She had always been the type of person who loved or hated fiercely. There was very little room for grey in her life. As sheâd gotten older though, she found that far more difficult to live with. People were complicated and sometimes there were explanations for situations. It didnât change the hurt, or whatever wrong had been committed but it provided reasoning. So instead of pushing him away, she listened. As much as she hated to admit it, she still had feelings for him. The revelation should have changed that, but it didnât. Even if it had, he was with her for the foreseeable future. They were having a child together.
He had let her go before, and she had been devastated. It was a quiet hurt that she had kept to herself, but it had been there. Sheâd quickly missed the text messages and surprises, and most of all- his presence. And all of it had gone in a snap. So quick that it felt like in the blink of an eye she missed all of it. One moment she was taking him to meet her family and the next they were two completely separate people.Â
Theo knew she was lucky to have a great relationship with her parents. She was reminded of it every time she saw them, or received a phone call or text. The beginning of her life could have marred all of it, she knew this. Theo hardly had any memories of Desmond Bowman, and the ones she had of Zhanna were darker. If Darla and Daniel hadnât stepped in, Theoâs life would be completely different from the one she had now. Sheâd gotten lucky, and she absolutely knew it. It hurt to know that Eli didnât have that with his parents. âThen you have to tell her.â
It was enough that she had slept with him while he was engaged to someone else. The fact that she was pregnant because of that complicated things even more. But what she wouldnât be is the other person. The two were close to begin with, so she didnât have to move her arm very far to press it against his chest. âIf you want me then you need to do that because itâs not fair. To her or to me.â
Caroline hadnât expected Eli to run after her when she left him at the barââhe never had been the typeââbut she had expected to see him by now, if only so he could ask if it was time for them to go home and continue icing each other out in private. She had committed to standing strongââto pacing around the B&B, biding her time until Eli finally made the first move. She was determined to test the bounds of his indifference; was it possibly limitless enough to let her stagnate until the crowd cleared out and went home, leaving him with no choice but to find her?
She had walked off to be aloneââcompletely alone, rather than just overlookedââin the hallway that led toward the bathroom. Every few minutes, someone would walk throughââa couple holding hands, a set of friends giggling among themselvesââand each time, sheâd put her phone to her ear or furrow her brow to appear busy, distract from what she was actually doing: hiding. It was during one of these performances that she felt her phone buzz in her hand, and she breathed a quick sigh of relief, certain that Eli had finally waved the white flag in the form of a text. Instead, she peered down at a shelter-in-place alert, her resolve to wait out Eli growing thinner by the second.
It took another five minutes for Caroline to caveââsomething she rarely didââand set off in search of Eli. A text to him had gone unanswered, leading her on a walk of the B&Bâs ground floor, peering in and out of empty rooms and occupied corners with little luck. She approached another door and she opened it just slightly, finding that it lead to the B&Bâs small library. Figuring that she wouldnât find Eli there, she begun to close it behind her before she heard his voice. I donât think I could do it again. About to open the door fully, certain that sheâd find him talking on the phoneââto who, she wasnât sureââor engaged in a conversation with a coworker, she froze at the sound of a womanâs voice. Then you have to tell her.
Suddenly, Caroline was positive she had simply misheard, though the urge to confirm that overwhelmed her. Her brain was telling her that she had simply wandered into a coupleâs private conversationââthat she was imagining Eliâs voice because she wanted to find himââbut the fact that she knew what she heard, that she was never wrong, that she would know his voice anywhere compelled her to take a step into the room. She had braced herself to find two strangers, to laugh it offâââoh, Iâm so sorry, I didnât think anyone was in hereâââand close the door behind her. She hadnât actually expected to find Eli, standing with another woman, her arm draped tenderly across his chest. She stared for what felt like an eternity, unsure of what the look on her face even read as, unsure of what she was even feelingââconfusion, anger, a longing to be wrong for the first time in her life.
Eli was already nodding, already forming the speech in his mind. He knew Caroline deserved better. Sheâd deserved better from the start. Where he found her to be domineering, he knew someone else would find her endearing. Where he thought her to be uptight, he knew someone else would think her organized, inspiring even. It had been selfish in its own way-- he was realizing now-- to follow his parents wishes for him when he felt none of the fire she deserved. To marry her because of them when it should have been because of her. It seemed so clear now. How had he not seen it before?Â
He opened his mouth to say yes, he was going to tell her. Not here, though. Not surrounded by strangers in an unfamiliar town. She deserved better than that too. And though his hands ached to rest over Theoâs, he resisted the urge to touch her. âI--â
Eliâs head snapped up, swiveling in the direction of the voice he knew far better than he wished to in that moment. He longed to be mistaken, felt ice bloom where the warmth of Theoâs touch had lingered. No. This was not how this was supposed to happen. He blinked, as if it might erase that look on her face as he turned to her.Â
âCaroline--â His voice sounded frail, the sound choked off by the lump that had suddenly formed in his throat. He was to blame for this, he knew. The past few weeks with her, where heâd been standoffish or rude or snappy, came flooding back, threatening to sweep him away with the guilt that ran like rapids. Telling her the truth had been enough of a daunting task. Waving it in her face in the middle of a Valentineâs Day gala? It wasnât fair. He didnât want this for her.Â
But heâd made a promise to himself, to Theo, to Caroline herself, that he was going to be honest. So, he didnât make any moves to step away from Theo, merely situated himself between the two women, almost as if shielding Theo from Carolineâs ire. âIâm sorry.â The words sounded cheap, like the silver-painted plasticware that set the tables in the ballroom. âThis is not how this was supposed to happen. This is not how this should have happened. I--â
He dropped his head, some part of his heart acknowledging that this was about to hurt. This was about to get messy. This was about to happen in front of Theo. âI canât marry you, Caroline.â