It had been three days since Audrey had left her house. Three days since she'd had a terrible fight with her husband before he'd left to fly to New York for pre-production on a new movie he'd been cast in. Three days for the angry red welt to turn into an ugly bruise around her eye. She hadn't seen anyone since the fight. She had lied to the director, Aaron, when he'd called to see why she hadn't shown up on set of Bad Blood for filming. Claimed she was home with the flu and didn't want to get anyone sick. She'd used the same excuse when her sisters had called and wanted to spend time with her and her new puppy, Thor. She'd even lied to Madison the day before when he'd sent her a text, asking to meet up for lunch. Madison had needed to be lied to the most.
While things were beginning to fix themselves between Audrey and her ex, she couldn't risk letting him see her face like this. With a black eye that she couldn't look him in the eye and lie about. Madison didn't need to know. It was her problem to deal with, not his. Maybe Madison was why this was happening to her. Maybe this was karma's way of paying her back for leaving him as cruelly as she had. She'd left a good man, so karma had sent her a bad one to make her regret leaving the one man she'd loved more than anything in the world. The same man that, if she was being completely honest with herself, she was still completely in love with.
A knock on the door, followed by the sound of Thor barking broke Audrey from her thoughts. Â She stared at the door, wondering who the hell it could be. Everyone she knew was convinced that she was sick and had stayed away like she'd hoped they would. Until now, apparently. Audrey stayed in her seat, praying the person would go away if she pretended she wasn't home.
"Audrey, I know you're here. Your car is in the driveway."
Her heart nearly stopped at the voice. Madison. What was he doing here? She could have sworn he'd said they could wait to have lunch until she wasn't 'sick' anymore. Fuck. He knew she was home. She had a black eye. What the hell was she going to tell him? She looked down, realizing she was still in the shorts and tank top she'd been in when she was reading out by the pool earlier and an idea struck her.
"Just a minute!" Audrey called, snatching a book off of her bookshelf in the living room and throwing on an over sized pair of sunglasses to cover up the black eye. Once she had the glasses on, she went to the door and opened it. Her breath caught in her throat as she saw Madison standing there. Even though she'd known it was him at her front door, the sight of him still took her breath away. "Sorry, I was out back reading." Audrey explained, opening the door wider for him. "come in."
Madison followed her inside, trying to keep his mind off of thoughts about her in those little shorts she was wearing. He had other things he needed to think about. Like how he was certain there was something up. He'd heard from Dorothy that Audrey hadn't been at work in a few days and wouldn't see her. That wasn't like Audrey to avoid her sister. He'd tried to get her out to lunch with him but she'd insisted she was sick. Yet here she was in shorts and looking as healthy as ever. Something just wasn't adding up.
"Too sick for lunch with me and to go to work, but not too sick to skip out on reading by the pool?" Madison asked, raising an eyebrow as he watched her leading him out back. "You know, if you didn't want to have lunch with me, you could have just said so."
"Oh, no, that's not it!" Audrey said, distraught at the thought of Madison thinking she didn't want to see him. "I was sick, and then I started feeling better this morning, but didn't want to risk lunch, so I just came out here to read instead." She really hoped he believed that lie. She was really getting bad at lying to him.
Madison was sure Audrey wasn't telling the truth. But he wasn't going to call her out on it. ...Not yet, anyways. He followed her lead and sat down on one of the patio chairs, his mind racing. He'd come to Los Angeles for a reason. And it hadn't been just to play for the Dodgers. He'd seen the tabloids, read the reports of bruises being seen on Audrey. Heard that she'd brush them off as the result of a trip and fall. An accident. He might have believed that if he didn't know Audrey. If he didn't know she wasn't that clumsy. She wouldn't have been on their college's softball team on a scholarship if she was that clumsy.
Madison wanted to believe that the gossip was just that; gossip. He wanted to believe that Audrey hadn't allowed herself to fall into this kind of situation. But the time he' spent with her at the bar that first night and how jumpy she'd been, and the times they'd been texting or hanging out over the last few weeks led him to believe there might be some truth to the rumors.
"I'm glad you're feeling better, Aud," He said, the familiar nickname he'd had for her slipping out of his mouth. He fidgeted in his seat, wondering how to bring up the question he wanted to ask her so badly. 'Hi Aud, is your husband kicking your ass?' He couldn't just blurt something like that out, could he? Her in those shorts and those sunglasses covering her eyes weren't helping him focus, either. "Those glasses are pretty distracting. It's not even sunny out, it's overcast." He pointed out. "Could you take them off? I can't see your eyes."
Audrey panicked almost immediately. If she took the glasses off, he'd see her eye. He'd ask questions. Questions she knew she wouldn't be able to lie her way out of. But if she didn't take them off, he would assume there was something wrong. It was a lose-lose situation for her. Maybe she could cover this up. "Fine, but you have to promise not to laugh at me."
"Why would I laugh if you take off your glasses?" Madison asked, confused.
"I was playing with Thor the other day and he knocked me off of my feet and into the corner of a table," Audrey lied, slowly taking her sunglasses off, revealing the bruise covering her eye. "It looks worse than it feels." She added, though it still stung at times, even after three days.
Once her glasses were off, Madison felt a surge of anger through his entire being. There was no way a puppy could have caused a bruise like that just from knocking her over. Madison seen enough fights to know what a black eye from a fist looked like and that was definitely what that bruise was. "Audrey..." He began, gritting his teeth. "What really caused that?"
"I just told you," Audrey said, looking away from Madison. She couldn't look him in the eye and keep the lie up. She just couldn't do it.
"Cut the bullshit, Audrey." Madison said, his heart breaking as he watched her look away from him. He was ninety nine percent sure he knew what that black eye was from. "...Did he do this to you?" He asked quietly, hoping and praying that he was wrong.
The way Audrey froze, the look of defeat in her eyes as she turned to look at him was more confirmation than her words could ever be. That look said it all. "Audrey..."
"Don't," She said, shaking her head. "Don't say anything."
"Audrey, I can't ignore that." Madison said, appalled that she could even think to tell him not to say anything about it.
"Drop it, Madison." Audrey said, standing up from her chair and moving towards the house. "It's not your problem to deal with, it's mine."
"Not my problem!?" Madison asked incredulously. How bad had this been, how long had it been going on, that she was refusing his help? "He's hurting you. How is that not my problem? I've known you for years. How can you say it's not my problem?"
"Because it isn't," She said, refusing to look at him. "We're not together. Whatever happens to me isn't your concern."
Her words only fueled his anger more. "I don't give a damn if we're together, or if we're not. You wanted us to be friends. This is what friends do. I'm not going to just sit back and let that asshole do this to you!" He seethed, reaching out to touch her arm, dropping his hand when she flinched. Seeing her flinch away from him made his heart ache. The woman he'd been in love with for so long was broken. Even more broken than he was himself. "Aud. Look at me. Please."
"Just go, Madison." Audrey said, her back to him. She couldn't face him now. Not when he knew how much she'd lied to him since they'd been back in each others lives. Not now that he knew what she'd allowed to happen to herself. She couldn't stand to hear the concern in his voice. She didn't deserve it. "I can deal with this on my own."
"No. I'm not going anywhere." Madison said, getting up from his seat and following her towards the house. "I made the mistake of letting you walk away once, I'm not making that mistake again." He finished, moving to stand in front of her. "Let me fix you. Let me in, Audrey. I can't help you if you won't talk to me."
She shook her head again, tears welling up in her eyes. "I don't deserve your help. Not after what I did to you."
The fact that she didn't think she deserved to have him help her out of this situation was gut wrenching. "I don't care what happened then, Audrey. I want to help you. I can't see you hurt like this. I can't sit back and let it happen."
"Madison, I-"
"No! You listen to me," Madison said, reaching out to her, lifting her chin up so he could look her in the eye. "He doesn't deserve you. He's not good enough for you." Against his better judgement, he stepped closer to her, his thumb gently tracing the bruised skin around her eye. He smiled just the slightest bit when she didn't flinch away and moved closer to him instead. This was what he'd needed. To be close to her. All those years spent sleeping with other women, it had all been in a vain attempt to replace the woman standing so close to him now. So close he could lean down and kiss her. It was so tempting. His heart screamed for him to do it, but his brain screamed not to.
Audrey was having the same argument with her head and her heart. She closed her eyes, the soft touch of his skin against hers was soothing. Feather light touches instead of the rough hands of her husband. "It should have been you." Audrey said, her voice just barely above a whisper.
"What should have been me?" He asked, adopting the same quiet tone she'd used. Afraid if he spoke any louder, she'd realize how close they were and run away again.
"Everything. This... This house, this ring... It was supposed to be you. I wanted it to be you." Audrey said, biting her lip. "I... I still want it to be you.."
Madison felt his heart skip a beat in his chest. What did she say? She still wanted him? Weeks ago, he would have said he'd misheard her. That she was in love with her husband and over him. But now? Now, everything was different. He knew her husband was an abusive asshole, and here she was, still wanting him. "You can't mean that," Madison said finally, his hand dropping from her face. This was entering dangerous territory now. It was easier for Madison to behave and listen to his head when he was convinced she didn't want him.
"I mean it, Madi." Audrey said, instantly missing the way he'd so gently caressed her skin after his hand dropped away. "I never got over you. Even after I got married. I settled because I didn't have you. You were in Chicago and I was here because I fucked up. I was an idiot. It was you. It's always been you."
This was a lot to take in. The love of his life was telling him she wasn't over him. That she still wanted him, even though she was a married woman. Married women had always been against his rules. A ring just wasn't something he would disrespect. But this wasn't just any woman. This was the woman he'd been trying to replace for seven years. This was Audrey. His Audrey. The one he had let get away, and didn't want to see get away again. "Aud, you keep saying things like that and it's making it hard for me to stop myself from doing something stupid." Madison warned, pulling her into his arms, despite his brain screaming at him. "I can't promise I'll honor that ring on your finger."
"...What if I don't want you to?" She asked, looking up and into his eyes. "What if I asked for it?"
"Audrey, I-"
"Kiss me?"
 Two words. That was all it took for what little self control Madison had still had to crumble. He pulled her as close as he could, kissing her like he'd wanted to for seven years. Audrey returned the kiss eagerly, her arms locking around his neck. This was right. This was how it was always meant to be between them. Madison pulled away first, out of breath, and leaned his forehead against hers. His memories of of how her lips had felt against his hadn't done kissing Audrey any justice.
"I love you." He found himself saying, his heart winning against his head. He'd wanted to tell her that for weeks. He needed to hear her say it. Needed to know this wasn't just her asking him to kiss her in the heat of the moment.
"I love you, too," Audrey said without hesitation. "I never stopped. Not for one second."
That was all he needed to hear before his lips were on hers again, kissing her hungrily. He needed this, needed her. And Audrey needed him, too. She pushed on his chest, the two stumbling into the house, lips never leaving each other. Madison picked Audrey up to carry her, smirking against her lips as she wrapped her legs around his waist.
"Where?" He asked, groaning as Audrey's lips moved to his neck, feeling her gently nipping at his skin.
"Down the hall, first door on the left. Guest room." Audrey said before kissing him again.
Madison pushed the door open with his foot and walked inside. He set Audrey down on the end of the bed. He stood there watching her for a moment, wondering if this was all a dream. Wondering if he'd wake up in Matt's apartment on the couch he was constantly falling asleep on. It'd be a damn good dream if that was the case. Audrey bit her lip nervously as Madison looked at her. She was sure she looked terrible with that black and blue mess on her eye, but the way Madison was looking at her... It was the same way he'd always looked at her when they were together. When he'd tell her he'd never seen anything more beautiful. Audrey smiled up at him as she tugged at the hem of his shirt. He complied, pulling his shirt off silently. Once it was off, Audrey pulled him down on top of her, kissing him softly.Â
"Audrey." Madison interrupted, pulling back a little. "Are you sure?" Shut up, idiot! His brain, now taking his heart's side, yelled at him. You finally have her again!
"I've never been more sure of anything," Audrey said honestly, resting her hand on his cheek. "I love you. I want this. You and I need this." She said, leaning forward to put her forehead against his. "You said you wanted to fix me, right?" When he nodded, Audrey trailed her hands down his chest and stomach til she reached his belt. "So fix me." She said, smirking.
"I can do that." Madison said, a grin stretching across his face. And he did. For the rest of the afternoon and well into the night.Â