I say, “I wish she were dead.”
It’s not what I want to say. Not even close. It’s blasphemy; I stopped believing in God years ago, when things first started to hurt, but it’s sinning against her all the same. Or, more accurately, it’s too close. There is too much of what I want to say in between those five words. To want her to die is too much; it is terrible, terrifying, to want a graveside to mourn beside. And I don’t want that. Not really. But I do.
I wish she were dead. I don’t want her to die. Both the one wish. Two sides of the same truth.
I can stand it sometimes, for days at a time. There are always things to laugh at, things to smile about. Her joy at ordinary things. Her laughter at that one old joke. Her eagerness to please. Her innocence, childlike despite her fragile frame and all she’s done. All those years built up behind her. The monolith of her life, crumbling.
And then it is too much. The furrow in her brow when she tries to think of a name that matches the face before her, the face she’s seen a thousand times, the face she’s loved. The longing for old photographs and the despondency once they’re in her hands, her fingertips resting atop the film of dust, desperate not to disturb it; if the photograph is somehow obscured, there is a reason for not knowing. There is an excuse. The panic she feels at her own, unfamiliar heartbeat. The blood in her veins is an unknown. Her skin is alien.
And it is then that I want her to die. I am tired of mourning. I have mourned for years, clutching at her, trying to hold firm as she runs through my fingers like water. Her whole being is a cemetery. Each memory is a gravestone. Her thoughts are bodies, decaying. Skeletal. Then dust. There is nothing living there. She has had death in her for a decade.
Only, she lives, doesn’t she? She lives and she laughs and she loves the things she remembers how to love, and we love her back, fiercely, as though our fearsome love can claw her back from the underworld, can bridge those spaces in her brain and pull her back to us. We can’t, of course. She isn’t hiding in those spaces; she hasn’t fallen to the bottom of some pit or abyss in her mind. She has been consumed by them. Turned inside out. The abyss is her mind.
And of course I don’t want her to die. I don’t want to bury any more of her. I am tired of the burden of heaping sand. I am tired of grieving. I’m sick with it. Every day is a funeral of sorts. Every conversation is a eulogy. She hums half-remembered hymns in her chair, songs from her childhood without words. We sweep up the ashes she leaves in her wake. And we mourn until our throats are hoarse.
I am terrified that she will hollow herself out and we will have nothing left to bury.
This is what I want: to mourn perfectly, all at once, and for all of her. To put an end to this piecemeal sorrow. Not to lose her years before she’s gone. To say this who she was, this is who we’ve lost. To remember her as she was, when she still remembered us. Not to have exhausted my grief before the end of her life. To have something, somebody left to lament. For her to die alongside her body, and not before it.