âfolkloreâ; a review of the new album by Taylor Swift
Taylor Swiftâs eighth studio album showed the world that she is, indeed, this generationâs number one songwriter. folklore is sixteen tracks long, a whimsical album that seems to be what long-time fans have been hoping for since Speak Now, almost what Red tried to be â and it is, indeed, âsad, beautiful, tragicâ. The singer tries on different stories and narratives, a piecemeal exploration of young love, its wildness and fragility, and the pain of its loss, and the perspective that thirty years would give you. folklore sees Swift hopping on the lower-case trend, in which musicians seem to be contributing to the widespread rejection of the capital letter, seen most evidently in tweets and Instagram captions. Capital letter or not, folklore demands lyrical attention and investigative detail. With a 9.6 user rating on Metacritic, folklore has undoubtedly captured all our imaginations, longings and regrets, and wrapped it into a sparkling, Swift-like masterpiece of an album.Â
A softer start to Swiftâs eight studio album, in comparison to previous projects, which initially teases a return to the songwriterâs roots and an exploration of her younger days, back when her songwriting was accompanied by steel-string guitars and a country twang. the 1 begins with tentative piano leading into a snappy beat, a similar minimalistic loop to I Forgot You Existed, the leading track from 2019â˛s Lover album, although lyrically a complete contrast, and seemingly more authentic piece. Swiftâs resigned self-awareness (âin my defence I have none / for never leaving well enough aloneâ), which was previously entangled in preppy vocals and marching-band drum beats on ME! (âI never leave well enough aloneâ), is finally given space to breathe.
The wistfulness invoked in the 1 (âwe were something donât you think so?â âand if my wishes came true / it would have been youâ) sets the stage for upcoming tracks, such as cardigan, august, and illicit affairs, whilst also showing an acute awareness of modern day love, as her love "meet[s] a woman on the Internet and take[s] her homeâ. Once again, airy, higher-range vocals lift the track into the bridge, brushing past the sadness of her sentimental âwhat ifâ questioning.
cardigan was the most obvious choice for the first single, as the most pop song on the album, with piano overlaying a pleasant beat and shimmering synths. Unlike with her previous single choices, cardigan does not sacrifice her storytelling in the least, and is very much deserving of the music video it was given, and even the new cardigan delivered to celebritiesâ addresses and now available to buy as merchandise (stars and all).Â
In only the second track of the album, the listener is sure she is in for the long haul (âtried to change the ending / Peter losing Wendyâ), as Swift captures that discarded, found-again feeling in her classic storytellerâs way. The songwriter shows an acute understanding of how a relationship ends (âI knew Iâd curse you for the longest time / chasing shadows in the grocery lineâ) and how it feels to watch your lover âleaving like a father / running like waterâ. But still, she retains her hopeful âI knew youâd come back to meâ, just as she did when she was seventeen.
the last great american dynasty:
The most upbeat track on folklore, and yet a true storytelling masterpiece â proof that Swift no longer needs to sacrifice her songwriting talent for pleasant-but-shallow lead singles. the last great american dynasty tells the story of American socialite (or âmiddle-class divorcĂŠeâ) Rebekah Harkness, the woman who owned Swiftâs Rhode Island âHoliday Houseâ before she bought it in 2013. If you havenât already, I suggest you Google Harknessâ story, a fascinating tale, to find out more about her âBitch Pack friendsâ and the time she dyed a dog âkey lime green.âÂ
Swiftâs wry smile can be heard in the line âblew through the money on the boysâ, and you can practically hear the gleam in her eyes as she triumphantly sings âI had a marvellous time ruining everythingâ, but even more significantly are the subtle suggestions of the misogyny that tainted Harknessâ (and her own) reputation (âthe maddest woman / the most shameless woman / the loudest womanâ), frustrations that are articulated more clearly (and a little more darkly) on mad woman.
Immediately, track four is reminiscent of The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody) from her much-loved Red album, with the same beautiful contrast between the low, husky male voice, and Taylorâs warm, sweet tones. The steady piano tones provide support to a back and forth conversation, that moulds its shape at the end, displaying what Grammy award-winning producer Finneas OâConnell stated were his âfavourite lyrics of the yearâ in a tweet. exile has quickly become a fan favourite, and one of her most streamed songs on Spotify.
Instantly drawn in by a hauntingly beautiful vocal loop, my tears ricochet is the much-welcomed return of Jack Antonoff, with his familiar 80s synth charm and unique ability to build a song exactly as its read (Iâm thinking here of The Archer from the Lover album.)
Of course, the synth-ballad is the continuation of her long-time Track 5 trend, on which she purposely chooses often jarringly vulnerable tracks â think Dear John (Speak Now), The Archer (Lover), All You Had To Do Was Stay (with heartbreaking lyrics masked by an upbeat pop melody, in true 1989Â fashion) and Delicate (reputation).Â
my tears ricochet seems to be the folklore vocal experimentation that This Love was to 1989, with harmonies sung through a vocoder as often used on reputation â sonically, it seems to be a nod to her previous pop albums, whilst lyrically combining the skill of Speak Now and the muse of reputation (âand when you canât sleep at night / you hear my stolen lullabiesâ referring to her masters being sold to Scooter Braun.)Â
If we unpack the lyrics a little more, we can hear references to the Look What You Made Me Do music video â âyou wear the same jewels / that I gave you / as you bury meâ (in the music she can be seen not only lying in her own grave, but in a bathtub filled with very expensive-looking diamonds.)
The ending is particularly Antonoff-esque, with bright backing vocals and an urgent, pulsing bass, lifting and moving the song along.Â
mirrorball, to me, is exactly the sound of young love, swaying on a dance floor under a disco ball, navy and blue and pretty silver spinning from the ceiling. Swiftâs bright vocals, repeating âhushâ, âshiningâ for her love, lifts the moody twangs underneath, typical of American rock band The National (whose Aaron Dessner produced many of the tracks on folklore, including mirrorball).Â
This song is rife with tactile fragility and shattered-glass delicacy, and it really is on its âtallest tiptoesâ, in its âhighest heelsâ. Swift conjures in the listener the pain of walking the âtightropeâ, changing âeverything .. to fit inâ, as she frustratedly claims sheâs ânever been a natural / all I do is try, try tryâ, something that no doubt brings her closer to her millions of listeners. How can the obviously talented songwriter, of all people, feel like us everyday, ordinary folks? But clearly, insecurity and expectation are a burden on all of our shoulders.
mirrorball has quickly become one of my favourite tracks on the album (and possibly of all time), and probably because of its tentative relationship with one of my favourite tracks from her previous album, The Archer (also produced by musical mastermind Jack Antonoff). âIâm still trying everything to keep you looking at meâ, âIâm a mirrorball / Iâll show you every version of yourself tonightâ, speaks unequivocally to The Archerâs âthey see right through me / can you see right through me?â and âthey see right through me / I see right through meâ, and the pleading âhelp me hold on to youâ.Â
Upon first hearing seven, the first thing I was reminded of was Swiftâs Itâs Nice To Have A Friend, co-written with her long-time friend Selena Gomez for her seventh studio album, Lover, with its minimalistic, bubbly synth sounds that remind me of a creek in the forests of a childhood free from judgement and scorn. Taylorâs sweet vocals and harmonies certainly endeavour to take the listener back to âsweet tea in the summerâ, invoking nostalgia for the times we could âscream ferociously / any time [we] wantedâ. The piano- and string- heavy orchestration brings to mind the work of Lana Del Rey.Â
Once again we can feel Antonoff inexplicably all over this track, in the emotion and urgency, ever-present in the beat and the lift of the chorus â Swift and Antonoff prove once again to be a nostalgia-ridden, remarkable force of music, contemplating a long-lost love (âAugust slipped away into a moment in time / cause it was never mineâ.) Urgency and desperation and longing are muddled through the bridge, messy and gleaming, living âfor the hope of it allâ, taking us all "back when we were changing for the better.â august seems to be folkloreâs more whimsical, perspective-elevated older sibling to Getaway Car (reputation) and Cruel Summer (Lover), riddled with the same rhythmic urgency and pressing romantic declarations.
As always, multiple layers can be read into Taylorâs lyrics, but whatever the interpretation, the soft droning synths and heartfelt strings really tug at the heartstrings. this is me trying is glowing with the fear of growing up and growing old, of slipping away from childhood hopefulness and having a âhard time adjustingâ to a harsher, darker world. Just like Taylor, weâve all been there, struggling understand how we fit in to the larger picture, and for many of us, its not the easy journey we are taught, through plastic Hollywood movies and shallow, romanticised novels. (âthey told me all of my cages were mental / so I got wasted like all my potentialâ, and âfell behind all my classmates and I ended up hereâ)
Swift possibly hints at an experience in therapy, or at least that may be one interpretation â âpouring out my heart to a stranger / but I didnât pour the whiskeyâ, the track itself a beacon for those struggling with their mental health, but trying despite of the challenges they face. (âI just wanted you to know / that this is me tryingâ)
Again, this is me trying is littered with reputation-like references; âI had the shiniest wheels, now theyâre rustingâ âthey told me all of my cages were mentalâ. on King Of My Heart, Taylor sings of a âgold cage, but you painted me goldenâ, an image which is recreated in the symbolic Look What You Made Me Do music video. However, sonically, the wide, reverberating vocals and booming lower range seem like a sequel to The Archer (âand my words shoot to kill when Iâm madâ), both of which were notably produced by Jack Antonoff and, in my opinion, some of the pairâs best work.
illicit affairs is the song I have been struggling to get out of my head since its release, with its soft acoustic guitar and heartbreaking narrative. It sees Swift stepping into the shoes of the âother womanâ, a significant growth from questionable Better Than Revenge on Speak Now, in which she berates a woman for stealing a man. Eleven years older, and wiser, Swift shows the grey shades of morality and love affairs, channelling Death By A Thousand Cuts as she croons that her affair died âa million little timesâ. And only she can fit âclandestine meetingsâ into a sentence with wide-eyed sincerity â on anybody else, it would sound clumsyÂ
Here we are back to folky guitar plucking and childhood reminiscence, all wrapped up with a delightful attention to detail, mapping out the journey of her âinvisible stringâ, âa single thread of goldâ, with details of boyfriend Joe Alwynâs teenage job at a yoghurt shop, and their three-year anniversary trip to the lakes, alongside a reference to a âdive barâ we have heard on the reputation album (and seen in the Delicate music video).Â
Swiftâs sweet voice hovers lightly over backing track, and once again displays her own emotional growth and maturity, as she lets go of the âaxeâ of failed love, admitting wryly that ânow [she sends her exâs] babies presents.âÂ
Probably the most comforting lyric of all is that âhell was the journey but it brought me heavenâ; despite her years in âexileâ, she really did find her place.
Taylorâs voice hovers ominously over the piano, all too familiar, as we have indeed seen Taylorâs scorpion sting all over reputation. mad woman perfectly tells every womanâs experience with gaslighting in a more contemplative sequel to The Man. (âand you poke that bear til the claws come out / and you find something to wrap your news aroundâ)
Perhaps most perceptively (and least talked about), the singer/songwriter points out our internalised misogyny, as she laments that âwomen like hunting witches too / doing your dirtiest work for youâ, and yet she still manages to show a sense of comradeship, an understanding between two women on opposite sides (âgood wives always know / she should be mad, sheâll be scathing like me / but no one likes a mad womanâ).
Taylor, no doubt knowingly, chose ephiphany, the albums most shimmering track, to be crowned the thirteenth, a number she has a close affinity with. Her simple but mesmerising vocal captures all the tragedy of timelessness grief, a glimmering contemplation of the sadness and confusion in the world, with a nod to both her grandfatherâs experience of the Second World War and the current Covid-19 pandemic. With the lines âyou dream of some epiphany / just one single glimpse of relief / to make some sense of what you've seenâ, Swift explores inability to process pain, the need for relief and the fragile solidarity that can be found amongst humans sharing the same experience; âwith you I serve / with you I fall downâ. The outro, lead by a grieving violin, gives the listener some of this processing time, before moving onto the next, more upbeat track.Â
This is storytelling through song that truly marks her as the best songwriter of our generation, and certainly a highlight in her career of well-written and thoughtful songs, with fans calling for betty to become a whole novel and a refreshing perspective, for a woman to take on 'Jamesââ persona. The characters themselves appear to have been named after Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds children (Inez and James), with speculation that Betty will be the name of their third child, expected later this year. However, if we refer to the Track 3, the last great american dynasty, its star, Rebekah Harkness, was also known as Betty, so that may be who Taylor is referencing here.
The brash harmonica and steel strings add some grit the instrumental, a nod to her country roots, as the storyline exuberates Swift-style romanticism and whimsicality. A flourishing and triumphant key change reminiscent of the songwriterâs first international country-pop hit, Love Story, excitedly tips the reader from lyrical appreciation to hopeless adoration, as we all step into Jamesâ shoes alongside her, with movie-scene flashes and teenage melodrama muddying our emotions. Really, a storytelling masterpiece.
folkloreâs penultimate track features a one-note synth, providing the track with an urgent stability, and a soft, melodic guitar which, with Swiftâs vocals floating above, carries the song through. The production is exquisite in its simplicity. This song again returns to the insecurity of growing up with its opening line âour coming of age has come and goneâ, followed soon by âI never had courage in my convictions.â Swift displays her lyrical skill at twisting words and making pertinent culture references, with âthe devilâs in the details / but youâve got a friend in meâ.
peace shows the same self-awareness on Lover, the hook, âno I could never give you peaceâ, an echoed fear of her âreputationâ which Swift has expressed more openly in recent years, through tracks such as Delicate (from reputation), The Archer (Lover), and now, with folklore, mirrorball and peace.Â
hoax is by far the darkest track on the album, a lonely ending to a story brimming with nostalgia, longing, and a kind of rusted hopefulness. Desolation seeps from every lyric; âstood on the cliffside screaming, "give me a reason" / your faithless love's the only hoax I believe inâ, speaks of a woman worn down and âcome undoneâ following an obviously toxic relationship, and with her we are far from the young woman who once sang âIâve got that good girl faith and a tight little skirtâ on Style, the third track of her first thorough venture into pop 1989, whose release seems decades ago now.
A stripped, vulnerable track also closed the reputation album, but this time it is burdened with hopeless futility (âdonât want no other shade of blue, but you / no other sadness in the world would doâ), rather than a quiet profession of love and simple happiness.