I DRANK ALL THE HARD SELTZERS
Illustrations by Ava Williams (@ava_carrie on IG)
I remember the first time I saw people (and by people I mean girls (and by girls I mean WOMEN)) drinking White Claws. It was about 4 years ago and I was at a party where the token hot girls commanded their friend/faithful servant who was going out to the store to get some more âwhite claws or clams or whatever.â I instantly did not like white claws OR clams. You see, I unfortunately grew up in the 90s which means that I was programmed to believe, confusingly, that the worst thing a girl could be is âgirlyâ and that anything consumed primarily by women is inherently bad. This is probably why I spent the majority of my adult life drinking beer I didnât really like that much and NOT ordering salads when I went out to eat. Thatâs how you know Iâm a COOL girl, ok?
But nowadays, what with my Celiac diagnosis, I spend most of my days sitting in a rocking chair, eating salads and drinking hard seltzers, and I must say, itâs pretty alright. But for the first year of my gluten-free life I was extremely self-conscious about ordering hard seltzers in bars and really disliked the brands that looked too feminine. (See: Old habits.) And I was particularly offended by this one that came in a skinny can with mermaids on it.
For a brief while I tried just drinking straight tequila when I went out. However, this can be expensive, because as it happens, I am good at drinking straight tequila.
But now, in the year 2020, bars no longer exists, but if they DID, I would not be ashamed to be seen at one with a hard seltzer. Itâs actually quite liberating and I no longer feel the need to tell (theoretical) bartenders that I am ordering this White Claw RELUCTANTLY and with the appropriate level of SHAME but you see I have a condition that precludes me from drinking a COOLER more MANLY drink. It turns out they do not CARE.
Iâm even confident enough (sort of) to go to the grocery store and buy 5 different kinds of hard seltzers all in one trip. Because like a true consumer, I decided that if Iâm going to drink hard seltzers, Iâm going to drink ALL the hard seltzers and find the BEST hard seltzer. For SCIENCE.
Spoiler Alert: I didnât really pick a âbestâ because there are honestly so many good ones. Sorry, science!
WHITE CLAW (OR CLAM):
The seltzer that started it all. I, of course, appreciate the claw for being a pioneer in its field, but I also I enjoy it as a refreshing, mildly sweet (only 100 calories) fizzy beverage with the ability to get me a little drunk. I also like that itâs one of the few seltzers that you can find in a tall boy can, which, again, is probably because a big tall can has such cool-dude vibes. Honestly, I think all the flavors are good. Iâm partial to Mango, Lime, and Raspberry, but I havenât really met a White Claw I donât like. (I have however met a few hot girls drinking White Claws that I didnât like. Not the Clawâs fault!)
Takeaway: A solid seltzer that you can find pretty much anywhere and I applaud that.Â
Bonus: You may get mistaken for a hot girl.
TRULY:
All around, Truly may be my favorite brand. Itâs pretty similar to White Claw (also 100 cal) but with some new and, dare I say, more innovative flavors? Raspberry Lime? Fucking genius. In fact, the entire Berry variety pack is delicious. (It also includes Black Cherry, Wild Berry, and Blueberry Acai.) The Tropical sampler is also quite good. The Citrus varieties are probably the least exciting, but theyâre all winners in my book. I wish I was drinking one right now. Ok, actually? Now I am.
Takeaway: In my opinion, Truly is the best in show and I wish they sold cases of Raspberry Lime.
BON & VIV:Â
The infamous mermaid can. But you know what? Itâs pretty good. And you know what else? Mermaids are dope. I especially like that Bon & Viv has classy flavor combos like Clementine Hibiscus. Could I taste the hibiscus? No! But is clementine somehow way more exciting and different than orange? Yes it is. At only 90 calories a can, theyâre just a little less sweet than Truly and White Claw, but still quite enjoyable. Other interesting flavors include Pear Elderflower and Prickly Pear. Do I necessarily know what those things should even taste like? No maâam! Are they going a little hard on the pears? In my opinion, yes. But points for originality! And you know what? Throw in a few more points for the mermaids!
Takeaway: Embrace the mermaids.
SAN JUAN:
So Iâm not good at picking favorites, but Iâm okay at picking LEAST favorites. I donât want to put San Juan on blast to my 6 readers, but coming it at just 85 calories a can, itâs the least sweet and most weird of the bunch. It kind of tastes like wine? I want to like San Juan, I do, but as of now, I just cannot. San Juan if youâre reading this, I have a recommendation and that is to add 5 to 15 calories worth of sugar to your seltzer. It seems to be working for the other guys.Â
Takeaway: If you live in the Pacific Northwest and want to buy a local seltzer, get on the San Juan train and BYO sugar.
TRADER JOEâS (aka SHELL HOUSE):
I know itâs very on brand for someone like me to LOVE Trader Joeâs but...I do. And it so happens that Trader Joeâs has some VERY good hard seltzers (possibly the best?), and at a whopping 120 CALORIES (jkjk) I think weâre starting to see a correlation. Let me crunch some numbers. Ok yes, thatâs what I thought, more sugar = more good. They have just a few flavors at the moment, but they are easily ranked.
1. Shell House Meyer Lemon (straight-up the best lemon on the market)
2. Shell House Raspberry (very similar to White Claw and, come to think of it, Jello)
3. Shell House Pomegranate (not bad, but I expect it to be discontinued soon but I thank it for its service)
They are also, without a doubt, the most bang for your buck too, at $5.99 for a 6-pack. Thanks, Joe! If you can ever leave your house and go to Trader Joeâs again, I suggest stocking up for summer and inviting me over.
Takeaway: If you love you some lemon and want your seltzer to fit in a beer coozy, put on your face mask and get thee to a Trader Joeâs.
TRULY LEMONADE:
Wait, didn't we already do Truly? Yes we did and thank you for paying attention,  but this is a different Truly. First of all, Truly Lemonade comes in a black can, or as my friend (and illustrator) Ava put it, âbranded for tough boys.â Truly Lemonades are interesting because like the original Truly, they too are just 100 calories, but they are noticeably sweeter. How? Why? What magic is this? Well that, my friends, would be Stevia. Personally, Iâm not usually a huge fan of things sweetened with Stevia, but these are actually pretty tasty. Also, I like the flavor combos. (Thereâs a Mango Lemonade, Black Cherry Lemonade, Strawberry Lemonade, and get this...Lemon Lemonade.)
Takeaway: If youâre a tough boy and/or you like your sweets sweet, Truly Lemonade is the seltzer for you.
SEEKOUT (by 2 Towns Ciderhouse) :
So....these are...also not my favorite. I know this because of the many many seltzers I bought, the SeekOuts are the only ones still sitting, unrefrigerated and unwanted, on my bedroom floor. (I was storing all my seltzers there for a while because the fridge is, weirdly, too full of food to store like 90 cans of seltzer in there at once.) They're a just a little blah-tasting and lacking in the fizz department. But the flavors are interesting! For instance, the first one I tried was Cucumber + Juniper, which was kinda gross, but good for them for trying! Other flavor combos include Pineapple + Passionfruit, Key Lime + Mint, and Raspberry + Meyer Lemon. I think what Iâm learning about me is that I do enjoy a flavor combo done right.
Takeaway: If youâre hanging out on my bedroom floor and you donât like a lot of fizz in your fizzy drink, give SeekOut a try.Â
DISHONORABLE MENTION
HENRYâS:
In my research (for science), it seems that I got so carried away (drunk) that I somehow failed to notice that Henryâs is one of the few hard seltzers that is NOT gluten-free. Let me repeat,
**Henryâs Hard Sparkling Water is FULL of gluten.**
A dirty trick if you ask me! But for real, if youâre drinking alcoholic seltzers because you MUST (medically), be careful. Henryâs, I learned (while up sick in the middle of the night) and googling my symptoms, is owned by MillerCoors and Henryâs is a MALT beverage and malt = gluten. I only drank 2 of them (Strawberry Kiwi and Blueberry Lemon), and sadly they werenât even very good. Could that have something to do with the fact that they have, most unusually, only 88 calories? Itâs anyoneâs guess. But if I was going to make myself sick by eating gluten, I wish it had been from an Oreo or a ham sandwich.
Takeaway: Henryâs is not, I repeat, NOT an Oreo or a ham sandwich.
And I know there are more hard seltzers out there, but give my liver a break. Perhaps there will be a Part 2??










