[Why Donna? Fittingly enough, it's a long story. I started out RPing because of my best friends was into it, and he introduced me to his RP friends, including the author of the thoroughly excellent Goddess Correspondence, who had a lot of fun interactions with people on Tumblr in-character as Lydia and Elana. Lydia basically took over my main blog for about a week. I wanted to make a post in character as a cosmic being explaining what happening, and I went with Donna. I decided it would be fun if I started a similar project myself, and that's how this tumblr started.
So what drew me to this character? Well, first of all, I like working with characters/ideas that are challenging and weird and hard to pull off. Untangling Donna's infamously convoluted history and figuring out what it was like for her to experience it (including the "sum of all her pre-Crisis selves" retcon and her role as multiversal historian, which were revealed in the leadup to Infinite Crisis and then pretty much ignored), definitely falls under that.
She also lies at the intersection of lots of things that interest me--parallel universes, cosmology, the Titans, the Wonder family, and continuity. I am a Medieval lit major, so I like tracking really complex history. The great thing about Donna is that she allows me to look at the weirdest, most cosmic elements in the DCU from a relatable, human perspective.
And that perspective is what I really came to appreciate when I roleplayed the character more. I wound up RPing in another context for a while--which is part of why I was away for so long--and I got involved in a ton of pointless drama both IC and OOC. I wound up making Donna my main character instead of the one I originally created for there, which turned out to be very helpful. I have a tendency to overwhelm people and try too hard to take control of the situation. Donna is much better at just listening to people and being attentive than I am. She can handle the most painful, convoluted and just plain weird situations with compassion and grace.Ā It's hard to write a character like that and make them interesting. It's easy to dismiss Donna as boring or too perfect. That's another challenge I appreciate.
Of course, I'm not 100% happy with the way I've been doing things. I meant this Donna to be part of a specific story, which I'm still working on. I wanted to take this character, who's been mainly important as part of other peoples' stories, and find what her own story would be. I'm still working on that story and I'm pretty happy with how it's going, but I don't want to be limited by this status quo. It's very interesting and I've had fun exploring it, but it's also very limiting--not just in terms of what she can and can't do, but in terms of being what John Seavey called a "false status quo," a storyline that has to be inevitably resolved one way or another, leading to frustration when it's dragged out. I have a definite end point for Donna's storyline, but there might be other ones. As I get to interact with more people, I also mean to start more AU threads that aren't connected to it at all. (After all, Donna has always been entangled with continuity problems, and she even originated as a continuity error.) That's why I changed the name of this tumblr that's not connected to that specific context. And even within that context, I figure that now that she's settled in, she'd want to go with a name that's hopeful and affirmative.
Obviously, it's a reference to "Who is Donna Troy"--the title of one of her definitive stories, and a question that keeps coming up again and again in her history, as her backstory got repeatedly retconned. But another part of the reason her identity is so hard to figure out is that she's so thoroughly connected to other characters that it's hard to figure out what her own niche is. But I guess that's what that is--being one of hte central nodes in the dense web of interconnections that defines the DCU. In many ways, she embodies a lot of what us longtime fans love about the DCU--the connections, the history, the warmth and humanity and hope that seems desperately missing from what it's become. I think she's a great character and she deserves to be remembered.]