Once again watching the POTC trilogy and I’m really into Stiles/Derek/Lydia lately
Obviously Stiles is Will
Lydia is Elizabeth
Derek is Jack
Peter is Barbossa 😂😂😂
And it’s more of a romance between the 3 than just both guys liking the girl
I can’t be the first person to think about this I need to go find the fics.
If anyone HAD any good fic recs… let me know please and thank you.
Jackson is Norrington
I’m trying to figure out who would be Davy Jones. I don’t want to give that potential to Kate Argent. I feel like she’s more Beckett.
Oh maybe bad friend Scott and Scott is Davy Jones???? Actually I’m feeling that. Love ruined him in a way that could be solved if he just looked outside of himself???
Yeah yeah I’m seeing it now.
OK, but…
Derek is actually Will and Stiles is Jack.
Noble, grounded, and some self-esteem issues because of trauma related to his family? Sounds like Derek to me.
A little crazy, extremely clever, with mommy and daddy issues? Now that’s Stiles.
Although, we could also swap it again here because some of those traits carry over into Elizabeth. If we had Stiles as Elizabeth that would make Noah the governor and that kind of works perfectly. And then have Lydia as Jack, which doesn’t fit as nicely, but it still kind of works.
I fully agree that Kate Argent cannot work as David Jones because Davy Jones does get a minor redemption arc and Kate not only never even attempts it, she doesn’t see her behaviors as wrong, and she doesn’t do anything to earn it ever. However, that makes her perfect for Beckett because he doesn’t see owning and selling human beings is wrong and in fact, shames Jack because he released the slaves that Beckett had been transporting as cargo arms Beckett had him branded as a pirate for it. Although, where does that leave Gerard? The king of England?
I totally see where you’re going with Scott as Davy Jones but the only downside is that it would make Allison Calypso and that I just don’t see. I mean, the way she interacts with the story does work a little bit, but the intentions are not the same at any point. Because Calypso has all of the information from the start and Allison does not.
The more I start to think about this, I kind of like the idea of Lydia as Calypso and Jackson as Davy Jones, but that throws everything off and I’d have to start from scratch. Grrr! I did not plan on thinking about this this much! (but I’m enjoying the picture it’s creating and I will continue to do so outside of this post. bye bye)
Yes yes I agree with all of this as well. 😂


















