Last weekend I wrote to you from under a mosquito net on my bed at a Caribbean style guest house in Puerto Viejo, Costa Rica. It was the night following the day of the Women’s marches in the United States & around the world. I felt a sense of guilt for being unable to physically march in solidarity not only for American women but women from every country, for the women of today, the ones who stimulated this history & those who will come in the future.
This weekend I was back on US soil & not too far from Boston. Yesterday morning--Sunday, January 29--I woke & like most millennials that morning, I checked Facebook. The first blip to hit my newsfeed was a notification that a friend of mine was attending the Boston Protest Against Muslim Ban & Anti-Immigration Orders on January 29. I was not jet lagged but had completely lost track of the date. January 29. Today! (well yesterday now).
In December 2015 I went on a three week college sponsored road trip along the Mexican-American Border with a professor from Union College and five other students. Prior to driving 1,400 miles with a group in a mini-van I only had passing thoughts about the border but was always curious. This is a major part of American politics but growing up in the North East, this complex and conflicted topic hardly reaches our nightly news broadcasts and local newspapers.
For three weeks we confronted it. We went to East LA & learned about the Race Wars, saw the Great Wall--a captivating work of art that dwarfs any human, reminding them the history we are part of, humbling us that we are all in this together, long before we stepped out into this world and we will impact what is yet to come--among other sites that exposed racial tensions within the US and the fact that many races existed in what is now the United States of America, prior to European settlers spreading out across the land. From there we drove south to San Isidro, just on the border of Tijuana. This was our first direct encounter with the wall.
We went to a shopping center right at the border. American shopped and Mexicans commuted over to work. At first I was appalled, then I listened & thought.
The fact that the mall exists here is okay. Striking & a huge juxtaposition to the settings that rises above the hills just beyond the militarized, hideous wall (more about the appearance of the wall). When the shopping center was built, another one, with similar shops & layout, was supposed to be built on Mexico’s side. However, in the end a lack of funding prevented the second shops from being built.
Here I began listening more. For too long America has developed the idea of Manifest Destiny & the persona of saving all people of the world. I remember learning about this in high school & being quite bothered by this sentiment. Who were we to know what worked well for other places? Yes, we might be able to build a democracy & develop an admirable history that American citizens should forever be proud of. Nevertheless, we cannot possibly know what works for every nation of the world. Climate, size, history, religion, economics, cultural differences, minute esoteric details & so on, make each place & its people unique.
It was not until this past spring when I took a course I had long been itching to take--Social Entrepreneurship--that my thoughts from high school began to sort out. With social entrepreneurship, specific steps are taken slowly & with great awareness. A large part of developing a social entrepreneurial endeavor is spent on listening. Listening to the people you set out to assist, hearing, seeing, observing and empathizing with how they live life. When there is an issue of poverty or hunger, the listening comes into affect. An outside observer who knows how to remedy a problem has learned how the culture operates so when the help has been given & the outside party has left, they have left a solution that feels natural to the culture. Nothing has been changed about how the culture operates, thus they can sustain the positive change. This tactic encourages other cultures to support themselves from within, build themselves up.
In El Paso, Texas we talked to two women through the fence while they stood inches away in Juarez, Mexico. Both women agreed that they did not want to come to America. They wanted to stay in their country. If they left, if everyone left for America, then how could Mexico ever rebuild its economy & perpetuate a safer place to live. They thought in a socially and culturally aware way.
Ultimately, I do not believe in a physical wall, especially one that is highly militarized. I do not think that America needs to let in every person of the world, although I support the notion of asylum for those escaping life threatening situation & who hope to work hard & better themselves & their lives. That is what the American spirit was built on. I think workers permits are a wonderful idea for those who live close to the border. I think strides need to be taken to encourage people around the world, not just the people of Mexico, to think more like the two women in Juarez. Stimulate & inspire a desire for the people of other nations to want to stay & being the seeds of positive, effective, culturally & socially effective change. Only the people can make their country what they need it to be. It will take time & at the start might feel idealistic but just as outside forces need to listen to the voices, needs & traditions of others, the people within the same countries need to listen to each other, from those who feel voiceless to those with the most power & loudest voices.
So when I stepped off the T at Arlington, the Copley stop was closed due to the marching, & turned to face the street, hardly paying attention for a moment, my head shot up. There before me was a street, a street I have walked on many times before. A view I have seen over again without thinking much but is now imprinted in my mind.
From left to right the road was full of people walking forward with signs & chanting in unison, “No Ban. No Wall.” I was struck. I knew I was heading to the march but I went on a bit of a whim, without a sign, turning my car towards the T station when I had other errands to run.
I went to see & listen, just as I had been taught to do as a young girl. Listen to people. Open your eyes & open your mind. Having been educated about the border & being passionate about it, I felt a responsibility to attend. Also as an American citizen in a vibrant moment, I felt responsible. As the daughter of a father who dropped me off at school, from kindergarten to high school, & called out as I hopped out the door, “Love you… & be nice to everyone,” I felt responsible. Aside from feeling responsible I wanted to be there. I want to listen. I want to hear as many sides as possible.
Fill my ears. Fill my heart & mind. Get me to listen more & think more & then come back with well educated ears that have heard from every crevice & corner that I have the privilege of learning from.
Our president’s thoughts are easily accessible. I will listen to him. Despite how we feel as a nation, he is our president right now. He too is a person & deserves to be listened to. The other day someone said that he will follow President Trump until President Trump does something to really mess up. So far I may not agree with President Trump’s sentiments but I will give him the respect I give to each person of the world. Since I can turn the news on & hear from him, I went to the march to hear from every group that Boston is able to represent.
What I learned is that I might not be a physical protester. There were some signs I found to be to radical. I think the form of protest, marching & rallying is through conversation & writing. Maybe that makes me weak but this is where I feel I can be most effective & true to my beliefs. I will support, I will witness, I will love & welcome & nurture who ever needs that. I will empathize. I am here for anyone who needs an ear, who ever needs help raising their voice in a positive & effective way. I am here for you, who ever you may be. Open to all ears & waiting until I feel as educated & open minded as I need to be in order lift our country from this confusion. Hopefully America will again be a beacon for other nations of the world to do the same, on their own terms & social sustainable way.
This is a highly saturated & loud time for America. We have not seen protests like this since the ‘70s. It is a privilege for us to get out there & share our feelings, but balance our vocalism with our ability to listen, learn, reconsider & formulate.