Tagging @aphantasias because I jumped on this and forgot to tag you earlier, sorry!
Oh, ouch that hurts. And I’m going to add something else, though it’s definitely not going to be worded as well, though I’ve been chewing over it for the last two weeks. (I may also be projecting a bit, because I know that I do this and it’s fucking exhausting.)
I think one of Ilya’s love languages is acts of service. Yes, he comes across as brash and arrogant, but he’s generous to a fault. He’s basically financing his brother’s family and he’s doing what he can for his sick father, despite their messy relationship. He’s Shane’s service top (I had to look up what that meant, and well, yeah, that fits). Basically, the man would give you the shirt off his back if you needed it. With a sarcastic quip, maybe, but he’s gotta keep up the facade. And everyone loves a villain.
But I think there’s another, sadder, side to it all. I think that this generosity is also a bid for connection. Not just with Shane, but with everyone. With his family. With his teammates. The hope that, if he does enough, if he gives enough, maybe someone might give a hint of a damn about him. Not love him. Not even really care about him. Just something.
But it’s not enough. It’s never enough. No matter what he does, however much he keeps giving, how hard he tries, it won’t ever be enough. All he hears are demands, orders, judgements, expectations. Nothing to tell him that someone might actually care. Not since his mama, and if she couldn’t love him enough to stay, then how can anyone else?
But he still does it. Because it’s all he has. It’s all he can do. And because he still, somehow, clings onto that tiny bit of hope that, if he does enough, if he gives enough, if he does well enough, maybe someone will say he’s worth it. Maybe he might just be good enough for someone. Maybe.
You can see the toll it’s taking by the time the Olympics come around - on top of Everything Fucking Else. (Personally, I think there’s an argument to be made that Ilya didn’t want to compete, all things considered, but that’s another can of worms) Basically, by now, he’s running on fumes. He’s barely got anything left and he knows it, even if he can’t let himself admit it. He’s getting it from all angles; from Shane trying to talk to him (in a very dangerous environment, holy shit!) to his father lambasting him for his team’s performance to, well, basically everyone having an opinion and expectation of him. Even Svetlana, when she talks about Boston winning the Cup that year, adds another obligation to his list, another expectation, another thing he has to give. Granted, she’s not intending it that way, but it’s yet more pressure on not very stable shoulders.
But then he does win. And he gets that beautiful moment where he’s glowing with joy. Where he did it. He made it. He’s so happy. But even that can’t last. How long before something gets in the way? How long before even more is put on him, before his father starts saying he can still do better, that it’s not enough? Before everyone demands he give more. After all, he did it once, he’s practically expected to do it again. To keep giving them more. That shit will start up pretty damn quick, before he’s even had chance to enjoy his success. But even if he does get time, even if he does get the credit he deserves, it’s not going to undo years of damage that’s already been done. It just Never. Fucking. Stops.
All of this to say…by the time Vegas rolls around, Ilya has had years of this and it’s reached the point where he has nothing left to give. He’s empty, he can’t muster up anything - effectively, he’s burned out.
But then, there’s Shane. And, God help him, Ilya can’t let there be nothing else. Not now, not after so long. He has to have something, one last effort. Just one last thing. He has to have one more thing to give. For Shane. Please.
And somehow, there is something. One tiny, dark piece of something, deep down. It’s all he has, but it’s there. It’s sharp. It’s cold. It’s detached and harsh. But it’s there. And he grabs onto it. Because he fucking has to.
But, again it’s not enough. He knows it’s not enough. It’s never enough. But it’s all he has left to give. It’s the only part of him that Shane wants, the only part he won’t reject, the only side of Ilya that he has any interest in. But it’s so cold, so harsh and full of sharp edges that it almost feels wrong. There has to be something else, but there isn’t. This is all he has left, and it’s nowhere near enough. It’s never going to be enough - Ilya is never going to be enough for Shane. He’s never going to be good enough. It breaks both of them a little.
And then the ‘tuna melt date’ happens and he realises there’s an opportunity. He wants to do it right, to give Shane more, like he deserves. But he’s still so conscious of who he has to be, that he can’t let any weakness show. He knows Shane doesn’t like that, knows he doesn’t want that. And he tries, he really tries, and it seems to be sort of working, until that phone call where his walls crack a little against his will, and he’s horrified, terrified, that Shane is going to hate what he sees - but then the First Names happen and, just for an instant, he lets himself wonder, lets himself hope that maybe…
But it’s only for that one second before Shane pulls away, before he runs away, just confirming to Ilya that Shane doesn’t want his vulnerable side, his weak and undesirable side - that Shane doesn’t want him.
(Jesus, someone get that boy a life raft, he’s fucking drowning.)
And then there’s the clusterfuck that is Rose and The Club and everything (reinforcing to Ilya that Shane doesn’t want him, that he’s not enough, that he can’t give him what he wants), but then they’re in a hotel room in Florida and Shane is coming out to him, and fuck, Ilya is not equipped for this. No one ever gave him the ‘what to do when someone comes out to you’ speech. All he has is sarcasm and being an asshole. But even then, he finds himself admitting that the last time, before it all went to shit, was nice, that it felt different, it felt better, while he’s tearing himself apart, knowing he can’t have what he wants so badly, knowing he’s not worth it. But he can’t help but open up a little, even though it’s letting Ilya out, exposing that part of him that Shane rejected, that he has no interest in, that he promised he would never let Shane be exposed to. Because that softness? Vulnerability? That’s undesirable. He can’t let himself be that. Shane doesn’t want that. Ilya knows he doesn’t want that, so he has to keep it locked away, even if it kills him. He has to give Shane what he really wants. Maybe he can’t do much, but he can at least give him that.
But…he can’t. And he can fucking feel himself starting to break apart and it’s so stupid and all he can say is ‘sorry’. Sorry, because this isn’t what Shane needs. Sorry, because he can’t keep it inside. Sorry, because he’s so worthless and pathetic he can’t give Shane what he wants - he can’t be who Shane wants.
Except that, suddenly, Shane is kissing him and pulling him close, holding him like he hasn’t been held in years. It feels safe and comforting and Ilya can feel himself breaking, piece by piece, and he knows he shouldn’t, knows he can’t take this when he has nothing to give in return, but he can’t stop himself. So he tells himself, okay, but just this once. Never again. He can’t do this again, he can’t be selfish like this, he can’t take from Shane like this, he doesn’t deserve it, he hasn’t earned it.
But Shane doesn’t let go. He doesn’t run. He keeps holding him, and then they’re together again and then Shane calls him Ilya again, only this time, it’s real. This time, he means it. And, somehow, in spite of everything, that tiny hint of hope he felt in Boston doesn’t seem as foolish now. Sure, their situation hasn’t changed, but maybe there is a chance. Maybe he doesn’t have to hide himself away now. Maybe Shane actually does like him. Maybe they don’t have to hate each other. Maybe they could…
(Okay, I’m done. Woah, that got away from me and I think I gave myself a concussion and lost some brain cells hitting my head against my desk trying to word this right, though it still feels like complete word salad! Oh well. TLDR: Ow.)