Media Literacy Rant...
Ok, I've been on a reaction binge lately on YouTube and had the thought "what about M*A*S*H"?
So I'm watching these army and medical people in their 20s and 30s commenting on excerpts and saying how it's not in any way realistic and COMPLETELY FORGETTING THAT IT WAS MADE IN THE 70s AND SET IN THE 50s!!!!!!!
This is like looking at a show set in the 1600s in a European palace kitchen and comparing the food to today's nutritional guidelines or comparing a political drama set in the Aztec empire to the politics that would be used in modern international relations.
And all of this is setting aside the 45+ years old thing. Were some of the jokes tasteless, racist, misogynous, and homophobic? Yes absolutely! Was this show responsible for some of the most progressive storylines of its day with sensitive topics treated with care and delicacy? Also Yes Absolutely! Are there episodes that you could not make today due to changing values? Oh yeah, some episodes have NOT aged well. Are there episodes where you could swap the characters to a modern setting and have it be declared edgy? So true.
A piece of media should be examined both from a modern perspective and also with a clear understanding of the cultural and political climate in which it was made.
It's Pride month in the US so lets pick an LGBTQIA+ storyline:
There was an episode that aired in 1974 regarding the treatment of gay soldiers by their comrades. Private Weston comes in with wounds from both the enemy and his fellows. (remember the draft is in place in the US for the Korean war) It's immediately obvious to the staff that the wounds are not all from combat and after some digging from the MCs he confesses that there are two soldiers who are treated poorly in his unit - the one who is African American and one who is homosexual. Hawkeye listens to this, turns to the very anglo actor and says "So you're a n***o" (not intended as a slur at the time but has not aged well). The cast of characters then all need to grapple in their own way with the cultural, moral, social, and legal ramifications of outing this poor kid (18-22ish) in 1951 in a warzone. There are a lot of issues with the episode and not much discussion of structural inequalities but Private Weston is a whole character not a caricature and he is generally treated fairly by today's standards and is very sympathetic by the standards of both the production and the setting.
M*A*S*H is a period piece. Period pieces actually have a lot more freedom to tackle difficult topics because they can frame the morality as "back then" and "it wouldn't be like that now lol". Even the medical procedures being ridiculed were accurate to the time period. I've done CPR updates annually for the last 20 years. Part of the reason you are expected to do them annually is so that you have gotten the latest update - and the guidelines are reviewed regularly (kids and babies have changed the most but adults have changed a bit).
So all of this is a very longwinded way of saying that sometimes I want to reach into my computer and slap somebody.



















