hey quick question uhhhh did Tolkien ever mention whether or not the animals of Elves live longer than the animals of Men or not?
Cause assuming they don't, and horses and dogs and cats live relatively the same across Middle Earth regardless of who is caring or them, then literally why the FUCK are we assuming Elves have had their first "Short-lifespan trauma" when they meet a human and then experience first hand that human's short lifespan when they've been having to deal with their beloved pets dying off every 10-30 years or so since forever???
alternatively if elven horses and dogs and etc do live longer than those of men, I can imagine certain breeding practices among the human civilizations to elongate the lifespan of their animals 🤔 like, what if certain breeds just live longer because they've been cross bred with the elven variety over time
idk does anyone have any sage knowledge to share with the class

















