John Brown
Give me a character, and I’ll break their ass down:
1. How I feel about this character.2. All the people I ship romantically with this character.3. My non-romantic OTP for this character.4. My unpopular opinion about this character.5. One thing I wish would happen/had happened with this character in canon.
John Brown: 1. I find him to be quite mysterious and intriguing. I also feel his sense of humor might be the driest of all Black Butler characters, with the only possible exception being William’s.2. Historically, we could ship him with Queen Victoria; rumors spread that they hooked up after Albert died. She was said to have been buried with a photo of him in one hand, and that that same hand bears the wedding ring he gave her (it had once belonged to his mother). A bouquet of flowers was placed over that hand, shielding that photo and ring from the sight of those who viewed her open casket. In the manga I only pair her with her dearly departed Albert, so no “quality time” with the queen for our John Brown. Therefore, I have no romantic ship for him.3. I don’t know just how loyal he really is to the queen, but John is true besties with that favorite white horse of his.4. I think it’s super popular opinion that he could later be revealed as an angel. I’ve been giving some consideration lately, though, to the crack theory he’s not the original John Brown in her service. I don’t recall who suggested that to me (if the person who suggested it reads this, I hope they remind me), but it’s somewhat plausible. Historically, John Brown was an old, kind of scruffy Scottish dude who died in 1883, right? So how do we have this young-looking and kind of cute guy filling this role? Sure, we like our manga and anime filled with cute guys, but…? What if the original John Brown died in the manga, too, and he’s been replaced by this (possible angel) pretending to be him? What makes me consider it the more I think about it is that blasted “Windsor affair” hinted at by Vincent and Diedrich. Their discussion about that happens about a year or two before the attack on the Phantomhives, so 1883 or 1884. They could be talking about some weird event (potential scandal) that took place in 1883 involving Queen Victoria and (the original) John Brown. This isn’t so much an unpopular opinion as it is a relatively unexplored theory-in-the-making.5. I want a huge reveal that he’s an angel. Bring it on. I’ve been waiting for him and his horse to be the manga canon parallel to Ash/Angela and Pluto (but without the bestial fooling around) for so long now…. But seriously: 😇👱🏼➕🐴= 🚫…. 😅















