Why is one of the first things that we ever learn about Roy Mustang the fact that he is useless in the rain?
So at this point, I think weāve all heard or realized that Roy Mustangās rain/water motif is not just a physical limitation for his alchemy but also a symbol for his regret and āuselessness.ā Itās a brilliant metaphor that elementally balances him out.Ā
And itās introduced the moment we meet him.Ā
While it does serve as a bit of comic relief during the extremely intense first episode, the significance of it being in that episode is still important to Royās development and how the audience develops their understanding of him throughout the series.Ā
First, we need to contextualize it. The first episode is centered around Isaac McDougal, the freezing alchemist (as in an alchemist who freezes, not a really really cold alchemist, although āIsaac the Really Really Cold Alchemistā would be a fantastic name. Anyways). Isaacās goal is to freeze over Central Command via a city-wide transmutation circle using a philosopherās stone.Ā
The plot of the first episode is a parallel to the plot of the entire series, and it is full of foreshadowing. In terms of exposition, it isnāt very subtle. The basic exposition of characters like Ed, Al, and Roy is pretty much told to us through dialogue. However, that choice is justified. For people who are completely new to the FMA world, as I was when I watched this two years ago, the first episode has a lot going on. New members are not only meeting all the characters, but they are also trying to put together what alchemy is, where and when this is taking place, and who they should be rooting for. And THAT is where the brilliance (in my opinion) comes in. Watching the first episode through for the first time, the audience is rooting for Ed and Al (because they are the protagonists), and the military (because our protagonists trust them and are part of it). When our protagonists are told to capture Isaac and to view him as a traitor, we do, too. Itās only when Isaac confronts Ed about his beliefs about the military that we start to question our own. But even then, we arenāt given enough information to understand why we should question the military. However, watching the episode in hindsight, our loyalties are switched. Isaac becomes the hero trying to take down the evil military, and Ed, Al, and Mustang become the villains.Ā
So, back to Roy. During the first episode, aside from getting the basics of who he is and what he does, we donāt learn much more about him. Just these two things:Ā
1. He is a veteran of something called the Ishvalan War (and the Ishvalan War is apparently controversial based on conversations between Isaac and Roy and Isaac and Kimblee).
2. He canāt make things go sparky sparky when he gets wet.Ā
And those two things are arguably the most important parts of who Mustang is and what he has been through.Ā
First, letās talk about Roy, Isaac, and Ishval. As the first episode unfolds, the audience knows nothing about what happened in Ishval. But Roy and Isaac do. In hindsight, knowing how Roy feels about the Ishvalan War and what he did there, why on Earth would he be calling Isaac a traitor? Roy knows that the military is corrupt (although not to the extent that he will). Royās biggest regret is blindly following orders in Ishval. Roy has his eyes set on becoming the Fuhrer and changing things. Roy is literally a genocidal war criminal who stages a coup from an ice cream truck and overthrows the military. And somehow Isaac is the traitor?
Roy is following orders because he has to in order to achieve his goal. He is putting on a loyal-to-the-military act and biding his time until he can admit to the world that Isaac was right.Ā
Er, that his ideals were.
See, Isaac is Royās elemental opposite. Isaac is water, Roy is fire. He is also Royās narrative foil. While Isaacās plan lacked patience and was too rash to ever succeed, Royās plan has taken him and will take him years, and he has been extremely careful curating it. Itās ironic to me that the character associated with water would act more rashly and have less patience than the character associated with fire. Thatās not to say that Roy doesnāt act rashly. Royās impulsiveness and vengeance-driven actions are some of his greatest setbacks as a character.Ā
But Roy is also intelligent and strategic in achieving his greater goals. His dependence is on his closest allies, while Isaacās dependence is on a philosopherās stone. And while the characters do not yet know the ingredients for stones in the first episode, Isaacās use of one to accomplish his ultimate goal is what sets him apart from Roy and the Elrics. And yes, Roy does use a stone to regain his eyesight, but he does not depend on one during his coup. I would even argue that Isaacās use of a philosopherās stone could also be foreshadowing Royās eventual use of one in addition to foreshadowing the overall plot. Itās also important for us to see Isaac defeated in the first episode because it shows us that although philosopherās stones remove the law of equivalent exchange, they do not make the user all-powerful. At the end of the day, the user can still be defeated.
Another difference between the two is how their limitations are presented in this episode. Isaacās alchemy is unlimited because of the philosopherās stone, but the first thing we learn about Roy Mustangās alchemy is that he is limited by water. This leads me to the second point.Ā
Establishing Royās limitations in the first episode does a few things for us:Ā
First, it establishes that he is dependent on Riza and trusts her in his most vulnerable moments. That even though Riza knows how easily Roy can be overpowered, she still chooses to stay by his side, protect him, and help him accomplish whatever he sets out to do.Ā
Second, we get a peek at Mustangās creativity and perseverance. His determination and intelligence is displayed in how he overcomes the limitations presented, and it makes us want to root for him.Ā
Third, it gives us some information as to how alchemy works. We see a few types of alchemy in this episode: Edās without a circle, Isaacsās with a circle and elemental, Royās with his transmutation circle gloves and unique flame alchemy, and Major Armstrongās forceful style. This helps us get an idea of the varying styles of alchemy, varying ways of how it can be used and manipulated, and the different forces that use it for their benefit or the benefit of others.
Lastly, it begins theĀ āuselessnessā theme. It tells us that even though Mustang is an extremely powerful alchemist, there are still things that he canāt control. That there are forces that can overpower him, and the best thing he can do is to get back up and try again until he accomplishes his goal. We also see Royās anger at those forces, the ones that render him unable to do anything. And we see him use that anger to fuel his alchemy and overpower them.
āThe power of one man does not amount to much, but however little strength I am capable of⦠Iāll do everything humanly possible to protect the people I love, and in turn theyāll protect the ones they love. It seems like the least we tiny humans can do for each other.ā
Roy Mustang, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood