I think this recent conversation is interesting actually, because it reveals two schools of thought.
The request not to look back at a loved one you’re worried about goes against human nature. When you’re walking with someone you love and they’re out of your sight, the urge to find them and check on them is so strong. So I think whether or not Orpheus turning around is a failing or proof or his love depends a lot on what love means to you.
Are you doing everything you can to save her, even defying your own nature, your good sense, your worry, putting your own feelings and humanity aside in the hopes that at the end she’ll live?
The people who say that they wouldn’t have turned around are saying that her life is worth their discomfort, their stress, and fear on that long walk. But that they could distance themselves from it, even if it meant forcing their own face forward, for the sake of her life.
Or is love best exemplified by human nature itself? That you’re doing everything you can to save her, head straight forward. but then in a moment, on an instinct, you turn to look, because you love her, and you’re worried, and you can’t not.
The people who say turning around is the point say that love is not separate from human instinct, that it can’t be overcome. When we spin around in a second to find our friends and family in the crowd when we realize that they’re no longer at our side? That’s a pure show of love too.
Basically the debate is, ‘is love a thoughtful sacrifice or what we show in the moments where we don’t think at all.’ And think the answer is a combination of both. It’s why Orpheus finds his way to the underworld in the first place. And it’s why, even if you don’t turn around, the instinct is there, and you’re fighting it all the way.