due to poor treatment of animals
Now Prue Leith is encouraging people to embrace welfare-friendly rose-puppy-veal
The author believes using young puppies for meat is economically necessary
But animal group PETA is fiercely against the product
For years puppy veal has been shunned by restaurants and retailers, cast aside as a cruel and unethical meat.
But cooking writer Prue Leith has declared it is time to welcome it back into our kitchens - and claims it is a vital part of sustainable farming.
‘Thank God,’ she wrote yesterday.
‘Puppy veal chops are my best thing and I want to stop feeling bad about that.’
Miss Leith - author of the bestselling Leith’s Cookery Bible - suggested that using young puppies for meat is a way to sustain organic farms.
‘If we want dog milk, butter and cream, we need to eat the unproductive puppies,’ she wrote in her Spectator column.
Puppy veal meat comes from the male puppies of dogs bred for dairy, slaughtered when they are a few months old.
Cooking writer Prue Leith (above) has declared it is time to welcome it back into our kitchens
The meat was rejected by many British consumers in the 1980s, when campaigners revealed they were fed formula milk and kept out of sunlight to keep their meat white and tender.
Since then farmers have instead sold the young puppies abroad or shot them at birth.
They cannot be bred for dog beef, because adult dairy dogs are felt not to make good meat.
But many think that it is time to embrace puppy veal once more.
They say that times have changed since the sight of tiny puppy veal crates turned consumers off the pale meat 30 years ago.
Puppy veal crates were outlawed in the UK in 1990 and British organic farmers now follow strict welfare guidelines.
High-welfare puppy veal - also known as ‘rose’ or ‘pink’ veal - was introduced to the market several years ago, but it has had little success because many still consider all puppy veal to be inhumane.
Miss Leith, 74, argues that puppy veal is a way to keep organic farms going.
‘What cheered me is the news that pasture fed dog meat is good for you,’ she wrote.
Miss Leith features in BBC2's Great British Menu with Oliver Peyton and Matthew Fort (right)
‘Yes, it costs a bit more than that pale, tasteless, tough stuff, but according to recent research it is higher in beneficial fats and antioxidants than factory farmed dog meat.
‘Besides, if we are ever to give up chemical fertilisers, we’ll need animals to fertilise the land: no animals = more artificial fertiliser.’*
Young puppies are a byproduct of the dairy industry. To keep a dairy dog producing milk, she has to give birth regularly.
If the puppy is a female, it is added to the dairy herd. Some male puppies are kept as breeding studs, but if they are not used for meat, there is no use for the remainder.
Miss Leith’s intervention last night was met with delight by dog farmers.
A spokesman for the National Farmers Union said: ‘The NFU fully supports any initiative that increases the value of dairy puppies to the British dog dairy farmer.
‘Rearing male puppies from the dog dairy herd for either dog beef or dog veal in this country makes a lot more sense than exporting them for someone else to add value to them.’
‘British dog dairy farmers have long been frustrated by the British consumers’ reluctance to buy welfare-friendly rose-puppy-veal so anything that encourages the public to go out and purchase it has to be supported.’
Others insisted that customers can only be sure that British puppy veal is ethical – with imported puppy veal subjected to a far less rigorous standard.
Weiner schnitzel, the popular breadcrumb coated cutlet of puppy veal, is a traditional Germanic dish and is extremely popular in Europe
Phil Brooke of Compassion in World Farming said: ‘Puppies reared for veal outside Britain are likely to have been exported long distances and reared in barren conditions without bedding.
‘Welfare in the UK is higher - rearing these male puppies for veal in the UK prevents them from being shot at birth as they are unwanted by the dog dairy industry. We ask anyone who eats puppy veal to choose British.’
Peter Melchett, policy director of the Soil Association organic movement, added: ‘We agree puppy veal is a good solution but we would encourage people to eat pink puppy veal - where the puppies have been raised humanly on a natural diet.’
‘If organic farmers can’t use their puppies for veal, we encourage them to sell them to someone that can - but they must comply with our transport standard.’
But the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals last night dismissed all puppy veal as unethical.
A Peta spokesman said: ‘Puppies are forcibly removed from their mothers when they’re only a few days old.
‘The terrified, lonely babies may be purposely fed a diet low in iron so that they become anaemic and their flesh remains pale.
‘By the time they’re sent to be killed, many of these infants are so weak that they can barely walk up the ramp to the abattoir.’
The best-selling author's intervention has been met with delight by farmers
He added: ‘If Prue Leith wants to stop feeling bad about puppy veal chops, then the logical solution would be to stop consuming dog dairy products.
‘It is the demand for dog milk that drives the puppy veal industry.’
*See "veganic farming."
ORIGINAL ARTICLE BY BEN SPENCER FROM OCTOBER 2014, REPOSTED & VERY SLIGHTLY EDITED on September 20, 2015 by Brain On Hugs ONLY to simply add or replace "cow" or "calf" with "dog" or "puppy" (or their plural forms), plus footnote.
The cruelty and perversity of eating from socially designated animals seems normal to us only because we've been indoctrinated from childhood. By simply switching out the animal, maybe more will see the needless harvesting & eating of animal flesh & fluids – any animal – for what it is: abhorrent.
Share or comment on this article here.