18+ cw: unprotected [irresponsible] sex. just the tip (until it isn’t). mutual loss of virginity - slight bleeding. thighfucking. pussyjob. slippery slope. creampie. mutual pining. idiots in love. religious references/guilt. banter as foreplay lol
summary: your friend’s reputation of being good in bed is common knowledge to the entire living-and-breathing student population of columbia. confusion arises when he tells you he’s actually a virgin. (wc: 11k - i know 😔)
a/n: hello. :) this is PURELY self-indulgent wish fulfillment, initially written for the touch prompts “foreheads pressed against each other” + “two fingers against a pulse point,” then i swiftly lost control after the first 2k words. I LOVE LOVE LOVE MATT MURDOCK JUST THE TIP FICS, i love their authors, and so here is my contribution!!! addtl warnings: lots of talk about religion, purity culture talk, matt’s guilt (featuring my favorite: intrusive thoughts of bible verses during sex). matt & reader lose their virginity to each other. that’s it… enjoy my filth…
“No fucking way.”
It’s ridiculous: Matt’s desk isn’t made for two. Not even close. It’s for this reason that you’ve ended up almost on top of him, trying to act like your thigh isn’t pressed to his.
And if your excuse for all this was that you were trying to get any real learning in, you’d be a liar, and a bad one at that.
Because despite your valiant efforts at fighting the stubborn spine of your copy of The Phenomenon of Man flat, and despite Matt’s visibly pained attempts to not cringe so openly at the sound of its pages being manhandled, absolutely no studying has occurred.
The conversation has veered off course. Reliably, you’ve spiraled it toward the hot topic of hookups. It’s an area in which Matt seems to be constantly embroiled, as far as corridor gossip—and Foggy’s colorful commentary—is concerned. It’s also an area that feels masochistic to keep asking about, yet you do again and again with your needling and poking and prodding, for no other reason than to wind up that sick thrill of jealousy in your chest.
Of course, all of it is inconsequential to Matt. He never seems to take offense. He plays along with impeccable composure, which all the more confirms that your chances of getting with him live somewhere in the zip code of Fuck All and Nowhere. It’s your conviction he’s on a much different playing field than you—his revolving door of ruthless future litigators/intense poets/vowelless heiresses. All undeniably drop-dead gorgeous, much so that you weren’t even sure at first who you were jealous of, them or him.
Besides, it’s not that you like to wallow. You’d like to believe you’re fairly attractive yourself, thank you very much—but there’s much ease in giving in to joyless comparison when, like right now, Matt’s face is lit golden from the afternoon sun and he’s so beautiful, the shapes and lines of him so harmonious it’s only natural he’d be surrounded by people just like him.
Not like you.
So, rash girl that you are, you lash out the only way you can. Sarcasm, disbelief.
“You’re telling me,” you say slowly, jabbing your highlighter into the air, “that you, Matthew Murdock, are a virgin. You. You?”
His lips twitch at the corners, amused. “Is that so hard to believe?”
“What the fuck were they doing in and out of your room then? And I quote–‘he was really good’? You giving them confession or something?”
Matt feigns innocence, presses a hand to his chest. With an air of clipped smugness, “Who knows, maybe they were talking about Foggy.”
Your silence must clue him to the fact that you’re gaping.
“What? Girls love him!” he says, grinning wide. You can’t argue with that, at least, that much is true. “Besides, it’s a question of semantics. For one, what the word ‘virgin’ even entails when—”
“Just strangle me if you’re going to quote Wittgenstein again, Murdock. You’re a virgin or you’re not.”
Newly emboldened, Matt holds out a thumb to press it against your arm, pushing you playfully.
“Well, then, enlighten me.”
Enlighten me.
You’re being confronted at your own game and clearly, your prodding can’t hold its own water—embarrassment flooding you instantly at discussing something this bold with someone you’re wildly, secretly in love with. Matt seems to pick up on this, granting you a little reprieve. His mouth quirks, “Alright, I’ll tell you what I think, and you tell me if you agree.”
You have to hope you’re doing a good job of pretending his suddenly stern, even tone doesn’t send your blood pressure skyrocketing.
Calm as ever, he continues, “One would define a virgin as someone who’s never had sexual intercourse.”
One would also define your face as going nuclear, hotter and hotter with each second he discusses this so breezily. Just another day of laying out the facts, like he’s in a debate.
“Yeah,” you manage.
“Sexual intercourse, to mean sexual contact with penetration. Yes?”
“Oh, stop it, Matt,” you groan, hands fidgeting with the page.
“Well—yes?”
“Okay. Yes.”
“Okay.” He leans back, casual, like this is the simplest thing in the world. “If penetration has to be the only metric—then yes, I’m a virgin. Again, if it has to be.”
As if that made any sense, you nod at him, blinking. “Yeah, yeah.” Another blink, upon finally coming to your senses. “Has to be? The fuck is that supposed to mean?”
“Well,” he repeats airily, biting down a smile. Oh no, he’s enjoying this—“do you think sex is just penetration?”
It takes you a second.
To be more precise, it takes you three seconds. Your confused gaze flicks from his shielded eyes to his mouth, to the tip of his tongue, that which has darted out to wet his pink, pink lips…
Oh.
“Oh my God,” you utter. Cheeks aflame, you bury your face in your hands instantly, eager to escape his puppylike yips of laughter at your mortification. “Oh my God.”
Jesus. Of course he’d eat pussy like a champ.
“What? What?” His voice has gone high and incredulous.
“Shut up! This paints you more like an asshole in my book, actually.”
He’s grinning wide. “Because?”
“Because!” Dropping your hands, you stab a finger at him. “I’m pointing at you very disapprovingly, by the way. It’s one thing to brag about being good at sex, y’know, the–uh–uh…p..”
Just say the word, goddammit! You’re giving yourself away!
“C’mon,” he teases lowly, that delicious rasp in his voice. “You can do it. P-p-p–”
“Penetration,” you spit. “Ugh, Matt!”
You smack his chest and, scandalously pleased with himself, unbidden laughter escapes him. You have half a mind to simply leave the room; perhaps by doing so, you’ll be spared the punishment of suffering that immaculately handsome smile. Instead, you do nothing but groan.
“You are such an asshole. Anyway—being good at that is one thing, but you’re saying all that praise was for oral? That’s even worse.”
“Worse? How is that worse?”
“You can’t really coast on– on mutual friction with that. You gotta… um… actually be good at it.”
Immediate regret bubbles up as soon as the words leave your mouth. Because consequently you’re now picturing Matt’s face between an array of legs, all immaculately smooth, un-stubbly legs, shapely deerlike legs that aren’t yours.
A grotesque fantasy; it may be the worst thing you’ve ever done to yourself.
Matt raises his hands in mock surrender. “They said it, not me. I don’t kiss and tell.”
“Sure. Right.” Eyes returning to the textbook, you grumble low and bitter words you yourself can’t even make form of. Jealous, though you’d sooner bite your tongue in half than admit aloud that you are. In front of you, the chapter title reads The Season of Life—and Christ take yours now, you’re praying. Matt’s lucky enough he can’t see the withering look you’re leveling at him, but never one to pass up the opportunity to be petty, you utter, “That’s all fiction anyway.”
His head tilts fractionally.
“Sorry?”
“It’s all fiction.”
“Being good at oral is fiction?”
“Yes.”
“As in, not real?”
“Yes.”
Where you’re going with this, you don’t know either. Your brain and your mouth are no longer on speaking terms.
There’s a pause before he speaks again, his voice amused but careful.
“So in the entire span of human existence—through all of time—you’re telling me not one person has been good at going down on a woman? Not a singular one?”
“Yes!” You throw your hands up, giggling. All rational thought has hurled itself out the window, given way to stubborn absurdity. “Because I’m horrible. And egocentric, and I have to see to believe. Or—feel, sorry. So as far as I’m concerned, no, it has not existed.”
A barrage of your thoughts fill the silence that comes after. What are you even saying? What are you trying to insinuate? Are you coming onto him? Why can’t you just control the goddamn words coming out of your mouth?!
“That’s a terrible worldview,” Matt says at last.
“You’re welcome to leave,” you utter, plenty aware that this is his dorm room.
“Mm. Fiction,” he drawls, mouthing the word again like he’s testing wine. You dare to glance up at him and immediately know you’ve made a mistake: he’s got that smug thing going, head cocked and looking too entertained for his own good.
“I don’t know,” he muses, “it seemed pretty real to me. And to the very respectable women you’re currently calling liars.”
You roll your eyes hard enough you’re sure you can see your brain.
“No, I’m serious. Not only is that dismissive of their agency–”
“Oh God.”
“–but you’re also insinuating I was– What? Pity-praised?” Matt leans forward just slightly, that damned tongue darting out again to lick his smirking lips. “You think it was pity praise for the blind guy?”
“What?! No! I think–” You reel back, flailing, face hotter than it’s ever been in recorded history and you tug away from him as if that’ll help. “Matt, fuck you for real.”
Matt’s grinning so hard now, showing teeth and you can’t bear to face him so you rub your cheeks with your palms again.
“Christ. Okay fine, I walked right into that one.”
“Yeah, you did,” Matt repeats your words, mouthing fiction, shaking his head. “I hope that’s not from experience.” He pauses, tipping his head, a funny expression crossing his face. “Is it?”
“I- I– Well.” You swallow, finally slamming your textbook shut.
So as not to give anything away to his freakishly good perception, your next words are as matter-of-fact and carefully enunciated as you can manage:
“Who I put between my legs is none of your business, Murdock.”
Matt raises his brows, frowning and nodding as if to say, ah, alright then, if you say so. Sinking back in his seat, he lets out a sigh so dramatic, you’d roll your eyes again if your entire bloodstream weren’t currently on fire.
“Duly noted,” he says coolly. “And who I put between mine is fair game. Good to know.”
You blink. Fuck.
He’s right. You’re unsure what the etiquette here ought to be. What is it one does when your stupid-smart, obscenely hot crush hits you with an uno reverse that’s technically correct? And now you have to face the fact that you’re the asshole for slut-shaming him when really you’re just…
A little bit, catastrophically, stupidly jealous…?
“I– um– shit…” you answer brilliantly. “Um… Shit… Okay-you’reright-I’msorry.”
But Matt doesn’t have an answer to give you, no quip to shoot back. He dips his head low, and his shoulders start shaking incessantly. You can’t see much of his face like this—only his mouth twitching in a tight line.
He’s… crying.
That made him cry?
No way. You’ve never seen him cry before.
No, no. He’s wheezing.
From laughter.
“Ha!” he says, eyes bright behind his glasses as a full-bodied laugh finally breaks free from him, smug and delighted. “Got you!”
“Oh fuck OFF, Matt!” you snap, the heat clawing its way down your neck. “I thought you were crying! That’s not–!”
“You walked into that one again.”
“That’s not funny!”
.
Ever the asshole, Matt does find it pretty funny, though.
Your outrage, your flushed face, the ridiculousness of it all at your expense. And if he weren’t currently fighting for his goddamn life, he’d have the presence of mind to really savor it. Teasing is what the two of you do, an unconsciously learned dance. Yet for Matt, evidently, this back-and-forth holds more weight for him, it being what he can do to deflect from that… what even is it?
That bite in your voice, every time the topic turns to that.
Disdain, maybe. Disgust. Pity, if he’s being generous.
An indulgent part of him wants to believe it’s jealousy.
But why would it be? You’ve never given him any sign, done anything to be an indication that you’d think of him as anything more than a friend. He knows you: smart, uncompromisingly honest.
The kind of person who’d never waste time on someone who can’t keep his dick in his pants.
Which is clearly how you see him.
So that edge, those jabs and barbs and the snide twist with which you said really good… For lack of a better expression, he’s not blind to the fact that you’re disgusted at how careless he must seem. At the thought of him being cheap, shallow, shameless, all of it. Your image of him must be comical, he’s certain: throwing himself in half-clothed thrill, a meaningless chase of affirmation—since anything deeper would be too much.
Matt likes being your Friend. Loves it, if he’s honest. Which is why he lets you believe what you believe, and he does what he always does: grins, gets on your nerves, then backs off. Just like he’s supposed to.
Still, it’s not so easy, especially not like this. It’s not so easy now when he’s in sensory hell, and he can smell your apple-scented lotion and the ghost of sunscreen warm on the backs of your knees from walking across campus in the sun. He must catalogue it all: your clean sweat, blooming its sweet human humidity in the bend of your elbows; your anklet clinking and betraying your every restless shift; your rapid heartbeat he can’t even begin to dissect.
He can smell all of it, hear it, feel it, and God help him—just from this stupid conversation, he’s already hard.
Be self-controlled and sober-minded, for the sake of your prayers.
Matt exhales, long-suffering, trying to summon some humor for a shield.
“Fine,” he says at last, aiming for flippant and failing spectacularly. “I plead guilty. The rumors are true.”
Your dry snort hits him square, and he can practically feel the eye-roll radiating from you. Still, he goes on, fully aware of what he’s risking. Sentimentality scares you away, he knows this. “The nuns at the orphanage, they’d say it was something special. To share with someone within the sacrament of marriage.” Matt says it grandly, the theatricality making you snort again. Then a little pointedly, because he can sense your mouth already poised for a quip, “I’m not exactly waiting for my wedding night. If that’s what you’re thinking.”
The little hitch in your breath betrays you before you can speak.
“It’s just…” voice dropping, shoulders curling slightly, Matt doesn’t even know why he feels the need to explain this to you. A bid for understanding, maybe, though he knows that’s too much to hope for. “I haven’t found it in myself to go all the way yet, what with the”—he waves a hand vaguely, words quieting down into a mumble—“the words… in my head, and all.”
“What?” Your brow furrows. “What words?”
He shrugs, lips quirking into a cornered smile. “Nothing.”
“What?!” Before you can even finish talking you’re laughing, grabbing at his wrists in mock outrage. It makes him inhale sharply, your two fingers grazing the tender skin there, and he thanks God you don’t have his senses or you’d know how embarrassingly fast his pulse had leapt beneath your touch.
“What words, Matt? Do you hear the Holy Spirit or something? Is that a thing?”
He huffs. “I think it’s called a conscience, sweetheart.”
Sweetheart.
For a second—just a second—your heartbeat skips after he says it. Usually, for anyone else, it’d be that tell he knew by heart: Gotcha. Granted, it’s a useful gift, one that’s gotten him into more agreeable doors and down more girls’ jeans that he’d expect. Only it’s not like that with you. He’s long learned that you’re anything but usual to him, the opposite of an open book.
“Don’t call me sweetheart.”
Just as he’d expected, it’s annoyance. Not interest.
Matt glances away, smile wavering. “Ah. Sorry.”
But like it’s nothing you’re already chuckling and saying, more quietly, “All that repression, Matt. M’starting to believe your rumors now.”
Tilting his head back again, he nods to himself. There’s not much to say anymore, the two of you falling into a sort of ambivalent silence as you bury yourself back into the study material as if it’s suddenly become fascinating. But for him, it’s less studying the text and more studying you, picking up your heartbeat that seems to be beating quicker and quicker in… Anticipation?
Erratic, like a caught moth, like you’ve found something to say that’s titillating, or inappropriate.
He could do you one better. He could do inappropriate. He could ruin your friendship right now.
No, no. He has to bite his tongue, chastising himself. Bad Matt. Friendship. Don’t.
Still, your pulse keeps climbing faster and faster.
“Okay,” you finally eke out, mouselike. “My turn.”
Matt tilts his head.
“I’m a virgin too.”
Oh?
That’s not what he expected, and he’s not entirely sure how to react, brows lifting slightly. Keeping his expression careful, one hand rises to rub between his eyes the way he does only when he’s attempting to buy himself time.
Of course, there’s nothing wrong with your admission. It’s not a big deal; it shouldn’t even be one at all. Only, it’s sparked something in him that feels too much like relief. Yet it’s for this reason Matt had shut it down the second it reared its head. He knows himself well enough. If he lets that door open, lets himself want anything from that admission, that greedy part of him will enter and everything else he’s spent so long trying to hold back will come barreling with it.
He can’t afford that. So he shoves it down, hard.
“Okay,” Matt says gently. “That makes two of us then.”
You groan and collapse so far back into your chair it creaks in protest under you.
“Ugh. Actually, I’m like half a virgin too or something. Aren’t you gonna be a little weird about it? I was so weird about yours, I feel horrible.”
“No, not at all. I’m deeply moved by your honesty, actually.”
“Dick.”
He smiles.
You sigh, scratching at your temple. “I know there’s more leniency when it comes to girls, and I kind of hate that that’s a thing. Like, I don’t give a crap about it, which is why I do? Does that make sense?”
Matt nods solemnly, though the smile’s still tugging at his mouth. “No flaws in logic there.”
You swat at him again, but it’s lighthearted and your hand finds his arm and stays there, fingers drumming absently at the fabric of his sleeve.
“It’s not even about the sex,” you continue. “A lot of stuff makes me feel like it’s a lot more important than it actually is—”
“Hey.” He cuts you off, soft and steady, “You don’t have to justify yourself, you know. Not to me. I get it.”
You nod, shoulders relaxing. You’d gotten completely unaware of how worked up you were getting, the heat starting to pool again in your face.
“Thanks. Sorry.” You pause for a bit, thinking. “I’d just… I’d like it to be with someone I like. Doesn’t even have to be someone I love– I think I’d actually prefer that, just so it isn’t that big a deal. Just… not some random asshole.”
Right.
Matt has to chew the inside of his cheek until he starts to taste blood.
He could be that asshole. He really could. He could make this easy, make it soft, careful, good for you. For both of you.
“Mm,” he says, noncommittal. “Yeah, I know.”
“Just do it once—then it’s over.”
“Then it’s over,” he agrees helpfully.
“Stop repeating my sentences!” You laugh and slap his chest again, and by that touch he’s a little breathless. He exhales, tongue running along the back of his teeth. There goes the apple-scented waft from your skin again, mingling with the sun-warmed salt.
“Right,” Matt says promptly, forcing himself to lean back. He places his earbuds back in—a futile effort, he’s unable to hear anything over the blood rushing in his ears—and swipes back at his notes with the pad of his finger to seek where he left off.
The issue, of course, is that he’s hard.
Hard and sweating and stuck.
If God were any bit the merciful being He claimed to be, Foggy would walk in right now. He’d take any easy excuse to stop and force him out of his predicament. But Matt knows he won’t. He knows it’s just you and him, and nothing but his own will could stop him now.
Set a guard, o Lord, over my mouth. Keep watch over the door of my lips.
You’re murmuring to yourself over the book again, lips shaping out words he can’t hear because all his focus has narrowed down to the sound of your heartbeat. Then you’re leaning closer, pointing something out, and the hem of your top’s brushing his arm. You don’t realize how much he’s shifted, so when you turn to finally look at him, your breath’s fanning his cheek and he stills. You stop laughing, then you laugh again at the sight of his jaw tightening like he’s bracing for impact.
“You okay?” you murmur.
He forces a tired smile, an expression soothed to something carefully neutral. “Just trying to focus.”
“Oh, sorry.” You duck your head, meek, guilty. Suddenly abundantly aware of the weight in the air, you say, “I can move–”
“No, no.” Matt’s hand finds your waist with unerring accuracy, fingertips skimming your side in a featherlight touch. “Stay. I like it when you’re close.”
Something in your chest flutters, and Matt’s more than a little pleased at the shift in your pulse, the way his words had landed and rippled through you.
Christ, Matt. This how you do it?
He’s so close now he can hear every heavy thump of your heartbeat, and he’s listening hard, desperate in his search for anything to prove it’s more than biology, more than proximity, more than his wishful thinking.
But he can’t take it anymore. He can’t care anymore.
His thumb strokes your side.
“Alright,” Matt whispers, breath escaping ragged, “I’m gonna kiss you, okay?”
You nod before your brain can even catch up.
“…Okay.”
For an agonizing second, neither of you moves. Then he tilts his head, closing the distance slowly—almost painfully so, like he’s giving you every last chance to pull away. Your heart’s ricocheting so hard he can hear the shape of it.
And then his mouth is on yours.
The kiss when it comes is soft. His hand cups your jaw, thumb stroking your cheek as he presses his lips to yours. You make a sound—a little hum, surprised at yourself—and that’s all it takes for him to deepen it. He’s clued in infinitely to the goings-on in your body, the stutter in your breath, the way your hand lifts hesitantly before settling against his chest, fingers splayed over the steady hammer of his heart.
There’s the faint tang of your lip balm on his tongue when it dares to flicker against you, coaxing your mouth open. Strawberry, kiwi—no matter, he hungers to swipe all of it off you with his own lips. His tongue slides against yours and Christ, he can’t help the soft noise that rumbles in his own throat. When Matt pulls back it’s only enough to breathe, noses bumping, but before you can think any better of it—before you can even think about what you’ve ruined, what you’ve just begun—you’re already leaning back in for more, and he catches your bottom lip between his teeth in a fleeting, tender bite before kissing you again, harder this time and less careful.
Your fingers clutch at the fabric over his chest like you need something to anchor you. And just as you’re shifting closer and closer, the kiss much deeper, the chair under you creaks ominously and then—
It jerks, slipping sideways.
You yelp and flail gracelessly, but Matt’s faster by years, catching you before the fall can register. His arms wrap around your back, a firm hand finding your thigh to steady you as you land hard against his chest, your body flushed against his. You burst out laughing, breathless and embarrassed.
“I got you,” he murmurs, voice roughening at the edges. His black glasses have slid slightly crooked in the commotion, making him look just a little disheveled. His smirk is nothing short of devilish now that you’re straddling his lap fully, thighs bracketing his own with snug pressure.
It’s then that you both feel it: the heat and the hardness of him beneath you. Even through the barrier of clothing it’s impossible to ignore; by instinct, your body shifts to feed its own want, the hot ridge of his cock grinding against your center through your own clothes.
“Should we…” you start, unsure what it is you’re even asking.
“Yeah,” Matt says shakily, “Bed. Before you fall again and actually get hurt.”
You nod and start to move off him awkwardly, but he catches you again—arms looping around you without effort—and then he’s standing, lifting you against him like it’s nothing. By reflex, your thighs wrap around his strong waist, arms snaking around his neck as he carries you across the room. There’s a second you consider offering directions, murmur clumsy instruction, but Matt moves with complete certainty—exactly where to place you, exactly how to touch you. The surety makes your stomach knot with something sharp and bitter: experience, you think, even as you tell yourself not to—don’t ruin this, don’t rob yourself of how good it feels just to be wanted by him. Fighting against impulse, you swallow it down and let yourself surrender to the moment.
Matt deposits you gently onto the bed: a twin-sized mess of rumpled sheets and textbooks shoved aside. Coming up to between your legs, when he kisses you this time it’s worlds away from the one before—it’s deeper, hungrier, tongue slick and mouths sliding together in a mess of panting breath and soft noises, your fingers curling into the hem of his shirt.
“Can I—?” he asks between kisses, and you nod, already tugging it up. The dark shirt comes off easily, pulled one-handed over the back of his neck. Like an errant magpie, your gaze is caught momentarily by the silver glint of his cross necklace catching the light, just before your eyes slide down his broad chest, lean and defined, the clean cut of his abs tapering down with a trail of dark hair arrowing below.
Jesus.
But you don’t get to ogle him as long as you’d like—it’s your turn then, his hands at your sides, slipping beneath your shirt. Matt’s an impatient man and sure enough, sooner than soon your band shirt comes off, tossed somewhere over the bedframe.
“Goodbye, Nick Cave,” you murmur solemnly.
Matt huffs a laugh, and his lips scorch your newly-bare shoulder, then your collarbone, trailing heat as his hands roam—sliding over your soft stomach, then up to cup your breasts gingerly through your bra, thumbs brushing the edges of the material. You’re tugging at each other again, kissing between whimpers, your fingers fumbling at the button of your shorts, and Matt’s hand covering yours to help.
Cursing under your breath, you kick the shorts off with a frustrated huff, left in your underwear now, damp and clinging. Unfairly so, Matt’s still wearing those goddamn grey sweatpants that make everything impossible to ignore. You can see everything. You can feel everything. Still above you, now between your legs he ruts forward without meaning to, and his cock grinds against your soaked, clothed core through the layers of cotton and elastic. Like the rhizomatic nature of your conversations with him, natural and free-flowing, the both of you move in unconscious rhythm now, tuned in completely to the feeling of his thick ridge dragging across your core.
“I’m sorry,” he mutters into your mouth.
“For what?” you ask, breathless, trying not to fall apart too quickly.
He hesitates. “I just… didn’t know if you wanted to keep going.”
“Are you kidding?” you whisper. “I was about to ask you that.”
A giggle breaks out from both of you, soft and nervous, mouths brushing, and he kisses you again, desperate. “This feels good,” he mumbles against your lips.
“Yeah?” you breathe.
“Yeah. Yeah.” His fingers slide behind your back, fumbling at your bra clasp. You arch slightly, trying to help, but he curses softly. “Fuck—sorry—can’t—”
“Let me,” you say, laughing again, sitting up just enough to undo it yourself. His ears are flushed now, the tips red with embarrassment, and he opens his mouth to apologize again but your kiss finds him instead, as you reach for his hand and guide it to your chest.
Matt groans into your mouth when you place his palm over your exposed breasts, and he wastes no time, pawing at you greedily, kneading and squeezing like he’s starved for it. Fingers finding your furled nipples, pinching lightly, you shudder under him, clutching his wrist. Summer be damned, the velvet feel of his skin on your skin makes your head swim, and you can’t steal enough of his warmth to be sated.
His kisses then trail lower, down your neck now, down your sternum, each breath ghosting sultry heat across your skin, and then he’s at your navel, tongue flicking briefly at the dip there. But just as he ghosts lower, nose nudging at the waistband of your panties, you jerk. Acrid panic comes up your throat; before you can think you’re already tugging him up by his hair and the back of his neck, heart hammering against your ribs.
“Wait. Wait—”
He stills instantly, blinking up at you unseeing. His hair is mussed, lips wet, mouth open like he’d been caught mid-word. “…What?”
“I don’t—” The words knot in your mortified throat, and you can’t find the nerve to look at him directly. “Um—I just—”
It’s a burn not solely from want but from the shadow of uncertainty: the thought of him down there, to see you with such closeness, tasting you, and what if you’re disappointing, what if you’re not worth it, if every rumor you’ve pretended not to care about has been true after all and you’re nothing compared to them—
“What’s this, then?” His voice is low, teasing, sufficient enough to puncture your own spiral. Chuckling softly, he asks, “Gonna keep pretending it’s fiction?”
You flush so hard it makes your ears ring. “Shut up. Next time, okay?”
His brow quirks. “‘Next time,’” he echoes, savoring the phrase on his tongue like it’s proof you’ll never get away from him now.
“Ugh, Matt—just come here—” Flushing hot and annoyed, you yank him up by the necklace, mouth crashing against his before he can say another word, swallowing his grin into your kiss. Slick and consuming, it feels euphoric to slot your own mouth against his like this—lying down, full-body, you could kiss him for hours, your recent indiscretion forgotten—and you’re melting beneath him, your hips grinding up against his, your hands pulling at his pants.
Picking up on your insistence, Matt pulls back, breath ragged, and peels off his sweatpants. They catch at one ankle as you help him tug them off, hands brushing his calves. What’s left then is the stretched fabric of tight black boxer briefs, the full outline of his cock thick and unmistakable, a dark patch of damp where precome’s already leaked through.
You reach for the waistband, teasing it down with one finger. “This okay?”
His voice is strained. Nearly breaking. “Yeah. Please.”
Pulling the briefs down, you have to take a second as his cock springs free, flushed and leaking while it curves toward his stomach, the base nestled in a thatch of dark hair. You swallow hard, because he’s beautiful, Christ, he’s so hard, and he’s already twitching.
You shimmy your hips forward to be closer to him, legs parting, and he groans loudly the second your plush thighs close around his cock. Beginning to rut forward, he grinds against you slowly, dragging the thick length along your clothed slit, again and again, the damp cotton thankfully doing little to dull the obscene friction. The pressure of each hardened pass catches your clit just slightly makes you gasp, makes you rut back up against him. You can feel the heat bleeding off him, your cunt pulsing with how close he is, how much you need more.
It’s everything and nothing and still not enough. Then, as if to notice this, Matt’s hand drifts down, thumb brushing the waistband of your panties.
“These…” he murmurs lowly, fingertips tracing the edge of your panties with the kind of searing touch that makes your lungs forget their rhythm, “describe them to me.”
For a beat you’re not even sure you heard him right. “What?” you manage, though it’s hardly more than a whisper.
That damned smirk of him has made a reappearance, lips glossy from your kisses. The mockery in his tone is pure provocation, prodding at you endlessly, testing your limits. “Tell me what they look like.”
At his demand, the rush of blood behind your ears is instantaneous. You’re not sure whether it’s that or simply the love-addled lens you’re viewing him through, but a ridiculous little giggle betrays you, shy and uncontainable, as though your body is already conspiring with him. And so despite your attempts to suppress, you relent because he’s waiting, and frankly, because his devilish smile has unmoored you completely.
“They’re… white,” you begin, voice faltering as though you’re confessing something forbidden, “cotton. Lace at the sides.”
And because this is Matt, you can’t seem to stop, seizing his hand and tugging it down until his broad palm rests against the soft material, your pulse jumping beneath prickling skin.
Matt tilts his head as if he can see every detail anyway. Savoring the description, tasting it out as his smile curves wickedly. “Mm. Fancy?”
“Not really.”
“They expensive?”
“What? Jesus. No, you perv.”
“Good.” His tone’s dropped lower, thicker with play; its cadence is so warm it flushes heat straight between your thighs, beneath his palm most especially. And as if that singular word has become verdict— his purposeful fingers hook into the waistband sharply.
RRRIP—!
Your thighs jerk, eyes flying wide as the cotton gives under his decisive grip. Matt tears the panties apart at the seam as though they’re paper, unable to find patience to stop himself from wrenching the ruined fabric aside until you’re bared to him completely. It takes you a second to catch your breath, but you finally break into incredulous laughter, shock and arousal having knotted together in your chest so tight it feels like a stone in your sternum.
“Couldn’t wait,” Matt pants, “Sorry.”
“You’re not sorry.”
“No, I’m not.” His grin widens, flashing wolfish teeth. “Not even a little.”
“You’re gonna have to pay for that, Murdock.”
His laugh tumbles directly into your mouth as he kisses you again to shut you up, hot and reckless, and then drags lower once more— “This is okay, right? You’re okay with this?”
“Yeah. God, yes. Oh—” Yet despite thinking you’ve already tamped it down, the reality is that the two of you are now completely bared to each other; hence the voice of reason from inside your head still emerges, causing you to swallow hard. “Wait, Matt. Are we gonna— I mean, is this—?”
Christ, you don’t even need to finish. He knows what you’re asking, he can tell. And the fact of the matter is, it’s not simply the nature of his suggestibility. Matt’s will is strong, mostly unshakable. The only counterpoint is that it’s you. You’re the one offering, wanting, needing. He’s the one with the conscience clawing at him and telling him to stop.
But how the fuck can he stop, when you’re whimpering under him, begging for him so openly?
The thought of whether this is the line he’ll cross, it hammers in his chest and remains. Matt can’t bring himself to say it out loud, can’t let the words be real, because despite all his guilt, all his restraint, he wants it too much. He wants to do it right this time. He wants it with you.
He should stop.
“C’mon,” you whisper, bold and desperate in equal measure. “As long as it doesn’t go in, it’s okay. Right? For you?”
Matt’s breath shudders out of him, chest pressing hard against yours. His lips part on a half-formed prayer you don’t understand, and then he’s nodding, rendered helpless by the way you’ve said it.
“Jesus,” he mutters, breaking. “Yeah. Okay. Yeah.”
Wetting his lips, he pulls back and he pushes your pillowy thighs together slowly, and slides his cock between them, the swollen head dragging slickly between your bare folds, through your wetness. Slow at first, drawing each movement out until he feels like he’s about to die from lack of it. Every pass coats him more, precum mixing with your arousal, smearing the softness of your thighs as his cock glides in tight, controlled thrusts.
You’re wet. So wet he can hear it. The sounds filling the room are lewd and rhythmic, your thighs slick, your cunt clenching around nothing, desperate.
And Matt’s losing it.
He’s not even inside you and already he feels like he’s going to break.
His hands tighten on your hips, heavy enough to remind you he’s holding back by the skin of his teeth. With each pass of his shaft it’s cushioned indulgently by the soft flesh of your thighs, dragging along your folds, hot and wet and thick, the ridge of the swollen head bumping against your clit with every motion and sending zings of pleasure shooting up your spine until you’re breathless, gasping, toes curling.
You don’t realize you’re whining loudly until he leans over you, breathing hard onto your cheek, his chest heaving. Mouth brushing your ear, he mutters, “Mine.”
His claim on you makes your whole body arch, makes your cunt clench down uselessly on nothing, aching.
And it’s true. You’re his, no question now about it. All of it is proof enough: the wetness slicking your inner thighs, your bare pussy glistening and desperate and utterly bare beneath him.
You roll your hips up instinctively, desperate to catch more of him, to press harder against the hot, swollen weight grinding between your thighs, chasing the flash of electricity when the crown of his cock skims your clit. But his grip only tightens, fingers biting bruises into your waist, holding you down like he knows better than to let you move, like he’s the only thing keeping you tethered to sanity.
It feels like sin. This little game the two of you are playing at, it feels better than it has any right to, filthy and exquisite in equal measure. Each rut of his cock through the slick vise of your thighs drags the swollen tip across your folds, every pass smearing you wetter, every sound between you growing louder, lewder. The air is thick with it, every breath you take steeped in sex. It feels so fucking good—all of it, all of it—all building towards something, something you realize to be this conclusion: it’s not nearly enough.
“I want more,” you gasp, the words tumbling out unbidden as your eyes flick helplessly downward, caught on the sight of his cock sliding in and out of the tight press of your thighs. The swollen head keeps vanishing and reappearing, glazed with you, every filthy pass making you shiver harder, “Want you.”
“I know,” Matt exhales, and the sound is ragged, breaking in his throat. He presses his forehead against yours, his feverish skin scorching yours completely. “Me too. But we can’t.”
As if a spoiled child, you whine, “Why not?” high and frustrated as you rock your hips against him anyway, greedy, begging with your body even as he keeps you pinned.
Without needing to speak aloud, the answer to your question comes to him with absolute certainty. A hoarse rasp of conscience: Because I’m an asshole.
“Please,” you whimper, every instinct in your body screaming for more. His hands only tighten to keep you down, yet it finds no success in having you stop; it only makes your need bloom sharper, makes your pleas spill faster. “Please, it won’t change anything. We’re still friends, right? Right?”
And then, just for an instant, just enough to catch at your entrance, the head of his cock slips and pushes blunt and hot and shocking against the swollen threshold of your body.
The air is torn from both of you in the same instant, gasps ripping through the thick silence.
The shock of it intoxicates you, blinds you—just that sliver of him breaching you, and you’re undone.
Beside your head, his arm strains to brace his weight, with biceps taut and straining, veins standing out as though his whole body is about to snap. The silver cross around his neck swings free, dangling above your face, catching the faint light with every tremor.
Matt doesn’t move, shouldn’t, but his cock throbs where it presses into you, every instinct commanding him to push deeper, to sink, to lose himself. To give you what you’re pleading for.
“Fuck—m’sorry,” he grits, wrenching back, pulling himself back out. He’s shaking, chest heaving, the words tumbling from him wild and frantic. “Sorry, sorry, I didn’t mean to—I didn’t—You’re just so wet, fuck, I’m sorry—”
And if your hand causes you to sin…
“It’s o-okay—” You’re trembling, nails biting into the meat of his bicep. Your body is buzzing, still lit by the electric shock of him almost inside, and what terrifies you most is the clarity flooding you.
Singular and decisive: you can’t stop now.
“Matt,” you whisper, sordid with want, “what if—what if you put it in, just a little. A little, please. It’s not enough. It won’t even count.”
You sound like you’re begging for your life. Reduced to nothing but a bitch in heat.
Matt’s hand slides up to your jaw, thumb dragging across your cheek in a trembling, sultry caress, and his head dips, unsteady laughter rasping out of him, “Don’t tease.”
“I’m not,” you plead, “S’long as… s’long as it’s not fully in, it doesn’t count, right?”
“Fuck—” Matt exhales hard, head hanging as if the weight of it will break him. His throat works as he swallows, trying to claw the words out of his conscience.
He needs to stop. He knows he needs to stop.
Do not let my heart incline to any evil, to busy myself with wicked deeds.
But how can he refuse you?
“Fuck. Okay. Are you sure?”
You nod, frantic. For Matt, whose senses are paradoxically both focused entirely on you and tuned out by the intense arousal in his head, this simple gesture is insufficient. He shakes his head. “I need you to tell me you’re sure.” His lips brush over yours as he breathes it, a coded message of him desperately begging you to say stop, to absolve him, control him from his own sin.
You do no such thing.
“Fuck, I’m sure,” your eyes are wet, and you cling to him as if he’s the only thing keeping you alive. “I need you, Matt.”
Need you, Matt.
He squeezes his eyes shut. “Fuck. Okay. Just the tip, okay?”
You nod quickly, almost giddy with relief.
God can forgive him if it’s just the tip. It doesn’t even count. He’ll be forgiven.
No temptation has overtaken you that is not common to man. He will not let you be tempted beyond your ability…
Having made his decision, Matt bites down on a groan, then kisses you so hard it steals the breath from your lungs once more. You have the sense his mouth is fierce and desperate to seemingly smother the truth of what he’s about to do. And, ever obliging, his hand reaches down, fumbling between your bodies, guiding himself to your entrance.
Then he’s pushing forward.
Just the tip—barely inside, barely breaching. Enough to tear the air from your lungs, enough to lock every muscle in your body.
“Mmff—” the sound wrenches from him, low and ragged, almost a growl as your heat swallows the thick crown of him. His head drops, sweaty hair brushing your face. “Fuck—that’s tight. You okay?”
You nod quickly, clinging to his arm, your teeth sinking into your bottom lip as you feel him stretching you out.
“Y-yeah,” you gasp, fighting for your voice not to tremble, “it just… hurts. A little.”
Hurts.
Stop now, Matt. Stop it. Stop it.
If he’s looking for a sign, this is it. He’s hurting you. Right? He should stop. Pull out. Apologize. Pretend this never—
But your body won’t allow him to believe it. Not with the way you’re squirming under him with need. Still, he must keep to his word—just the tip. So he doesn’t move, though his cock throbs thick inside you, just the swollen crown wedged in that slick tight heat that’s clenching and fluttering so helplessly around him.
The moment he’s lodged fully inside your entrance, you instantly wish you hadn’t begged for it. The taste of it is too good, too much, and now that you’ve had it, there’s no way this could ever be enough. You want more. You want all of him.
As if hearing your own thoughts, Matt grunts low in his chest, the sound guttural. He grits his teeth, refusing: he knows better than this.
Instead, one hand braces you at the waist, keeping you still, the other fisting the rest of his exposed length. His hand slides up and down his shaft in a desperate grip, every stroke smeared with the arousal you’re drooling down his cock, wetting him to the base. He shouldn’t be doing this. He really shouldn’t. No condom, no plan, no fucking clue how to stop. All he’d need to do was push forward, slide the rest of his cock in and bury himself to the hilt. And as if to compound his own struggle you’re writhing, too, trying to roll your hips the tiniest bit, trying to fuck yourself on him, his grip on your waist being the only thing stopping you.
“Unfair,” you whined, trying to defy the iron clamp of his hand.
“What’s unfair?”
Jesus. He’s so hoarse he can’t even recognize his own voice.
“You get to—” your chest heaves, words tripping over the wreck of your own pathetic desperation, “—get to jerk yourself off while I—while I can’t even—” Another sharp whimper breaks you off, and for a second Matt thinks you’re going to start completely sobbing right then, with your cunt clenching down helplessly on the head of his cock buried inside you. “I can’t even take it all.”
Christ.
Matt swallows.
This girl is gonna be the death of me.
“S’not—” he tries, but the word shreds out of his throat like gravel, sweat dripping down his temple. His fist works himself tighter, faster, the slide of it wet and obscene from the mess you’re making all over him. You’re so fucking slick; all of it his, yours, both of you, smeared together down his cock and onto his knuckles.
“No, no– see–” As if to abate the mounting tension his fingers find your clit, rubbing in frantic little circles with your own wetness. The effect is instant: your back arching, cunt clamping down on his cockhead.
“See?” he rasps, eyes wild. “See? You can feel good too, sweetheart. Just like this.”
Thumb working circles onto your clit, you squirm helplessly under him, sobbing into his mouth when he kisses you again. Every squeeze of your pussy around him frees another curse from his lips, another jerk of his hips forward without his permission, the thick crown driving a fraction deeper before he can stop himself.
“Fuck—” his forehead drops to yours, trembling with effort, “fuck, sweetheart, I can’t—”
The moment his fingers drag again over your clit, you buck deeper onto his cock with a sob.
“I’m not gonna move,” he pants, nipping at your lip to keep himself tethered, “I’m not gonna—fuck—”
But even as he says it, his hips are already rocking, shallow thrusts plunging his cock just barely in and out of your pussy, every ridge of him catching on the trembling mouth of you. Just the tip, he tells himself. Just the tip. Over and over like a prayer.
The truth is, Matt doesn’t know what the fuck he’s doing. A live wire embodied, he’s guided by instinct and need alone, no practiced rhythm, no skill, just messy, urgent biology taking the reins. Having given way to baser impulses, his body moves the way it wants to, chasing what feels good, listening to every slick sound, every clench of your cunt, every gasp from your pretty mouth.
“Shit—sorry—sorry—” he grunts, rocking forward again, every shallow thrust ratcheting up the tension inside him like he’s being wound too tight, like he’d snap if he stopped.
“Matt—” you beg, arching up to claw at his arm. “More. Please. More.”
“I can’t,” he says hoarsely, but he doesn’t stop either, still working the tip of his cock into you with ragged little thrusts. “I shouldn’t.”
But your body’s melting open beneath him already, milking him just from that shallow stretch. Just the tip, just the tip, he repeats to himself, but every second inside you only makes him wonder how much better it would feel if he gave you all of it.
He shouldn’t, but Christ, it’s you.
You. Always you. Not just his friend, not just the girl he teases and studies with, but the one his hands ache to memorize, the one whose heartbeat he knows better than his own.
“Fuck—” the curse shudders out of him, his breath stinging your face, “You’re—Christ, you’re so good to me, my girl—”
Sweat’s beginning to sting his unseeing eyes now as he focuses on the way your pussy squeezes around him. But each time he pulls out, his hips push back in deeper—just a fraction, just a millimeter more. It’s not conscious, not yet, but his cock’s greedy, his body aching for more, and he lets it happen again. And again. And again.
His mouth is everywhere—kissing you hard, biting your lip, licking the sweat from your collarbone as his hips twitch, plunging deeper. Bit by bit. Inch by inch. Until he’s slipping past the point of no return, your walls stretching to take him, your moans soft and broken in his ear.
You gasp when the thick crest of his cock pierces deeper than ever.
“It’s alright,” Matt rasps, between his sultry claims of my girl into your neck. “It’s just a bit, just a little, it’s okay, right? S’okay? Sorry, sorry, shit—”
Make every effort to supplement your faith with virtue.
And then suddenly, inevitably, he’s in all the way.
Bottomed out, buried to the hilt, his hips pressed flush to yours. His cock seated deep inside your body, throbbing, pulsing, sheathed fully in your wet heat to the very base. He can’t breathe, can’t think, and the only thing tethering him to the moment is the frantic hammer of your pulse and the tight, fluttering clutch of your pussy strangling his cock like you were made to fit him.
Knowledge with self-control… self-control with steadfastness… steadfastness with godliness…
Fuck off, he thinks viciously, growling it in his head to drown the endless refrain of scripture that batters at him even as he trembled above you. He’s not praying anymore—he’s fighting to silence the voice that tells him this is wrong, that this is sin, when all he wants is to make you feel good.
“Matt,” you whimper, soft and urgent. “Move. Please.”
He squeezes his eyes shut, exhales raggedly against your jaw, and then—hesitantly, testing—he slides his cock out.
It’s too slow. Painfully so. Your swollen folds cling to him desperately, like your pussy is trying to suck him back in, each inch dragging fire across his length until he nearly loses his mind. Your cunt stretches, weeps around him, and when he pushes forward again, even slower, the shaft sinks back inside with obscene resistance, the slick sound of your bodies meeting loud in the overheated room.
“Fuck, so tight,” he gasps, forehead dropping to yours.
He pulls out again. Slides back in again. Every retreat slick, every push met with a bearing down so tight he chokes on his own breath.
And then he does it again.
And again.
And again.
Your thighs tremble against his hips, your back arching, your mouth falling open as you watch him—watch the way his cock disappears inside you, coated thick in your wetness, then reappears glistening, only to sink back inside to the hilt. A ring of wet white clings to the base of his shaft, spreading with every stroke, proof of how thoroughly he’s splitting you open.
“Oh my God,” you whimper, voice thin, eyes glued to the sight. “Matt.”
As if through otherworldly understanding, he says your name back to you, siphoning heat into your mouth—and almost without meaning to, his pace picks up. The slow grind of his hips becomes sharper, his thrusts longer, the rhythm picking up with every drag of your pussy milking him tighter. He pulls back halfway and drives forward again, harder this time, and the sound it makes—the wet slap of your bodies, the squelch of your slick around him—nearly unspools him.
“Fucking hell,” he pants, brow furrowed, eyes shut tight, as if concentration alone can keep him from losing himself entirely. “You’re so—so fucking tight, sweetheart.”
Your hands clutch his shoulders, helpless against the pace as he pumps into you now, faster, deeper, your cries tumbling into the room in a shameless chorus. And still you can’t stop watching his cock slide in and out of your pussy, faster and faster, his stomach clenching, his silver cross swinging tauntingly above you.
One moment he’s easing in, trying to keep that tight rhythm steady, whispering prayers and half-formed apologies against your mouth, and the next he’s simply gone, for lack of a better word. Crossing the threshold of his own control, he’s resorted to straight up fucking you, hips hammering into you, cock pistoning in and out like something feral’s taken hold of him. He’s sloppy, untrained, rutting wildly, but again, biology doesn’t need finesse, and when someone’s fucking you like this—driving into you hard, desperate, needy—the result is still more than enough to make you arch and moan and claw at his back like you’ll die if he stops.
“Fuck—fuck—” Matt pants, forehead slick and pressed against yours, his voice dissolving into hoarse groans each time his fat cock slams all the way in. He’s greedy with it, chasing his own high with reckless abandon. Ever errant, his mouth searches blindly for balmy skin—your neck, your jaw, your shoulder—pressing wet, scorching kisses between bitten gasps. He tastes sunscreen and sweat, your salt and his and that damned apple-scented lotion, the tang so sweet it makes him dizzy, and when your anklet clinks in counterpoint to his every thrust, the tinkling chime fills his ears like music, like a hymn that drives him to thrust harder.
The bedframe protests, the cramped mattress squeaking beneath the combined weight of his body pressing yours down into it. There’s no space left between you at all; he’s smothering you in heat, his musk, his ragged breath against your lips, and you’re drowning in it, in him. His cane clatters to the floor when his thrusts jostle it loose from the headboard, forgotten completely, as though he’s swearing off every marker of restraint with every thrust.
“Matt,” you breathe, and then again, louder, chanting it helplessly, “Matt, Matt, Matt…” with the same fervent rhythm he’d once used to pray the rosary, your cries his new litany.
He can’t get enough. Your cunt is so wet, so tight, clenching around him like it was made to keep him, and he can’t stop laughing breathlessly into your face, disbelieving, “So fucking tight—Christ, you’re so tight—” before his hand’s sliding down again to abuse your swollen clit, your shared wetness slicking his touch until your body jolts violently against him.
Knowing you so well, that’s all it takes—your whole body seizes, your mouth falling open on a silent cry as your orgasm rips through you like a snapped cable. Your vision goes white and you writhe beneath him, clutching and pawing at his back, shaking so hard your knees knock into his hips.
By reflex, Matt buries his face against your neck, his body surging with yours as your cunt spasms around him, soaking him even more. He knows he should pull out. He knows. But the way your pussy’s gripping him, sucking him back in, the soaked evidence of your orgasm leaking down his cock, the way you’re still trembling and panting his name like it’s salvation—
He can’t.
He’s not thinking anymore. Just fucking.
And the bed’s tiny, barely big enough for both of you, and there’s nowhere to go but into each other, sweat dripping off his forehead onto your own, your skin hot and shiny under his, your nails dragging down his spine, and he’s laughing now—breathless, manic—between thrusts.
…That each one must know to control his own body in holiness and honor…
It should shame him, too. Matt catches it: the slight copper tang of blood lacing the air, the sting of your body stretched too suddenly—but instead it makes him shake, makes him rut harder, makes his cock twitch greedily inside you. Some dark part of him finds the trace of blood endlessly alluring, proof that you’ve ruined each other for anyone else. He doesn’t stop to think, finding himself unable to.
…not in the passion of lust.
Was he this much of a fucking freak, that verses floated up unbidden even while his cock was bullying your cervix, stretching you indecently deep?
He’ll be forgiven. He’ll be forgiven.
As long as he doesn’t come inside you.
That’s the line. That’s the last shred of self-control he has left, and he clings to it while his hips rut and slam with abandon, while your body milks him so good he’s dazed with it.
But he wasn’t supposed to go this far, so what’s a little farther?
He doesn’t believe in halfway sins. If he’s going to hell, then he’ll make it worth everything.
“I’ll pull out,” Matt rasps, his voice half-promise, half-prayer. “I’ll pull out, I swear—just a little longer, just—fuck—”
But “a little longer” turns into a little too long. His rhythm breaks down into sloppy, desperate pounding, each slam of his cock inside you wetter, louder, deeper than the last, his breath coming in ragged sobs. His cross necklace clinks wildly above your breasts, slick against your skin where his chest presses you down. His mouth drags open over your lips, teeth nipping, tongue sloppily seeking to catch yours, and when you kiss him back he groans like he’s being possessed, his entire body jolting with the force of his thrusts, helpless as he says again without thinking, “Mine.”
And finally, in acquiescence, you whisper back, “Yours,” clamping down so tight, twitching and moaning under the maddened stroke of his thumb over your overstimulated clit, and he can’t take it, can’t fight it anymore. The thought of pulling out vanishes as though it never existed.
“Oh fuck—fuck—” he chokes, hips slamming forward one last time, burying himself deep as he can go and his cock pulses violently, spilling hot, thick spurts of his seed into your cunt.
It gushes out of him, painting your walls with ropes of it, mixing with your creamy slick as he groans loud and shameless into your open mouth, kissing you through the ruin. His body wracks with it, every muscle seizing, every thrust reduced to helpless little jerks determined to push his spend as deep inside you as he can.
And all you can do is take it—take every spurt, every twitch, your body clenching and milking him desperately as though it refuses to let him go, your name and his name blurring together into moans and gasps until there’s nothing left but the sound of your hearts, hammering in tandem, and the wet, lewd squelch of his cock still seated in your dripping, stuffed cunt.
Matt gasps against your throat, body twitching with aftershocks as his cum leaks out around his cock and down the curve of your ass. You whimper at the warm, slippery sensation, still pulsing around him, still clinging, your cunt reluctant to let him go.
Afterwards, there’s nothing but silence.
Neither of you has any mind to move. His cock is still lodged deep inside you, twitching weakly with every tremor that runs through him. You’re trembling together, not from cold or the heat but from everything, from the enormity of what you’ve just done and the enormity of how right it still feels despite that.
Finally, Matt groans in defeat and rolls his weight just enough to keep from crushing you. It’s not far, though. Not far enough to leave, which relieves you immensely.
His arm slides beneath your back, gathering you against him like he has no intention of ever letting you go, anchoring you to him, anchoring himself to you. Your legs slip apart at the shift and a tiny whimper of protest spills from your throat, but his grip only tightens, grounding you as if to say, don’t drift away from me.
The sheets are damp beneath your back, your thighs tacky where sweat has sealed you together. Matt’s hand spreads broad at your ribs, thumb stroking lazy arcs into your slick skin. His other arm stays firm beneath you to lock your bodies together, his cross cool and sticky where it’s fallen between you.
“…Jesus Christ,” you finally whisper, the words barely more than breath.
“Yeah.”
Your lips are still swollen from his mouth. “That was intense.”
The pause that follows is thin and fragile as an oyster windowpane. He has no desire to break it at all, but he has to for your sake, and you’re aware of the conscious effort he makes to soften his voice, stripped raw: “You okay?”
“Yeah.” You turn your head toward him, brows faintly knitting, heart twisting. This must be it, he’s going to tell you he wishes it hadn’t happened. “...I was about to ask you.”
Oblivious as you usually might be, you know you’re feeling each other out, testing the waters.
“Yeah. I’m okay,” he answers finally, then, so quiet in comparison, he continues, “but you’re not… freaking out?”
“No,” you murmur. Your throat tightens as you add, almost shyly, “I liked it.”
“Yeah. Me too.”
Matt huffs affectionately against your hair, and tilts to nudge his nose against your temple, pressing dazed little kisses along your cheek, your face, your jaw. Tension having snapped, the silence fractures into soft, exhausted laughter—half relief, half disbelief. And for a long moment you’re content to drown in it, until Matt shifts, arm bracing to push himself up, muscles trembling.
Your hands clutch at him before he can slip free. “Don’t.”
“I should—I should get you cleaned up.”
“Later,” you insist, pulling him down again, hooking your leg over his to keep him trapped. Your voice is small but iron-willed. “Let me have this, Matt.”
There’s no fight in him, not when you ask like that. He finds it to be what’s ubiquitous across it all: the inability to deny you what you want, no matter what. And so he collapses back into you obligingly, burying his face in your neck.
A small giggle slips out of you. He lifts his head, curious. “What?”
“I think my brain’s finally coming back online,” you say, stretching enough to wince at the soreness between your thighs.
“Aw, tragic,” Matt drones, “You were so agreeable when it was melted.”
You smack his arm weakly. He catches your hand, presses a kiss to the back of it, and keeps it there against his mouth.
“We should probably get back to studying.”
“Speak for yourself. You’re the one who said you were behind.”
“You’re the one who made me more behind!”
His laugh is a vibrating buzz against your collarbone, tickling you as he nuzzles in closer. “Five more minutes, then.”
You hum, pliant, with no snide retort to shoot back.
For once, you don’t care. For once, you're not afraid of what comes after.
The clatter of dice hits the table, and someone curses irately at rolling another nat one. The campaign pauses just long enough for Marci to look up from the character sheet she’s been only half-invested in, propping her chin in her hand, still a little incredulous that she let Foggy drag her out to D&D instead of spending the afternoon at his place. But he’d been mysteriously insistent on it, and now, watching Foggy grin like a man sitting on a royal flush, it dawns on her what he’d had planned all along.
“They better not hook up,” she mutters idly.
“You might as well just pay up now,” Foggy says without missing a beat, sliding his root beer aside to make room for his pile of winnings. He doesn’t even look at her, oozing smug satisfaction. “I told you it was gonna be today. No way it was gonna take another month.”
Marci glares at him. “How the hell do you even know?”
“I’ve been watching those two make goo-goo eyes since freshman year. It was only a matter of time,” Foggy says, matter-of-fact. “Besides, she was wearing the apple lotion today. That stuff drives Matt crazy. He’s toast.”
There’s a beat of silence around the table before Marci groans, digging into her purse reluctantly.
“You guys are so weird. And disgusting.”
“Yes we are,” Foggy agrees cheerfully, plucking the bill from her hand. He tucks it neatly into his wallet and tips his dice bag toward her in mock toast. “To young love, and finally getting its head out of its ass.”
Hi! Gosh I’m so sorry I hope I’m not late to this but I just found your profile today and thought this was the most fun thing ever.
• What is your ideal date setting?
My ideal date setting would be probably going out to an amusement park/ arcade and then top it off with going to a cafe afterwards.
• What is your favorite song?
My favorite songs differs a lot depending on the mood but right now it’s “Be Like A Woman” by Chris Rainbow
• Which movie brings you comfort?
My comfort movie is 10 Things I Hate About You or any 90s/2000s rom com
• Which fandom would you want your date to be from? (Choose a # from the list below)
5 or 6 (the wizarding world or stranger things)
• What is your favorite snack/dessert?
My favorite dessert is cheesecake or cake
• Is there a specific gender you prefer to be paired with?
Male
I hope I’m not too late to submit this but if I am the I totally understand! Thanks!
Thank you @d1lf-loverrr for your submission to be set up on a blind date.
Based on your responses, Cupid is pairing you with Eddie Munson!
Getting a summer job at the local arcade wasn't how your pictured spending your summer. However, you also didn't picture that you'd be shooting baskets at the hoop toss game with Eddie Munson. For someone who was the basketball team's biggest enemy, he really knew ball. That still didn't answer your question as to why he kept coming here every other day when he clearly wasn't the type of person to hang around in an arcade. Unless...
It wasn't until he asked you to join him for a slice of cake at the café after your shift that your suspicions were confirmed. As you ate a slice of cheesecake, and he enjoyed some devil's food cake, you realize that this summer hadn't been a bust after all. Sure chasing after middle schoolers at the arcade wasn't what you envisioned, but without that job you wouldn't have had the opportunity to spend time with Eddie. As he smiled and shared his favorite songs, you knew that this was simply meant to be.
Thank you for your submission! Eddie is such a fun character to write for, and I hope you liked this piece!
being in love with steve harrington, who can't see a life beyond nancy wheeler, is incredibly difficult
steve harrington x fem!reader (s2 era)
word count | 2.4k
be warned! | general sad themes, unrequited love...?, steve is an unintentional dick, angst, fluff, jonathan byers being a good friend, no nancy hate, upside down is canon, ambiguous-ish ending maybe for a part two, not proof-read!!
notes | I haven't written in literal ages (thanks, school!) so if this one sucks.. then I didn't post it! But I love Steve and I'm super excited to post for him. I've been a Stranger Things fan since 2016. Genuinely. Big moment for little me. Hope you enjoy!
If you would have thought that you'd be spending your Friday night curled in your sheets, tucked under your duvet, crying like a kid, you would've at least brought yourself a snack to comfort you. Maybe a water to calm your raw throat.
But this was an unexpected rush of emotions, brought on by none other than Steve Harrington himself.
The problem was, you didn’t even have the dignity of being mad at him. Because Steve Harrington didn’t try to hurt people. Well, maybe Jonathan Byers, or Billy Hargrove if he was being a dick, but never someone innocent. Never you.
He was a storm that only ever noticed the damage once everything was already wet and ruined and wrecked.
Your face was damp, your pillowcase stuck to your cheek. Your throat felt like you’d swallowed sand. Your hair was a mess, some pieces stuck in your tear-streaked face.
You stared at the ceiling long enough for the darkness to start moving in your peripheral, for the shadows to look like something crawling. Something stretching its arms across your bedroom walls like the Upside Down had figured out where you lived.
It didn't. Not tonight, at least.
Tonight, it was just the dull ache in your heart and the sound of Steve's voice rolling around in your brain.
Your eyes stung when you blinked. Your chest kept doing that stupid thing, that tight, breathless ache like your body couldn’t decide if it wanted to sob or vomit.
You pressed the heel of your hand to your mouth to keep quiet. To contain the sobs that tried to escape past your lips and echo off your walls. To try and contain your own feelings, just for one more minute.
The worst part about what Steve had said wasn't that he said it. No, Steve didn't really think before he spoke. It was how easy it was for him to say, how naturally it came.
You’d been talking about nothing. Literally nothing. The kind of conversation you had when you wanted the time to pass a little quicker. The kind of conversation most people would run from. Just small talk.
You’d said something about how boring Hawkins felt lately.
Steve had scoffed, soft and fond, like you’d just said the funniest thing in the world.
"Yeah," he’d said, smile tugging at his mouth, eyes drifting somewhere far away. "I don’t know. It wasn’t always like this."
Your stomach had fluttered, stupidly hopeful. "What changed?"
He’d shrugged. And then, like it was a confession he’d been carrying in his mouth all day:
"Nancy."
Just her name. Nothing else. Like that was the beginning and the end of it. Your smile had stayed on your face out of pure muscle memory.
"Oh," you’d said, trying to conceal whatever disappointment you felt. Like it didn't feel like swallowing a piece of glass.
Steve had laughed a little, like he hadn’t even noticed the shift in your voice. "I mean--not, like, now, you know," he’d added quickly, rubbing the back of his neck. "Just.. I don’t know. It was.. different. When it was her."
Nancy Wheeler was perfect.
You couldn't even deny it. She was a perfect student, a great daughter, insanely pretty, incredibly and obnoxiously loyal, strong and resilient. Nancy Wheeler might've been proof God had favorites.
Stomach riddled with knots, you nodded anyways. Because you were good at being the person people talked to when they couldn’t have what they wanted.
Steve Harrington liked Nancy Wheeler like she was the air he breathed.
A creek from your window caught your attention suddenly, the sound unusual for a window that stayed closed unless it was summer. You froze for half a second, heart jumping like you’d been caught doing something illegal.
The window opened, and to your surprise, Jonathan Byers poked his head in.
"Hey," Jonathan’s voice came through, careful. "You awake?"
"No," you replied, wiping your tears away with your pillowcase before Jonathan could spot them.
His reply came quick. "Can I come in anyways?"
You didn’t answer. Didn’t need to. The door pushed open a little more and Jonathan stepped in like he didn’t want to startle you. He didn’t turn on the light. He didn’t do that overly bright what’s wrong? voice that made you want to crawl out of your own skin.
"You left school early," Jonathan noted. Because of course he noticed. Jonathan was too observant for his own damn good. "You feeling okay?"
You swallowed hard, eyes fixed on the ceiling like it might give you an answer if you stared long enough.
"Yeah," you lied again, because lying was easier than saying Steve Harrington broke me in half and didn’t even notice that he did anything wrong.
Jonathan didn’t move for a moment. You could feel him standing there in the dark, the weight of his attention steady and quiet.
"Okay," he said finally.
The word didn’t sound like he believed you. It sounded like he was letting you have the lie without punishing you for it. You heard the soft shift of him sitting on the edge of your bed. The mattress dipped slightly from the weight of him sitting.
"I’m not here to interrogate you," Jonathan added, voice low. "I just… wanted to check on you." You blinked rapidly, trying to force the sting away. "Steve was worried when you didn't show up in last period."
Even the sound of someone saying his name made you feel like you were going to faint. "I bet."
The tone in your voice was enough to tell Jonathan something had happened with Steve to make you leave. He just knew you that well, the way someone knew another person when they've grown up together.
"What'd he do?" Jonathan's voice held a hint of something angrier than worry. In some ways, Jonathan wasn't fully trusting of Steve still.
Which, yeah. Fair.
"He was talking about.. her," you said, and even the word tasted bitter. "Nancy."
Jonathan didn’t flinch. He didn’t defend her. He didn’t insult her. He didn’t turn it into some dumb rivalry just because he got the girl in the end. He just listened.
You let out a small, shaky breath. "He said her name like.." you struggled, blinking away tears that refused to stop. "Like it was the only one that mattered."
Jonathan didn't push you to go on. He waited, shifted a little, but stayed patient, eyes trained on your face like he was watching your every miniscule movement.
You turned your head slightly, staring into the darkness until you could barely make out Jonathan’s outline.
"I think I’m in love with him," you whispered, the words stinging your tongue.
"Yeah," Jonathan said gently. "I figured."
Your eyes snapped open, horrified. "You--you knew?"
Jonathan made a small sound that might’ve been a shrug. "You’re not that subtle."
"I thought I was subtle," you croaked, mortified.
"No," Jonathan said, almost fond. "You’re.. obvious. In a way that’s kind of painful to watch."
You let out a broken laugh that immediately dissolved into a sob. "Oh my God. Does-Does Steve.."
Shaking his head, Jonathan replied with a chuckle, "No. I don't think he has a clue."
"I hate it," you said, voice shaking harder now. "Because he’s--he’s nice to me. He’s sweet, and he makes me laugh, and he looks at me like I matter sometimes, and then he talks about Nancy like she’s the whole world and I feel like--"
"You're the second option when she's not around."
You blinked, staring at Jonathan with wide eyes. He'd just read your mind perfectly. It was a little bit jarring.
"Yeah," you softly said, "like I'm his backup when Nancy's not around."
"Steve’s a.. good guy," he said, and the way he said it wasn’t worshipful. It was careful. Honest, even if he hated that it was. "But he’s not careful with people. Not always. Not in the way you are."
Your kindness transcended life itself. The way you cared for everything and everyone, even if it was stupid Tommy Hagan or one of the kids. The way you thought about each word carefully before you spoke. The way you held yourself softly and gently.
"What do I do?" Jonathan turned to you like he didn't quite expect those words.
He thought for a moment, taking a slow, deep breath in. "Give yourself time. Give yourself space. You're more than whatever Steve makes of you. And he's just a stupid boy." You laughed at that, sniffling at the end. "Let yourself feel what you're feeling. Then pick yourself back up and be better. Not for him, for you."
"When'd you get so wise?"
"Probably when I learned there's a whole world under our own." He paused. "Listening to Nancy rant will also do that, too."
"Thank you," you whispered. "You're a good friend."
Jonathan’s eyes softened in the dark, like your words hit him somewhere he didn’t talk about.
He didn’t smile the way Steve smiled; big and easy and careless. Jonathan smiled like it was a privilege.
"Yeah," he said quietly. "Well.. I’m trying."
Your throat tightened again, but this time it wasn’t grief that flooded you. It was gratitude. The kind that made you feel a little pathetic, because it shouldn’t have been this rare to be treated gently.
Jonathan stood up slowly, like he didn’t want to jostle the air. He hovered for a second, awkward in that way he always was when things got too tender. "Just get some sleep, okay? Nancy said she wants you to come over tomorrow to make sure you’re feeling better."
"Tell her I’ll use the door like a normal person," you teased, feeling a bit lighter. Jonathan chuckled, still deciding to exit out your window.
It shut behind him, and the room was quiet again. But it didn’t feel as empty.
Saturday morning came like a punishment.
You woke up with your throat still raw, your eyes swollen, and your stomach hollow like you’d been starved for years. The house felt too normal and bright. It made you want to scream.
You managed to wash your face and brush your teeth without looking too closely at yourself in the mirror, because the girl staring back just didn’t quite feel like your normal self.
Downstairs, you barely tasted breakfast. You barely heard your parents talking. You just moved like a shadow, pulling on your shoes, grabbing your jacket, stepping outside into the cold.
The air was sharp enough to wake you up fully.
Unfortunately.
Hawkins didn’t give you the luxury of staying in bed forever. Neither did the Wheeler’s’ front porch, where you found yourself standing, trying to use your jacket to shield you from the nip in the air.
You lifted your hand to knock, but the door opened before you even could.
Nancy Wheeler stood there in a sweater and jeans, hair pulled back, eyes alert like she’d been waiting for something terrible to happen. When she saw you, her gaze flicked over your face with that same sharp observation Jonathan had.
Something in her expression softened.
"Hey, I’m glad you felt up to come by," she smiled softly. "Come on in."
You hesitated for half a second, then walked in slowly, wiping your palms against your jeans like you could scrub the nerves away.
Then you saw him. Steve Harrington. The one person your heart yearned for, yet broke for. It was awfully poetic. It was also really, really bad timing.
He looked up when you walked in. And his face--his stupid face--lit up with relief? Or maybe a touch of warmth?
"Hey," Steve said, voice bright. "There you are."
Your chest tightened so suddenly it almost stole your breath.
There you are. Like you belonged to him. Like you were something he could count on.
Your mouth went dry. Nancy’s eyes flicked to Steve for a fraction of a second. Then back to you. It was no secret Jonathan had shared your words from last night with her. It was also obvious he did not tell Steve.
Steve took a few steps closer, brows drawing together in a look of confusion.
"Are you okay?" he asked, quieter now. "You weren’t at school yesterday. Jonathan said you--"
Your stomach sank at your name on Jonathan’s tongue, like it had passed through other mouths and become something public. You knew he wouldn't do that, but it still made you anxious. "I’m fine," you said automatically, then stopped yourself.
No. Jonathan told you not to do that.
You swallowed, forcing the truth out in a more real way. "I wasn’t feeling good," you said. "That’s all."
Steve’s face shifted, concern deepening. "Okay," he said. "Well.. I’m glad you’re here now."
The words shouldn’t have hurt. They did anyway. Because being glad you were here didn’t mean he wanted you. It just meant he liked having you near. And that was the problem. You didn’t want to just be near, you wanted to be everywhere he was. To invade his space like a parasite that he would welcome.
Nancy cleared her throat, stepping forward slightly like she was giving you an exit. "We were just going over everything again," she said. "Making sure we’re ready if.. anything happens."
Her voice didn’t tremble when she said it. But her eyes flicked to the windows, to the shadows beyond them. And you remembered, suddenly, that your heartbreak didn’t exist in a bubble.
There was an entire other world beneath yours. A place that didn’t care about Steve Harrington’s feelings. Or yours.
Jonathan appeared in the hallway, hair still messy, expression unreadable until his eyes landed on you. Then, subtly, he softened. Like he was proud you came anyway.
"You okay?" he asked again, but this time it wasn’t about Steve.
You nodded once, barely. "Yeah," you whispered. "I’m okay."
Jonathan held your gaze for a beat, like he was reminding you: Give yourself time. Give yourself space. Be better--for you.
Steve shifted beside you, glancing between you and Jonathan like he could feel the tension but didn’t know why. Then he did the thing that made your heart do something awful. He smiled. He leaned in slightly, voice dropping like it was a secret meant only for you.
"Hey," Steve murmured, almost shy. "Did I do something?"
Your breath caught. You just stood there, frozen, because the truth was a loaded gun in your throat. Because the answer was yes.
Yes, Steve.
You did.
But you didn’t do it on purpose. That almost made it worse.
You swallowed hard, forcing your face to stay neutral. "No," you said softly. "Just.. really don’t feel the best still."
Steve’s shoulders eased immediately, relief washing over him so fast it was insulting.
"Okay," he breathed out, smiling again like you’d just saved him from something. "Cool. Cool."
You hated yourself a little, because part of you was still happy to be the one who made him feel better.
a steve harrington x fem!hopper!reader stranger things rewrite - season 1 - 5
synopsis: y/n hopper has had a rough life, the loss of her sister, a dead beat mother and now an alcoholic father. when william byers goes missing and her and the kids she babysits start to uncover things her life finds meaning; friends, love and family.
warnings!: slow burner, enemies to lovers, ex’s to lovers, grief, death, violence, gore, smut, near death experiences, alcohol, smoking, reader is hopper’s daughter but there is no mention of being biologically related so she could be adopted, suicidal thoughts… more to be added.
particular warnings will be at the start of each chapter!
authors note: i hope you all enjoy this, ive planned a lot of it and am very excited! this is a slow burner, so you’ll have to wait awhile for anything real to happen but i think it’ll be worth the wait :)
if you want to be added to the tag list please comment on the most recently posted chapter, it just makes it easier for me to find!
Fools: Steve would be a Republican! Steve would be a patriot!
Me, someone with a working brain: Steve would be fucking disgusted by the bigotry, hatred, warmongering and cruelty that modern day America is full of
Steve became Captain America to fight against antisemites, homophobes, racists, misogynists and warmongering fascists...he would view America's government and those who support it as EVERYTHING he utterly loathes
being able to play songs in your head is cool and all but not really if you can't control what and when it plays so this is a visualization of me trying to concentrate while angel of music plays in my head
Pairing: Clark Kent (Superman 2025) x cashier!reader
Synopsis: You’re a recent college grad that just moved in with your best friend Jimmy Olsen and found a job as a cashier running a late night corner store in Metropolis. When a tall, blue eyed stranger stumbles in at 3 am and threatens to turn your life around, the lines blur between you and you find yourself wanting more.
cw: meet-cute-ish, being down bad, cocky-ish! clark, sexual tension, horrible flirting, overthinking, roommates with Jimmy, reference to sexual content? (eventually will have smut but we're not there yet), cigarettes are cool, is this a situationship who's to say, no proofreading for this sorry
---
You don’t know how it starts. Seriously. You had only just started working at this cafe? Bodega? You weren’t sure what to call it. Under EMPLOYEES WANTED, it was marketed as, “a cross between a coffeeshop, gas station, and a bar”, but you found it had none of the perks and more of the hassle. I mean you guys didn’t even sell gas or good coffee. All you knew is that you were Metropolis’ one stop shop for late night ice cream, or cheap wine, or booze when they were fresh out of a breakup or, hell, even a minion themed band-aid if they scraped their knee. Whatever, they wanted, you definitely had, probably on some obscure high shelf, or tucked away under the cash register (like your cigarettes when the nights dragged wayyy too long, which was often).
Not that you were complaining. You had volunteered for the late shifts – although it was more of an assignment – but from what you had experienced so far, usually there weren’t too many late night visitors. You weren’t exactly the expert on most things in Metropolis, as you had just moved in with your friend Jimmy to get away from living with your parents postgrad, so you didn’t really have an idea of the clientele in this part of the city. All you knew was count the change fast, make sales even faster, and lock up the store in the morning. Cool. No questions asked.
Until, you were sitting behind the register, playing The Mighty Crabjoys in your earbuds and singing at the top of your lungs at approximately 3:36 in the morning, picking at the gum stuck to the sole of your shoe with the pen you used to write receipts, when you glanced up for a second just to see a giant man slouching in front of you, smiling, but scratching the back of his neck sheepishly.
“JESUS CHRIST” you yelled startled and at full volume, almost falling out of your chair, and knocking off the origami crane army you had made from gum wrappers, “You scared the shit out of me!”.
Pulling your earbuds out quickly, you manage an embarrassed smile, cheeks flushed, and try to apologize at the very second the stranger tried to speak.
“Sorry?”, you tried again, grabbing your phone and turning down the volume still blasting from your discarded earbuds, as you glanced up to his eyes for the first time.
God. The second you glanced up it felt like being shocked by a million electric eels. His eyes were startlingly blue and lit up, and his face was clearly amused. He was extremely good-looking, with dark curls falling in his eyes, and dimples peeking out, and a snug t-shirt. He had glasses that were large and slipping down his nose and he pushed them up nervously as you gaped at him.
“Oh. I just said I love that song”, he nodded, setting his items down on the counter in front of you.
You were at a loss for words. You glanced across the items he put down, cataloging them and trying to remember how much they all cost. A million thoughts ran through your mind. I like your face, you thought. You come here often? Why are you awake at this hour? What are you doing right now? What are you doing after this? Do you have a girlfriend?
Instead, you settled on something equally clever that sounded like, “i’m-uhhhh-really???”.
He cleared his throat, “uh yeah. They’re my favorite band, you know. Just super punk rock". He shuffled in place, gesturing to the counter, “how much will this cost, by the way?”
You shook your head slightly like an Etch-a-Sketch, trying to rustle your thoughts back into place and get some normality in your body. Jesus. You’re acting like a teenager. To be fair, you hadn’t had much luck with guys recently. You were still getting to know the ins and outs of the Metropolis bar scene, and you were trying your best out there, but as of this moment you had spent most of your time wing-womaning for Jimmy. And you hadn’t met that many guys that you thought were attractive. None had beautiful eyes, and dimples, and curly hair that was begging to be touched.
Speaking of dimples, the man cleared his throat again, jarring you back to attention. Ok, think, you told yourself. You glanced over his items, a box of bandages, an icy-hot patch, a tide stain remover pen, and a gatorade. Seriously?
“Uh that’ll be $10.35” you said, your voice squeaking, as you grabbed a bag and began placing the items inside, just to give your hands and eyes something to do. You were pretty sure if you made eye contact again, you would probably combust. Or something.
At the same time, in your periphery, you watched as he reached his arm, to his back pocket, to pull out his wallet.
“Got some insane injuries or something?” you tried, pathetically.
He chuckled, “yeah something like that”, as he continued glancing down to count the change in his palm. You followed his gaze down to look at his gigantic hands. Goddamn. You were ogling this guy like a monster.
“You know we also have superman themed band-aids if you’re interested in that sort of thing”, you blurted out. “Just got them in this week and they’re on sale”.
Mentally, you cursed yourself. Wow. Really cool conversation right here. Number one, at flirting in the entire world. Casually, the most handsome man you’ve ever seen in your entire life, and you’re bringing up Superman band-aids.
He reached out to hand you the cash, and his fingers brushed your palm. “Haha, I think I’ll have to get those next time”. You stared dumbly at the cash and pushed the paper bag towards him with your other hand.
“Uh do you want a receipt?” you asked quickly, glancing up. He surveyed your face and you swore he looked at your lips. Or maybe, that was you hopeful thinking. Hopeful praying, more like.
“Nah, I think I’ll manage”, he responded. “Have a good night” he called back as he began walking to the door. You watched his broad shoulders move away from you gradually. As he pulled the door open, he hesitated for a moment, and then turned back.
“I liked your singing”, he said, and then stepped into the night, bag swinging in his arm as he disappeared around the corner and out of your sight.
—
A few days had passed since that late night and you were still – embarrassingly so – thinking about it. You hadn’t even told Jimmy because 1) he worked during the day when you slept so you hadn’t run into him yet and 2) you couldn’t bring yourself to bring it up. What was there really to say? Hey Jimmy, I saw the hottest man in my entire life and I forgot how to speak and talk and he also likes my music taste and singing. There wasn’t too much to mention.
So instead, you find yourself back behind the counter and it’s late at night again, lacing a cigarette between your fingers, and trying not to think about him. But you are. You’re rehearsing and trying to think of clever things to say. This wasn’t you. Usually, you were pretty nonchalant around guys. At least that was what you are trying to convince yourself.
During this mental war waging in your brain, the door jangled, knocking you out of your stupor and forcing you to look up. It was him. All 6’4 of him, loitering in the aisle, and scanning the shelves, and probably feeling your gaze burning into the side of his neck. You force yourself to look down and blink, seeing his perfectly curled hair behind your eyelids. Great. You try to focus on your cigarette and stop your hands from shaking.
Eventually, he comes to stand in front of the counter, dropping his items down and offering a muted greeting.
You’re mentally calculating the total of the 3 oranges, bundle of bananas, and microwavable meal, when he interrupts your train of thought,
“You know those things are bad for your lungs”, he said, nodding towards your cigarette.
You scoff. “This is probably worse for your body”, you say, holding up the microwavable meal and waving it in front of him. “Don’t you know how to cook?”, you joke.
He scoffs in return. “I do actually. It just happens to be 3:48 in the morning and I was working late and I didn’t quite feel like Paul Hollywood.”
You nod solemnly. “Few get that privilege. One could only wish to achieve his masterful baking. Your total is $9.64.”
He hands you the money. “No singing tonight?”
The tips of your ears go pink. You manage a laugh. “You’ll have to pay extra for that from now on, I’m afraid. I’m unfortunately not in the habit of singing for strangers”.
“Well, I’m Clark, Clark Kent. So now we’re not strangers. And how much extra?”, he inquires. “Like $3-4 more or?” he says trailing off.
You act mock hurt. “My singing is only worth $3 to you? I’m hurt honestly.”
He laughs at that and meets your eyes. “Ok, fine. I’d pay $20. But you’d have to throw in the Superman band-aids as well”
That gets a real laugh out of you. “You drive a hard bargain. I’ll have to think about it.”
He nods at this. Then, flicking his eyes down to the cigarette in your hand, he says quietly and drawn out, “You know, I’ve never smoked before.” His eyes are unreadable as they lock onto yours.
You feel like you can’t breathe. You hold the cigarette out towards him, trying to still your arm and act casual. “Do you want to try?”. You don’t know what’s come over you.
Without responding or breaking eye contact, he reaches out and his warm hand envelops your wrist. His hands are massive and easily cover the skin there. Your pulse jumps and you’re certain he can feel it. Slowly, he leans down and puts the cigarette between his lips. He closes his eyes and slowly breathes in. You feel like all the air is sucked from your chest. Like you’re in a vacuum. Your heart feels like it's beating out of your chest and you feel the blood rushing in your ears. He opens his eyes slowly and breathes out, releasing his hold on your wrist.
“Huh” you stumble out, watching him.
“What?” he asks, looking self-conscious now, and shyer. Is he blushing? He’s still leaning down close to you.
You put the cigarette to your own lips, breathing in, and lean across the counter on your tip toes. Instinctively, his hand cups the side of your face. With your lips barely brushing his, you breathe the smoke into his mouth and then barely lean back, so you can search his face for a reaction.
His eyes seem impossible dark as he takes in the smoke. You can barely see the blue in his eyes as his pupils are dilated. His hand still holds your face, his thumb brushing your temple. Your stomach flips. You bite your lip and try to think of something to say, but you’re speechless. He breathes out.
At that moment, someone steps into the shop and the door jingles. Clark jerks back and grips the bag of items. He clears his throat and nods at you, backing away slowly as if he just realized what he’s been doing.
“It was great to see you again,” he says, his voice low. Had it always been that low? You’re not sure. It feels like it rumbles through your chest.
You nod in response but your mind is spinning. “Have a good night, Clark” you manage to say, as he steps into the night.
—
It begins your routine. He comes in on random late nights, looking extremely tired and winded like he just worked out for 5 hours. And he buys random items. He flirts with you over the counter. And you act like you don’t like his flirting. Which you do like it. A lot. Obviously.
And you learn about him. You learn he really likes eating frozen dumplings. You learn he drinks lots of coffee. You learn he works as a reporter and he loves to write and he does lots of it. You learn he likes baking pies and sweets. On the rare occasion you have other customers and he swings by, he’ll leave cookies and a post-it note. You learn he’s a farmer midwestern boy from Smallville and he was on the debate team. He’s always debating with you about something.
And he learns about you too. He finds out you scribble doodles across any paper you can find and get ink stained fingers. He finds out that you wear a certain hat when your hair gets greasy. He learns that you like when your nail polish gets chipped and you twist your rings around your fingers when you get nervous. He finds out you listen to too much Radiohead and you love blowing bubbles when you chew gum and you like singing but you hate karaoke.
And you don’t tell Jimmy. Even when he bothers you about it when you go out. Like last Saturday night, when you found yourself wedged between Jimmy and his friend Lois Lane. Apparently, there was another friend from work but he couldn’t make it. Jimmy was disappointed. ‘He’s perfect for you’, he insisted. ‘I’ll set up the blind date’. But you refused. But how could you explain it? I have a crush on this guy who comes and buys way too many random groceries at 3 am and who I have weird sexual chemistry with. It was crazy when you thought about it. And if you tried to explain it? No way.
You keep Clark to yourself. Sometimes he stays at the counter for so long, bantering with you, or sharing your cigarettes (if you share it then you both get less of a chance of lung cancer). He’s caring like that.
Like last night when he stepped in and you couldn’t help but tease him.
“Seriously, Kent?” you tease, “You’re a reporter, aren’t you supposed to be getting your beauty sleep right now? Don’t you want to look your best when you’re interviewing Superman tomorrow?”.
He pretends to look annoyed, but you can see the smile pulling at the corner of his mouth. His eye roll is totally unconvincing. He has too much caring behind his eyes to mask.
“I actually thought I’d work some overtime and do some secret investigating on local cornershops. What do you think of the headline, ‘Local girl terrorizes handsome man for wanting a late night box of cereal’?”
“Hmmm. Needs some work”, you reply, “And handsome is really generous. Maybe you try Midwestern corn muncher harasses hardworking middle class individual. Seems more accurate”.
At this, he puts both his hands on the counter and leans down to look at you. The flannel he’s wearing is rolled up to his biceps and the top two buttons are undone giving you the slightest look at his toned chest. You can smell his cologne from this close. And his toothpaste. And maybe his mouthwash. And his glasses are slightly askew.
He keeps looking at you and you’re looking at him and trying not to stare at his big dumb pouty lips. You feel your heart threatening to beat out of your chest.
You want to kiss him so bad. You don’t think you can stop yourself. But, just as you lean in slightly enough to break the space between you, he smirks.
“I thought you said I wasn’t handsome”, he murmurs.
That damn counter is your prison. The physical manifestation of the line between you and Clark, as you keep flirting but never crossing into anything real. You think you’re doomed to probably die behind this desk, thinking about Clark Kent.
So naturally, you pretend like the routine is fine, that you’re okay with seeing Clark Kent, maybe once a week, twice if you’re lucky and swallow the idea that he could want more with you. You pretend like you don’t think of him, especially when you get home from work and Jimmy is already asleep and you’re slipping your fingers beneath the waistline of your shorts. And you pretend it’s not his name on your lips when you get off and you’re not picturing his smirk or his dimples or his biceps. You’re good at pretending. Right?
—
Until one night, when it isn’t Clark that stumbles into the shop, it’s Superman.
“You alright there, Smallville?” you joke, barely glancing up until the man doesn’t respond.
Looking up, you realize it’s not Clark. How could you think it was him? Hunching over and holding his abdomen is Superman, covered in his blue and red, and complete with the cape billowing behind him from the gust of wind that slams the door shut and ushers him in.
Superman, who you only know from seeing on the news on your TV or from the Daily Planet newspapers that Jimmy leaves on your dining room table that you glance at in passing, is here in this shop. You’re used to seeing him as this symbol of strength and hope, either caught mid-flight or propping up a building. But now, he seems too real. Rather than the Man of Steel, Krypton’s mightiest hero, he’s here in the flesh, entering your shop just like any other customer, looking for something after a long night.
He stumbles now, barely able to stand, hairs sweatily smashed against his forehead.
“Oh my god? Superman? Are you okay?”, you say, abandoning your usual position behind the counter and rushing towards him to catch his body before he slumps to the floor.
He doesn’t respond, his eyes barely open and his mouth barely pushes out a groan. You’re in shock. You scan the shelves just above his head for the bandages. Your apartment is just a few blocks from here, so you could definitely nurse him back to health there. And Jimmy was probably asleep – not that he would mind. He’d probably be overjoyed at the thought of having Superman in his apartment. The only problem is making it there.
You hastily grab as many healthcare items you can off the shelves and pack a bag. Leaning down to Superman you drape his arm around your shoulder and attempt to lift him. Jesus.
“You’re gonna have to help me here”, you whisper, scanning his face.
He manages to hear this and stands with intense effort. He’s leaning a good amount of his weight on you and you’re trying your best not to teeter over.
Ok this is Superman and I can do this, you mutter under your breath and move towards the door. Once you step into the street and manage to lock the door of the shop behind you, after fumbling with your keys from the adrenaline, you begin the walk to your apartment with the bag clenched in your hand and Superman in tow.
---
This is Part 1 of some garbage I wanted to write. Also! This is my first time writing something so sorry if it sucks.
man… the suit stays ON and we’re going to DRY HUMP we all know you’re into it, superman! this is basically our version of the jonathan bailey bulge picture ☝🏻
dailybridgerton
romaincrisis
discoholicmusic
gummygunk
stormborns
andulkaphoto
vaporwave
