i really like the way hotd s3 is currently developing rhaenyra's character and it just makes me love her more. like yes please keep morally complicating her, keep challenging the reactionary assumptions underlying her entire arc! bring out her entitledness, her recklessness, her hypocrisy! challenge the idea that she'd make a "good" ruler! challenge the idea of a victory made glorious by violence! and emma d'arcy is doing a phenomenal job, this season has solidified their rhaenyra as my personal favorite hotd performance. they got soooo much material to chew on and they absolutely devoured, that emmy better be theirs istg
on the flip side, you can tell that this season is afraid to be similarly as unflinching with alicent due to the audience reaction to her, and it makes her writing frustrating to me. there are still ghosts of a more complicated and engaging character, like when she says helaena might be her redemption or when she tries to pressure helaena to get an abortion. but there are other times when common sense just contorts itself to handhold the audience's lowest common denominator into sympathizing with her. im not a fan, imo it's cowardly writing that sacrifices quality for legibility
other impressions: criston cole's arc is really hitting it out of the park. daemon is fantastic, matt smith just oozes charisma and makes a great devil on rhaenyra's shoulder. despite everything, the show got me to think wow these two awful men are great and compelling characters. mysaria doesnt have as much of a central focus, but sonoya mizuno's little facial expressions in her relatively limited screen time absolutely deliver her humanity. i find myself wishing for more mysaria, more rhaesaria, their dynamic is just so good. i also find myself really liking rhaena. phoebe campbell has a bright future imo, they were able to perfectly embody her desperation, especially in s3e1, and that was able to make rhaena's arc land for me despite all my initial misgivings
I am really liking all of this above, and also alicents character (self proclaimed lover of her in all her forms)
I see the critique of her character and i can agree to alot of the points,
But when i see her this season, shes finally handling what it means to be without any powers ptotecting her. Maybe she is a foil to the creatures of her own faith(theory im working on) but she is just trying her best to protect the child, the daughter, she has left. Its not perfect, not the smartest, but most of the tools she has have been taken from her. I think her character is fractured because withoit thebtrapppings and her authority, she doesnt know whos she is. Its been fascinating to watch.










