Every Charlie/Vox Parallel: Season 1 Episode 5 "Dad Beat Dad"
And we finally add Alastor into the mix! Honestly I could just sum up this part with this:
Who's been here since day one?/Who's been faithful as a nun?
Makes you chuckle with an old-timey pun? Your executive producer...
I'm truly honored that we've built such a bond
You're like the child (Partner) that I wish that I had
I care for you just like a daughter (pal) I spawned (found)
It's a little funny, you could almost call me Daaaadd(dy) :)
(look for Radiostatic's silhouettes in that last pic)
aka Alastor decides Lu and Val should lose their daddy privileges.
So we start off "Dad Beat Dad" with Charlie having a slight manic episode about her plan, which of course she's explaining in goofy drawings:
Charlie: Nope, no! Not really! Haha! I've been up all night trying to figure out why the hotel isn't working. [Crushes paper with hand] We've done trust falls. We've tried sharing our feelings. We only have a couple months left before the angels come- [Turns into demonic form and laughs maniacally before turning back to normal] And at this rate...
Much like a certain someone at the start of season 2:
Vox: But I think we can spin that. [He uses his powers and in his screens three hand-drawn images appear] I think we can use the hotel's reputation and Hell's renewed hope, and start a Hell-wide uprising against Heaven! With us at the top, hah?!
Valentino: Ugh, I know you won't believe this, but I don't understand.
In this narrative parallel set, Val and Vel both to some extent occupy Lu's position in Charlie's story in Vox's, though as this post points out the narrative parallels between Lu and Val are very rich and central and worth exploring beyond just that narrative spot.
Charlie describes her relationship with her dad at the start of this episode as complicated and distant:
Charlie: No, we just have never been close. After he and mom split, he never really wanted to see me. He calls... sometimes, but only if he's bored or like, needs me to do something.
Which may be how Vox feels his relationships with the Vees are:
Vox: Hello there, Velvette! How are you this hellish morning?
Velvette: Oh, cut the shit, Vox. I need you up here now!
Very likely Vox believes he and the Vees have never been deeply close - if they are seemingly not privy to his relationship with Al and he's reluctant to c all Val his 'partner', he probably has those walls up - and he might believe they only keep him around for when they're bored or need him to do something.
Now, Lu, Vel and Val actually do love Charlie and Vox. This is really obvious from everything we see. On V&C's side, this internal conviction that their families don't actually love them is probably partially from their own self-loathing. If the parallels pay off with Lilith in s3, it may be because both are damaged from feeling rejected by one parent/friend, and afraid to ever trust the love of the other, because it could go badly again.
On Lu & the Vees side, it's probable that they all have some trouble with really showing their fondness for V&C in tangible ways. For as much as Lu/the Vees do care for C&V, and will step in for them when it counts (1x08/2x08), they often struggle to really show it through tangible, day to day actions. Charlie: I need to speak to Heaven. Well, whoever's in charge up there, above Adam, above anybody. I need to go to the top.
Lucifer: Oh, no. No~ No, no, no, no, Charlie, no, no, no. That's, uh hah, no.
Charlie: [angrily] Look Dad, [normal] I don't ask you for much, I never have, but this, this is really important to me. It's the most important thing I've ever done. And I... need you. I need your help.
In a darker world, on the Vees side:
Vox: You read my mind. That's actually why I'm here. I may need to borrow Angel Dust for a bit. And before you say anything, just wait till you hear me out. The next part of my plan is gonna make the princess kill herself. (laughs)
Valentino: Our plan. Mine, and Velvette's, too. Or did you forget? (seethes) I'm not gonna wait in the wings again while you and Angel take center stage.
Vox: Oh, Val. Is that jealousy I hear? Come now, Val.
I think Alastor's verse in DBD - "I'm your guy, your DAY-TO-DAY" is important here in this narrative parallel. Alastor highlights how he's there for Charlie doing the gritty, day-to-day hard work of actually helping her, not just throwing grand gestures her way when things get dire ( That's how he frames it, anyway), which means a lot more to Charlie in the long run ("Dad, stop, he's protecting this hotel! How come he can have faith in me but my own father can't?) than things like 'champagne fountains' or 'caviar mountains'. And for Vox, who seems to do a lot of the gritty, day-to-day work of running the Vees like holding Overlord meetings or smoothing over Val's tantrums, the 'day-to-day' small sacrifices might mean a lot.
Both C&V choose to try and win over their families to their dreams by showing them all the cool things that could happen, rather than just telling them to go along with it:
Charlie: Please, just come see what I'm trying to do. You'll see why it's a really good idea. And Heaven is bound to agree if I get the chance to talk to them. Please, Dad.
Vox: ♪ Think of all your dreams that could come true ♪/Valentino: ♪ Even the wet ones? ♪/Vox: ♪ Yeah, those too! Imagine what it could enable! ♪/Velvette: ♪ For my label! ♪
In both cases, C&V have asked Lu and the Vees for help or interest in making their dreams come true. Lu & the Vees have basically said 'no' to being asked, so C&V probably don't feel terribly supported by them or like they believe in their goals. They have to persuade and win them over instead.
And of course this disconnect in both families is what Alastor worms his way into and tries to use as a means to undermine the familial bonds between each side:
In Charlie's case, he pours on the flattery:
Charlie: Okay! Okay, anyway. Dad, look at this lovely parlor where people can get to know each other and share secrets and stories and intimate feelings! Without Alastor, we wouldn't have been able to pretty it up this much.
Alastor: Charlie has a very unique vision. I am happy to fulfil her bizarre requests.
Charlie: Oh, thank you, Alastor.
In Vox's case he pours on the ragebait:
Alastor: Flocked by your partners. With their far more impressive contribution to your flashy little clown show. What really are you contributing besides... noise?
Vox: (laughing and stammering) Uh, I'm the face? The face of the revolution, where the fuck have you been?
Alastor: Yes, but still, if that's all...
Vox: You think they could've pulled this off without me? It's me who made this happen. I have the vision.
Alastor's motivations here are interesting, in that he's ostensibly just doing this in both cases to be a manipulative little shit. He's got bigger plans, and manipulating C&V into thinking he's the person they need to care about, instead of their loving families, is part of that. But on the other hand, there's definitely subtle clues that Al does actually care about C&V in his own Alastor way. I'm not sure I have receipts on this, but there I think is an interview/post where Viv confirms he's "already adopted" Charlie in his head, and we've all seen the way he looked at Vox before things fell apart. Charlie, as my most popular post pointed out, is a lot like Vox, (duh, the whole point of this analysis!) so Al seems to be drawn to this personality type.
💬 2 🔁 8 ❤️ 53 · Link So I've reposted this awesome post a few times, and it only recently occurred to me that hey, what exactly are the i
Al, as I suggested in analyzing this musical number, invokes Vox when he's thinking about family; he almost formed a familial bond with Vox, a friendship/found family, and then from his point of view, lost that when it turned out Vox was just using him (from his POV), wasn't as good as he thought, etc. And the same thing happens to him (from HIS POV, let me emphasize) in the S1 finale. He opens himself up to Charlie, another hyperactive disaster bi with crazy dreams, and letting himself "get accustomed" leads to him getting hurt. So in S2, he both rejects Charlie and the hotel, and goes to destroy Vox's found family (just for power, obviously, no subconscious emotional motivations there whatsoever, no sir). The ending of s2 hints he's decided to do the same thing to Charlie's family, as he looks at her and Vaggie before glaring at Lu.
So s2 and the Vees serve as a preview of what Al wants to do to the Morningstars. Break apart the family his begrudgingly favorite disaster bis have that isn't him.
Like I mentioned, Al opens his case with a reminder that he's always been around ("Who's been here since day one?" "Back then, you and I were as close to equals as I'd imagined down here" (Makes sure Val hears this). Then that he's been "faithful", makes them laugh, shared good times with them. He emphasizes his presence in C&V's lives while really highlighting Lu and the Vees absence.
This post actually hits on a lot of the nitty-gritty of how Al deliberately undermines Val and Vox's relationship specifically. There's similarities to the way he undermines Lu & Charlie's family bond in 'Hell's Greatest Dad'.
💬 2 🔁 27 ❤️ 115 · I will support jealous Alastor propoganda til I die.
He puts himself physically in between them, he invokes how close he is to them, insists on how Vox 'needs him' and how he's helped Charlie. Lu and Val try to interrupt ("Others say that in your needy hour..."/You two should just fuck already") which annoys Alastor, who proceeds to undermine the bond more, with a smug smirk about how easily he could bend C&V to his will.
Like I mentioned, he really hits that he's the 'day-to-day" in Charlie's world. He hits on their emotional closeness ("I'm truly honored that we've built such a bond"/"I thought you fond me 'inspiring"), and deliberately sows seeds of discord between the two families ("Sadly, there are times a birth parent is a dud"/"You'd be nothing without those two"). It's interesting too that the familial bonds Al chooses to undermine most directly are heteronormative - father-daughter, romantic couple (yes, a gay poly one, but still a romantic dyadic couple) - when he also emphasizes "the family you choose is better" in the number. Being queer, and queer in a specific way that basically defies all heteronormative organizations of family - coupling romantically, childbirth, etc. - Al probably has a very confusing feeling about these two weirdoes he wants in his life. He can kind of insert himself into the "adoptive father" role with Charlie, but what is his relationship with Vox? An "Old Pal?" Friends? He doesn't want to be 'friends', or partners, or lovers, so whatever is there doesn't have a category or a label. (it's called wanting a QPR Al, embrace it).
Anyway, focusing on C&V more. Charlie and Vox both fall for this hook, line and sinker. Charlie is actually a little smarter about it since she's still cautious around Al in 1x07, but she seems in this number to believe in Al, and Vox believes every rage-bait thing Al says to undermine his family in season 2. Charlie wants unconditional approval from a parent, which Al mimics for her. Vox wants Al to approve of him, and Al keeps reeling him in with the teasing promise that he'll approve of him one day. So with Alastor's seeds of discord, both C&V are taken in and let him undermine their relationships with Lu/the Vees. And Lu and Val are both very angry and jealous about this.
Lu is able to, in this episode, recover some of his relationship with Charlie by opening up to her about why he's having a hard time with this specifically, while Val gets angry and storms off:
Charlie: Dad… just... help me.
Lucifer: I... I can't.
Charlie: Why can't you?
Lucifer: Charlie! You don't understand. Heaven never listens. They didn't listen to me. They won't listen to you.
Charlie: You don't know that!a
In Scream rain
Valentino: Plus, I don't even know why you're asking. You just do whatever the fuck you want anyway, all for your stupid fucking plan, right?
[Alastor looks at Vox with a smug face]
Valentino: And this whole thing, (Valentino waves a hand at Alastor) it's getting old fast, Vox.
love these visual parallels
Val and Lu both have musical numbers expressing their love for C&V and their fears of losing them:
Lu: ♪ I won't lose it all again. Now you're the only thing worth fighting for. ♪ [While he is singing, silhouettes of higher angels appear, surrounding Lucifer with spears. Next shot shows Charlie being surrounded by spears that slowly come towards her, with Lucifer noticing them in horror, and pulls Charlie away on the other side to defend her.] ♪ More than anything, more than anything. ♪ ♪ I'll shelter and adore you more than anything ♪
Valentino: ♪ Val, don't be dramatic ♪/♪ He's just a man ♪/♪ He's being rude 'cause he's stressed-out/♪ trying to do his master plan ♪/♪ Think about the future, Val ♪/♪ Don't let success break up the band ♪/♪ But as he rises higher ♪/♪ things aren't like they were before ♪/♪ And if he glows any brighter ♪/♪ will he see me anymore? ♪
But Lu's is a number he shares with Charlie, while Val's is a monologue. He shares it with Vel, not with Vox. Lu fears the Angels will take Charlie away from him, that she'll die to them; Val fears Vox will leave him if he gets too powerful. And while this openness between Charlie and Lu does let them start repairing their relationship, it isn't enough to stop it from going sour again a bit in Season 2, which we'll get to. Val doesn't share his feelings with Vox, who is too caught up in s2 with his plan anyway, and it leads to a real fracture between them.
So in 1x05, we see Charlie and Lu open up to each other and repair their relationship a bit:
Charlie and Lucifer: ♪ All that I'm hopin' ♪ /♪ now that my eyes are open, is that we can start again, ♪ /♪ not be pulled apart again /'Cause in the end, You are part of who I am. ♪ /Lucifer: ♪ I'll support your dream, whatever lies in store. ♪
With Vox and the Vees, of course, they started the series in a much more secure place, so their moment of reconciliation will have to be in the future, hopefully. But this also doesn't bode well for Charlie and her family in season 3, since Alastor seems to be fully planning on sowing the same seeds of discord between the Morningstars he sowed between the Vees. And we've seen that Charlie is just susceptible enough to his manipulations to believe him.
I think C&V both will probably need to deal with alienating their family because of Alastor in Season 3; now, it's possible Alastor might in both of their cases have wanted to keep them at some point, but he feels rejected by them both now and his undermining of their families is motivated by revenge as much as by possessiveness. So C&V both need to work towards building up trust and bonds again with Lu, Val and Vel, the people who, when the chips are down, really will be there for them. (Also in Charlie's case, Vaggie and her hotel friends). Both C&V's arcs are probably about learning to appreciate the people they do have instead of chasing after approval from people who are either A, manipulating them, or B, don't love them - or at least not enough to really treat them right.
We'll see how that plays out in future seasons.












