Every day I am confronted with a Wait That's Just Fanon??? event.
Today, it's that I would have sworn up and down that Tianlang-Jun getting imprisoned was on the basis he had kidnapped Su Xiyan, explaining her disappearance into the water prison at the hands of the Old Palace Master but. Nope. Book straight up says she disappeared and was presumed dead only after the battle.
#what?????#well that looks way worse for TLJ#gotta scrap all of aasb now
When I tell you that the urge to go edit some of RTM hit me like a truck last night, god.......
#but hang on. if SXY disappeared AFTER the battle then where was she DURING the battle????#girl they're killing your man! @parkersgeorg
Already imprisoned by the OPM, and then supposedly she disappeared after the battle, from the way Wu Chen tells it at first in the Zhao Hua Monastery scene:
As a deeply proud person, Benefactor Su couldn’t accept this, and she was even less willing to tolerate the dubious looks of outsiders. So the Old Palace Master brewed her a drug that was harmful to demons. After drinking it, she left Huan Hua Palace, and from then on, no one knew what became of her…
But the confusing part about her imprisonment is twofold: how long was she there, and how far along in her pregnancy was she already? Because the way it's framed, it gives a TINY window for OPM discovering their romance and then having TLJ sealed.
cutting for my usual yapping length:
the only way SXY's pregnancy makes sense if the OPM only discovered it as he "subjected her to torture" AND if she gave birth something like two-three weeks later is if she was in denial of pregnancy. (which is great, i love that it's a thing that can actually happen to people, the human body is wonderful and horrifying).
but even going with that, something that never made sense to me re: SXY taking poison and leaving the water prison is... why the hell did the OPM let her go?? it's canon that he wanted her as "his personal slab of meat" (SY's lovely expression for it) and he had just succeeded in sealing away TLJ and in claiming TLJ had killed her. so why would he just let her go? that doesn't make any sense!
My headcanon is that the OPM never intentionally released SXY fully out of his custody. When she took the poison, he let her out of the high-security Water Prison so she could get proper medical care for the poison and presumably abortion (because he didn't actually want her dead), but he still was keeping her under house arrest. But since house arrest didn't have as much security and SXY was very capable and had other allies within the sect, she was able to escape soon after being released from the Water Prison. (But this was never in the OPM's plans.)
And to make sense of the timeline...I'm sure somewhere in Airplane's wide world of kinks there's a pregnancy acceleration plant or artifact. Maybe she really wasn't very far along when she took the poison, but she realized she wouldn't last long enough to deliver the baby if she waited for the natural progression, so she purposefully grabbed the Pregnancy Accelerator. That could also be part of the explanation for why she was in such bad shape, if the Pregnancy Accelerator is tough on the body.
...but I still kinda like the fanon timeline and explanation better. We can ignore canon sometimes, as a treat. I would bet this wasn't something MXTX thought a lot about, she's on record saying she puts all her focus on the main couple when she writes.
ahaha i mean, a lot of svsss reads like it was thought up on the fly- both LQG and SQH, for instance, read like they were invented the moment they first appeared and not a second sooner- so i'm not demanding canon make sense, just wondering whether there's elements we missed. i like your theory a lot! yeah, if the OPM didn't realize SXY was pregnant until mid-torture, it'd make sense he would go "oh shit okay to the medical wing with you for your abortion" and then SXY, faced with no other choice, did drink the poison, then leapt out the window while he wasn't looking.
there's a universe where wu chen found her slightly later and kept baby binghe to raise him in zhao hua temple...
It's possible she didn't realise until she was further along so let's say she's near the end of her first trimester or even partly into her second. People have not know they were pregnant until then
Sometimes the baby grows slightly weird and the woman doesn't show for a long time.
So let's say that. Maybe she doesn't have a lot of symptoms due to being a cultivator.
She gets captured and tortured. Tianlang-Jun is tricked and imprisoned immediately but OPM keeps the threat of that as a way to control Su Xiyan as he tortures her. Her pregnancy becomes impossible to ignore and they fight back and forth and he finally claims when she is midway through her third trimester that Tianlang-Jun is going to be imprisoned and offers her a deal which she takes
But it's actually months later
Binghe is born but is a little premature. Viable and able to withstand the circumstances due to being half heavenly demon and the protagonist, but still not full term fully















