And the tags: #shane literally an asian man in the whitest fucking sport like. yeah shane has never been hurt by hockey shane doesnt lnow anything hes dumb
I'm sorry, but I am going to disagree with you here. Shane is portrayed in the book and the show as "not really thinking about stuff like that" and I think that is a very common reaction to being racialised when all you want to do is play your game.
I live in the Czech Republic, which, wonderful as it is in so many ways, is in the running for the whitest country on earth. My close friend is Saudi, and his name is Mohammed. He could not find a place to live for months because no one would rent a flat to him. Because he's Saudi, and his name is Mohammed and so many Czechs have a serious case of ignorant white fright. He is regularly subjected to intense racism, but every time anyone points it out to him, he says: I don't think about things like that. He denies it happens to both himself and when others tell him it's happening. And, he's a nice person, so he tries to explain it away and see the best in people. So, to recap, he is literally an Arab man in the whitest country on earth, and he regularly refuses to accept that anything untoward has happened, or to pay any attention to the darker side of this country.
I think this is a common experience of the people who are not terminally online discussing racism, and is very realistic for an autistic, high-performance athlete character who is single-mindedly focused on being the best hockey player in the world. Shane spends A LOT of time narrowing his focus down to Hockey, maximizing his performance, and Ilya. This other shit canonically does not occupy his mind that much. Now, maybe this is a trauma response, but if it were, SHANE WOULD NOT KNOW IT. That's how trauma responses work. And, Ilya would not know it either. They are, at this point, a couple of sweet 20-something hockey boys who are not enmeshed in social justice discourse, and if Rachel had written them as if they were, it would not have been better.
I'm not saying Rachel Reid is beyond criticism, but an mlm hockey romance novel is a very different genre than a tumblr social justice post. I think she does a good job of writing characters you have to think about, and whose thoughts about themselves give you, the reader, space to have your own thoughts about them. She obviously loves Shane because she writes him so sympathetically, but he's not perfect! Neither of them is. They are both so right about some things, and so wrong about others. And, she does not write Shane as dumb at all, she just writes him as living in his brain less than Ilya does. Again, very realistic for an athlete.