In reality, probably not many of them. If any. The modern narrative of whoâs poaching and where animal parts end up is very much entrenched in the pulp novels of the 20s and 30s. Most people think of poachers as either a Percival McLeach/Negaverse Steve Irwin/old white guy with a mustache⊠or as a poor African. But the realityâs a lot more complex and the mediaâs bad at picking up on it for a lot of reasons- largely because people hate nuance and donât understand the difference between illegal poaching (always bad) and legal, regulated trophy hunting (complicated. sometimes bad. sometimes good. depends on the situation, the reality of where conservation dollars are coming from, and whether or not you believe one animal can or cannot be sacrificed for the good of the species.)
So hereâs the thing about rhino hunting: itâs perfectly legal IF you have the permits. Itâs just expensive. You have to get the permit to hunt and the permit to import back to your home country. Rhinos selected for hunting are old, post-reproductive bulls. Theyâre not really genetically valuable anymore, and having the ability to sell hunting rights encourages African landowners to keep rhinos on their land. Trophy hunts arenât figured into the poaching numbers⊠at all. When they say that poaching has gone up or down, they are not including trophy hunting because those numbers are totalled separately. Trophy hunters have to buy permits, and this is not a financial problem for them. While itâs not completely unheard of (thereâs one guy in particular, a South African big game rancher/hunter named Dawie Groenenwald, who did bring in twelve Americans to trophy hunt on his land- read more about that here: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2016/10/dark-world-of-the-rhino-horn-trade/), thatâs not where the real money is. Iâm certainly not saying that all trophy hunting is legitimate or even if any of itâs a good idea. What Iâm saying is that itâs irrelevant to the poaching numbers.
The people killing these rhinos arenât taking them as trophies.
Theyâre selling the horns in Vietnam.
Other Asian countries too, mostly China and anywhere thatâs had significant sinicization, but Vietnamâs burgeoning economy and the meteoric rise of an emergent upper-middle business class has meant that itâs where all that rhino horn is going. Itâs a status symbol, a way to curry favor with business higher ups (Source: http://www.poachingfacts.com/faces-of-the-poachers/buyers-of-rhino-horn/). This isnât even a secret. The people who traffic rhino horn say openly where it goes (Source: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2016/10/dark-world-of-the-rhino-horn-trade/). They talk about how it gets there, and who does the killing. Itâs an enormous industry and immensely valuable. TRAFFIC has been working on this for over a decade now, figuring out whoâs killing the rhinos and where the horns are going. Nine years ago, the first big report from TRAFFIC came out on the trade from the African rhino-having countries to Asia. Hereâs the link to that: http://awsassets.panda.org/downloads/trafficrhinoreportsummary.pdf
Nat Geo did the numbers again in 2015, in that article I linked above. Things havenât changed much since then.
The reason poaching went down during covid isnât that the actual hunters werenât allowed to travel. (Besides, do you really think that if it was rich white dudes doing the majority of the poaching, it would have slowed down or stopped? Money, dear boy, can get you pretty much anything you want. A chartered flight to Kenya, a private home to stay in⊠a rhino permit or twoâŠ) Rather, the middleman dried up. Itâs only profitable to kill a rhino if you can move the parts, and if your middleman isnât traveling between the rhino countries and the Asian market, wellâŠ
And you can probably guess who the middlemen are. Often theyâre students. Frequently theyâre workers. And until recently, they were mostly Vietnamese or Chinese nationals. Now, TRAFFIC notes that many rhino horn syndicates are using white South Africans due to heightened suspicion. (Source: http://english.vietnamnet.vn/fms/environment/125451/profiling-ups-risk-for-asian-rhino-horn-mules.html)
And normally, there actually is a lot of traffic between China and Vietnam and the rhino countries. I donât know if people here are quite aware of the relationship between China and several African countries- particularly Kenya, but thereâs been a lot of Asian investment into Africa. In Kenya, you see a lot of Chinese workers coming in, working on development projects, and then going back to China. Something like 20% of African infrastructure projects are funded by China; one out of every three is built by Chinese firms. (source: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-07-19/china-s-belt-and-road-leaves-kenya-with-a-railroad-to-nowhere). Most of the part-time labor is local (source: http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/801581468195561492/pdf/WPS7614.pdf), but not all of it- and the full time labor, while mostly local, is roughly 22% Chinese citizens. There were well over 150,000 Chinese workers in Africa before the pandemic (source: http://www.sais-cari.org/data-chinese-workers-in-africa). You also saw a lot of Vietnamese workers⊠before the pandemic. Both China and Vietnam called their citizens home pretty quickly. Vietnam in particular. By July 2020, arrangements for most Vietnamese workers in Africa had come through after a good deal of public outcry, and they were back in Vietnam (source: https://saigoneer.com/vietnam-news/19011-stuck-in-guinea-equatorial,-vietnamese-workers-forced-to-work-despite-rampant-covid-19-cases).
No middlemen, no profit. No profit, no poaching. Itâs not a triumphant story of white trophy hunters butting out of a place they donât belong; itâs a much more complicated story of economic oppression of native Kenyans, South Africans, and citizens of other rhino countries and exported Vietnamese and Chinese workers.
Poaching isnât what it used to be. Itâs gotten a lot more complex, and reducing it to something that hasnât been true since the 1950s-1970s means that we ignore the real problems and direct our energy into something that isnât happening. Itâs like⊠how when a corporation tells you to take personal responsibility for climate change. This isnât a single person sneering and shooting a rhino. This is an entire industry that CITES and other NGOs are trying hard to grapple with. The nature of the beast has fundamentally changed. I get that itâs really easy to blame Europe and America for the shit thatâs been done to subsaharan Africaâs natural resources. Itâs right, too, but⊠the story of people attempting to extract resources from the continent isnât over. Ignoring that the market for rhino horn isnât the trophy industry just makes it easier for that particular black market to go unchecked.
Additional sources and information:
https://www.savetherhino.org/what-we-do/reducing-illegal-trade/
https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/06/rich-men-rhino-horns/529455/
https://www.savetherhino.org/thorny-issues/trophy-hunting-and-sustainable-use-rhinos/
http://www.poachingfacts.com/poaching-statistics/rhino-poaching-statistics/
https://www.fws.gov/international/permits/black-rhino-import-permit.html- this oughta give you an idea on what a US import permit entails. If you have the money and time, itâs⊠really not that hard to hunt a rhino.