Bridgerton season 4: mixed feelings, but overall probably my favorite
Sophie (and especially her friendships with the other servants)
Benedict is definitely still bi
Cressida Cowper came out ok and has read Mary Wollstonecraft! She has the aggressively pink drawing room of her dreams! Eloise forgives her and they're kind of friends again!
Eloise and Hyacinth finding a way to a stronger sisterly relationship!
Basically everything with John, Francesca, and Michaela was great. I really cared about them this season despite knowing tragedy was inevitable, and I found Francesca's reaction to grief...horribly relatable. Francesca being autistic-coded was really, really obvious to me this season, and some of the things (like her stress at having her routines suddenly disrupted), ha, well, my routines aren't as scheduled but...yeah. Michaela, on the other hand, is ADHD-coded, so I guess that's gonna be their Dynamic next season.
Penelope was gorgeous. Forever baffled by that reviewer who was all "this is unrealistic, she's not hot". Like, one, most people fall in love based largely on personality, and "hot"/"not hot" marriages happen all the time? But also, Colin Bridgerton is fine but I'm not sure I could pick him out of a lineup of dark-haired youngish men. I'm more into butch women in general but goddamn, I would swipe right so hard on Penelope. She's just...wow.
Overall I feel like this season was a bit less focused on the main couple and had more going on with other characters, and I can see why people didn't like that so much from a genre romance perspective, but I enjoyed it a lot more from a TV perspective. One of the things I've always found meh about genre romance series is that 90% of the focus is the main couple, with cameos of couples from previous series popping up to be blandly maritally happy plus some seeds for the couple in the next book. It feels sort of claustrophobic and shallow to me - I want to see the couple in the context of their community and other relationships, living full lives that aren't just about their romantic relationship. The TV show does a pretty good job of it (although established couples still tend to be blandly maritally blissful).
It's true that season 4 has a LOT of side character subplots - Lady Danbury trying to get the queen's leave to visit her home country, Alice Mondrich navigating the court, Penelope quitting Lady Whistledown, Eloise trying to dodge marriage and navigating her relationship with Hyacinth, who can't wait to jump into the marriage mart, probably some others that I'm forgetting, and most importantly, setting up Francesca, John, and Michaela for season 5. But I still felt we got plenty of Sophie and Benedict, and in season 4 of a TV show that is as much as an ensemble show as a couple-focused romance, we have to expect a lot of plot threads being picked up or tied off.
THINGS I DIDN'T LIKE/THAT WORRY ME ABOUT SEASON 5:
I really don't like the implication with Violet and Benedict both that when you fall in love with the right person, you naturally become sedate and conventional. Yes, at the end it's indicated that Violet wants to reconnect with the part of her that was a wild girl (although not, I suspect, the way Benedict was wild, because sexist double standards), and yes, Benedict does tell Sophie he's bi and she's ok with that. And yes, it's not really healthy to live the bohemian party lifestyle forever (and the dark side of that which he encounters when he saves Sophie from assault may have soured him a bit). But...it's just a little too close to the idea that bisexuality is just youthful experimentation that becomes unimportant when you meet the right opposite-sex partner.
Like, I don't have a problem with Benedict ending up with a woman! It's just the framing of "right partner" = "become a good conforming member of society" that I'm ehhhhh about. I hope that at least in future seasons we'll see Benedict pursuing art or music more seriously, and maintaining connections with the good parts of his bohemian life, the people he says he cares about, introducing Sophie to them. They both love art, after all! I just don't want that entire phase of his life to be put away as a "childish things". And I don't think Sophie would, either!
Which brings me to my big concern about season 5. I really liked Francesca and John's autistic4autistic-coded romance, and they really made me care about John even knowing he was doomed. One of the tropes I dislike most in genre romance is the one where neither of the main couple can ever have known "true" passionate love before. The show seems to have softened that up - Francesca and John are both very awkward about sex and don't have the instant magical chemistry the main couples do, but they clearly love each other deeply and are figuring out the sexual aspect. It seems like if they had more time, they would get there with the physical aspect. So while I presume Francesca and Michaela will have intense easy chemistry because they're a main couple, it's at least not going to be a case of "I loved my dead spouse but I realize now it was platonic and I never enjoyed sex," or at least I hope it won't be. Francesca having a queer awakening with her dead husband's cousin brings enough novel intensity and angst, I feel!
But here's the thing: I don't believe the show will treat a f/f main couple with the same focus they have for the f/m couples. They know their audience, and their audience is mostly straight women. It's very clear in how they film the sex scenes (which is fine! We need more female-gaze sex scenes in media, and there are a lot more straight women!).
I also fear they will not allow two Bridgerton women to have f/f romances, again, because they want to keep their viewers and a lot of the viewers are presumably not attracted to women.
So I will be very surprised if season 5 doesn't also include a major heterosexual couple (besides Violet and Lord Anderson), and I'm worried it will have to be Eloise. I really, really don't want Eloise to be straight or end up with a man, even if they massively rewrite her love interest from the book.
But worries aside, I think this was my favorite season.