How To Be Polite In Fic Comments And Write A Good Review, In Particular For Smut
- Donât like, donât read. AO3 asks for your consent to read explicit fics. Do not complain after you consent, you have given your consent by clicking âproceedâ and reading the fic.
- The tags are there for a reason. Read ALL the tags and pay attention to them before reading the fic, the tags are there for a reason and it is to inform you so that you can make better decisions for yourself.
- A review is far âlouderâ than pressing the kudos button. Many authors who began writing before a âlikeâ button was extant donât really find a number beside a heart to provide any sense that people are reading and enjoying their work. Using words is always superior to pressing buttons to simply make a number go up. This isnât a product, this is a community and usually people post fanfiction as a bid for connection with other fans. Otherwise, there would be no reason to share it at all.
- Fanfiction is a gift that is shared, not a product that is sold. You are paying nothing for this, it is free; the author has no obligation to post it either, it is a privilege that it was shared with you. I am explaining this because what this means is that reviews are not reviews for a product; you do not say negative things when someone gives you a gift, that is unkind and rude. Donât be mean.
- Saying you liked it is good; saying WHY you liked it is better. Why did you like the story/chapter? What part was your favourite? Did you like the way the author wrote a character? Did you like a particular sentence or line of dialogue? Tell the author these things. What are you telling your friends when you recommend the fic? Why not also tell the author those things, we would love to hear them.
- Remember that author is a human being; would you say it to a strangerâs face if they were in front of you and you were being witnessed and filmed? Consider your words and their impact on someone you do not know personally.
- If someone shares smut, and it arouses you, thatâs greatâit is not good to tell the author that outright. If you say you enjoyed a fic and the fic was a smutfic, it is understood that you mean it aroused you or otherwise contributed toward orgasm for you, you donât need to say that it did outright. This is a piece of etiquette that helps balance the boundary of âdonât talk about your sexual feelings with a strangerâ and âposting fic is a bid for community connectionâ. I personally find âhotâ to be an acceptably âcasual politeâ descriptor that implies that a reader liked my fic, without overstepping personal boundaries.
- Emojis are fine! Emojis are useful! In fact, you can be much more explicit with your emoji reaction than your verbal one, with smut, because emojis are open to interpretation by the one reading them. It is still helpful to not only leave emojis, but to use them as punctuation or enhancements to your words. Authors are creatures of words, so words mean the most to us.
- It is unconscionably rude to ask the author to write you things, and this includes asking them to alter the story to your request. What is posted up is not the whole story, there is probably a great deal the author has already written but is not ready to post for whatever reason. And remember, the author gains nothing by posting the fic. You are the one in debt, not the author, if you must view the world in terms of debt and who owes whom what. Do not ask for things to be changed to suit your individual desires.
- We canât tell what tone youâre using because this is text. Yes even with âtone indicatorsâ. While a friend may know what you mean when you say âOh this is so filthyâ or âwhatâs wrong with me I love this lolâ, a stranger doesnât. A stranger will not know what tone you mean that, and remember the Fiona Principle: anything negative or ashamed you say about yourself is also something you are saying about people who share that trait or desire. Remember how harmful self-deprecation and shame can be to everyone around you, even when you think you are using a playful tone. Tone is not conveyed with text, and words have multiple meanings; make sure you understand what you actually want to say.
- When in doubt, be formal rather than informal. The author is not someone in your friends group.
- You are allowed to reply to other peopleâs comments! The comments are a community space, feel free to discuss the story with other readers; know, however, that the author can see that conversation, because the author is part of the community.
- We can see what you write in your AO3 bookmark notes, even if the bookmark is private.
- ASSUME makes an ASS out of U to ME. Do not assume what or who someone is based on their kinks, characters, or tropes. For example I have had many, many people assume they know what gender I am after reading my stories, and make comments both to my face in comments and where they think I canât see in their AO3 bookmark notes. This is incredibly rude and dehumanising, donât fucking do this. I have had people state with astonishing confidence that I am every gender under the sun but my own, and this is especially rude when the author has stated what theyâre writing is autobiographical. Yes, this has happened to me. Multiple times. Just because you and the author share a gender and the author had a different experience with their gender than you does not mean they are wrong or âfakingâ. Writing particular kinks does not mean they are âan eggâ, and a cute emoji does not erase that you decided something about another human being you donât even know.
- Posting smut is not an invitation for people to proposition the author, nor is it advertisement for the author wanting a sexual relationship with anyone. This would not be appropriate with any performer or sex worker and it is not appropriate with an author either.
- Time does not matter, this is an archive. It does not matter when a fic was posted, it is always nice to get a new review on it. You are not ânecro-ingâ or âcreepingâ if you review a fic that is weeks, months, years, or even decades old.
- Repetition doesnât matter either. Did you read a fic you already reviewed? Review it again! Thereâs no rule that says you canât and in fact seeing repeat readers is a joy many authors donât realise we have until that reader says something.
And above all, remember: if you want more fic, it is critical you encourage authors. The whole point of posting fic publicly is connection. The connection with other fans is the reward/payment for the labour of writing and the vulnerability of sharing it. If there is no connection then how are we to keep feeling there's a point to sharing our fic with anyone but ourselves?