Hear me out: what if Shane was the one who tried to get Ilya to do an open relationship in TLG?
Obviously Ilya tragically attempting to please his bf and keep him happy by telling him to fuck other people is already excellent whumpy goodness BUT
Imagine Shane’s deep insecurity born from knowing he was never enough for Ilya and desperation to compete with all the other women Ilya openly fucked and the shame of knowing he MUST have done something wrong for Ilya to have just ghosted him for so long after they hit it the first time culminating in Shane trying to pretend he’s okay with Ilya sleeping with other people.
Ilya finally realizing how deeply he fucked Shane up by conditioning him to accept that he would never be enough for Ilya. That all his little comments and digs and fuckboy games actually landed and Shane really didn’t understand or believe he’s enough for him. Even though they’re dating and in love. Even though Ilya assumed Shane must at this point know how mind numbingly absurdly ruined him for everyone else good Shane is.
Maybe instead of Shane actually pitching it to Ilya he just casually references the other women he assumes Ilya is still seeing, or makes some comment in bed begging Ilya to tell him he’s his favorite and then apologizes after because “sorry I know that’s needy it was the heat of the moment I know you love me I just get jealous sometimes”.
Just Shane casually assuming he’ll always have to share and never be enough for Ilya and Ilya horrified to realize just how resigned Shane is to assuming Ilya will never be satisfied with him the way Shane is with Ilya.
Great news, I decided to completely abandon my grad school assignments due today, my work project due tomorrow, and all sense and responsibility in order to drop everything and write this. I didn’t have any intention of actually doing it myself but here we are I guess.
https://archiveofourown.org/works/80069411
PLEASE other people write this fic idea, mine is just a one shot done in single sitting because I couldn’t get it out of my head.









