I donât think anime vs western animation are as different as people claim due to the fact they have inspired and fed off each other for decades (theyâre friends!!), however I do think our environmental messages to kids are⊠significantly and interestingly different
whereas, say Ghibli films express a deep Shinto-based respect and reverence for nature:
fighting for it as a means of both self-preservation and expression of heroism revolving around justice
and a matter of other groups of humans (the government often) going up against the stalwart youth
This is contrasted to western animation which tends to be likeâŠ. hey! look at this funny bat! And pollution is an evil spirit you can fight like physicallyÂ
that isnât to say the west doesnât depict environmentalism as heroic and even involving collective action, Captain Planet is a good example of this
but individualism is still very present, the struggle is stalwart youths versus an individual or individual corporation, hell, sometimes you even get a sympathetic backstory for the corporation and weirdly cool rock song
to be clear, antagonists like Lady Eboshi in Princess Mononoke are sympathetic too, but it is⊠different, Lady Eboshi is trying to survive due to circumstances but it is all of Irontown that represents a system of corruption
In comparison, there is this western idea of corruption coming from individuals rather than systems as well as the fact they arenât trying to save nature because we are part of it, but because nature itself is a person and thus worthy of respect
In Fern Gully the fairyâs represent nature, the Lorax represents nature, Captain Planet is literally just nature, all things we can talk to and relate to, where in Princess Mononoke and Nausicaa the ultimate nature spirits are something you canât talk to and are frankly terrifying, awe-inspiring, and mighty
Western epistemology is heavily rooted in Christianity which says that man has dominion over fish of the sea, fowl of the air, and creatures of the land, ect, which leads to a utilitarian and separate view of natureâ what can it do for us as separate (higher) beings, and the only way to combat this view is to say âactually nature is a person and thus worthy of protectionâ
Whereas Japanese Shintoism has much more emphasis on the idea that we are all part of a whole with nature, nature is the ultimate divine with nothing more important than the other, and something worthy of protection not because we can understand it, but because we canât
âItâs a mistake to think about nature from the idea of efficiency, that forests should be preserved because they are essential to human beingsââ Hayao Miyazaki
this is not to completely bash western animation, it does have other strengths such as emphasizing childrenâs relationship to empathy, empathy toward others in âToy Storyâ and empathy toward themselves in âInside OutâÂ
However, our methods of conveying environmentalism could use some updating and steering away from âgoofyâ and ârelatableâ and maybe a little more terror and awe involved with fighting the good fight
